Young Jijii or Toyotaro/Toyble?

[SaiyàBitō]

And before you say, NO, this is not related to the fanfic of DBAF.

BUT:

This is about the comparison between the two artists.

How do you all feel about the two?

[Lord Beerus]

Young Jijii's art style is certainly quite refined and far more detailed, making what he draws all the more aesthetically appealing and pleasing. But at the same token Toyotaro art style has come a long way and feels representative of how Toriyama's art style evolved from the Majin Boo arc to what it is now. I think the main issue with Young Jijii's art style is that it feel very stuck in how characters were drawn from the Namek/Freeza arc to the Android/Cell arc.

[kei17]

Definitely Young Jiji.

Toyotaro's art superficially looks promising in cover art, but its unskillfulness gets revealed once you start reading the content: Non-detailed muscles, ackward facial expressions, inaccurate wrinkles in clothes, and very stiff digitally drawn lines. He is good at drawing DB character likenesses, but he seriously lacks the basic skills that are needed for a professional manga artist. When I read his manga, I feel like I'm watching a DB anime with Goku voiced by a Nozawa impersonator who knows nothing about acting.

On the other hand, Young Jiji knows how to draw manga properly. His art doesn't have the aforementioned flaws in Toyotaro's manga. His biggest weakness is the eye-straining poor color palette that he uses in colored works, but it's not a problem in B&W manga.

[Tzigi]

Toyble. When I see YoungJiji's drawings I always get the impression that his characters are just a tiny bit... chubby? overweight? They look like well trained people who let themselves go a bit and had gotten an unseemly layer of fat. And I get that feeling so much that it detracts me from the story.

[KameRule]

I prefer Young Jijii, and his art is definitely more refined and detailed; the only problem I have with his stuff is that particularly when using Super Saiyan forms 3 through 5, I can barely tell the characters' faces apart.

[Faustus]

Toyble lately has gotten so darned good at composition and choreographing action I frankly don't think it's even close.

Meanwhile on the other hand YoungJijii is still lifting panels straight from prior work and producing some of the least appealing designs for new characters in anything ever*. More detailed, yes, but the awkward way he draws hair and certain facial expressions in general (esp. smiles) is another two strikes against him, to my mind.

*Admittedly, that "Marble" fellow is pretty cool-looking.

EDIT: Toyble's also got a goddamn sense of humor.

[Hellspawn28]

Jijii has great detail art, but he is known to trace a lot from what I remember. Toyble has gotten a lot better with his art since his AF manga. So Toyble wins.

[Scarz]

This is tough choice to make. If we're going by a pure artistic stand point, I prefer Toyable over Jijii, although I believe Jijii is the better artist skill wise. I don't think Jijii traces any more (unless I'm wrong here) and his action scenes are pretty solid. But there's something about Toyable's work that seems more organic and pleasing to me. It must be the way his characters are drawn, they seem less, I dunno, sharp, hard, stiff? Whichever the case may be, yeah, I prefer Toyable's artwork art lot more.