dragon boss z wrote:No, just what you think are facts are not facts.
I know you'll be triggered from this reply, but please try to calm down and grasp what I'm trying to tell you
Isn't that exactly what I'm telling you? You think that you're speculative arguments are gonna prove anything, but they aren't, because they're all speculations. You're just trying to stick to your opinion and can't handle the fact that you can't disprove my argument. All you're doing is SPECULATE. I'll show you the definition, if you lack the meaning of it:
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
Again, what you're doing is speculating scenarios which never happened. You're trying so hard to stay relevant, and I can't believe you even survived this long on the Versus Thread, because you aren't debating. You ridiculed me in this comment and talk very strong while all of this tone is a contradiction to your true ability of debating. You are
speculating. This is as simple as it can get.
My offensive manner isn't for me to be a douchbag, but it is for you to look at yourself. You might as well be triggered from what I say, but that would show all the more than you
hate to lose or admit your mistake. Again, you aren't countering my main argument which is supported factually by the show, and evident by scans which I provided. You keep saying things like "I think", "Probably did-", "Maybe"...etc. Such Key words are not meant to be used when you're arguing over something and debating somebody else over it. You have to be concrete and solid, which you're clearly missing.
dragon boss z wrote:And stop acting like you are the superior debater
It doesn't take a genius to figure that an argument factually supported > speculative talk. All you're doing is speculate arguments and ignoring my argument which is backed up without refuting then act as if you're doing a fine job. I'm not acting, since I have no reason to do so. The fact that you thought I'm doing so shows more that you yourself can't handle me in this due to my arguments being, probably, superior to yours...? Considering that I have the show with me, you might have gotten troubled given you're only speculating (sarcasm). Again, if you calm down and not get triggered, then it's better
You are pulling things quite far and trying too hard to argue on something, despite the fact that you're only speculating, which leads me to believe that I'm better than you.
Here are some elements to be taken into consideration about debating properly:
[spoiler]1.) People who depend on factual material, evidences and valid supports rather than speculation and opinions
2.) People who are ready to debate you and are capable of providing evidence on par, if not more, than me
3.) People who logically argue over things, and rightfully concede if they are wrong, without pointless resistance for the purpose of maintaining one's own beliefs. (This also applies to me)
4.) People who are blunt. Being so nice in debates is fine, but it sometimes restricts people from expressing all their knowledge and arguments. Though that doesn't mean you should be rude and disrespectful
5.) People who debate with passion. I don't stand debating with people who do not enjoy debating with me. It's fair that both me and the other debater are willing to Debate for the enjoyment of it
6.) People who don't like to drag a debate for long. Just debate for a specific set of point; Debating for a predetermined amount, and leave the debate as it is, left to be judged by others. Dragging debates pointlessly results in nothing but Agreeing to Disagree (forcefully) and sometimes flame wars, which aren't favourable results.
7.) People who argue with a powerful tone, though they must have the experience to back it up.
8.) People who show clarity. I need to understand the person I'm debating as much as possible. Though the one I'm debating, including me, should be capable of understanding the other in general, so no blaming would occur
9.) People who are capable of making worthy Rebuttals.
10.) People who are used to Debating Often.[/spoiler]
Speculation is not Knowledge ~ Robert M. Price
That's something you need to understand and grasp, since you're not remotely trying to show evidence or simply you cannot, thus you're resorting to speculation, given you can't even counter me at all
dragon boss z wrote:Make a comic vine account and lets do a CaV of SSG Goku (BoG arc) vs current base Goku. Other members vote on who they think debated better and not who they think would actually win. I bet you I would be the winner so if you want to keep up your "I'm the superior debater" attitude then take up my challenge. If not stop claiming your argument blows min out of the water.
This is as childish as you can get eh? There is absolutely
no reason for me to go and make an account their just so that I could see
other people's opinions. It's OBVIOUS that you're desperate to the point you're looking for people's opinions now, and you think that they will prove that you're right? If you can't prove yourself against me to the point you want others to help shows all the more that I'm more superior in debating than you. Using your logic I can tell you to hop on to Google+ and DragonBallZAmino, make a poll on who debated better and I "bet" you I would "win".
It's a given that People who argue with evidence > people who only use speculation to back themselves up. You hold no credibility at this point, so if you want to redeem yourself, learn from your mistakes and not get triggered and increase the speculative manner and claim you're better.
Comicvine is the same community which most of its members has Goku at best Multi-Planet Buster. I'm not here to challenge you on going to that community and see who wins, I myself know I'm superior, and you only use
speculations while I'm using
evidence.
dragon boss z wrote:No you just think what you are showing are facts.
No you just think what I'm showing you isn't facts
You're only
speculating everything so that it comes by to your own beliefs which honestly all the less interesting of a debate. Ignoring my evidence and saying it isn't facts without backing yourself up means I'm winning here and your point would mean void
dragon boss z wrote:If we just go off of statements alone, all we know is ssj Goku surpassed his SSG state. When Goku destroys the final blast in base form that was just a moment of him reaching deep down to stop the blast, it was never stated "base Goku surpassed SSG".
If we go by statements, feats and Implifications which you blatantly ignored, Not only Ssj Goku surpassed SsjG Goku BoG, but base Goku also did. I already clarified this but you ignored which is no longer surprising. It was never stated SSjB Goku is Stronger Than King Piccolo" so King Piccolo > SsjB Goku, and that's exactly your logic. It was shown later on feat-wise and Implification wise that Goku's base far surpassed anything he ever showed in BoG. Goku You're speculating it was for a moment, despite Goku stating and implying that he surpassed his limits in front of Beerus, and later it's shown Goku is even stronger in base than what he ever showed against Beerus, but no, your Speculation > Proof. Well, sarcasm off, It is shown and proven. If you can't refute that properly
with evidence, you lost, no matter how much speculative talks you have up your sleeves.
dragon boss z wrote:Of course he would try to win, and if they transformed to Vegito he would of tried to win as well. And I do agree SSG is above Vegito, I just don't think it's by too much.
Goku wasn't just "trying", he thought he
could beat Beerus, the same character who knocked Ssj3 Goku with utmost ease who's supposed to have Gotten as strong as he could have possibly gotten, and that's talking about Goku:
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
Yet BoG Vegito is no match for Beerus, who SsjG Goku was thought to have been capable of beating Beerus. Failed Ritual Goku was thought to have been SsjG by even Vegeta who knew of Vegito's power and obvious inferiority to Beerus. This shows how you speculated:
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
You are entitled to your own opinion, I have no obligation to say you can't have your own. However, you cannot use that opinion which is not backed up at all in a debate, unless you can support it which you CLEARLY can't other than using
speculation.
dragon boss z wrote:No, I showed you plenty more logic than that.
You clearly haven't, and I'm not her to lie about you anyways. You clearly
speculated everything you said
dragon boss z wrote:Base Goku was hurt by a bullet because he got "rusty"
How does this correlate with the issue of Base Goku vs SsjG Goku BoG?
Absolutely Nothing, so this renders this trial futile. Also, using this would also mean you're trying to say that Kid Goku is sturdier than Current Base Goku, and Goku has actually got stronger which is later shown in the Tournament of Power, and I clarified this which, eh, not surprisingly, you ignored.
dragon boss z wrote:Krillin made him go ssj
If you want to claim that Krillin hasn't gotten much stronger then you'd be implying that Base Goku is barely Namek Saga Tier, so
stop speculating the power of Krillin. Krillin doing that Goku only shows he got stronger as on episode 75 and 76 it was clearly shown that Krillin gotten so strong he learned to perfectly control his Ki which is exactly similar to what Goku has been learning.
Krillin controlled his Ki and was able to combat Fake Super Shenron who Goku states he could combat with
only if he goes full power (in general, so this could very well relate to base Goku), and Roshi also states and implies that Krillin back then rose beyond his earlier powers. Fake Super Shenron and the rest of the clones are all based on Goku's and Krillin's energy and was considered a threat by Goku. Krillin got far stronger than back then according to Goku and troubled Gohan and beat him.
You're just speculating Krillin is weak, while this shows he isn't, despite the other fact that Goku was holding back given that he showed later on that his Base is beyond Krillin
dragon boss z wrote:Frost made him go ssj
That's all a terrible speculation. How are you saying Frost is weak? He forced Goku to Go Ssj in the Universe 6 Arc and NOWHERE has it been shown that Frost is weaker than SsjG BoG but quite the opposite. In fact, in the Tournament of Power Arc, Frost made Hit go serious for a bit:
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
Frost being God Tier has no trouble. Saying frost pushes Vegeta to go Ssj proves your point is frankly denial as it doesn't, because you're
speculating that Frost is weak, which he showed not to be so.
dragon boss z wrote:Buu beat him in their sparring match
That's some top notch speculation of Fit Buu's strength which you, OF COURSE, came up with and ignored the fact that he got stronger. Fit Buu got stronger, unknown by how much, but enough to beat Goku in his base form. That's all we need, and you speculating he hasn't gotten much stronger ain't gonna prove anything since Vegeta in 6 months became God Tier, Frieza in 4 months became God Tier, and Gohan in a couple of hours became High-End God Tier.
dragon boss z wrote:he can still go SSG
I guess Goku's current base form is weaker than Namek Saga Ssj Goku because he can go Ssj. Him being able to go SsjG absolutely proves nothing, because that's just a TRANSFORMATION. I hope you can grasp this, but it's just a TRANSFORMATION. Goku only ABSORBED its POWER, so it has nothing to do with transforming to SsjG.
dragon boss z wrote:Krillin survived his punch to the face
Base Goku survived a punch from Mutated Merged Zamasu so I guess he's at that level! Surviving =/= Relative in power, so this is ALSO invalid
dragon boss z wrote:he had trouble with the trio de danger, ect.
Having trouble with the Trio De Dangers proves nothing. Nice going, speculating that Bergamo (he's part of them) isn't God tier despite going up against such level of strength. Goku struggling with them makes absolutely no sense, or he's holding back against Basil and Lavender, since by that logic you're using, Basil would be superior to Bergamo
Also, there's evidence that the Super Saiyan Blue form Goku used Against Bergamo is inferior to His Regular Super Saiyan form which he used Against Toppo, yet his SsjB form is stated to be a power which rivals the gods, and Bergamo pushed that while being amped by the Kamehameha. This also explains why Base Goku is shown to he throwing Bergamo with utmost ease
Unless you want to say the trio de dangers got stronger, your point is invalid.
dragon boss z wrote:There are plenty of examples of him being below SSG in base and I mentioned them before, you just brush it off as everyone is SSG level... That clearly isn't the intention Toriyama had in mind.
I'm not brushing anything, you're just using speculations all over the place and use things which have nothing to do with your point. You ignored almost all my argument so that speaks for itself upon You. You don't suggest what's Toriyama's intention since based on the factual materials I provided Akira's intention would be for Goku's base to surpass SsjG which is what he did directly in BoG Movie. You, on the other hand, bash everything and claim you're right.
So I'm a "better" debater is a right statement.
dragon boss z wrote:That would only be the case if Vegeta can go SSG too, but that is never shown. If Goku is the only one who can go SSG that means he is using power from the ritual to go SSG.
It is shown in the manga that Vegeta can go SSG, but SSG never had a time limit in the manga.
Mmmmm ok so? What you're saying absolutely has nothing to do with what I'm saying, so you went out of the topic, albeit purposedly. Goku going SsjG doesn't mean he's doing so by the Ritual, he just acquired the form and this only contradicts the point which was made in BoG that it was a time-limit transformation. SsjB is a Super Saiyan stacked ON Super Saiyan God so SsjG existed ever since RoF but was never shown to us.
dragon boss z wrote:Whis was referring to gods, not every random fodder from other universes.
That's another example of
speculation which you clearly is doing. Come on mate Whis CEAELY said it IN GENERAL, he didn't say the gods if destruction. Stop claiming everybody to be fodder because that's utter facepalming
speculation. This is utter speculation you pulled which is NEVER said to be the case. You're funny, and yet you're telling me I'm an inferior debater? You're speculating while I'm providing evidence. Big difference.
dragon boss z wrote:Except that there is a statement that flat out says base Goku can't beat Frieza, so that proves that you ignore some statements to.
I'm not ignoring any statement, but you're sticking so much to this statement while ignoring all other confirmations from the Buu Saga and the show itself that you're about to worship this statement, mind you. Guides, show and context disagree. Beerus stating this was all based on what he watched from Whis, and Beerus knows shit.
Proof of Beerus knowing shit about Goku is Beerus stating that Ssj Goku's Power is at best only slightly above Frieza and at best that's all he can do, despite that being atrocious in every possible aspect, which leads us to believe that it's a contradiction of Beerus is simply provoking Goku:
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
Everything in the show disagrees with you. That's enough on its own. I'm not drifting the course of the debate into another one, so leave the Base Goku vs Frieza argument for later.
dragon boss z wrote:And don't say "because it is contradicted" because base Goku being above SSG is contradcited as well in some cases.
It was never contradicted and you haven't shown me where is it contradicted except by using
speculation. Even if we want to say there are 2 to 3 points which contradict it, they hold no candle in front of concrete horde of evidences. See the difference? You should have recognized the difference by now. Base Goku < Freeza is contradicted more than it is supported, and you can't change that and I'm gonna say it over and over.
dragon boss z wrote:I agree in his fight with Beerus wearing the Monaka costume he did seem SSG level, but then at other times he doesn't. This is the problem of different writers working on different episodes.
"Other times"? There aren't other times at all mate. More than 20 evidences are out there which prove that Base Goku > SsjG Goku BoG. That's enough
dragon boss z wrote:Saonel and Pirina only became ultimate Gohan level after powering up, and when they did that Piccolo became fodder to them. Only his special beam canon could really injure them.
Here you go again,
speculating that Gohan hasn't gotten stronger. By your logic SsjB Goku is at best Buutenks level, since Ultimate Gohan rivaled SsjB Goku. Gohan got far stronger than he already was which was stated by Piccolo that he still has room to grow in strength and he'll take that option, and he did so. Saying Gohan is only Buu Saga Tier is cringy, because clearly he isn't. Piccolo hasn't become fodder much at all, as he was STILL
relative to them despite it being slight.
dragon boss z wrote:You act like that's impressive. Golden Frieza was already above SSB Goku in the RoF arc, so Frieza probably didn't have to get that much stronger to catch back up. He probably got a couple times stronger at most.
Yes it is impressive since Goku got astronomically stronger in the Tournament of Power which I showed and clarified but you, with no surprise, ignored it. This is an example of you speculating BIG TIME:
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
Probably? So he didn't get stronger much because you think he didn't based on your own thoughts which originated from thin air? You could have went and made your own research or even read my argument which has the show beside it but you obviously, not surprisingly, ignored it.
dragon boss z wrote:Yes I know, which is why I do think it is possible for his ssj form to be SSG level. But he never said that while in base.
Yet it was later stated, shown by feats and implies that his Base far surpassed his Super Saiyan state from BoG which kept on surpassing SsjG BoG at an alarming rate.
[/quote]
dragon boss z wrote:I know, you missed the point. The point was that if Goku went ssj3 he would of been stronger than Beerus in the movie version. However he didn't do that. The only logical explanation is that he couldn't. So even though in the Super version where Beerus was way more than 8x stronger than him, if Goku couldn't even get from 60% of Beerus to over 100% of Beerus in the movie version, it is possible he couldn't power up the same way in the anime version.
What? I'm still not sure why you're comparing BoG to Super in the aspect of the scale Akira invented which is retconned by DBS. You're speculating this which is shown by how you're saying "it is possible", meaning there's a huge room for doubt and it isn't supported. I do get where you're coming from, but that is completely rendered invalid by the fact that if we follow this logic, we'll have to force the God scale into DBS. Goku in DBS hasn't recognized he got back to Ssj so him not going any further makes sense as he continued to fight as a Ssj, and hasn't noted anything like failing to transform.
Another point about the movie is that Whis said Beerus went 70% against Goku, but that was general which includes the moment where Beerus was going to eradicate Goku. That moment forced Goku to give up, which made him realize his utter inferiority. The 6, 10 and 15 scale might not mean 60%, 100%...etc since that's a fan calculated extended version of the God scale, and we don't know if this scale works linearly or exponentially. So that's out of the point either way.
dragon boss z wrote:Stopping that attack in base was just a cinematic choice that was supposed to be epic. It wasn't the writers intent to show "hey look base Goku is stronger than ssj Goku now".
You don't choose what's to be taken literally and what's Not. The same episodes were titled to have Goku surpass SsjG and this was represented by how Goku referenced himself and one's own limits of power, which was a direct reference to power. Either way, everything shown to us is to be taken into consideration
At some point you tried to argue this way claiming every single 50+ evidence to be the writers "Fucking up" or not intending the scans to mean that way, which you can't judge that since you and everyone else have no idea of that matter and what You're talking about
dragon boss z wrote:That's because Goku felt Buu's max power, Frieza told Goku exactly how much power he was using, and Goku went all out against a suppressed Cell who had regeneration, so of course he knew how he stood against them. And I know Goku know's he couldn't beat Whis after Beerus told him he wasn't on that level, but if Goku really got hundreds of times stronger since his fight with Beerus he would want to at least try and fight again.
Not really, as characters can tell who's stronger than the other by just looking at them. An example is Recoome. Goku even states that he recognizes his inferiority
just by looking at him which he bluntly implies and implies it has nothing to do with sensing. This same case goes to when Goku judged Pui Pui. Goku knew how powerful Buu is from the start and recognized that his power can drive deep from the start and that he could beat him as a Ssj3 prior to showing his power fully. What do you mean "of course he knew"? Provide evidence for that. He knew He's weaker than Cell and that he could not stand a chance against him by looking at him and that was before showcasing half of his power in front of Korin.
dragon boss z wrote:The problem is Roshi getting that strong that quick is story breaking. Roshi was confirmed to be just namek tier in the RoF arc, so that means in just a couple years of training he surpassed all of Z? That means if they put Roshi in the hyperbolic time chamber he could of defeated Buu... It means if he decided to train earlier he could of solod every DBZ villain...
That's a flaw in Toei's part and not mine. I'm merely following Toei's pieces which they left available to be picked. Roshi is shown to have gotten that strong, just like how almost all characters got retardedly stronger in DBS in a short amount of time to follow the pace of the high-end characters. Comparing DBS logic to the rest is not even optional, because both continuities have different logic than the other. In DBS, Android 17 skyrocketed into a God Tier Character in about 7 years while being a poacher only (obviously he wasn't a God Tier in the Buu Saga or even remotely close or else the Genki Dama would have vaporized Kid Buu without struggle. So that "Training" of his started at the very least after the Kid Buu died).
dragon boss z wrote:I don't think 17 is stronger than Golden Frieza, and according to a DBS writer and one of the guide books he isn't.
Android 17 miraculously combated Jiren and kept up with Goku and Vegeta on episodes 126 and 127, a blast of his struggled momentarily with a God Of Destruction blast and was capable of stoping Jiren's blast by a shield. Creating a shield and withstanding the opponent requires you to at least release 2x the energy of the opponent infornt of you or the power:
Barrier
First Appearance: Chapter 367
Category: ki manipulation
People: Artificial Human No.17, Cell, Vegetto
Special Characteristics: A technique where they use ki to create a barrier around themselves, guarding against their opponents’ attacks. It can guard against ki attacks, as well as physical attacks such as missiles. What’s more, Vegetto succeeded in avoiding being absorbed by Majin Buu (evil). However, in order to use Barrier, they must constantly emit ki. In order to cancel out the physical attacks and ki attacks of their opponents, they must emit at least twice their opponents’ ki. It could be called natural for No.17, with his infinite energy generator, as well as perfect-form Cell, who took over that infinite energy generator, to be able use this technique. Also, you can understand how Vegetto, said to be the best in the universe in everything from the control of ki to ki strength, would be able to use it as well. However, it seems that this technique cannot guard against the attacks of those who have ki far stronger than one’s own. (Daizenshuu 4, p.113)
Golden Frieza got glared. Nuff said
dragon boss z wrote:Ummm no. How did you come to this conclusion? Imo super perfect Cell is only about 10x stronger than 100% Frieza. Frieza could of surpassed that after a few weeks of training.
That is your logic as characters shouldn't get as strong as they have gotten in a short amount of time. Also, only 10x Namek Saga Frieza? I mean that is your opinion but it's kind of so controversial. So I'll leave this for another debate
dragon boss z wrote:What? Goku and Vegeta went ssj on all 3 of them, not just Basil. But all 3 are around Buu tier as even Basil on steroids is weaker than Buu.
Goku and Vegeta as Ssj struggled against Basil and Lavender yet base Goku fought Fit Buu and knocked away Bergamo who's superior to Both Basil and Lavender. Lavender > Basil on steroids. Rou expects that lavender should win against the other fighters before Lavender mentions anything about killing his opponents. Sidra states that basil is pathetic for getting defeated and Bergamo mentions that they underestimated universe 7, implying that basil was just a start up and thought Basil would be enough, rather than showing the stronger opponents. Lavender Kept up with Gohan who's above Buu before the poison gets to Gohan even.
dragon boss z wrote:This is true and I agree with it. My point is that you can't judge everyone's strength off of Goku and Vegeta because they power up for no reason half the time.
At some points they do power up for a reason and most of the time the other characters are shown to be of value, and some are casually knocked out by
stronger opponents which might be misleading to their strengths as they get wasted easily due to the characters which are quite considered high-tier in the Tournament.
dragon boss z wrote:Both base Kale and Caulifla are weaker than base Goku and Vegeta, that is made clear.
Ok So? I never disagreed and their bases are definitely weaker than Base Goku and Vegeta in the Tournament of Power, but this has nothing to do with the issue of Base Goku vs SsjG Goku BoG so this is to be ignored. But you definitely ignored the main idea of my comment, which clearly shows how their bases (Kale and Caulifla) are God Tier.
dragon boss z wrote:No, it's not what's shown. I actually kind of believe that originally Goku was supposed to have absorbed all of the SSG power but Toriyama changed his mind because it made them too strong
That's some quality speculation you got there. Problem is, it was never shown that Akira changed his mind so what you're saying is utter
speculation and nothing more or less. Getting too strong means he changed his mind? Haven't you seen shows with OP characters here and there? DBS has played the role of characters which far exceed the level of anything shown prior to it, so being "too strong" is not a reasoning and it's cringy to even consider it so. We don't choose what the intentions of character powers are, we simply follow what's given.
dragon boss z wrote:That is probably the reason Toyotaro decided to have Goku just keep the SSG form instead of absorbing it.
Manga is completely different than the Anime. Each scale differently, and here I'm using the Anime to prove a point in the Anime. I would use the Manga to prove something in the Manga, and same thing here. Comparing both together in an attempt to correlate each other is null. Also, Toyatora changes the plot under his own well. Akira's original intentions were to have Goku absorb that power and anime rolled with it, unlike the Manga.
dragon boss z wrote:And there is also the fact that King Kai was afraid that Goku had the power of a god without the ritual, and I know you brought this up and said that he didn't mean power, but he literally said "power" and why else would he be afraid? He was clearly afraid of the universe destroying power of a god.
King Kai never said or even implied that if was about power. In fact, it's quite the opposite; He was shocked of how Goku can go SsjGSsj without the ritual, because originally it was thought to be a temporary form. This is further supported as right before they move onto the king Kai scene, Gohan and Krillin were shocked Goku could go into a transformation beyond SsjG without the reference of Power at all. He wasn't afraid of the Universe busting Waves because Goku already cancelled Beerus's attacks and started controlling his SsjG Form:
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
King Kai clearly stated that he can't believe Goku could go SsjG without the ritual since SsjG was thought to be a form which is only achieved by the Ritual and has a time limit.
dragon boss z wrote:I already told you the argument. Things like Roshi and Krillin pushing base Goku is impossible if he is way above SSG level unless he is holding back.
He was holding back but that is quite evident and some other statements, feats and Implifications show that they are God Tier. What do you mean "impossible"?
Your argument is like this: "There's no way they're that strong! Although I have no proof, it's just.... impossible hurr durr". This is no argument, why do you think characters like Roshi and Krillin can't get that strong? While there hasn't been a proper build up for them in the first place, that is not to say we can disregard anything based on our baseless opinions, which is exactly what you're doing, and you're also
speculating quite a lot desperately just so that you want to stick to your
speculative point.
They simply got stronger, but you basically can't believe that because "T-There's nn-no way!" despite there's evidence against your speculation
dragon boss z wrote:Those characters clearly aren't supposed to be god tier.
You have
no obligation to suggest what's supposed to be and what's not so. We only follow what's
shown to us and that's it, not
speculate and then claim that this isn't supposed to be the. are based on our opinions and desperate trials which defy what's
given in the show. If you can't stick to what we're given then you've already lost this, from the start.
dragon boss z wrote:If you told Toriyama you think Roshi is above ssj3 Goku from the buu saga he would think you are crazy. I know what you are saying could make sense if you just take every feat and statement trying to make them as strong as possible, but that is not the author's intent. Those characters were never meant to be god level. Even people like Seththeprogrammer who high balls like crazy only thinks Krillin is namek to androids saga ssj tier.
He is the same person who originally wanted base Goku to become God Tier from the start. Both the DBS Anime and the DBS Manga are different from Akira's original draft as Toei and Toyatora manipulate many events from the draft so we have no idea what is Akira Toriyama's intention, so you're not to judge. I'm following the Anime which consists of direct feats and statements which prove my point. The author was never asked and probably there will be no need for that in the first place. Your logic is the same as saying Android 17 is supposed to be Buu Saga Tier at best because "There's no way! Intention-wise he isn't supposed to be that strong!". We know nothing of Akira's real intention, so what we follow is what we're
given. At least you concede that feat-wise, statement-wise and Implification-wise Base Goku > SsjG Goku BoG
Also, Why should I listen to SethTheProgrammer? He has multiple bullshits like denying what a Guide says, taking statements out of context, having 100 years Time Skip GT Goku beyond Ssj4 Gogeta despite GT Perfect Files stating that Gogeta is the strongest being in GT, and many more. He has some good instances but he's not to be taken under face value, as he's just like any other fan. I couldn't care less what he thinks.
dragon boss z wrote:I'm not judging who is fodder. Do you even know the definition of fodder? All the characters who are knocked off without dialog, are really weak compared to other characters, and only have a couple minutes of screen time are fodder.
Our topic is about SsjG Goku BoG vs Base Goku current so when you're saying fodder it appears to me you're making his also fodder to SsjG BoG based on speculative manners. The ones who are easily knocked away are mostly fodder or appear to be so only because they're knocked by powerful warriors and high-end tier characters or they simply were lazy to give a proper build up to almost all the 80 characters which were in the Tournament, either way it has nothing to do with our topic
dragon boss z wrote:I'm not ignoring the show, and the writers would most likely agree with me so your statement above seems kind of ironic.
Funny thing is, you never asked the writers and what they give us means little as the last time they answered a versus question they added the notion of "my personal point of view". We follow what the show gives us, and that's it. Inventing answers is not optional, and is not to be used in a debate because it's a
speculative point which is what you've been depending on all this time.
You have no argument. Yet you claimed that you could beat me in a debate? Failing to give evidence and only speculating renders you losing completely
dragon boss z wrote:Why not? Basil was one of the strongest in universe 9. Buu beat up a powered up version of Basil. That means besides Bergamo Buu is stronger than every person on universe 9's team. And just so you know feats hold more weight that implied statements.
No it doesn't. That just means Basil is weak in comparison to Buu. That proves nothing, other than Buu > Basil which has nothing to do with our topic. You inputted this thinking it makes sense, even though random points hold no value at all.
Lavender > Basil, but that's for another debate. Regardless, this holds nothing to our main issue so your point means
absolutely nothing.
Feats, Implifications and statements all prove my point so this throws you away. You tried to say that Ssj Goku is needed for Namek Saga to Android Saga tiers (you have Krillin at that), despite it being awfully contradicted. I applaud your efforts but they're all invalid. Honestly, you need to stop this
dragon boss z wrote:Goku said he would be usefull because of his skill, not strength.
No, Goku referenced power bluntly as possible which was relating to Krillin on episode 76 when he improved and got stronger. Goku and Gohan imagined the old Krillin fighting basil and based on his skills he was shown to hold his own, so skills is already set here. Quite clearly Goku referenced power and told Gohan Krillin will be fine based on what he knows from Krillin, which is episode 76, the last time he saw him.
You should agree to disagree, because you're clearly trying to stick to your opinion to the point you started speculating. I'll leave this up to you