Saiyan Saga plot hole?
Moderators: General Help, Kanzenshuu Staff
- Polyphase Avatron
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6643
- Joined: Wed Mar 27, 2013 10:48 am
Saiyan Saga plot hole?
They tried using Shenron to wish to kill Nappa and Vegeta, but he couldn't, since they were stronger than Kami.
But then why didn't they instead wish for their ships to disappear/explode, which would make them suffocate to death in space?
Did they just not think of that?
But then why didn't they instead wish for their ships to disappear/explode, which would make them suffocate to death in space?
Did they just not think of that?
Cool stuff that I upload here because Youtube will copyright claim it: https://vimeo.com/user60967147
- Blade
- I Live Here
- Posts: 2262
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 2:45 pm
- Location: Contrary to popular belief, not on Kanzenshuu forums.
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
It's just another case of the "Why not just wish for more wishes?" conundrum - in that either the characters in Dragonball are deliberately supposed to be so unintelligent as to never consider the idea, or the likely reason, that Toriyama wrote the story on-the-fly without any real thought for the wider implication of events in the narrative.Polyphase Avatron wrote:They tried using Shenron to wish to kill Nappa and Vegeta, but he couldn't, since they were stronger than Kami.
But then why didn't they instead wish for their ships to disappear/explode, which would make them suffocate to death in space?
Did they just not think of that?
I mean, Toriyama at least made some effort to limit the power of the Dragonballs by throwing in rules here and there, but at the end of the day the guy's writing is basically a narrative history of a cascade of deus ex machina. He was never going to be able to rein things in comprehensively - as it just went against how he worked.
'Multiculturalism means nothing in Japan, for every outside culture must pass first through the Japanese filter, rendering it entirely Japanese in the process.' - Julian Cope.
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
In universe, they simply weren't clever enough to think of that.Polyphase Avatron wrote:They tried using Shenron to wish to kill Nappa and Vegeta, but he couldn't, since they were stronger than Kami.
But then why didn't they instead wish for their ships to disappear/explode, which would make them suffocate to death in space?
Did they just not think of that?
Out of universe, because of plot reasons.
Well, I doubt that that wish could be granted. That only really works when there's no limit for the wishes. But there's really no reason for why wishing for the destruction of their ships would not work.Blade wrote:"Why not just wish for more wishes?" conundrum -
- Blade
- I Live Here
- Posts: 2262
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 2:45 pm
- Location: Contrary to popular belief, not on Kanzenshuu forums.
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
Based on what? It's never stated whether it would or wouldn't work, but what we do know is that no one ever tries. If the Dragon has the power to restore a whole planet, revive the dead or grant immortality - then why is it implausible that it's beyond its power to grant extra wishes?rereboy wrote:Well, I doubt that that wish could be granted.
My point, rereboy, is that there are a lot of occasions when the Dragon could have been utilised differently - but a combination of Toriyama never fully exploring or wanting to elaborate on the extent of the Dragon's capabilities mean that there are many instances where we can question the reasons as to why wishes weren't handled differently - the example I gave just being one of these.rereboy wrote:But there's really no reason for why wishing for the destruction of their ships would not work.
But there are, of course, many others - such as (but in no way restricted to): "Increase my power by X amount", "Seal X enemy away somewhere where he can't harm anyone anymore", "Erase X enemy's memories and make him forget why he wants to cause harm", "Give X enemy (or cure X protagonist of) an incurable heart disease (see what I did there?)" and so on...
'Multiculturalism means nothing in Japan, for every outside culture must pass first through the Japanese filter, rendering it entirely Japanese in the process.' - Julian Cope.
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
Because its very well defined that there are limits to what can be granted. That particular logic works only when there are no limits to the wishes. Its like: "I will grant you one wish!" "Will you grant me anything?" "Yes, you can ask anything at all!" "Then, I wish for more wishes".Blade wrote:
Based on what? It's never stated whether it would or wouldn't work, but what we do know is that no one ever tries. If the Dragon has the power to restore a whole planet, revive the dead or grant immortality - then why is it implausible that it's beyond its power to grant extra wishes?
In DB its not like that. Its more like: "Will you grant me anything?" "No, I can't grant you things that surpass the power of my creator, I can't grant the same exact wish more than once, if the wish is to revive a large number of people, I can only revive the ones who died at most one year ago, etc". "Then I suppose asking for more wishes wouldn't work, huh?" "Nope".
- Blade
- I Live Here
- Posts: 2262
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 2:45 pm
- Location: Contrary to popular belief, not on Kanzenshuu forums.
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
Whilst it's established that there are limits, they are are poorly defined, never fully explored or retconned as the story progresses.rereboy wrote:In DB its not like that. Its more like: "Will you grant me anything?" "No, I can't grant you things that surpass the power of my creator, I can't grant the same exact wish more than once, if the wish is to revive a large number of people, I can only revive the ones who died at most one year ago, etc". "Then I suppose asking for more wishes wouldn't work, huh?" "Nope".
Besides, to say that the power of the Dragonballs cannot exceed the power of their creator would be imply that Kami could restore people to life, and that Guru could revive entire planets - which we already know isn't true, that's totally beyond their power. Back when Kami literally was God as far as Toriyama was concerned, that particular logic would make sense - but as we know it was more or less superseded and retconned as the story progressed.
Basically: the in-universe logic is tangled and flawed. You can't really argue with what I'm saying using in-universe examples that are already contradictions, you're wasting your time.
'Multiculturalism means nothing in Japan, for every outside culture must pass first through the Japanese filter, rendering it entirely Japanese in the process.' - Julian Cope.
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
I stated that I doubted that it would work. Not that it would definitely fail. And I based my opinion on the fact that your example is thought up for wishes without limits, while the wishes granted by the Dragon Balls are grounded in their power by various limitations, which makes the chances of the Dragon Balls being able to grant something as abusive of their own power as granting more wishes fairly slim, IMO.Blade wrote:
Whilst it's established that there are limits, they are are poorly defined, never fully explored or retconned as the story progresses.
Besides, to say that the power of the Dragonballs cannot exceed the power of their creator would be imply that Kami could restore people to life, and that Guru could revive entire planets - which we already know isn't true, that's totally beyond their power. Back when Kami literally was God as far as Toriyama was concerned, that particular logic would make sense - but as we know it was more or less superseded and retconned as the story progressed.
Basically: the in-universe logic is tangled and flawed. You can't really argue with what I'm saying using in-universe examples that are already contradictions, you're wasting your time.
So, I don't think I'm wasting any time by stating my opinion, which happens to be perfectly reasonable and logical.
Last edited by rereboy on Mon Jan 20, 2014 3:36 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Pantalones
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1432
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 2:30 pm
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
They couldn't wish for Shenlong to destroy their ships because it would be essentially the exact same thing as just wishing for the Saiyans to die, which was already established as something Shenlong couldn't do. I'm guessing that you just can't "cheat" your way around the rule like that.
But yeah, the "within the creator's power" rule is kind of iffy considering all the things the Dragonballs get used for later on. I guess it'd probably make more sense to say that the power of the Dragonballs is proportional to the creator's power, and that (just like the Dragon Clan Nameks who made them) they're a lot better at creation/healing than they are at destruction (hence being able to restore a life or even an entire planet, but at the same time not being able to kill a couple of guys with a power level in the multi-thousands.) To put it in numbers, you could say their destructive potential caps out somewhere in the 300-600 power level range (closer down to where Kami himself probably is), while their potential for granting wishes of creation/restoration goes way, way, waaaay beyond that level.
But yeah, the "within the creator's power" rule is kind of iffy considering all the things the Dragonballs get used for later on. I guess it'd probably make more sense to say that the power of the Dragonballs is proportional to the creator's power, and that (just like the Dragon Clan Nameks who made them) they're a lot better at creation/healing than they are at destruction (hence being able to restore a life or even an entire planet, but at the same time not being able to kill a couple of guys with a power level in the multi-thousands.) To put it in numbers, you could say their destructive potential caps out somewhere in the 300-600 power level range (closer down to where Kami himself probably is), while their potential for granting wishes of creation/restoration goes way, way, waaaay beyond that level.
- DBZGTKOSDH
- Namekian Warrior
- Posts: 12401
- Joined: Sat Jul 02, 2011 7:45 pm
- Location: Greece
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
Did they even know that the Saiyans were traveling for 1 year?
James Teal (Animerica 1996) wrote:When you think about it, there are a number of similarities between the Chinese-inspired Son Goku and that most American of superhero icons, Superman. Both are aliens sent to Earth shortly after birth to escape the destruction of their homeworlds; both possess super-strength, flight, super-speed, heightened senses and the ability to cast energy blasts. But the crucial difference between them lies not only in how they view the world, but in how the world views them.
Superman is, and always has been, a symbol for truth, justice, and upstanding moral fortitude–a role model and leader as much as a fighter. The more down-to-earth Goku has no illusions about being responsible for maintaining social order, or for setting some kind of moral example for the entire world. Goku is simply a martial artist who’s devoted his life toward perfecting his fighting skills and other abilities. Though never shy about risking his life to save either one person or the entire world, he just doesn’t believe that the balance of the world rests in any way on his shoulders, and he has no need to shape any part of it in his image. Goku is an idealist, and believes that there is some good in everyone, but he is unconcerned with the big picture of the world…unless it has to do with some kind of fight. Politics, society, law and order don’t have much bearing on his life, but he’s a man who knows right from wrong.
- Polyphase Avatron
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6643
- Joined: Wed Mar 27, 2013 10:48 am
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
But it wouldn't be the power of the dragonballs killing them, it would be the lack of oxygen in space.Pantalones wrote:They couldn't wish for Shenlong to destroy their ships because it would be essentially the exact same thing as just wishing for the Saiyans to die, which was already established as something Shenlong couldn't do. I'm guessing that you just can't "cheat" your way around the rule like that.
Cool stuff that I upload here because Youtube will copyright claim it: https://vimeo.com/user60967147
-
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1214
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2013 11:50 am
- Location: Spain
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
This reminds me so much of DBZ Abridged.
You know, you could just ask ME, the Magical Dragon, to send them to an asteroid field.
You know, you could just ask ME, the Magical Dragon, to send them to an asteroid field.
I'm a webcomic artist! Check out http://tapastic.com/series/Hearts
Spoiler:
- Kamiccolo9
- Namekian Warrior
- Posts: 10353
- Joined: Fri Jan 11, 2013 9:32 pm
- Location: Regensburg, Germany
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
I thought that the Dragon Balls were incapable of killing Nappa and Vegeta because they were so much stronger than Kami was. Was it ever said that the Dragon Balls could not kill anyone?Pantalones wrote:They couldn't wish for Shenlong to destroy their ships because it would be essentially the exact same thing as just wishing for the Saiyans to die, which was already established as something Shenlong couldn't do. I'm guessing that you just can't "cheat" your way around the rule like that.
But yeah, the "within the creator's power" rule is kind of iffy considering all the things the Dragonballs get used for later on. I guess it'd probably make more sense to say that the power of the Dragonballs is proportional to the creator's power, and that (just like the Dragon Clan Nameks who made them) they're a lot better at creation/healing than they are at destruction (hence being able to restore a life or even an entire planet, but at the same time not being able to kill a couple of guys with a power level in the multi-thousands.) To put it in numbers, you could say their destructive potential caps out somewhere in the 300-600 power level range (closer down to where Kami himself probably is), while their potential for granting wishes of creation/restoration goes way, way, waaaay beyond that level.
Champion of the 1st Kanzenshuu Short Story Tenkaichi Budokai
Kamiccolo9's Kompendium of Short Stories
Kamiccolo9's Kompendium of Short Stories
Cipher wrote:If Vegeta does not kill Gohan, I will stop illegally streaming the series.
Malik_DBNA wrote:"Achievement Unlocked: Rule 34"Scarz wrote:Malik, stop. People are asking me for lewd art of possessed Bra (with Vegeta).
- thatdbzguy
- Banned
- Posts: 880
- Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2013 12:27 am
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
They'd never be able to wish Goku back if they did.
But yeah, DBZ is Plot-Hole Central. Considering how it's one of the worst written mangas ever, finding plot holes shouldn't be much of a shocking thing.
But yeah, DBZ is Plot-Hole Central. Considering how it's one of the worst written mangas ever, finding plot holes shouldn't be much of a shocking thing.
Khalid Shahin wrote:Yeah, pretty much sums the show up right there.Dragon Soul Funimation Lyrics wrote:Nothing ever dies; we will rise again!
- Gaffer Tape
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6054
- Joined: Tue Dec 08, 2009 5:25 pm
- Contact:
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
Sure they would. As Oolong says, they could just wish him back next time.thatdbzguy wrote:They'd never be able to wish Goku back if they did.
Do you follow the most comprehensive and entertaining Dragon Ball analysis series on YouTube? If you do, you're smart and awesome and fairly attractive. If not, see what all the fuss is about without even having to leave Kanzenshuu:
MistareFusion's Dragon Ball Dissection Series Discussion Thread! (Updated 4/1/24!)
Current Episode: A Match Made in Hell - Dragon Ball Dissection: The Super #17 Arc Part 2
MistareFusion's Dragon Ball Dissection Series Discussion Thread! (Updated 4/1/24!)
Current Episode: A Match Made in Hell - Dragon Ball Dissection: The Super #17 Arc Part 2
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
This is gettin' old, man. Discussing it in your own thread is one thing, but it seems you're just spamming this "point" at every minuscule opportunity. It's borderline trolling by its purest definition.thatdbzguy wrote:But yeah, DBZ is Plot-Hole Central. Considering how it's one of the worst written mangas ever, finding plot holes shouldn't be much of a shocking thing.
deviantART
FanFic: DragonBall GT Revised [thread]
Powar Levuls: Main Series | Movies and Specials | GT
Nintendo/PSN/Steam: KaboomKrusader
ACNH Dream Address: DA-1637-4046-7415 ("SlamZone")
(Not) lost (enough) DB Super plots!
A handy video guide to Kanzenshuu-level grammar quality!
FanFic: DragonBall GT Revised [thread]
Powar Levuls: Main Series | Movies and Specials | GT
Nintendo/PSN/Steam: KaboomKrusader
ACNH Dream Address: DA-1637-4046-7415 ("SlamZone")
(Not) lost (enough) DB Super plots!
A handy video guide to Kanzenshuu-level grammar quality!
- thatdbzguy
- Banned
- Posts: 880
- Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2013 12:27 am
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
No they couldn't. "Next time" they'd be able to use the Dragon Balls, it'd be well over a year.Gaffer Tape wrote:Sure they would. As Oolong says, they could just wish him back next time.thatdbzguy wrote:They'd never be able to wish Goku back if they did.
Shenlong can't revive people who've been dead for over a year.
Khalid Shahin wrote:Yeah, pretty much sums the show up right there.Dragon Soul Funimation Lyrics wrote:Nothing ever dies; we will rise again!
- Gaffer Tape
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6054
- Joined: Tue Dec 08, 2009 5:25 pm
- Contact:
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
Untrue. Shenlong is only limited to a year in reviving exceptionally large groups of dead people.
Do you follow the most comprehensive and entertaining Dragon Ball analysis series on YouTube? If you do, you're smart and awesome and fairly attractive. If not, see what all the fuss is about without even having to leave Kanzenshuu:
MistareFusion's Dragon Ball Dissection Series Discussion Thread! (Updated 4/1/24!)
Current Episode: A Match Made in Hell - Dragon Ball Dissection: The Super #17 Arc Part 2
MistareFusion's Dragon Ball Dissection Series Discussion Thread! (Updated 4/1/24!)
Current Episode: A Match Made in Hell - Dragon Ball Dissection: The Super #17 Arc Part 2
- DBZGTKOSDH
- Namekian Warrior
- Posts: 12401
- Joined: Sat Jul 02, 2011 7:45 pm
- Location: Greece
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
I think this happens only when they wish back a large amount of people. But then, they didn't know about that.thatdbzguy wrote:Shenlong can't revive people who've been dead for over a year.
And like I said before, they didn't know that they were traveling for the whole year. They could have been busy for a year, and then come instantly with a spaceship on Earth, because aliens.
James Teal (Animerica 1996) wrote:When you think about it, there are a number of similarities between the Chinese-inspired Son Goku and that most American of superhero icons, Superman. Both are aliens sent to Earth shortly after birth to escape the destruction of their homeworlds; both possess super-strength, flight, super-speed, heightened senses and the ability to cast energy blasts. But the crucial difference between them lies not only in how they view the world, but in how the world views them.
Superman is, and always has been, a symbol for truth, justice, and upstanding moral fortitude–a role model and leader as much as a fighter. The more down-to-earth Goku has no illusions about being responsible for maintaining social order, or for setting some kind of moral example for the entire world. Goku is simply a martial artist who’s devoted his life toward perfecting his fighting skills and other abilities. Though never shy about risking his life to save either one person or the entire world, he just doesn’t believe that the balance of the world rests in any way on his shoulders, and he has no need to shape any part of it in his image. Goku is an idealist, and believes that there is some good in everyone, but he is unconcerned with the big picture of the world…unless it has to do with some kind of fight. Politics, society, law and order don’t have much bearing on his life, but he’s a man who knows right from wrong.
- thatdbzguy
- Banned
- Posts: 880
- Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2013 12:27 am
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
Huh. If that's the case, then there really is no good reason as to why they didn't wish for that.
DBZ relies too much on the obnoxious stupidity of it's characters.
DBZ relies too much on the obnoxious stupidity of it's characters.
Khalid Shahin wrote:Yeah, pretty much sums the show up right there.Dragon Soul Funimation Lyrics wrote:Nothing ever dies; we will rise again!
- DBZGTKOSDH
- Namekian Warrior
- Posts: 12401
- Joined: Sat Jul 02, 2011 7:45 pm
- Location: Greece
Re: Saiyan Saga plot hole?
thatdbzguy wrote:Huh. If that's the case, then there really is no good reason as to why they didn't wish for that.
DBZ relies too much on the obnoxious stupidity of it's characters.
DBZGTKOSDH wrote:And like I said before, they didn't know that they were traveling for the whole year. They could have been busy for a year, and then come instantly with a spaceship on Earth, because aliens.
James Teal (Animerica 1996) wrote:When you think about it, there are a number of similarities between the Chinese-inspired Son Goku and that most American of superhero icons, Superman. Both are aliens sent to Earth shortly after birth to escape the destruction of their homeworlds; both possess super-strength, flight, super-speed, heightened senses and the ability to cast energy blasts. But the crucial difference between them lies not only in how they view the world, but in how the world views them.
Superman is, and always has been, a symbol for truth, justice, and upstanding moral fortitude–a role model and leader as much as a fighter. The more down-to-earth Goku has no illusions about being responsible for maintaining social order, or for setting some kind of moral example for the entire world. Goku is simply a martial artist who’s devoted his life toward perfecting his fighting skills and other abilities. Though never shy about risking his life to save either one person or the entire world, he just doesn’t believe that the balance of the world rests in any way on his shoulders, and he has no need to shape any part of it in his image. Goku is an idealist, and believes that there is some good in everyone, but he is unconcerned with the big picture of the world…unless it has to do with some kind of fight. Politics, society, law and order don’t have much bearing on his life, but he’s a man who knows right from wrong.