Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
Moderators: General Help, Kanzenshuu Staff
- Baggie_Saiyan
- Namekian Warrior
- Posts: 10283
- Joined: Sat Mar 30, 2013 5:22 pm
- Location: Atlantis.
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
I've had a thought what if Toriyama's version is how Goku looks period after the ToP? And whenever he engages in battle his hair goes wild.
It's the only explanation I have for why Toriyama designed it as such, because as others I'm at a loss for words otherwise.
It's the only explanation I have for why Toriyama designed it as such, because as others I'm at a loss for words otherwise.
- Luso Saiyan
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1479
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 10:33 am
- Location: Portugal
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
I'd rather they follow Toriyama's designs and guidelines whenever he provides them, so no. He didn't save anything. Nothing needed saving to begin with.
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
So you'd have preferred a design that just looked like a Super Saiyan God color swap?Luso Saiyan wrote:I'd rather they follow Toriyama's designs and guidelines whenever he provides them, so no. He didn't save anything. Nothing needed saving to begin with.
Yikes..
-
- Banned
- Posts: 534
- Joined: Sun Jan 28, 2018 8:18 pm
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
This...and I love and admire Toriyama greatly...but even geniuses fail on rare occasion.....t0ffe3m4n wrote:So you'd have preferred a design that just looked like a Super Saiyan God color swap?Luso Saiyan wrote:I'd rather they follow Toriyama's designs and guidelines whenever he provides them, so no. He didn't save anything. Nothing needed saving to begin with.
Yikes..
I don't know what happened or what Toriyama was thinking, but his drawing of mastered UI Goku was absolutely terrible. Like I wasn't expecting that at all...it was awful..
Thank god for Yamamuro
- Luso Saiyan
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1479
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 10:33 am
- Location: Portugal
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
I prefer however he envisions his characters to be as opposed to what fans want it to be. He should know, he created it.t0ffe3m4n wrote:So you'd have preferred a design that just looked like a Super Saiyan God color swap?
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
If he was so keen on his idea, he wouldn’t let anyone changed it like he did with Super Saiyan God. That didn’t happen here.Luso Saiyan wrote:I prefer however he envisions his characters to be as opposed to what fans want it to be. He should know, he created it.t0ffe3m4n wrote:So you'd have preferred a design that just looked like a Super Saiyan God color swap?
Kanassa wrote:Goku barely took a backseat in the Buu saga, at best he took a leisurely stroll round back while everyone else cried for him to come back.precita wrote:Goku will still be around but take a Buu saga approach backseat.
-
- Banned
- Posts: 534
- Joined: Sun Jan 28, 2018 8:18 pm
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
Err Yamumuro isn't some random fan on the internet. You do realise that the drawing of mastered UI Goku in the Vjump scan is from Yamamuro, right? It's NOT fan artLuso Saiyan wrote:I prefer however he envisions his characters to be as opposed to what fans want it to be. He should know, he created it.t0ffe3m4n wrote:So you'd have preferred a design that just looked like a Super Saiyan God color swap?
- Luso Saiyan
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1479
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 10:33 am
- Location: Portugal
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
You don't know that.HeroR wrote:If he was so keen on his idea, he wouldn’t let anyone changed it like he did with Super Saiyan God. That didn’t happen here.
Nobody said he was "some random fan on the internet". His design is different from what Toriyama drew because he adapted it based on what he, as a fan, wants it to be (or thinks that's what fans want, which is an even worse mindset). As opposed to what Toriyama drew.ZenkaiBoosts wrote:Err Yamumuro isn't some random fan on the internet. You do realise that the drawing of mastered UI Goku in the Vjump scan is from Yamamuro, right? It's NOT fan art
- mute_proxy
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1378
- Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2017 11:09 am
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
For some reason I don't like the hair remodeling, I mean I get the base hair, or the straight up SS hair, but the hair being just a bit lifted and motionless, just doesn't feel right. I do prefer the black haired version over the silver one, but if I were to chose between the silver designs, I'd pick Toriyama's
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
Toriyama fought to have his design of Super Saiyan God despite all the changes they tried to do with it like give Goku more muscle. He was adamant that this was what Super Saiyan God was going to look like. The fact that they changed UI Goku's design compared to Toriyama should tell you that he didn't care as much, otherwise it wouldn't have happened.Luso Saiyan wrote:You don't know that.HeroR wrote:If he was so keen on his idea, he wouldn’t let anyone changed it like he did with Super Saiyan God. That didn’t happen here.
Nobody said he was "some random fan on the internet". His design is different from what Toriyama drew because he adapted it based on what he, as a fan, wants it to be (or thinks that's what fans want, which is an even worse mindset). As opposed to what Toriyama drew.ZenkaiBoosts wrote:Err Yamumuro isn't some random fan on the internet. You do realise that the drawing of mastered UI Goku in the Vjump scan is from Yamamuro, right? It's NOT fan art
Kanassa wrote:Goku barely took a backseat in the Buu saga, at best he took a leisurely stroll round back while everyone else cried for him to come back.precita wrote:Goku will still be around but take a Buu saga approach backseat.
- Luso Saiyan
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1479
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 10:33 am
- Location: Portugal
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
Or they were the ones who ceased to care about being 100% faithful. We don't know. What I do know is that it's not how it was designed, and to me, they should be faithful to whatever Toriyama provides them.HeroR wrote:Toriyama fought to have his design of Super Saiyan God despite all the changes they tried to do with it like give Goku more muscle. He was adamant that this was what Super Saiyan God was going to look like. The fact that they changed UI Goku's design compared to Toriyama should tell you that he didn't care as much, otherwise it wouldn't have happened.
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
Very unlikely since they stuck true to almost all of Toriyama's designs up to this point with them given Future Trunks blue hair. And again, they tried to changed Toriyama's design for Super Saiyan God and Toriayama said 'no' and refused to bend on the subject. If Toriyama wanted that design for UI, it wouldn't have changed since we have real history when something like this happened. Not just a 'what if'.Luso Saiyan wrote:Or they were the ones who ceased to care about being 100% faithful. We don't know. What I do know is that it's not how it was designed, and to me, they should be faithful to whatever Toriyama provides them.HeroR wrote:Toriyama fought to have his design of Super Saiyan God despite all the changes they tried to do with it like give Goku more muscle. He was adamant that this was what Super Saiyan God was going to look like. The fact that they changed UI Goku's design compared to Toriyama should tell you that he didn't care as much, otherwise it wouldn't have happened.
Kanassa wrote:Goku barely took a backseat in the Buu saga, at best he took a leisurely stroll round back while everyone else cried for him to come back.precita wrote:Goku will still be around but take a Buu saga approach backseat.
- Luso Saiyan
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1479
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 10:33 am
- Location: Portugal
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
It's been a while since then. And he had blue air in his Battle of Gods design. They didn't change it then. Yet that's how he wanted it to be, considering that he drew him again with blue hair several arcs later.HeroR wrote:Very unlikely since they stuck true to almost all of Toriyama's designs up to this point with them given Future Trunks blue hair.
Fortunately.HeroR wrote:And again, they tried to changed Toriyama's design for Super Saiyan God and Toriayama said 'no' and refused to bend on the subject.
Toriyama did want that design for UI, otherwise he wouldn't have done it.HeroR wrote:If Toriyama wanted that design for UI, it wouldn't have changed since we have real history when something like this happened. Not just a 'what if'.
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
Been awhile, but we still have history that tells us if Toriyama wants something, it happens. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. So the fact that he allowed Toei to make changes to his original design should tell you that he didn't mind the changes. So trying to say 'well, that was a while ago', really doesn't cut it here. Especially when one of the writers of Super actually said that Toriyama has the final word on everything and all anyone can do is give him suggestions.Luso Saiyan wrote:It's been a while since then. And he had blue air in his Battle of Gods design. They didn't change it then. Yet that's how he wanted it to be, considering that he drew him again with blue hair several arcs later.HeroR wrote:Very unlikely since they stuck true to almost all of Toriyama's designs up to this point with them given Future Trunks blue hair.
Fortunately.HeroR wrote:And again, they tried to changed Toriyama's design for Super Saiyan God and Toriayama said 'no' and refused to bend on the subject.
Toriyama did want that design for UI, otherwise he wouldn't have done it.HeroR wrote:If Toriyama wanted that design for UI, it wouldn't have changed since we have real history when something like this happened. Not just a 'what if'.
Kanassa wrote:Goku barely took a backseat in the Buu saga, at best he took a leisurely stroll round back while everyone else cried for him to come back.precita wrote:Goku will still be around but take a Buu saga approach backseat.
-
- Beyond Newbie
- Posts: 224
- Joined: Sun Jul 02, 2017 3:53 am
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
Had they known that all of Toriyama's new designs would be recolors done with very little thought and effort, Toei would've probably just gotten someone with more creative talent for designing characters to do the designs. Someone like NakatasuruHeroR wrote:Very unlikely since they stuck true to almost all of Toriyama's designs up to this point with them given Future Trunks blue hair. And again, they tried to changed Toriyama's design for Super Saiyan God and Toriayama said 'no' and refused to bend on the subject. If Toriyama wanted that design for UI, it wouldn't have changed since we have real history when something like this happened. Not just a 'what if'.Luso Saiyan wrote:Or they were the ones who ceased to care about being 100% faithful. We don't know. What I do know is that it's not how it was designed, and to me, they should be faithful to whatever Toriyama provides them.HeroR wrote:Toriyama fought to have his design of Super Saiyan God despite all the changes they tried to do with it like give Goku more muscle. He was adamant that this was what Super Saiyan God was going to look like. The fact that they changed UI Goku's design compared to Toriyama should tell you that he didn't care as much, otherwise it wouldn't have happened.
- Luso Saiyan
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1479
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 10:33 am
- Location: Portugal
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
Again, why are you implying that he doesn't want what he draws? He is drawing it, hence that's how he envisions it, hence that's why he wants it to be. No ifs, ands or buts.HeroR wrote:Been awhile, but we still have history that tells us if Toriyama wants something, it happens. No ifs, ands, or buts about it.
Or he does mind the changes and they go with it anyway. An equally perfectly valid conclusion.HeroR wrote:So the fact that he allowed Toei to make changes to his original design should tell you that he didn't mind the changes.
Oh really? So why has he expressed criticism on the anime in the past (the extent of which is unknown)? Why do they change things that he provided if he has final word? Again, they are the ones changing the original design.HeroR wrote:Especially when one of the writers of Super actually said that Toriyama has the final word on everything and all anyone can do is give him suggestions.
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
As I said, history along with people who actually works on the show saying Toriyama has the final word on everything and all they can do is make suggestions like how Toyo suggested Vegetto and made Zamasu stronger. So Toei couldn’t just strong armed their design. So it’s weird that you’re using ‘they made changes’ as an argument when people in the know outright said Toriyama’s gets the final word. Unless you think they’re lying.Luso Saiyan wrote:Again, why are you implying that he doesn't want what he draws? He is drawing it, hence that's how he envisions it, hence that's why he wants it to be. No ifs, ands or buts.HeroR wrote:Been awhile, but we still have history that tells us if Toriyama wants something, it happens. No ifs, ands, or buts about it.
Or he does mind the changes and they go with it anyway. An equally perfectly valid conclusion.HeroR wrote:So the fact that he allowed Toei to make changes to his original design should tell you that he didn't mind the changes.
Oh really? So why has he expressed criticism on the anime in the past (the extent of which is unknown)? Why do they change things that he provided if he has final word? Again, they are the ones changing the original design.HeroR wrote:Especially when one of the writers of Super actually said that Toriyama has the final word on everything and all anyone can do is give him suggestions.
And as far as we know, Toriyama’s version maybe closer to a rough draft, not the completed version
Finally “he expressed criticism on the anime in the past”, yeah but in what? Animation, storyboarding, them not using his ideas?
Kanassa wrote:Goku barely took a backseat in the Buu saga, at best he took a leisurely stroll round back while everyone else cried for him to come back.precita wrote:Goku will still be around but take a Buu saga approach backseat.
- Luso Saiyan
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1479
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 10:33 am
- Location: Portugal
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
You're the one implying that Toriyama doesn't want what he draws, which is completely ludicrous. If he has final word, how come they go out of their way to change what he provided? Do they assume they know better? Do you think he enforced Trunks' blue hair? No. So much so that they did nothing. But he drew him that way since BoG. Only during the Future Trunks arc did they care enough to change him (but not his younger self). Toriyama didn't forced them to do it. Otherwise they would have done that right in the beginning.HeroR wrote:As I said, history along with people who actually works on the show saying Toriyama has the final word on everything and all they can do is make suggestions like how Toyo suggested Vegetto and made Zamasu stronger. So Toei couldn’t just strong armed their design. So it’s weird that you’re using ‘they made changes’ as an argument when people in the know outright said Toriyama’s gets the final word. Unless you think they’re lying.
And were are not talking about filling story gaps. We are talking about character design.
And maybe not. That's your assumption.HeroR wrote:And as far as we know, Toriyama’s version maybe closer to a rough draft, not the completed version
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
Luso Saiyan wrote:You're the one implying that Toriyama doesn't want what he draws, which is completely ludicrous. If he has final word, how come they go out of their way to change what he provided? Do they assume they know better? Do you think he enforced Trunks' blue hair? No. So much so that they did nothing. But he drew him that way since BoG. Only during the Future Trunks arc did they care enough to change him (but not his younger self). Toriyama didn't forced them to do it. Otherwise they would have done that right in the beginning.HeroR wrote:As I said, history along with people who actually works on the show saying Toriyama has the final word on everything and all they can do is make suggestions like how Toyo suggested Vegetto and made Zamasu stronger. So Toei couldn’t just strong armed their design. So it’s weird that you’re using ‘they made changes’ as an argument when people in the know outright said Toriyama’s gets the final word. Unless you think they’re lying.
And were are not talking about filling story gaps. We are talking about character design.
And maybe not. That's your assumption.HeroR wrote:And as far as we know, Toriyama’s version maybe closer to a rough draft, not the completed version
No. I am saying if Toriyama wanted what he drew, that would be in the show like he did for Super Saiyan God. You’re the one saying or implying Toei forced it, ignored what Toriyama wanted, despite people who worked in Super saying that Toriyama has the final word. In fact, he redrew Zamasu in the Super manga because he didn’t like how Toyo did it orginally.
Why the change happened isn’t known. But it wasn’t done without Toriyama’s permission based on everything we know about Super’s production.
Kanassa wrote:Goku barely took a backseat in the Buu saga, at best he took a leisurely stroll round back while everyone else cried for him to come back.precita wrote:Goku will still be around but take a Buu saga approach backseat.
- mute_proxy
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1378
- Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2017 11:09 am
Re: Has Yamamuro Saved Ultra Instinct?
So what you're saying Toriyama wanted a false black haired UI, a new random Vegeta form, SSRage and a Vegeta clone arc also? Say what you will, Toei DOES have a lot of liberties.HeroR wrote: No. I am saying if Toriyama wanted what he drew, that would be in the show like he did for Super Saiyan God. You’re the one saying or implying Toei forced it, ignored what Toriyama wanted, despite people who worked in Super saying that Toriyama has the final word. In fact, he redrew Zamasu in the Super manga because he didn’t like how Toyo did it orginally.
Why the change happened isn’t known. But it wasn’t done without Toriyama’s permission based on everything we know about Super’s production.