SupremeKai25 wrote: ↑Thu Mar 05, 2020 10:01 am
Tell me something that happened in Dragon Ball without the writers calling for it. Spoilers: there is nothing. Because this is fiction, anything that happens is because the writers wanted it to happen.
Okay...so bad writing doesn’t exist period, because it was ‘meant to happen’.
SupremeKai25 wrote: ↑Thu Mar 05, 2020 10:01 am
Also how was it bad writing? Black learned that there was a weapon that could take out his immortal partner and thus thwart his entire plan, so he decided to fuse to make sure they couldn't get singled out again. And no, it wasn't just "Zamasu's ki disappearing for a second" that made him call for fusion, it was Future Zamasu literally telling him that they made a grave miscalculation, that mortals couldn't be underestimated again, and that they had the potential to shatter their plans.
Zamasu didn’t see Black improving so quickly once again, Black shouldn’t have gone through with it, at this point Black and Zamasu could have slaughtered everyone eventually.
The ‘weapon’ you speak of failed, and it was about the only thing that could have stopped Zamasu apart from Zeno or other Gods.
SupremeKai25 wrote: ↑Thu Mar 05, 2020 10:01 am
He also wasn't really stupid... just very overreactive because he did not want to take any chances, especially after he had come so far and had sacrificed so much for his plan.
He was incredibly stupid...he got so powerful within a short amount of time and didn’t even bother reassuring Zamasu. At this point you’re looking for reasons to justify this mistake. Goku Black in the anime was a lot more calm than in the manga.
Grimlock wrote: ↑Thu Mar 05, 2020 12:27 pm
Nope. Vegeta refers Super Saiyan God Super Saiyan as "Super Saiyan"
in Movie 15 and I think in Toei's retelling too.
Nope, in Toei’s adaptation they referred to it as “that that has surpassed Super Saiyan”. You are bringing up one mention of SSGSS being called Super Saiyan, the majority of the time it is referred to by Blue in Super.
Grimlock wrote: ↑Thu Mar 05, 2020 12:27 pm
Because that is precisely what Super Saiyan Rosé is.
No hun, that’s what you want it to be. In the manga it’s SSGSS, in the anime it’s even been stated by Dragon Ball Park Monthly to be a “Goku Black version of Super Saiyan” and it matches SSGSS in strength.
If you want to think that, be my guest, but the anime is way different than what Toriyama envisioned, and nothing you say will change that, at this point you’re projecting head canon.
Miracles wrote: ↑Thu Mar 05, 2020 6:52 pm
The same level of Goku is BLUE, not SSJ. TOEI's writing is a mess with their non clarifications.
Because he knows about regular Super Saiyan and Super Saiyan God Super Saiyan. It matches SSGSS in strength but it isn’t his version of SSGSS. Whenever Son and the others spoke of Rosé they never mentioned “Godly Super Saiyan”, “Past a Super Saiyan”, they only refer to it as “Super Saiyan”, because it’s a Goku Black version of Super Saiyan, period, Zamasu knew about Goku and those forms, how do you think he came to steal his body? Toei’s writing is bad, but you have no leg to stand on in this argument.
Miracles wrote: ↑Thu Mar 05, 2020 2:55 pm
TOEI didn't explain anything about Black's forms. They just said he could go SSJ, lol. I posted the link where Toriyama's notes has Black able to go SSJ and then a SSJ of a different color from Goku's. That obviously means Black's Rose.Which isn't Toyotaro's idea since he followed that model note Toriyama gave. Having Black go SSJ and then SSJ Rose. As Toyotaro has stated, he does not deviate from Toriyama's main plot points. BTW, Toryima also wrote BoG and RoF, not just Broly. The Super series is adapted from BoG and RoF and his outlines. This is still his story, TOEI and Toyotaro are not coming up with the narrative. They get the main plot from Toriyama and fill in the gaps to get from the main point of Toriyma's story to the completion of it.
Toei drifts very far from Toriyama’s plot outlines. Not to mention his notes are very vague, Super Saiyan of a different hair color can be perceived in different ways especially under the amount of pressure they were under at the time, they simply made a mistake. As unfortunate as it is, Rosé is different from Toriyama’s idea as well as Toyotaro.