A post was made a few months ago here about how DBZ would be slaughtered today.
You can't ever count out a show dedicated to entertainment with flash, action and appeal to emotion with the epic music, voice acting and bone crushing sound effects. It's too much for the eyes to resist.
jeffbr92 wrote:They could have done better... Still with Jiren blasting Goku off the stage, but then having Freeza to blast Jiren on his back to also fall of the ring. We could end this god damn episode with Freeza being the last man standing, but no they have to include #17 in every way possible and even worst prolong the battle unnecessarily.
That has to be my biggest complaint about this episode, it's just unnecessary padding for the sake of padding. Unneeded padding, a second fake out death attack with no real impact, and only one more episode left? I'm strongly thinking we may get a cliffhanger at this point, which is not what I want.
Considering the movie will be a straight continuation of this arc, that should be more than expected.
Dbzfan94 wrote:But it's not even that. Just that his "sacrifice" was so poorly done that I knew he wasn't dead.
IKR, no sad song and stuff... I suspected about it, but I didn't want to believe as I thought they wouldn't be so stupid to play the fake death again.
Last edited by jeffbr92 on Sun Mar 18, 2018 12:49 am, edited 1 time in total.
Power levels are not just big numbers:
Spoiler:
Power levels establish tension and drama. People who care about them (well, people who care about them in a narrative) don't care about the big numbers or the fancy explosions. If you have character A who's so much above character B, who's the main character, you're gonna be left wondering how in the hell character B, the character we're supposed to care and root for, is going to escape the situation or overcome the odds. It makes us emotionally invested.
If character B doesn't escape the situation in a believable way that's consistent with previous events, then that emotional investment is gone. It was pointless tension, pointless drama made just to suck in the viewer. It has no critical value whatsoever. The audience is left believing that the author can just create whatever scenarios he wants and what happens to the characters is decided by whatever the author wants to happen, regardless of the events that happened in the story. Which, in fairness, is what happens, but the audience wants to be fooled. The audience wants to know that the world they're following has rules. That the world they're invested in isn't going to bend to external factors that are irrelevant to them.
An author can do whatever he wants with the characters, that's not false. But the author should also have the responsibility to make sure it fits in cohesively with the other events in the narrative he has created.
jeffbr92 wrote:They could have done better... Still with Jiren blasting Goku off the stage, but then having Freeza to blast Jiren on his back to also fall of the ring. We could end this god damn episode with Freeza being the last man standing, but no they have to include #17 in every way possible and even worst prolong the battle unnecessarily.
That has to be my biggest complaint about this episode, it's just unnecessary padding for the sake of padding. Unneeded padding, a second fake out death attack with no real impact, and only one more episode left? I'm strongly thinking we may get a cliffhanger at this point, which is not what I want.
Considering the movie will be a straight continuation of this arc, that should be more than expected.
Dbzfan94 wrote:But it's not even that. Just that his "sacrifice" was so poorly done that I knew he wasn't dead.
IKR, no sad song and stuff... I suspected about it, but I didn't want to believe as I thought they wouldn't be so stupid to play the fake death again.
I hear ya, I was just hoping they would wrap ToP up and at least get everyone back to earth for the movie. I just want to wash my hands with ToP at this point.
Hyena_Yamcha wrote:Am i the only one who's bothered with them not mentioning Yamcha at all in this episode ?
They show Yamcha in the group shot in Roshi's glasses when he was talking about all the friends Goku was fighting for.
Interesting enough Mr. Satan and Buu weren't in that shot, I guess Goku doesn't care about them as much.
For Mr. Satan, maybe Goku is secretly mad at him for taking his son's credit for defeating Cell. For Majin Buu, they'd have to draw Roshi's glasses twice as large.
Professor Freeza wrote:No. Nostalgia is a very potent argument. Honestly if DB or Z aired today for the first time, it would be SLAUGHTERED.
So you're quoting the wrong person as I'm not blind due nostalgia.
8bitdee wrote:You can hope that is better, but you shouldn't expect it to be. We have been given no reason to expect better when it's always been flawed.
Why not? I don't see why a TV show can not evolve to be better than what was on its past days.
Like I said, you can hope that it evolves but why do you expect it to? DBZ proved to be successful, so Toei has no reason to change its formula if it works. And the financial success of Super proves that. If you want something to be better, you let them know with your eyeballs and wallet. Since you're watching and paying for it (assuming you're not illegally watching) then you're letting them know you're okay with what they're doing, so you should not be expecting them to make a better product when the language they speak is "we're getting views+money so we're doing a good job just repeating what we did before."
Last edited by 8bitdee on Sun Mar 18, 2018 1:04 am, edited 1 time in total.
I was fine with this episode, I really was. Yeah, connecting Jiren's self-serving nature with goku's "wholesomeness (ignoring his assholeness early in the arc, and basically this whole seems to try to retcon the whole "Goku is a shit head who only cares about fighting") was clumsy, but I was okay with everything else. Clearly the week off was for this episode's benefit.
And then the final 5 minutes happen.
Sigh. DBS you couldn't help yourself could you? You just couldn't be not shitty for just one more minute.
I knew Freeza was going to comeback because he's too important to completely write off, and I still think he's going to be the major villain in whatever comes next. But 17, FUCKING 17, despite being told that he commited suicide, despite the show trying to wring as much emotion as it could from the death of a fan favorite, Super literally goes "lol jk" and just brings him back.
FUCK THIS SHOW. in a single moment, 17's reappearance represents just how utterly lazy and gutless Super's writing is. Now going forward, I expect any major event or sacrifice to be completely undone at any moment; nothing fucking matters.
People! Rewatch the episode right after Jiren trys to attack the Z-team. After Goku gets mad and punches him, Jiren unleashes a bunch of ki blast, you see Goku manuevering around them, what you MIGHT have missed is that Goku is actually riding along those energy blast with his own! SLow it down. That is so epic!
" I swear on that faith I can never back down now" - Goku
Turambar wrote:..........and that is why Dragon Ball is the best Shounen anime of all time.
Nope, let's not get ahead of ourselves.
The episode was great only due to action and animation. (okay, I do hope this is not the only thing that you care about)
Sorry. Thought that might be a popular opinion here
I don't really know what to think of 17 being alive. It would have been more epic for only Frieza and Goku to be there. The two guys who were enemies between each other long ago working together. 17 being there takes that impact away a lot, at least for me. I also said time again before my thoughts about 17's crazy power up in Super, about how I dislike it, and making him outlasting Vegeta in the tournament seems weird, I did expect that from Frieza, being a powerful and important villian throughout the series, but from 17? Wow it's like watching a different show to be totally honest.
So...with Jiren attempting to murder U7 can we finally classify him as a villain? What he did is no different than what Majin Vegeta did back in the Boo Saga. Truly despicable villain behavior.
MagmonKai wrote:That single episode topped 110 for me. Why couldn't that Tate guy work on DBS from the beginning? The show wouldn't have been even more awesome. Nothing to say but wow, such a good episode, too bad it's ending next week. What a bummer.
dragonball0900 wrote:I don't really know what to think of 17 being alive. It would have been more epic for only Frieza and Goku to be there. The two guys who were enemies between each other long ago working together. 17 being there takes that impact away a lot, at least for me. I also said time again before my thoughts about 17's crazy power up in Super, about how I dislike it, and making him outlasting Vegeta in the tournament seems weird, I did expect that from Frieza, being a powerful and important villian throughout the series, but from 17? Wow it's like watching a different show to be totally honest.
I'm still puzzled why people find it unacceptable for Android 17 to be that strong. When he was introduced he was stronger than SSJ1, so right out of the gate he was stronger than 100%-powered Frieza. Why is Frieza allowed to grow so much stronger in six months but not 17 in the decade since he was introduced?
Last edited by 8bitdee on Sun Mar 18, 2018 1:13 am, edited 1 time in total.
dragonball0900 wrote:I don't really know what to think of 17 being alive. It would have been more epic for only Frieza and Goku to be there. The two guys who were enemies between each other long ago working together. 17 being there takes that impact away a lot, at least for me. I also said time again before my thoughts about 17's crazy power up in Super, about how I dislike it, and making him outlasting Vegeta in the tournament seems weird, I did expect that from Frieza, being a powerful and important villian throughout the series, but from 17? Wow it's like watching a different show to be totally honest.
I'm still puzzled why people find it unacceptable for Android 17 to be that strong. When he was introduced he was stronger than SSJ1, so right out of the gate he was stronger than 100% Frieza. Why is Frieza allowed to grow so much stronger in six months but not 17 in the decade since he was introduced?
Because Frieza's power up had an explanation. His race was born like that and Frieza directly said that he would make big increases when training because of that. With 17 however, there was no statement whatsoever explaing his big power up, I understand if he gets stronger than SSJ3 and weaker than the God form, I would even tolerate if it was closer to the latter. But blue level? There are even lots of feats proving that and I just don't aprove of that.