Kanzenshuu members' favorite arcs!

[Soppa Saia People]

Uh, why are you discussing the ROF Arc in a thread that has almost no relation to it?

And you know I was the one who voted for it?

Right?

It does have a relation. I'm going to be ranking it when I get back from school

[Lord Beerus]

The one thing the Resurrection F retelling arc did better than the movie, was the ending. Everything else was a giant, hot, steaming pile of fecal matter compared to the movie.

FUCK. THAT. ARC.

I thought the retelling did everything better than the movie barring maybe the animation. The Shenlong wish plothole was fixed, no bullshit 1.3 million line, we got an explanation why Vegeta have the god powers, Goku and Vegeta's training scenes were great, no Shisami putting up a fight against Piccolo out of nowhere, Goten and Trunks actually sensed Ki and came, we got some great Muten Roshi moment for once that is not perverted, Tagoma is miles better than the movie and actually became one of my favorite henchmen, the callback to Goku sparing Freeza when Gohan defeated Ginyu, the infamous ring scene was done better, and I find Vegeta's fight against Freeza much more satisfying.. The only thing that bummed me in the adaption is the main battle and how they ditched the 1-inch punch.

In my opinion, the Super adaption of RoF is way better than the movie. Overall the movie have better animation, but even then it wasn't really anything special and quite dull. Tate's cut in #26 blows everything in the movie out of the water.

As for my favorite arcs, I haven't watch DB and DBZ for a long time so I can't really say anything now. My favorites one as far as I can remember is the Boo, Freeza, and Saiyan, and I dislike the Cell Arc. My favorite arc for Super is easily the Future Trunks Arc, with the Battle of Gods Arc being my least favorite.

The Shelong wish was never an actual plot hole to begin as he granted one before disappearing and then when was summoned again, he just granted the remaining two wishes that never did after being summoned before. There was zero explanation for how Vegeta got God ki beyond training with Whis. Something that already happened in the movie itself. Goten and Trunks arriving to battle contributed nothing other than a dick joke. I also thought the SSJB Vegeta/Golden Freeza beatdown last too long and cathartic feeling of that scene felt lost because the one-sided fight dragged on.

I will agree that the exclusion of 1.3 million line and ring scene were handled better. And while they did more with Tagoma than they did in the movie, they wasted it for Ginyu to return. And they instantly wasted that, too. I personally found Shisami a more interesting henchman than Tagoma in the movie so I was upset his role got demoted in the retelling. I also thought the additional training of Goku and Vegeta was kinda neat.

[Soppa Saia People]

Let's get right into the rankings!
#15

The Shadow Dragons arc! 1 Point
#14

The Baby arc! 2 Points
#13

The Golden Freeza arc! 5 Points
#12

The Champa arc! 6 Points
#11

The Goku saga! 11 Points
#10

The 21st Tournament arc! 26 Points
I'm a bit sad that the first two arcs only got 37 point between each other.
Tomorrow, we carry on with DB, have a 3 way tie (that ends Super) and get into our first Z related saga.

[Anime Kitten]

I'm disappointed that the ROF and Champa arcs were as low as they were.

My suggestion for tomorrow's ranking would be to add the number of points alongside the arc title. That way it would look a little more neat.

[MarCas92]

My Personal Rankings vs Result Predictions

17.RoF//////Super 17
16.Super 17//////Bog
15. BoG/////Shadow Dragons
14. Zamasu //////Baby
13. Universe 6 vs 7 Tournament//////RoF
12. Shadow Dragons///////Universe 6 vs 7 Tournament
11. Baby//////Hunt for the Dragon Balls
10. 22nd Budokai//////21st Budokai
9.Hunt for the Dragon Balls///// Red Ribbon Army
8. Piccolo Daimao/ /////22nd Budokai
7. Android/ /////Piccolo Daimao
6. Boo/ /////23rd Budokai
5. 23rd Budokai/ /////Zamasu
4. Namek/ /////Saiyan
3. Red Ribbon Army/ /////Boo
2. 21st Budokai/ /////Freeza
1. Saiyan/ /////Android

[Boo Machine]

Darn. I was hoping the 21st tournament would make it higher. Oh well. Number 10 ain't bad I suppose.

This is pretty neat though. It's like our own little DBcember.

[MajinMan]

The fact that the Baby arc is below ROF is sad.

[Soppa Saia People]

The fact that the Baby arc is below ROF is sad.

TBF, Baby got more votes. ROF only got 1 vote.

[kinisking]

My Personal Rankings vs Result Predictions

17.RoF//////Super 17
16.Super 17//////Bog
15. BoG/////Shadow Dragons
14. Zamasu //////Baby
13. Universe 6 vs 7 Tournament//////RoF
12. Shadow Dragons///////Universe 6 vs 7 Tournament
11. Baby//////Hunt for the Dragon Balls
10. 22nd Budokai//////21st Budokai
9.Hunt for the Dragon Balls///// Red Ribbon Army
8. Piccolo Daimao/ /////22nd Budokai
7. Android/ /////Piccolo Daimao
6. Boo/ /////23rd Budokai
5. 23rd Budokai/ /////Zamasu
4. Namek/ /////Saiyan
3. Red Ribbon Army/ /////Boo
2. 21st Budokai/ /////Freeza
1. Saiyan/ /////Android

This isn't a bad idea. If i'm not lazy later, I'll do an equivalent.

[Soppa Saia People]

#10-5
#10

The Red Ribbon Army arc! (29 points)
#9



The 22nd Tournament, The Piccolo Daimao arc, and The Future Trunks arc (all 34 votes)
#5

The Cell arc! (43 votes)
Tomorrow we finish this.

[Anime Kitten]

The Zamasu arc landed itself much lower than were my expectations. In contrast, the Androids arc resulted in a vastly higher position than I expected, as it receives much criticism on this very forum.

[Soppa Saia People]

The Zamasu arc landed itself much lower than were my expectations. In contrast, the Androids arc resulted in a vastly higher position than I expected, as it receives much criticism on this very forum.

TBF, The Cell arc had the least amount of points for the "Z" era.

[DBZAOTA482]

The Zamasu arc landed itself much lower than were my expectations. In contrast, the Androids arc resulted in a vastly higher position than I expected, as it receives much criticism on this very forum.

Vocal minority and in this forum's case, the minorities are the majorities.

[Lord Beerus]

Didn't know the 22nd Tournament arc was so loved. I found it good but nothing was really great about it apart from Goku vs Tien, which was a spectacular battle (despite the bullshit ending) and single-handedly propelled the overall quality of the arc.

[Doctor.]

I thought the 22nd Budokai was incredibly boring and just flat-out mediocre. I'm surprised so many people like it, I've always seen it as the weakest arc in the series, but I thought most people thought it was the weakest tournament arc.

[Soppa Saia People]

I thought the 22nd Budokai was incredibly boring and just flat-out mediocre. I'm surprised so many people like it, I've always seen it as the weakest arc in the series, but I thought most people thought it was the weakest tournament arc.

22nd tournament is the best tournament. It also has the best fight in the series.

Didn't know the 22nd Tournament arc was so loved. I found it good but nothing was really great about it apart from Goku vs Tien, which was a spectacular battle (despite the bullshit ending) and single-handedly propelled the overall quality of the arc.

I'm much more shocked that anything from Super beat out any of the OG arcs. That may be a case of recency bias.

[MajinMan]

The 22nd tournament is my second favorite arc, so I'm happy to see it get some love. I think there was a miscount in the rankings because there are only 4 arcs left, but the rankings stopped at #6. Unless I'm mistaken of course.

[The Patrolman]

Oh man I missed the deadline

[Soppa Saia People]

The 22nd tournament is my second favorite arc, so I'm happy to see it get some love. I think there was a miscount in the rankings because there are only 4 arcs left, but the rankings stopped at #6. Unless I'm mistaken of course.

The 3 way tie fucked me up. It's fixed now.

[DBZAOTA482]

I thought the 22nd Budokai was incredibly boring and just flat-out mediocre. I'm surprised so many people like it, I've always seen it as the weakest arc in the series, but I thought most people thought it was the weakest tournament arc.

Yes the tournament with the most character development, the best fights, and best atmosphere is considered the worst.