ABED wrote: ↑Wed Mar 18, 2020 7:50 pm
I would argue people place too much emphasis on the bigger stuff and not nearly enough on details and execution. I like new stuff as much as the next guy, but GT had plenty of new stuff, it just wasn't executed well.
Look if we're gonna talk about creativity or lack thereof, it should be noted how much of DB took inspiration from classic Hong Kong martial arts movies. He takes an awful lot from outside sources.
Well the assumption should always be that what is done is done
right, but it's harder to get into the nitty gritty details of stories that don't exist yet. And I would absolutely agree that GT's concepts were better but poorly executed, but that execution is more important than anything else. If DB
isn't going to go crazy with different ideas and structures (and let's be honest, the things people
call different in GT or Heroes are just lamer versions of what we've already seen with a new coat of paint), it should be the best version of the thing it's already been anyway. It's not like I'm saying "Dance party arc or bust" here, I just want a thing I enjoy. But I do think that, inevitably, Dragon Ball needs to evolve if it's going to break back into being something I take seriously as a story. No amount of Goku Black or Moro arcs will do that. If you say the name "Cumber" near me I'm going to call the police on you.
ABED wrote: ↑Wed Mar 18, 2020 7:50 pm
It worked for The Beatles and Metallica.
I don't know if this is sarcastic or not, I have literally zero knowledge on either of those. I'm just going to assume you're calling me a genius.
ABED wrote: ↑Wed Mar 18, 2020 7:50 pmAaaaaaaaaaaand you lost me. I have no interest in DB with other characters. That's not Dragon Ball. It's a story about martial arts. Why should any story not involve fighting? Hell, we've got those in filler episodes like the baseball one.
Is it really though? If you did a DB story where every enemy had weird powers that Goku needed to counter in a totally different way ala JoJo or Naruto, would it still count as martial arts? The complete lack of diversity or real thought in battles is the biggest issue with DB's fights nowadays. Even in the ToP, nobody's abilities really functioned all that different, and Goku solved every problem using overwhelming strength. It's
boring.
As for the characters, those suck too. Nobody
does anything anymore, but when they do, people complain, and it's because it feels like a pandering cop-out. People love Z, but they also constantly note that Goku is kept away from the fight a
ton of the time. Super shows why this is, and it's because Goku is so fucking strong that nothing feels challenging. The spotlight is spent on other characters a
lot in the stories people like the most, so where is the line drawn? We know we don't have to have Goku around most of the time to make a good story, we know he doesn't have to get the final blow on the villain (or at least, people like the Cell saga), so what's the limit?
Or hell, look at something like the Bardock special. Do you not consider that Dragon Ball? Because that's closer to the extent I'm saying here, and it's still pretty good. Bardock being Goku's father doesn't matter, that's the
point, and it's still good. Can we do a story ostensibly about nobody we've seen that just
happens to use Goku's iconography at various points and that makes it okay? What's even the difference?
ABED wrote: ↑Wed Mar 18, 2020 7:50 pm
So unique it won't be DB anymore... so, yay? If you are going to go this far left of field, it will be something else, so why not do something else instead of DB?
Because Dragon Ball is bigger than those two things? I read Jaco, and that really hits both of my marks. It's good! And... I also read it because I knew it was Dragon Ball. This cramped definition of what Dragon Ball can do is gonna kill it. If you're constraining what DB can be to a specific set of characters focused on a nebulously-defined "martial arts" you're just going to be stuck rearranging an already-small set of pieces in a different order unless you start retconning shit.
ABED wrote: ↑Wed Mar 18, 2020 7:50 pm
Yay commercialism. It's what gave us DB to begin with.
What the hell kind of mindset is that? If you're gonna talk like that, why do you even care if Dragon Ball gets better? Even if you say a desire for capital created the series, it's obviously a big part of what's holding it back right now.