If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
Moderators: General Help, Kanzenshuu Staff
- Cursed Lemon
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1377
- Joined: Fri Mar 22, 2013 5:29 pm
- Location: Location, Location
- Contact:
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
I think the question that needs to be answered is whether or not Nozawa's portrayal of adult Goku is heard as "feminine" at all by Japanese listeners.
It's difficult to imagine English Goku as having a mildly effeminate voice.
It's difficult to imagine English Goku as having a mildly effeminate voice.
Special Beam Cannon!
(゚Д゚)σ 弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌⊃
(゚Д゚)σ 弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌弌⊃
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
It’s not feminine to people with ears. Or at least no more feminine than what you would expect from a young boyCursed Lemon wrote: ↑Thu Jun 27, 2019 10:16 am I think the question that needs to be answered is whether or not Nozawa's portrayal of adult Goku is heard as "feminine" at all by Japanese listeners.
.
The whole granny Goku insults people like to throw on the Japanese version never had an iota of validity. She voices Goku like a young boy. Compare Nozawa’s Goku to any actual female character. Nozawa is clearly voicing Goku in a lower register so he sounds like a perpetual 10-year old
I think the problem is the fandom, largely, has a rigid idea of masculinity. Goku has bulging muscles and is super strong so he should have a deep macho voice.
It’s the same with the complaints levied at Clinkenbeard’s Gohan by old funi dub fans. “it’s too feminine” it’s no more feminine than what would be expected of a young boy who hasn’t gone through puberty.
-
- I Live Here
- Posts: 4186
- Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 12:09 am
- Location: Houston, Texas
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
The only time an English dub of Dragon Ball gave Goku a “deep macho voice” was with the AB Group dub. I never understood this argument that Sean Schemmel makes Goku sound “macho”. From what I can tell, this idea that Sean Schemmel makes Goku sound “macho” is often something detractors argue about whenever some dub fans try to claim that Nozawa makes Goku sound “feminine” and “gay”, which of course is a ridiculous notion itself.
I guess what I’m trying to get at is that Nozawa doesn’t make Goku sound feminine (in fact, part of the reason her voice works is because of how androgynous it sounds) and Schemmel doesn’t make Goku sound especially masculine.
I guess what I’m trying to get at is that Nozawa doesn’t make Goku sound feminine (in fact, part of the reason her voice works is because of how androgynous it sounds) and Schemmel doesn’t make Goku sound especially masculine.
- Robo4900
- I Live Here
- Posts: 4386
- Joined: Mon Oct 03, 2016 2:24 pm
- Location: In another time and place...
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
Even that wasn't really "Macho". Just deep. He didn't sound macho so much as he sounded rather aloof.WittyUsername wrote: ↑Thu Jun 27, 2019 11:28 am The only time an English dub of Dragon Ball gave Goku a “deep macho voice” was with the AB Group dub.
Rather a shame that the French English cast was handled so badly, though; I think David Gasman could have given us a really great take on Goku, if he'd gone for something more reminiscent of his Rayman.
Though honestly, even his deeper, aloof take could have been fun with better dialogue and direction.
The point of Dragon Ball is to enjoy it. Never lose sight of that.
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
I can’t imagine there’s any other woman on Earth that could pull it off, let alone in English; Nozawa is truly a one-off and Toriyama had an amazing instinct in imagining her as his voice. He cast her as Goku as a kid; she could’ve easily done well there but sucked as the adult version but she nailed it. There was no way of knowing, almost 35 years ago, that she would’ve put on a flawless performance as Goku Black, but it just happened that way.
I always imagined a male with a boyish, higher register being able to pull it off. Like Joshua Seth who played Tai in Digimon—he convincingly pulls off kid and adult roles (whether it would’ve fit Goku is another matter). After a time, Schemmel managed to stumble his way into a fairly competent Goku (I guess 20 years of practice will do that for you), but he’s still way too “bass-y” to have a kid voice.
I always imagined a male with a boyish, higher register being able to pull it off. Like Joshua Seth who played Tai in Digimon—he convincingly pulls off kid and adult roles (whether it would’ve fit Goku is another matter). After a time, Schemmel managed to stumble his way into a fairly competent Goku (I guess 20 years of practice will do that for you), but he’s still way too “bass-y” to have a kid voice.
Thanos before Thanos was cool.
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
Ehh I dunno I just rewatched the Akira dub a couple weeks ago where Joshua Seth voiced Tetsuo. I see what you mean of him being a male who has a naturally higher register but I can’t see him being a good Son Goku for some reason.Thanos wrote: ↑Fri Jun 28, 2019 8:37 am
I always imagined a male with a boyish, higher register being able to pull it off. Like Joshua Seth who played Tai in Digimon—he convincingly pulls off kid and adult roles (whether it would’ve fit Goku is another matter). After a time, Schemmel managed to stumble his way into a fairly competent Goku (I guess 20 years of practice will do that for you), but he’s still way too “bass-y” to have a kid voice.
I could see him as a good Kuririn for sure.
- 8000 Saiyan
- I Live Here
- Posts: 2841
- Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2016 9:03 am
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
She did Turles (who's basically Goku if he had never hit his head) back in the 90's, so I knew that she could do the same thing with Goku Black.Thanos wrote: ↑Fri Jun 28, 2019 8:37 am I can’t imagine there’s any other woman on Earth that could pull it off, let alone in English; Nozawa is truly a one-off and Toriyama had an amazing instinct in imagining her as his voice. He cast her as Goku as a kid; she could’ve easily done well there but sucked as the adult version but she nailed it. There was no way of knowing, almost 35 years ago, that she would’ve put on a flawless performance as Goku Black, but it just happened that way.
I always imagined a male with a boyish, higher register being able to pull it off. Like Joshua Seth who played Tai in Digimon—he convincingly pulls off kid and adult roles (whether it would’ve fit Goku is another matter). After a time, Schemmel managed to stumble his way into a fairly competent Goku (I guess 20 years of practice will do that for you), but he’s still way too “bass-y” to have a kid voice.
"It was deemed to be too awesome." - Scott McNeil on Dragon Ball Kai not being aired yet in Canada.
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
When I hear Nozawa I don't hear a woman's voice. People who use the slight that Goku in Japanese sounds like an "old woman" are just being prejudice.
It's kind of like Bart Simpson in English. He doesn't sound like a woman to me at all and when you actually see the actress performing the voice it's slightly disturbing.
It's kind of like Bart Simpson in English. He doesn't sound like a woman to me at all and when you actually see the actress performing the voice it's slightly disturbing.
- TheBlackPaladin
- I Live Here
- Posts: 3772
- Joined: Wed Mar 31, 2010 10:05 pm
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
I must respectfully disagree. To qualify as prejudice, the reasoning those people are using would have to be something along the lines of, "A woman shouldn't voice Goku period," or, "An old woman shouldn't be allowed to voice Goku." Yes, that would be prejudiced against women, old people, and old women. However, to say, "It's OK if an old woman voices Goku, but the voice that Masako Nozawa uses for him sounds like an old woman to me that doesn't feel like it would come out of that obviously male body, and it sounds distracting as a result"...is not prejudice, that's a subjective opinion.
Personally, I don't hear for a ton of people asking for Goku to have a "badass, deep, macho" voice. Rather, I hear people people preferring that his voice sound recognizably male. A great example would be Peter Kelamis--his voice is most definitely a high-pitched voice, but it still sounds like a high-pitched male voice. Thus, it's easier for a lot of people to accept. For that matter, I'm surprised to hear as many people as I have refer to Sean Schemmel's voice for Goku as "deep"...looking at all the other international dubs, he's actually one of the higher-pitched voices that Goku has had. Not the highest-pitched, no, but among the higher ones.
As much as we may not like to admit it, acting isn't all that matters when it comes to effective casting choices--the actor's look and sound are factors. For example, Danny DeVito is a phenomenal actor, but I'd never cast him as Superman. I'm sure he could act the part just fine, but his appearance would be distracting to the point where people would have a difficult time accepting that he's the "Man of Steel."
All that to say...there's nothing wrong with a woman voicing Goku, but where it gets tricky is that her voice definitely sounds like a woman's voice, and that's too distracting for many people. Heck, it was distracting for me for quite a while. I still don't think her voice sounds like it would come out of an adult male's body. Rather, I came to accept her performance as grown-up Goku by embracing how strange her voice was, and acknowledging that a strange voice fits for a strange guy like Goku.
A "rather haggard" translation of a line from Future Gohan in DBZ, provided to FUNimation by Toei:
"To think of fighting that is this fun...so, it was pleasant fight, as many as, therefore is a feeling which is good the fight where."
"To think of fighting that is this fun...so, it was pleasant fight, as many as, therefore is a feeling which is good the fight where."
- ABED
- Namekian Warrior
- Posts: 20280
- Joined: Thu Jan 31, 2013 10:23 am
- Location: Skippack, PA
- Contact:
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
Because Bart is a 10 year old boy.omegacwa wrote: ↑Wed Jul 03, 2019 2:11 pm When I hear Nozawa I don't hear a woman's voice. People who use the slight that Goku in Japanese sounds like an "old woman" are just being prejudice.
It's kind of like Bart Simpson in English. He doesn't sound like a woman to me at all and when you actually see the actress performing the voice it's slightly disturbing.
The biggest truths aren't original. The truth is ketchup. It's Jim Belushi. Its job isn't to blow our minds. It's to be within reach.
"You miss 100% of the shots you don't take - Wayne Gretzky" - Michael Scott
Happiness is climate, not weather.
"You miss 100% of the shots you don't take - Wayne Gretzky" - Michael Scott
Happiness is climate, not weather.
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
But here’s the thing Masako Nozawa’s Goku doesn’t sound like an old woman. You can certainly tell it’s a woman doing the voice but in the same way you can usually tell when a woman is voicing a little boy. You suspend your disbelief. Since people are using Nancy Cartwright’s Bart as an example, it’s very obviously not a real young boy doing the voice and you can tell it’s a woman doing a boy voice but “it’s close enough”TheBlackPaladin wrote: ↑Wed Jul 03, 2019 9:01 pm
I must respectfully disagree. To qualify as prejudice, the reasoning those people are using would have to be something along the lines of, "A woman shouldn't voice Goku period," or, "An old woman shouldn't be allowed to voice Goku." Yes, that would be prejudiced against women, old people, and old women. However, to say, "It's OK if an old woman voices Goku, but the voice that Masako Nozawa uses for him sounds like an old woman to me that doesn't feel like it would come out of that obviously male body, and it sounds distracting as a result"...is not prejudice, that's a subjective opinion.
Fans who refer to Nozawa’s Goku as “Granny Goku” are unquestionably being prejudice toward Miss Nozawa’s age and appearance rather than her talent or skill as an actress and judging the performance separate from the actresses physical appearance.
I’ve seen a smaller segment of fans who don’t like Nozawa’s Goku because it’s too high pitched or they don’t think Goku should still “sound like a little boy” which is at least an honest opinion and not “Goku sounds like an old woman because I’ve never heard an old woman speak in my life
Live action acting=/= voice acting. Physical appearance doesn’t factor into voice acting. Nobody is saying Nozawa should play Goku in live action.the actor's look and sound are factors. For example, Danny DeVito is a phenomenal actor, but I'd never cast him as Superman.
- TheBlackPaladin
- I Live Here
- Posts: 3772
- Joined: Wed Mar 31, 2010 10:05 pm
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
Certainly, but how strong a suspension of disbelief is will vary from person to person. I personally don't think Masako Nozawa's voice for Goku sounds like an old woman, but to be honest, I can understand why others would get that impression.MasenkoHA wrote: ↑Wed Jul 03, 2019 10:15 pmBut here’s the thing Masako Nozawa’s Goku doesn’t sound like an old woman. You can certainly tell it’s a woman doing the voice but in the same way you can usually tell when a woman is voicing a little boy. You suspend your disbelief. Since people are using Nancy Cartwright’s Bart as an example, it’s very obviously not a real young boy doing the voice and you can tell it’s a woman doing a boy voice but “it’s close enough."TheBlackPaladin wrote: ↑Wed Jul 03, 2019 9:01 pm
I must respectfully disagree. To qualify as prejudice, the reasoning those people are using would have to be something along the lines of, "A woman shouldn't voice Goku period," or, "An old woman shouldn't be allowed to voice Goku." Yes, that would be prejudiced against women, old people, and old women. However, to say, "It's OK if an old woman voices Goku, but the voice that Masako Nozawa uses for him sounds like an old woman to me that doesn't feel like it would come out of that obviously male body, and it sounds distracting as a result"...is not prejudice, that's a subjective opinion.
Oh trust me, I couldn't agree more!* What I meant was that there are qualities beyond an actor's acting ability that determine whether or not they're a good fit for a role. Using a visual example wasn't a good idea on my part as it doesn't illustrate my point. Let's put it another way: casting Gilbert Gottfried to voice Superman in an animated production wouldn't be a good idea, because even if his acting was perfectly on-point, his voice would make the character very difficult to take seriously.MasenkoHA wrote: ↑Wed Jul 03, 2019 10:15 pmLive action acting=/= voice acting. Physical appearance doesn’t factor into voice acting. Nobody is saying Nozawa should play Goku in live action.TheBlackPaladin wrote: ↑Wed Jul 03, 2019 9:01 pmthe actor's look and sound are factors. For example, Danny DeVito is a phenomenal actor, but I'd never cast him as Superman.
*That said, the Japanese voice acting industry is such that how "handsome" or "beautiful" a seiyuu is actually is taken into account, sadly. That's more of a modern development that wasn't in place back when Dragon Ball was first cast, but both Japanese animation studios and Japanese talent agencies nowadays see a seiyuu's physical attractiveness as part of their marketability...and, by extension, a reflection of the marketability of the projects they're involved in.
That shouldn't matter, because, like you very accurately noted, nobody sees a voice actor during their performance...but, that's the reality of the biz over in Japan now.
Worse yet, it's even starting to creep into the dub side of things--I know of a few anime dubs (at least in LA) where the Japanese producers requested headshots of the dub actors as part of their dub casting approval process.Thankfully this isn't super-common, but it has been known to happen.
A "rather haggard" translation of a line from Future Gohan in DBZ, provided to FUNimation by Toei:
"To think of fighting that is this fun...so, it was pleasant fight, as many as, therefore is a feeling which is good the fight where."
"To think of fighting that is this fun...so, it was pleasant fight, as many as, therefore is a feeling which is good the fight where."
- SuperSaiyaManZ94
- I Live Here
- Posts: 2714
- Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2019 9:01 pm
- Location: Alabama, USA
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
Exactly, i just don't get the level of shade and dislike that some people throw at her performance as Goku and to a lesser extent Gohan and Goten. Yes it's a woman doing their voices but so what? It doesn't sound "too feminine" or "old lady" and never has to me because she's been the one and only voice behind them all since the series began over 30 years ago. Then again i would bet some of those people complaining about her performance are fans of the dub who are so used to Sean Schemmel's take and have barely if ever watched the Japanese version. It's a unique performance among the many VA's behind Goku and never struck me along the lines in which those mentioned above criticize it for.MasenkoHA wrote: ↑Wed Jul 03, 2019 10:15 pmBut here’s the thing Masako Nozawa’s Goku doesn’t sound like an old woman. You can certainly tell it’s a woman doing the voice but in the same way you can usually tell when a woman is voicing a little boy. You suspend your disbelief. Since people are using Nancy Cartwright’s Bart as an example, it’s very obviously not a real young boy doing the voice and you can tell it’s a woman doing a boy voice but “it’s close enough”TheBlackPaladin wrote: ↑Wed Jul 03, 2019 9:01 pm
I must respectfully disagree. To qualify as prejudice, the reasoning those people are using would have to be something along the lines of, "A woman shouldn't voice Goku period," or, "An old woman shouldn't be allowed to voice Goku." Yes, that would be prejudiced against women, old people, and old women. However, to say, "It's OK if an old woman voices Goku, but the voice that Masako Nozawa uses for him sounds like an old woman to me that doesn't feel like it would come out of that obviously male body, and it sounds distracting as a result"...is not prejudice, that's a subjective opinion.
Fans who refer to Nozawa’s Goku as “Granny Goku” are unquestionably being prejudice toward Miss Nozawa’s age and appearance rather than her talent or skill as an actress and judging the performance separate from the actresses physical appearance.
I’ve seen a smaller segment of fans who don’t like Nozawa’s Goku because it’s too high pitched or they don’t think Goku should still “sound like a little boy” which is at least an honest opinion and not “Goku sounds like an old woman because I’ve never heard an old woman speak in my life
Live action acting=/= voice acting. Physical appearance doesn’t factor into voice acting. Nobody is saying Nozawa should play Goku in live action.the actor's look and sound are factors. For example, Danny DeVito is a phenomenal actor, but I'd never cast him as Superman.
DB collection related goals as of now:
1.) Find decent priced copy of Dragon Box Z Vol. 4 (Done)
2.) Collect rest of manga
3.) Get rest of Daizenshuu (2-7)
1.) Find decent priced copy of Dragon Box Z Vol. 4 (Done)
2.) Collect rest of manga
3.) Get rest of Daizenshuu (2-7)
- Gyt Kaliba
- Kicks it Old-School
- Posts: 8861
- Joined: Fri Sep 28, 2007 1:38 am
- Location: Arkansas
- Contact:
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
I've long started to suspect that that's started to creep in on the fan side of things at least a little bit too. While the week-to-week popularity will vary greatly, especially based on the announcement or release of projects they're in, I've noticed for a while now whenever I check Behind the Voice Actors for something that the 'Most Popular' actors on the side bar tend to be the ones that people would also call physically attractive generally. Hell, looking at the All Time Top Ten right now - Tara Strong, Jamie Marchi, Todd Haberkorn, Matthew Mercer, Johnny Yong Bosch, Bryce Papenbrook, Vic Mignogna, Cherami Leigh, Laura Bailey, and Monica Rial - while they're all actors with a ton of beloved roles, there's also not a single one amongst them that I haven't seen at least one person before comment on their attractiveness too.TheBlackPaladin wrote: ↑Wed Jul 03, 2019 10:52 pm *That said, the Japanese voice acting industry is such that how "handsome" or "beautiful" a seiyuu is actually is taken into account, sadly. That's more of a modern development that wasn't in place back when Dragon Ball was first cast, but both Japanese animation studios and Japanese talent agencies nowadays see a seiyuu's physical attractiveness as part of their marketability...and, by extension, a reflection of the marketability of the projects they're involved in.
That shouldn't matter, because, like you very accurately noted, nobody sees a voice actor during their performance...but, that's the reality of the biz over in Japan now.
Worse yet, it's even starting to creep into the dub side of things--I know of a few anime dubs (at least in LA) where the Japanese producers requested headshots of the dub actors as part of their dub casting approval process.Thankfully this isn't super-common, but it has been known to happen.
Again, I don't really have any proof phenomenon, but it's awfully curious to me.
AniManga Travelogue - Currently Reviewing: Dragon Ball (Z)
Twitter
Switch Friend Code: SW-0745-6427-7791 (let's play some Dragon Ball: The Breakers!)
Switch Friend Code: SW-0745-6427-7791 (let's play some Dragon Ball: The Breakers!)
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
I guess I don’t mean prejudice exactly, but I mean people hear it and immediately dismiss it as “granny Goku” as another poster stated.
I understand the voice might be “shocking” to someone who is first hearing it and saw the dub first, but to me, it doesn’t sound feminine. Compare it to say, Bulma, Chi Chi, Videl and so on. It doesn’t sound “womanly”. Undoubtedly it’s high pitch but that’s about it.
As much as I don’t really care for Goku as a character after the Namek arc I still greatly respect Nozawa and her performance.
Also to follow up on the Bart Simpson thing, I was just sighting that as an example of a woman voicing a male character in a way that is convincing and when you see the physical actress making that voice it looks odd because it does sound masculine. I understand Bart is 10 years old, but they have done “future” episodes with adult Bart and she still does the voice and it works in the same way as Goku, IMO.
I understand the voice might be “shocking” to someone who is first hearing it and saw the dub first, but to me, it doesn’t sound feminine. Compare it to say, Bulma, Chi Chi, Videl and so on. It doesn’t sound “womanly”. Undoubtedly it’s high pitch but that’s about it.
As much as I don’t really care for Goku as a character after the Namek arc I still greatly respect Nozawa and her performance.
Also to follow up on the Bart Simpson thing, I was just sighting that as an example of a woman voicing a male character in a way that is convincing and when you see the physical actress making that voice it looks odd because it does sound masculine. I understand Bart is 10 years old, but they have done “future” episodes with adult Bart and she still does the voice and it works in the same way as Goku, IMO.
- Super Sonic
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 5171
- Joined: Tue Feb 03, 2004 4:45 pm
Re: If a woman were to voice Goku in English, who should it be?
That's one of the great things about voiceover is that you're not limited to physical appearance as one may be with a live action performance. For example, James Avery and Kevin Michael Richardson did great voices for the Shredder. They couldn't play him in a live action role as they were different body types and not Japanese, but their vocal performances were good and fit well in animation.