Black holes don't work like that.Arugela wrote:We know he wasn't there before he reemerged. He went somewhere. So a black hole is a good bet. I think he went to another dimension then got back somehow. Possibly via IT. Or the black hole simply ran out of juice and reinverted itself and he popped back in.
Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Moderators: General Help, Kanzenshuu Staff
- Polyphase Avatron
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6643
- Joined: Wed Mar 27, 2013 10:48 am
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Cool stuff that I upload here because Youtube will copyright claim it: https://vimeo.com/user60967147
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Yup, we did. Here's the crater right after the spirit bomb explodes:Polyphase Avatron wrote:I don't think we saw the bottom of the crater after he emerged, did we?Asura wrote:There would have been another crater/more damage if he came from the ground with the eruption of energy though.Polyphase Avatron wrote:
That's what I was basing it on. I'm guessing he was just like a meter or so below the bottom of it. Probably the force of the explosion smashed him into the ground, or it's how he evaded it.
Here's the beam of light that happens when Goku's returning, notice it's directly in the center, meaning there should be a lot of damage/another crater directly in the center if he erupted from the ground there, but there isn't.
Now here's a view of the crater during UI Goku and Jiren's fight:
- apex_pretador
- I Live Here
- Posts: 2081
- Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2015 12:17 pm
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
I believe so. That "black sphere" just sucked in light within a range, which is literal definition of a black hole. As for Goku being sucked and other competitors not, we have to keep in mind that all competitors are strong and they were many times farther away from the black hole than Goku, who was basically almost at the event horizon and totally exhausted.
As for where mass comes from, the spirit bomb's energy was compressed into a singularity
As for where mass comes from, the spirit bomb's energy was compressed into a singularity
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
In this thread: no one understands what a black hole is or how one operates. Everyone makes up their own rules and explanations for what black holes are and how they operate so that they can confirm their own theories about how Goku and Jiren created a tiny black hole. The struggle. It is real.
My Full Rewrite of the Moro Arc
I've begun a full-scale re-write of the Tournament of Power! Here's Ch. 1, here's Ch.
2, and here's Ch.
3!
I've begun a full-scale re-write of the Tournament of Power! Here's Ch. 1, here's Ch.
2, and here's Ch.
3!
- Lord Beerus
- Namekian Warrior
- Posts: 21389
- Joined: Sat Oct 25, 2014 5:20 pm
- Location: A temple on a giant tree
- Contact:
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Hmm. So it's not really a black hole then, would you agree?Pluto wrote:It shrank considerably, massive black-holes are suspected to be smaller then our planet size, if not less.Lord Beerus wrote:It certainly looked like a black hole in first inspection. Given Whis' comments of how Goku fought against the power of Genki Dama consuming it, it would appear what happened is that the immense pressure for Jiren and SSJB Kaioken Goku pushing the Genki Dama back and forth, lead to the sphere itself collapsing and turning itself inside out. Revealing the void or passageway into the realm of the energy that the Genki Dama consisted off and where it collects and stores its energy.
If Jiren is strong enough to withstand the pull, and on the other hand Goku not, then the whole arena should've collapsed in no time sucking all the weaklings. Kinda hints to just a reference to have something "real" to compare to the powers, it may just be a reference after all, a lousy one though for us physics geeks.
Spoiler:
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Don't you think it's possible though that TOEI just made it look like a black hole to make it look cool, without even knowing themselves how it works or how it operates?Ziegander wrote:In this thread: no one understands what a black hole is or how one operates. Everyone makes up their own rules and explanations for what black holes are and how they operate so that they can confirm their own theories about how Goku and Jiren created a tiny black hole. The struggle. It is real.
It collapsed and sucked in the energy of the spirit bomb, then Goku fell into it, and then he completely disappeared. Until they eventually explain what happened to Goku there, the black hole theory is still a pretty solid theory if we're just going by the visuals, since like I said I doubt that TOEI would follow real scientific rules if they were going for a black hole here.
- Polyphase Avatron
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6643
- Joined: Wed Mar 27, 2013 10:48 am
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
I think it would have been a pretty important thing for Whis to mention when he was explaining what happened. No one said anything of the sort, instead they just said that the Genki Dama exploded and Goku may have been vaporized, then Whis said that he just barely evaded the explosion. I still think he was under the floor.Asura wrote:Don't you think it's possible though that TOEI just made it look like a black hole to make it look cool, without even knowing themselves how it works or how it operates?Ziegander wrote:In this thread: no one understands what a black hole is or how one operates. Everyone makes up their own rules and explanations for what black holes are and how they operate so that they can confirm their own theories about how Goku and Jiren created a tiny black hole. The struggle. It is real.
It collapsed and sucked in the energy of the spirit bomb, then Goku fell into it, and then he completely disappeared. Until they eventually explain what happened to Goku there, the black hole theory is still a pretty solid theory if we're just going by the visuals, since like I said I doubt that TOEI would follow real scientific rules if they were going for a black hole here.
BTW, in your screenshot of the crater floor after Goku emerges it's not very clear and we can't see for sure that there isn't more damage.
Cool stuff that I upload here because Youtube will copyright claim it: https://vimeo.com/user60967147
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Rather then judging, just enlighten us.Ziegander wrote:In this thread: no one understands what a black hole is or how one operates. Everyone makes up their own rules and explanations for what black holes are and how they operate so that they can confirm their own theories about how Goku and Jiren created a tiny black hole. The struggle. It is real.
Ps, we know jack shit about black-holes, and i happen to understand most of what science gave us so far.
Yup, either that or what just Asura said.Lord Beerus wrote:Hmm. So it's not really a black hole then, would you agree?
Asura wrote:Don't you think it's possible though that TOEI just made it look like a black hole to make it look cool, without even knowing themselves how it works or how it operates?
It collapsed and sucked in the energy of the spirit bomb, then Goku fell into it, and then he completely disappeared. Until they eventually explain what happened to Goku there, the black hole theory is still a pretty solid theory if we're just going by the visuals, since like I said I doubt that TOEI would follow real scientific rules if they were going for a black hole here.
In the year 42 of our god calendar, Zarma acquired a special patent for his original design.
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Myself and at least one other mentioned how, aside from the energy (or non-energy) being black, there is no other evidence to suggest Jiren and Goku made a black hole, because what we saw in the episode exhibited absolutely NONE of the behavior typical to a black hole. Gravity being especially the key thing missing. I don't know how to make that plainer.Pluto wrote:Rather then judging, just enlighten us.Ziegander wrote:In this thread: no one understands what a black hole is or how one operates. Everyone makes up their own rules and explanations for what black holes are and how they operate so that they can confirm their own theories about how Goku and Jiren created a tiny black hole. The struggle. It is real.
Ps, we know jack shit about black-holes, and i happen to understand most of what science gave us so far.
This thread can be easily summed up as, "Did Goku and Jiren create a black hole?" With several posters coming in to say, "Yeah, it looked like one, so I'm positive they did," or "Definitely. It was black, it was round, holes are round. Black hole."
My Full Rewrite of the Moro Arc
I've begun a full-scale re-write of the Tournament of Power! Here's Ch. 1, here's Ch.
2, and here's Ch.
3!
I've begun a full-scale re-write of the Tournament of Power! Here's Ch. 1, here's Ch.
2, and here's Ch.
3!
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Whis doesn't say he just barely evaded the explosion, he says:Polyphase Avatron wrote:I think it would have been a pretty important thing for Whis to mention when he was explaining what happened. No one said anything of the sort, instead they just said that the Genki Dama exploded and Goku may have been vaporized, then Whis said that he just barely evaded the explosion. I still think he was under the floor.Asura wrote:Don't you think it's possible though that TOEI just made it look like a black hole to make it look cool, without even knowing themselves how it works or how it operates?Ziegander wrote:In this thread: no one understands what a black hole is or how one operates. Everyone makes up their own rules and explanations for what black holes are and how they operate so that they can confirm their own theories about how Goku and Jiren created a tiny black hole. The struggle. It is real.
It collapsed and sucked in the energy of the spirit bomb, then Goku fell into it, and then he completely disappeared. Until they eventually explain what happened to Goku there, the black hole theory is still a pretty solid theory if we're just going by the visuals, since like I said I doubt that TOEI would follow real scientific rules if they were going for a black hole here.
BTW, in your screenshot of the crater floor after Goku emerges it's not very clear and we can't see for sure that there isn't more damage.
"In that big explosion, the raging power of the Spirit Bomb that entered Goku, and Goku's own power to resist it... Beyond that clash of power, Goku broke through the shell to the deeper potential within himself."
Whis was trying to explain how Goku got the transformation, but nothing about what happened to the spirit bomb or where he went or what that black hole looking thing was.
It's pretty clear given it looks exactly like the first picture before he re-appeared. There's no difference between the two pictures. Also there's this shot that I forgot about which shows Gohan & Piccolo in the same position they were before Goku appeared, and now after, and the crater still looks the same.
Before
After
I'd say this lends a bit more credence to the black hole theory, since it still begs the question of where the hell did Goku go if not another dimension of sorts? Plus if he was just under the floor, how come no one could sense him at all?
- Polyphase Avatron
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6643
- Joined: Wed Mar 27, 2013 10:48 am
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Those dust clouds could be obscuring the damage. And couldn't they just not have sensed him because his ki was so depleted?
Cool stuff that I upload here because Youtube will copyright claim it: https://vimeo.com/user60967147
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
What do you mean? You can see right through the clouds, they're transparent. They said his ki completely vanished as if he was vaporized, so I don't think it was because his ki was so depleted. Plus, how would he even get under the floor? The spirit bomb/black hole thingy exploded in mid-air, and Goku fell into it in mid-air, how would he somehow transition to be underneath the floor?Polyphase Avatron wrote:Those dust clouds could be obscuring the damage. And couldn't they just not have sensed him because his ki was so depleted?
- Polyphase Avatron
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6643
- Joined: Wed Mar 27, 2013 10:48 am
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
The animation is kind of hard to make out, and it's only on screen for a few seconds. I wouldn't put too much stake in your interpretation of how it looks. And it's quite possible for someone's ki to be so low that it can't be sensed... after all Whis said he was using the power of the Genki Dama to power his body, so they could have sensed that but not his own ki and figure that it was just the residual energy of the Genki Dama instead of Goku. I think when it exploded he was blasted downwards. I mean you see a pillar of light erupt from the floor and then he stands up from the crater floor... it just makes the most sense to me.Asura wrote:What do you mean? You can see right through the clouds, they're transparent. They said his ki completely vanished as if he was vaporized, so I don't think it was because his ki was so depleted. Plus, how would he even get under the floor? The spirit bomb/black hole thingy exploded in mid-air, and Goku fell into it in mid-air, how would he somehow transition to be underneath the floor?Polyphase Avatron wrote:Those dust clouds could be obscuring the damage. And couldn't they just not have sensed him because his ki was so depleted?
Cool stuff that I upload here because Youtube will copyright claim it: https://vimeo.com/user60967147
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Well, I guess you're free to believe in your own interpretation of the events since it's still unclear as to what happened (and hopefully it might be explained during tomorrow's episode), but I think there's more than enough evidence in the pictures to show that he didn't come from the floor. Even if you're having trouble seeing what's behind that smoke cloud in the second picture, it's off-center from where Goku would have come from, and it's also too small for that beam of light which would have made a crater the size of the light.Polyphase Avatron wrote:The animation is kind of hard to make out, and it's only on screen for a few seconds. I wouldn't put too much stake in your interpretation of how it looks. And it's quite possible for someone's ki to be so low that it can't be sensed... after all Whis said he was using the power of the Genki Dama to power his body, so they could have sensed that but not his own ki and figure that it was just the residual energy of the Genki Dama instead of Goku. I think when it exploded he was blasted downwards. I mean you see a pillar of light erupt from the floor and then he stands up from the crater floor... it just makes the most sense to me.Asura wrote:What do you mean? You can see right through the clouds, they're transparent. They said his ki completely vanished as if he was vaporized, so I don't think it was because his ki was so depleted. Plus, how would he even get under the floor? The spirit bomb/black hole thingy exploded in mid-air, and Goku fell into it in mid-air, how would he somehow transition to be underneath the floor?Polyphase Avatron wrote:Those dust clouds could be obscuring the damage. And couldn't they just not have sensed him because his ki was so depleted?
- Polyphase Avatron
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6643
- Joined: Wed Mar 27, 2013 10:48 am
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Lots of times craters are a lot smaller than the blasts that create them (look at the Genki Dama on Namek for example). Anyway unless it is further explained I'm sticking to what I said.
Cool stuff that I upload here because Youtube will copyright claim it: https://vimeo.com/user60967147
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Hey, if it turns out that the show ends up saying the Genki Dama was compressed into a "black hole" that sent Goku into another dimension where he trained with Zarama for 100 years and learned to utilize Ultra Instinct, I'm fine with that. I just think people in this thread are incredibly quick to jump to the conclusion that it was definitely a black hole because it sort of looked like one.
My Full Rewrite of the Moro Arc
I've begun a full-scale re-write of the Tournament of Power! Here's Ch. 1, here's Ch.
2, and here's Ch.
3!
I've begun a full-scale re-write of the Tournament of Power! Here's Ch. 1, here's Ch.
2, and here's Ch.
3!
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
Even if it was a black hole, Goku is well beyond universal, so he should be able to easily tank it. I think it was much more than that...
Then again, his body was depleted before he got hit by the bomb. Surviving that is much more impressive now that I think about it in those terms...
Then again, his body was depleted before he got hit by the bomb. Surviving that is much more impressive now that I think about it in those terms...
Re: Did Goku and jiren create a black hole?
And that is what we clearly are saying as well, from what i could tell, everyone was trying to make sense of it, without saying "In this thread: no one understands...".Ziegander wrote:Myself and at least one other mentioned how, aside from the energy (or non-energy) being black, there is no other evidence to suggest Jiren and Goku made a black hole, because what we saw in the episode exhibited absolutely NONE of the behavior typical to a black hole. Gravity being especially the key thing missing. I don't know how to make that plainer.
This thread can be easily summed up as, "Did Goku and Jiren create a black hole?" With several posters coming in to say, "Yeah, it looked like one, so I'm positive they did," or "Definitely. It was black, it was round, holes are round. Black hole."
When one assumes of knowing something, at least in a better manner then someone else, expression is key. Myself, i have no problems standing corrected, learning something new, but, belittling does not aid anyone, it makes any kind of "right knowledge" seem bad cause it's just not given properly.
Everything aside, it's a refreshing development, and it's worth having a normal, intellectual debate over it.
In the year 42 of our god calendar, Zarma acquired a special patent for his original design.