supercat wrote:
1. What does Namek Frieza > Base Goku (start of Super) have to do with Base Gohan (RoF)? Let's try to stay on topic, rather than try and compare two characters whose base forms probably aren't even close to one another.
Well I feel most people would assume base Goku would be above a base Gohan who hasn't been training. Though this isn't really confirmed, so fair enough. Though he did have some abysmal showings. For example when Shisami cam forward PIccolo asked if Gohan needed help against him and Shisami knocked away his ki blasts and Gohan let him grab on to him. Gohan's body was pierced by Tagoma's attack while his power was suppressed and read by the scouter to be above Ginyu force level, which means it was still below first form Frieza level (or else it would of been stated) though it was a cheap shot. And when he was fighting Ginyu in Tagoma's body, Ginyu said his power was disappointing, and if base Gohan was above 100% Frieza, I just don't see Ginyu saying that. Not only out of respect of Frieza's old power, but it wouldn't make sense for Ginyu to think Gohan would be that strong. I think if he was above Frieza in base Ginyu would be surprised by that power, not disappointed. But that might be looking to far into it.
2. Feats are greater than statements huh? So going by that logic, Roshi > / = Piccolo right? I mean why not? Roshi was completely out of energy, yet he was still able to push back Frost, who was not only stronger since his battle with Piccolo, but was completely fresh. Piccolo on the other hand, couldn't really do the same against a weakened Frost, who had just been pummeled by Goku just moments before. So no, feats do not outweigh statements.
Piccolo put up a much better fight against Frost, even if he was weakened. Roshi just took Frost off guard a bit and it was only for a few seconds. Piccolo technically overpowered Frost with one arm, block his attacks with one hand, and would of won if Frost didn't cheat. I don't see surprising Frost for a few seconds is a better feat than that. I will completely agree how stupid the Roshi feat was, but in no way was it better than Piccolo's.
3. And... I don't remember any statements indicating Gohan was weaker than his Cell saga self. Just that he wasn't at his best. As far as I know, Cell saga Gohan was not his best. Gohan's uncertainty about some of Frieza's men was likely pertaining to Tagoma or the fact that he just didn't want to underestimate in general.
True. All we know is Gohan isn't at his best. But since at this point he couldn't go ssj2 anymore, I think it's logical to say he is weaker than when he could still go ssj2.
4. Still doesn't change the fact that Roshi was completely drained when he was able to push back Frost, someone who is far above him. So this analogy really doesn't help support the whole Piccolo and Gohan were held back by some grunts on the Frieza Force argument at all.
I mean they are both stupid scenes. I mean even the lowest I would put Gohan and Piccolo, they still should be able to instantly beat all of the soldiers.
5. We're talking about the series here not the movie. And no, no one in Super said Perfect Cell > Tagoma. Implications and opinions are not direct statements, so I won't think otherwise until someone in-universe literally says Tagoma hadn't surpassed Perfect Cell.
But nobody said he did surpass Cell, and nobody ever said Piccolo surpassed Cell. Piccolo was considered fodder by Dabura who was Cell level. Vegeta thought he could win the tournament in the buu saga in base and Piccolo was going to be in the tournament (he may of just of been being cocky).
6. I don't know if you get the message behind what I meant about Roshi and Namek Frieza. I'm saying, Roshi pushing back someone vastly superior as Frost completely stomps the theory that Gohan and Piccolo were nerfed, since they were held back by the Frieza Force.
I mean it is a good counter, but Frost wrecked Roshi seconds later and was only pushed back due to surprise. It's not like the soldiers got in their way only to be knocked back a few seconds later. They were stuck behind them for a prolonged period of time.
7. This whole, "this happened in the past, so it has to be consistent" argument really holds no value. Strength increases haven't really been consistent in the past, because if they were, Vegeta (Saiyan Saga) wouldn't have gone from 18,000 to the low millions in the Frieza saga. So no, being too absurd of a power up alone can't really be a reason why Tagoma didn't reach Buu-tier. This is a series where massive power ups have taken place. Perhaps not to that extent, but until someone in-universe says it's not possible, I really have no reason to doubt.
Saiyan power boosts were explained with zenkais, Piccolo was explained with fussion, Krillin and Gohan got their power unlocked, and when someone got a big boost from training it was usually from a new intense type of training. I mean with Tagoma's case it may be less of a power thing and more of a special super strong body thing. It is mentioned multiple times that Tagoma's body is extra tough because of his constant beatings. He said his skin was like steal and regular attacks had a reduced effect. Piccolo also mentioned how it was dangerous for a guy to be that fast and strong with a body of steel.
9. I'm not going to repeat myself. And in fact, I'm getting really tired of this debate. Clearly we're not agreeing with one another, so why not just agree to disagree? I don't care if I can or can't convince one user to see it one way or another, and quite frankly, I know I'll never agree with your viewpoints. Really no point in continuing this debate.
I mean I don't know about the Japanese version because I can't speak it, but in the english version it is made clear Goku thinks Piccolo would be more useful than a untrained Gohan. Now if the english version messed up on the translation that's one thing, but I specifically said that's how it is portrayed in the english version. While for most of this debate we can agree to disagree, but if you say that (in the english version) Piccolo isn't implied to be above rusty Gohan in episode 30 by Goku, then you are just wrong. So I would actually recommend watching the english version (for you to say what you did almost certainly means you didn't) before responding to my argument. Or at the very least say "that's what I got from the subs". But unless you are fluent in Japanese I highly doubt you could fully understand the underlying tone of the conversation. So in conclusion, the dub may be wrong, but the dub clearly has Goku imply he wants Piccolo over Gohan, and it really isn't subtle at all. I recommend the scene, it's actually funny. Oh and I actually just looked back at another scene in the english version and Goku literally says word for word "We need someone who can fight right now and Gohan is way to rusty to help us".
10. Bad writing or not, a huge power up took place. We should be grateful this series even exists, rather than nitpicking and trying to cram everyone into some made up power scale, very few even seem to care about. About Piccolo, Trunks was impressed when Piccolo had powered up out of the RoSaT, and when Goku said Piccolo would lose, Trunks was surprised. So... why would Trunks have that reaction towards a semi-perfect Cell-tier fighter?
Trunks really wasn't that surprised, I just looked at the anime and manga. Goku wasn't even sure if Piccolo went in the ROSAT or not yet, but he did bring it up because he thought Piccolo was stronger. Vegeta wasn't that impressed either (anime only), but Trunks mentioning how strong Piccolo got was anime only as well.
11. No Piccolo just implies that SSJ2 isn't Gohan's best, and that by going Ultimate he could get even stronger, and literally be at his best.
He said awaken the power you had when you fought Buu, he didn't say "the form". Though I guess it can be interpreted either way.
12. Let Buu handle it doesn't mean they were going to dump all of it on Buu necessarily. Plus, Buu has regeneration and stamina that far exceeds Gohan's.
Ya, but it seems Buu was written out of the arc because he was too strong. And there are multiple statements implying he is the strongest besides Goku and Vegeta. He was also the first person Goku went to recruit for the U6 tournament.
Again, like I said, I don't think we can agree with one another, so let's stop this debate here. There's no way I'm going to adhere to any of your points, and it seems mutual.
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
This isn't directed at you, but no matter how many instances, statements, and feats one brings up it seems nothing will convince some people to just accept the way things are written rather than nitpicking every aspect of something. Constantly fussing over these minute details and arguing with one another only demoralizes the fanbase.
I debate for fun, and these threads are made for going in depth in the series. There are some arguments that would do just as you say. For example getting into a heated argument about how many galaxies character A can destroy. An argument that obviously can't be proven either way with no real evidence on either side about something that the creators didn't even think about. However respectfully debating how strong one character is compared to another is fine.
And you say that kind of like you think your arguments are the more accepted way and the not nitpicking version. While I agree with the Tagoma argument that is probably the case, it is absolutely not the case with RoF Gohan being stronger than Buu. So we are both trying to use head canon for different arguments.