Indeed. A direct comparison between the two should have been made in order to clarify the power scale. So, I doubt that Broly is superior to Jiren. Imo, he is near his Full Power, meaning that he could rival 3rd Omen Goku, subsequently all GoDs (given Goku's statement on Broly's power).Koitsukai wrote: ↑Sun Aug 11, 2019 1:01 amBut Broly was never stated to be stronger than Jiren, so your own logic contradicts your statement.Miracles wrote: ↑Sat Aug 10, 2019 8:30 pm ^Because Jiren being stronger than Beerus, simply is headcanon. Jiren can't be stronger than Beerus when it was never stated, secondly, Toriyama's next villains are stronger than the last, therefore, Goku not knowing if Broly is stronger than Beerus, who is stronger than Jiren, can't be the weaker of the two. It makes no sense because it destroys Toriyama's strength escalation narrative.
Besides, we shouldn't highball Broly that much on his first appearance. We are talking about an individual who went from below Base Goku/Vegeta to Omen 3 tier from just a couple hours of fighting. And he is just using his standard SSJ, which although can be stronger (×100 Base) it isn't like a god form. Kefla, a fusion of a Saiyan similar to Broly and another who had the advantage of learning extremely quickly, at her mutated SSJ2 was proved to be a match and actually weaker than Omen 2 Goku. So Broly is definitely a character who has received generous offers in terms of power.
Exactly my thoughts. Beers was meant to be stronger than Golden Freeza and this won't add up to the logic.PerhapsTheOtherOne wrote: ↑Sat Aug 10, 2019 9:17 pmBut is this narrative always in effect? It wasn't when Beerus was made to be this supremely powerful being from the jump from BoG to RoF, and Hit wasn't actually stronger than Golden Freeza considering he was overall inferior to SSB, even if that SSB was stronger than before.Miracles wrote: ↑Sat Aug 10, 2019 8:30 pm ^Because Jiren being stronger than Beerus, simply is headcanon. Jiren can't be stronger than Beerus when it was never stated, secondly, Toriyama's next villains are stronger than the last, therefore, Goku not knowing if Broly is stronger than Beerus, who is stronger than Jiren, can't be the weaker of the two. It makes no sense because it destroys Toriyama's strength escalation narrative.
Besides that, there's a strong case to be made from implications and statements that Jiren has the potential to be stronger than Beerus by proxy of how Beerus has been compared himself to other Gods of Destruction.
At the very least, I believe that Ultra Instinct is meant to be cleanly above Beerus and thus Jiren with his hidden power would logically be above this, since it was Jiren's regular full-power that was in contention for potentially being above Beerus. Broly doesn't have this since he only gets the same kind of comparison as regular full-power Jiren. You could say he'd be stronger than that, and I'd believe it, but definitely not Hidden Power Jiren and Ultra Instinct Goku.
The way I see it, it isn't about the next villain being stronger than the last one, it is about the effort and power that the heroes will have to exert in their fight that increases.Miracles wrote: ↑Sat Aug 10, 2019 8:30 pm ^Because Jiren being stronger than Beerus, simply is headcanon. Jiren can't be stronger than Beerus when it was never stated, secondly, Toriyama's next villains are stronger than the last, therefore, Goku not knowing if Broly is stronger than Beerus, who is stronger than Jiren, can't be the weaker of the two. It makes no sense because it destroys Toriyama's strength escalation narrative.
Against Beerus: Super Saiyan God
Against Freeza: Super Saiyan Blue
Against Hit: Blue Kaio Ken
Against Zamasu: Fusion/Spirit Bomb
Against Jiren: Blue KK, Blue Evolution, Ultra Instinct, Spirit Bomb
Against Broly: two Super Saiyan Blues, True Golden Freeza and Fusion
I threw the arcs of Super into the mix and it works, but Broly stays loyal to how the movies proceed in terms of this effort from the main characters. That's what I think is what everyone misinterpreted WITH Toriyama's plan.
Even the Z movies display this. And Janemba was perhaps stronger than Hirudegarn. Of course it could be an exception, but Final Bojack really pose a threat to LSSJ Broly? Anyway...