This is from the manga discussion thread, I brought it here because it was off topic there.
[spoiler]
lord turbo wrote:
Yes... beforr Namek, after Namek everyone appears to be aware of Freeza's final form, doesn't seem like a secret anymore.
Who? The only one who I think mentioned Frieza's final form after namek is Sorbet, the leader of the entire Frieza force.
How can you be so confidently sure though? I think Namekians are aware of basic math and simple numbers.
The Namekians don't even use power levels to measure strength.
There is nothing clear about it, that's just your personal opinion, period. If they were weaker than Freeza it would have been pointed out which it wasn't, therefore, Tarble is not wrong. It needs to be contradicted first for it to be wrong.
Being as strong as Frieza's first form is not being weaker than Frieza. In RoF Frieza said after 4 months of training he thought he could reach a power level of 1.3 million. I believe Frieza was talking about his first form (as it is the only thing that makes sense and the number is most likely based off of the 530,00 line in the F song), and I do think Frieza underestimated himself heavily, but the line was not delivered as a joke and I doubt Abo and Cado were stronger than Frieza's estimated power after 4 months.
And Tarble said Thode two were as strong as Freeza which Goku did not disagree with. We have two conflicting statements here, which one is correct?
They aren't conflicting, anything between a power level of 530,000 and 120,000,000 is "as strong as Frieza". Base Goku not being able to beat Frieza just means he can't beat Frieza, so it means he would lose to Frieza somewhere between "530,000 and 120,000,000". However we know base Goku is at least 3,000,000 so his base form would be somewhere between 3,000,000 and 120,000,000.
The fact that in the 7 year time gap between the cell and buu saga Goku and Vegeta only got a few times stronger max, due to the fact their ssj form was still weaker than ssj2 kid Gohan, means that it is highly unlikely he got 50x stronger overall in just his base.
The same movie that references the Tarble special and I thought we were counting the anime because it might be filler so why are you using it, yet I can't use the same anime that proves base Saiyans > Freeza (Namek era)?
And like I said the Tarble special never proves Abo and Cado are as strong as full power Frieza, and I never said the anime should be taken at face value alone. I'm saying if the line comes up in the movie, some people disregard it, but then the line comes back in the anime even stronger to try to put doubts to rest, I think the message is clear. In the manga version Beerus doesn't even say anything about Goku being able to beat Frieza until he goes ssj2. It's a similar line to the anime as well, "Well now I understand just how you managed to defeat Frieza. But it ends there, I see nothing more."
If you're going to write off the anime then don't use it support your own claims, only fair right?
I'm saying take the anime with a grain of salt as a lot of it seems like nonsensical filler. However Toriyama is involved and some plot points come from him. If a line is in the movie, anime, and manga, there is a high chance it came from Toriyama himself. Also if we go by what the anime said Tagoma is above the Ginyu force. He was never stated stronger than Frieza and he only beat a base Gohan and Piccolo who had trouble with Frieza soldiers Roshi could beat. Piccolo and Gohan also went down to the same attacks that took down skinny Roshi and Krillin, and neither of them died from the hit or even took serious damage.
Which is the exact same line unchanged, not from multiple sources like you claimed earlier, I forgot to mention in the anime and manga Beerus is completely unaware how strong Goku is until after he sees him in action so why is word held as law from a suppressed Goku that didn't even fight?
Which moment are you talking about? Beerus didn't know about Goku's further forms, bot I don't remember him being caught off guard by him after transforming. Whis was able to tell ssj3 Goku's strength right when he went into it as well.
That's false, Goku had zero issues with Yakon.
I guess. He was almost hit, but that could have been Goku just being cocky. I do think base Goku could have beaten Yakon on an even playing field.
18 was not dominating the kids, not even close, why are you ignoring the kids stated 18 used to be stronger than their SSJ fathers, yet start off the fight as base and make zero mention of 18 holding back?
Read the chapter again. It was a few panels of 18 casually beating them and Goten says they have no chance of winning lets go ssj.
Also to be clear I do think base Goku would win with kaioken easily and with all of his techniques he does have a chance of winning based off that. But in just flat out raw power, 100% Frieza should hold the edge.[/spoiler]
lord turbo wrote:
Other than Future Trunks verbally mentioning he increased the boost of his SS2, and it was addressed, SS2 Future Trunks = SS3 Goku. SS2 Vegeta > SS(2?) Black > SS2 Future Trunks = SS3 Goku > base Goku = base Vegeta.
It may have been regular ssj2 Trunks fighting base Black, and powered up ssj2 Trunks was weaker than ssj3 Goku, and Goku may not have been at max power like he wasn't at max power against fat Buu. If Vegeta found a way to increase his ssj2 like Trunks did, (possibly the rage boost against Beerus let him learn from the experience like how Goku learned from SSG in the anime) then I could see his ssj2 being above ssj3 Goku.
Its a power comparison, someone made a false comparison and was corrected, yet you act like the characters wouldn't or haven't done this before.
It depends on the situation. Abo and Cado being in the realm of Frieza doesn't need to be corrected. Goku could sense how strong they were and he knew how strong Frieza was throughout his time on Namek.
Piccolo wasn't nerfed, more baseless speculation and DBS is a
collaborated effort, one where Toriyana hinself says he doesn't mind where others take liberities with his story. Who are you, some random poster on the internet, to decide whay counts and doesn't in DB, you have no official say or authority to make such calls in the first place.
Piccolo was stopped by Frieza fodder and taken out by moves that skinny Roshi survived. Sounds nerfed to me. And I'm not saying what does and doesn't count, if you want to go by anime continuity then that's fine, but I could also say Piccolo got weaker. I mean Tagoma getting so strong pretty much breaks the continuity as it means he had more growth than a ssj training for multiple years in the ROSAT. A zarbon level soldier getting beaten up for a few months reaching close to perfect Cell tier basically means his potential craps all over the legendary ssj transformation and Piccolo fused with two other Namekians, lol. Even Nail by himself had a higher base power level than Zarbon, Tagoma reaching that level of strength so quickly makes no sense no matter how you look at it. Now if it was mentioned his race actually has some crazy ability like saiyans that multiplies their power after near death that would be one thing, but nothing like that was mentioned.
Not quite, we know at least SSJ for Goku is above a KKx20 boost and Goku and Vegeta are shown equal in all of their (Minus SS2) forms consistently in the DBS manga so doing simple deduction U6 and Zamasu arc base and SS Goku and Vegeta are more or less the same as their Buu Saga selves, something I've been saying this entire time
That is not backed up by your weight argument at all. 23rd budokai flippled giant Piccolo in the air. That feat is already in the dozens of tons range. So is buu saga and dbs base Goku a similar level of power to 23rd budokai Goku? no.
You realize you can't prove anything right? You're just stubbornly going "Nuh Uh" at this point to which I have nothing more to say to you.
I did give evidence, you just ignore it. Saying "his power is amazing" means it was amazing compared to his final form. 1.5x stronger is not amazingly stronger.
Prove it, also, Goku was fighting the same in base as he was in SSG when he lost it, yet, when he went SS there was zero change in performance so I disagree with your opinion there.
Ok, so if you think going ssj and ssj3 no longer makes base Goku stronger, but that is contradicted later in the series as the power ups clearly give him boosts again.
Freeza simply stated Caulifla was stronger than SS Goku on Namek, not extra adjectives like much/far stronger.
Either way, he only said that after she went ssj.
Not with its power scaling it doesn't,
The only real problem is final form Frieza being weaker than base Goku, but stronger than Piccolo and ssj Gohan by a large degree. If we go by the manga I would think Goku would need ssj to do what he did against Frieza, but that could be explained by Frieza not being at full power yet, or Goku holding back in the manga during the U6 tournament, which is likely considering when assault form Frost hit him Goku actually wasn't hurt and said that he finally felt something. Also as kid Goku said, his tournament strength is different from his killing strength or however he said it.
also RoF film doesn't exist in some vacuum separate from BoGs film either so...
I didn't say didn't. RoF is definitely the sequel to BoG, I'm saying that as of now it is the best thing that fits into the manga continuity for the RoF arc. Like if someone wanted to just read the manga but get the complete story as of now the RoF movie seems to be the best option to fill that gap.