Hellspawn28 wrote:Toei tends to rehash a lot of old ideas. If AT had nothing to do with BOG, Beerus would have been a brainless idiot similar to Broli and has a transformation that is super buff up. The other DBZ movies and GT rehash old ideas as well.
Beerus would have been an exact clone of Freeza it Toriyama didn't interject with his cat design, thank god for that. A lizard like Freeza.... with powers to make powers to make people evil...... like Babidi? Toei would have really made BoG a lot worse than it was I admit.
OWmyDragonBallz wrote: And yet, Minus turned out to be bullshit as it contradicts the manga severely, but this doesn't surprise me as Toriyama is extremely forgetful. Dragon Ball ended a long time ago. His thought process back then was that it was over after he ended the manga. All these retcons like DB minus are just for entertainment. I would place them in the alternate universe category with things such as the SSJ Bardock special.
The only think Minus contrasts greatly is with Goku's launch to earth and its meaning behind it. For the worst arguably beyond the already restated concept that Goku was sent there purposely to destroy it, not to hide from Freeza. The real damage though is the meaning of him being the first on screen SSJ. His very symbplism was the fact that he defied his darker ancestory in favour of a brighter path created from his good heart and warrior acceptance... according to Minus it was all just luck.
OWmyDragonBallz wrote:Still though, Toriyama didn't put any originality into Minus. It seems like a giant Superman rip off. The animated Bardock special seems to make a hell of a lot more sense. But I guess to be fair, that's in the Anime's continuity while Minus can be in the manga's if you truly want to take it literal to the manga's. But both versions still give off the same message that Goku was sent to earth as a kid to avoid Freeza. The outcome was the same, but the way they went about it was a bit different.
^This I agree with entirely. That very detail that Goku was sent away by his parents to escape an exploding planet pedated by his parent's foresought fears is - indeed a superman swipe. It hurt the series more because the original story was infact the most original conceot of the situation, it was the argument easily distinguished Goku from Superman and the source of his character development. Now its all gone in favour of genericism.
DBZGTKOSDH wrote:Bardock & Gine couldn't tell their true intentions to Raditz, because Freeza would have heard everything, since they could only talk through scouters. Which is why Raditz thought that Goku was in a mission: they lied to him so that he can know his location.
Thats not at all a farfetched potential plot- band-aid but its all speculatory like everything else we try to make sense of, AT never tries to fix them himself which is whats breaking up the already solid story.
DieHard wrote:OWmyDragonBallz wrote:Still though, Toriyama didn't put any originality into Minus. It seems like a giant Superman rip off.
Cuz being an alien of an species which planet was destroyed with only other 3 survivors who visit earth wasnt already a ripoff.LOL
Its just a small coincidence. A state of being isnt really ripping it off. Its just a likely referencial circumstance.