dragon boss z wrote:
Just because 18 was shocked from their power doesn't mean they are stronger though. Roshi was shocked at kid Goku's power, but Roshi was still leagues above him if he got serious. And in the anime ssj Goten and Trunks teemed up on 18 for a while and she held them back, which pretty much means the writers of the anime also must of thought 18 was at least stronger than them individually, and the funimation dub had 18 say she was scared for the audience.
Tbh there is proof both ways. But if they did surpass 18 I would say it's more likely they did it after their ROSAT training.
The anime is clearly wrong on that part. They also made a movie (the one with Bio Broly) where they showed Goten and Trunks being able to damage an opponent that stomped Android 18. That part of their fight between SSJ Trunks and Goten vs Android 18 was filler and was not in the manga, it's like how it was showed the Ginyu Force vs Yamcha, Tien and Chiaotzu, fillers that contradict power scalling. And the funimation dub is something we shouldn't trust at all.
dragon boss z wrote:
18 never said it was dangerous for her though. And she seemed pretty confident she could end it. She flat out said she was going to win right after that attack. So at the very least she should be above their suppressed level that she saw.
And I know the anime and funimation shouldn't be used, but I was just showing how the people who are in charge of the anime and the dub interpreted a certain way. If it really was as clear as you are saying that Goten and Trunks were above 18 that wouldn't of ever made it through.
If Android 18 was confident she could finish the battle by winning, then why she decided to cut through half the disguise of Mighty Mask? She knew that was the only option, she could've easily continue the match if she was stronger than them, but she didn't continue it. She was saying how much power it has the attack.
dragon boss z wrote:
Well 18 never said she thought she could lose. And she wouldn't know for sure if they would get disqualified. I do agree funimation's interpretations could be off. Including Toei's interpratiations, I'm just saying this isn't black and white. There are arguments on both sides.
She did know they would get disqualified since she was present when the kids weren't allowed to participate. If she thought she wouldn't lose then there would be no reason why she decided to cut the Mighty Mask disguise. Android 18 clearly shows inferiority against SSJ Trunks and Goten. Specially since the ki blast was suppressed and made Android 18 surprised.
dragon boss z wrote:
Because 18 can't really get any stronger, while Goten and Trunks are just tapping into their potential. If they went into the ROSAT for two years and both came out ssj2, then together they could have a chance against Buu. At the very least they would be stronger than everyone else, which would make them Earth's last hope. Notice Piccolo never thought it was a good chance to begin with. So he just thinks they have the potential to be the strongest on Earth. It doesn't mean they are currently the strongest.
Well I might agree here, since I also have some doubts that the kids are above Piccolo. I always interpreted Piccolo's line of the kids as the last hope of Earth being more to the potential they had as saiyans. Although maybe it is possible that they indeed surpassed Piccolo, that's something I don't really know, but they are clearly above Android 18 for sure. But just an important detail, the kids were able to surprise Piccolo a bit, while Goku was there like nothing. That would imply that the kids are near Piccolo's power, we don't know if above or below, but they are around his power, since the kids were able to surprise Piccolo, but not as much as Android 18.
We also need to keep in mind that the kids were able to fight against Gohan and Vegeta, making feats that Android 18 and even Android 16 wouldn't be able to do. We just shouldn't underestimate the kids just because they are recently just kids. The story is telling us that they are stronger than what many people think.