Yuli Ban wrote: Wed Jun 02, 2021 7:28 pm
ZeroNeonix wrote: Wed Jun 02, 2021 11:18 am
Also, Vegeta sacrificed himself in an attempt to write his mistakes. He didn't just say he was sorry and expect people to move on. He showed that he was changed through his actions. Bra on the other hand? She feels real bad. ...That's it. She's so sorry. So let's just forgive her.
To give Bra the BOTD, she literally JUST stopped her rampage and there's no situation where a sacrifice is necessary. Like it was no more than two or three minutes prior that she broke down. Nothing's happening right now. The next few fights don't have any danger of going so catastrophically wrong either.
Goku got through to Vegeta to convince him he fucked up and the situation was deteriorating rapidly at that so he had no other choice. And this was part of a longer sequence of events that didn't even immediately pay off for him considering he was still sent to Hell. He didn't have a chance to mope around and feel bad or realize he betrayed his wife and son because a piece of Lovecraftian bubblegum was about to kill everyone. Boo denied us a chance to see Crying Majin Vegeta (you know he would've done it, too— Vegeta's an emotional monkey underneath that rocky exterior).
Would be some shit, though, if Vegetto's inevitable rampage is what opens up Bra's chance for atonement. If there's any way to fuck up an atonement arc, that's it. To say the shark has been jumped is like saying "breaking news: humans have invented the wheel!"
I'm not so much criticizing the character as I am the writing. If Salagir didn't write Bra a chance to redeem herself, and yet he expects people to forgive her because she feels guilty now, that's bad writing. Bra may get a chance to redeem herself later, but the damage has already been done. When Toriyama wrote a similar situation, Vegeta was always laser focused on his goal of getting his rematch with Goku. So when he disobeyed Babidi, it was clear what his motivations were. He was always in control, because he only wanted one thing in life: to surpass Goku. In contrast, Bra only disobeyed because...I dunno? She felt like it? She had no clear motivations. And Salagir seems to think that lack of clarity means he can get away with saying she was just doing what Babidi ordered, despite showing her disobeying his orders.
When Vegeta got his change of heart, he gets a moment with his son, where he realizes he failed as a father and embraces the boy for the first time in his life. He knocks Trunks out and hands him off to Piccolo for protection, before blowing himself up in an attempt to disintegrate Buu. When he does this, he understands fully that he is going to Hell for all the bad things he's done, yet he makes that sacrifice anyway, because it was the right thing to do. It was the only thing he could do to clean up the mess he created. He failed, but he still tried, and his self-sacrifice was an emotional moment for the series. Bra's version of this was just sloppy. She breaks herself free after being told she's passive. She cries about it and feels sorry, and then it's revealed that Vegito was the "true villain" all along, because he correctly predicted that she would do something like this and threatened to kill her if she got to be too powerful. This comes out of nowhere, and every character immediately jumps on Vegito's case, completely forgiving Bra and even making excuses for her. She has done nothing to redeem herself, and yet the story acts like she doesn't need to.