Matches Malone wrote: Sat Oct 17, 2020 2:07 pmThis comment explains things far better than I ever could:
I sincerely hope that you
could do better than this, because the comment you've quoted is, frankly, unacceptably tendentious, and talks past the point being made, which is that Goku has spared people he arguably shouldn't have when considered according to the dictates of common sense.
Firstly, what does "100% over and not a threat" even mean, in this context? That someone has simply declared the fight 'over'? Yeah, okay. If you consent to completely heal a rival, who literally gored you five minutes ago, back to full strength (Piccolo), or turn your back on a guy who can still slice you in half (Freeza), what does 'not a threat' even mean? By those benchmarks, Moro isn't a threat to Goku either. There's nothing he can directly do to him in that state, as Chapter 64 spent many pages showing us.
The only relevant comparisons given are Piccolo, Vegeta and Freeza (the rest is a waste of word count because it's busy discussing irrelevant examples), and the first two are hand-waved with basically 'it turned out okay in the end, so it's fine', which has nothing to do with Goku's decision-making process and the question of whether letting those people go was strictly sensible
at the time - for Vegeta, Goku himself conceded that it wasn't smart, even as he asked Kuririn to do it. If Vegeta hadn't been diverted from his original purpose by Freeza's actions, he'd've been back 36 days later to kill them all.
So, what? It's smart because it didn't
happen to turn out badly (when it easily
could have)? How is that a reasonable argument about the quality of Goku's decision-making process as a character?
As for Freeza, Goku goes as far as to do it
twice, which the comment you've quoted completely elides. On the
first one, he tells him to go off and cower, and is lucky not to get sliced in half for doing so - but he nevertheless calls it giving him a last chance, and he calls
Freeza stupid for not taking it. Because this is the way that Goku thinks. He goes on to say he should train some more and come back if he wants to settle things.
On the
second one, it's in response to begging for his life, and Goku recognises this would be treating him in a way Freeza treated nobody else. But he does it anyway, for some reason (presumably because he thinks such an end "isn't worthy of you"), and then he tells him to "learn the value of life" - how likely is this outcome, in your estimation (answer: not at all, because Freeza immediately tries to kill him)? But no, Goku telling
Moro to submit is the 'out-of-character' action, apparently.
And what does 'always learning from his mistakes' mean? As far as that comment is concerned, Goku hasn't even
made any mistakes to learn
from.
Maybe you should stick to making comments for yourself.