sintzu wrote:
He didn't job, when he was healed by Zamasu he kicked Vegeta's ass but unlike the anime Vegeta fought back. You can have someone lose and make it look OK. he also kicked Trunks' ass and forced him to run away for help.
Here's the different though. In the manga, Black just beat Vegeta up old school style. In the anime, Black outright impaled him and Vegeta wasn't expecting it. Even then, he saved Goku and Trunks' lives with his last bit of energy, so he did 'fight back' despite having his lung pierced.
Jigurashi wrote:The manga gave Vegeta a good performance against Black the first time around but it was a terrible way of handling the threat level of an antagonist. Black was the big antagonist until the true main antagonist (M-Zamasu) appeared, and having him just get shitted on in his first fight with a top tier fighter was terrible.
I think what did Black in in the manga is how he reacted to Vegeta beating him. If he was more like Anime Black and said stuff 'this pain will make me stronger' or laughed or smiled while Vegeta kicked his shit in, then it would have been better overall and made it looked like Black already knew Future Zamasu would save him instead of it just being coincidental. I mean, when Black was getting his shit kicked in by Vegeta in the anime, he kept his act together, so he kept his 'dignity' while getting out-powered.
Him going the traditional whine and cry when overpowered did his character no favors, especially since he wasn't an established threat like King Piccolo, Piccolo Jr, Nappa, Vegeta, Freeza, Cell to a lesser extent, or Super Buu before they had their meltdowns. Black's best feat at that point was beating up Future Trunks, who was more or less fodder to Goku and Vegeta.