Gods of Destruction and Makaioshin
- Rukura
- I'm, pretty, cozy, here...
- Posts: 1848
- Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2011 4:29 pm
- Location: Space Lisbon, Space Portugal
Gods of Destruction and Makaioshin
Hearing about the new tidbits regarding the existence of the Makaioshin, I thought of them as being the other side what we already knew. You know, gods vs demons, Kaioshin vs Makaioshin, Heaven vs Hell...well, maybe not the last one, since both of them have their own realm separate from the Other World.
That makes sense, right? We have the gods that create, the Kaioshin, and the ones that destroy....wait, who's really playing this role now?
It makes sense to have gods vs demons, with the Kaioshin vs Makaioshin; but in Battle of Gods we learn that we have Gods of creation, the Kaioshin, and Gods of Destruction. And they don't seem to really be working with each other, since the Kaioshin get concerned about the planets they just created not too long ago. But after waking up, Beerus talks about going to kill Freeza. (Which Kaioshin himself says he could've instantly killed, but just didn't)
So...what's his role? Is he as much of a God as the Kaioshin, just a different kind that does the dirty work that needs to be done? Are we gonna learn that he (and maybe even Whis) is a Makaioshin? Are the Gods of Destruction a separate faction, unrelated to either side? Is there any information that sheds some light on this, or is anything we can say about it just speculation?
That makes sense, right? We have the gods that create, the Kaioshin, and the ones that destroy....wait, who's really playing this role now?
It makes sense to have gods vs demons, with the Kaioshin vs Makaioshin; but in Battle of Gods we learn that we have Gods of creation, the Kaioshin, and Gods of Destruction. And they don't seem to really be working with each other, since the Kaioshin get concerned about the planets they just created not too long ago. But after waking up, Beerus talks about going to kill Freeza. (Which Kaioshin himself says he could've instantly killed, but just didn't)
So...what's his role? Is he as much of a God as the Kaioshin, just a different kind that does the dirty work that needs to be done? Are we gonna learn that he (and maybe even Whis) is a Makaioshin? Are the Gods of Destruction a separate faction, unrelated to either side? Is there any information that sheds some light on this, or is anything we can say about it just speculation?
Last edited by Rukura on Wed Oct 01, 2014 10:47 am, edited 1 time in total.
Full checklist of all Xenoverse clothing pieces, accessories and Z-Souls (Many thanks to jrdemr for the Z-Souls sheet): https://www.dropbox.com/s/u8vxc8m0fehev ... .xlsx?dl=0
Re: Gods of Destruction vs Makaioshin
I always interpreted the demons as just a different race and the Makaishin is just the king, like how Vegeta was the king of the Saiyans and the dog (I forgot his name, if someone could remind me) was the king of Earth, instead of Godly beings like the Kaioshins and Hakaishins. Still doesn't explain the fact that they have their own realm, true, but they could have been so powerful that maybe they were exiled?
- TheDevilsCorpse
- Moderator
- Posts: 11378
- Joined: Sun Jun 20, 2010 4:34 am
- Contact:
Re: Gods of Destruction vs Makaioshin
First, I have to ask, "new"? Though it was reprinted in more recent materials, the Makaio(shin) information is ~5 years old from the Super Exciting Guides. =P
Anyway, the Hakaishin and the Makaio(shin) are two different things. Beerus destroys planets in order to provide a balance to the constantly increasing number Kaioshin provides the impetus for, but he does not act on the god's orders. The Hakaishin destroys according to his own individual judgment. Unlike the God of Destruction, there's nothing about the Makaio(shin) destroying anything. The only things we're told about them is that evil Shinjin go to be with the Makaio and that the Makaioshin govern evil from the Demon Realm (Makai). Oh, and that the Kaioshin are currently stronger than their evil counterparts. This wouldn't fit with Beerus and Whis, as they are both stronger than the Kaioshin. The Chozenshu guides concur with all this.
In short, it's all about balance. The Kaio(shin) are involved as a counterpart to both, but it's different aspects for each relationship.
That said, I wish we had more information on the Makaio(shin) by now. I'd like to know exactly what they are. I'm tired of the speculation on if they are the evil outcast Shinjin, or something else entirely? If so, what?
Anyway, the Hakaishin and the Makaio(shin) are two different things. Beerus destroys planets in order to provide a balance to the constantly increasing number Kaioshin provides the impetus for, but he does not act on the god's orders. The Hakaishin destroys according to his own individual judgment. Unlike the God of Destruction, there's nothing about the Makaio(shin) destroying anything. The only things we're told about them is that evil Shinjin go to be with the Makaio and that the Makaioshin govern evil from the Demon Realm (Makai). Oh, and that the Kaioshin are currently stronger than their evil counterparts. This wouldn't fit with Beerus and Whis, as they are both stronger than the Kaioshin. The Chozenshu guides concur with all this.
In short, it's all about balance. The Kaio(shin) are involved as a counterpart to both, but it's different aspects for each relationship.
That said, I wish we had more information on the Makaio(shin) by now. I'd like to know exactly what they are. I'm tired of the speculation on if they are the evil outcast Shinjin, or something else entirely? If so, what?
- Rukura
- I'm, pretty, cozy, here...
- Posts: 1848
- Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2011 4:29 pm
- Location: Space Lisbon, Space Portugal
Re: Gods of Destruction vs Makaioshin
Fair enough, for all the times it's been mentioned and reprinted, I lost track of how "new" it was and holy crap it's been half a decade since that came outTheDevilsCorpse wrote:First, I have to ask, "new"? Though it was reprinted in more recent materials, the Makaio(shin) information is ~5 years old from the Super Exciting Guides. =P
By the end of my post I was coming to a similar conclusion, but it's good to know that there's some sort of official corroboration on that. Though, it's still weird to have a Demon Realm with Makaio and Makaioshin that don't do anything, even if to, to an extent, do the God of Destructions' job keeping a yin/yan kinda balance.TheDevilsCorpse wrote:Anyway, the Hakaishin and the Makaio(shin) are two different things. Beerus destroys planets in order to provide a balance to the constantly increasing number Kaioshin provides the impetus for, but he does not act on the god's orders. The Hakaishin destroys according to his own individual judgment. Unlike the God of Destruction, there's nothing about the Makaio(shin) destroying anything. The only things we're told about them is that evil Shinjin go to be with the Makaio and that the Makaioshin govern evil from the Demon Realm (Makai). Oh, and that the Kaioshin are currently stronger than their evil counterparts. This wouldn't fit with Beerus and Whis, as they are both stronger than the Kaioshin. The Chozenshu guides concur with all this.
In short, it's all about balance. The Kaio(shin) are involved as a counterpart to both, but it's different aspects for each relationship.
I think it's funny that we also have the Hakaio mind-controlled folks in Heroes, that has nothing to do with anything lol
At this point, I wonder if the whole point of making up the Gods of Destruction and all that surrounding information was just to have the Battle of Gods twist of Goku not being able to win, while also not needing to win to save the day.
I guess we might get something with Xenoverse coming. Isn't Towa a Makaio or a Makaioshin? Maybe we'll have something in the new movie. (By the way, isn't there some date for Beerus to wake up again? When was that?)TheDevilsCorpse wrote:That said, I wish we had more information on the Makaio(shin) by now. I'd like to know exactly what they are. I'm tired of the speculation on if they are the evil outcast Shinjin, or something else entirely? If so, what?
Full checklist of all Xenoverse clothing pieces, accessories and Z-Souls (Many thanks to jrdemr for the Z-Souls sheet): https://www.dropbox.com/s/u8vxc8m0fehev ... .xlsx?dl=0
- TheDevilsCorpse
- Moderator
- Posts: 11378
- Joined: Sun Jun 20, 2010 4:34 am
- Contact:
Re: Gods of Destruction vs Makaioshin
Well, Makai is the truly evil portion of the Living Realm, inhabited by demons and mages, and governed by magic (which is their version of science). I assume the Makaio(shin), seeing how they are said to govern evil, would do something in their own realm at least. We just don't know exactly what that is yet. Though it could be something as simple as the how the Kaioshin (ignoring their secondary Sozoshin creation job) just watch over things and rarely interact with "mortals", the Makaio(shin) could do the same. Which would actually amount to them not doing much of anything.Rukura wrote:By the end of my post I was coming to a similar conclusion, but it's good to know that there's some sort of official corroboration on that. Though, it's still weird to have a Demon Realm with Makaio and Makaioshin that don't do anything, even if to, to an extent, do the God of Destructions' job keeping a yin/yan kinda balance.
I think it's funny that we also have the Hakaio mind-controlled folks in Heroes, that has nothing to do with anything lol
At this point, I wonder if the whole point of making up the Gods of Destruction and all that surrounding information was just to have the Battle of Gods twist of Goku not being able to win, while also not needing to win to save the day.
Yeah. I know they didn't intend any connection since it's related to Babidi and not Beerus, but I feel like they could have picked a better name for the Hakaio. It sounds like a lower god that would serve under the Hakaishin, like the Kaio do for the Kaioshin.
Battle of Gods was originally created for the sole purpose of having an evil villain that utterly destroyed and spread evil, and what better than a God of Destruction for that role? Toriyama changed all that to remove Beerus being evil and was the one that decided Goku wouldn't win too. The original draft of the film was supposed to have Goku fighting against Beerus and all his friends who had been turned evil, allowing him to discover what it meant to be a true hero. I assume all the Toriyama's tidbits about the Hakaishin are mostly just to flesh out the position and make things interesting. The Makaio(shin) situation shows you what it's like when you have practically no lore about something.
No. There's speculation about her, but nothing official on the matter. So maybe we will get something, maybe we won't. Another reason why I'm looking forward to Xenoverse. It's a mystery I would like solved and the mention in the Full Color Buu Arc Q&As, but then not elaborating on the concept, was both beyond irritating and disappointing.Rukura wrote:I guess we might get something with Xenoverse coming. Isn't Towa a Makaio or a Makaioshin? Maybe we'll have something in the new movie. (By the way, isn't there some date for Beerus to wake up again? When was that?)
Whis put Beerus to sleep for 3 years at the end of Battle of Gods, so he should wake up in AGE 781. Whether he interacts with the gang again is another story. Maybe we'll see with DBZ2015.
- Rukura
- I'm, pretty, cozy, here...
- Posts: 1848
- Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2011 4:29 pm
- Location: Space Lisbon, Space Portugal
Re: Gods of Destruction vs Makaioshin
So, basically, there's a chance that they just chill in their Realm and be ("being", as just their state of existence) evil. That would explain why the Kaioshin are stronger than themTheDevilsCorpse wrote:Though it could be something as simple as the how the Kaioshin (ignoring their secondary Sozoshin creation job) just watch over things and rarely interact with "mortals", the Makaio(shin) could do the same. Which would actually amount to them not doing much of anything.
Though, going back to that point of the Kaioshin being currently stronger than the Makaioshin, it would be very shonen to suddenly have one that breaks the mold and makes them a serious threat. And, at this point, we have the Kaioshin count down to 2 so you gotta wonder how much of an upper hand they ACTUALLY have
Yeah, it's weird and might get someone who's not in the know to make wrong assumptions. They could've just called them, dare I say it, freaking Majin.TheDevilsCorpse wrote:Yeah. I know they didn't intend any connection since it's related to Babidi and not Beerus, but I feel like they could have picked a better name for the Hakaio. It sounds like a lower god that would serve under the Hakaishin, like the Kaio do for the Kaioshin.
If only Toriyama had created some kind of evil faction that Watanabe could've pulled from? lolTheDevilsCorpse wrote:Battle of Gods was originally created for the sole purpose of having an evil villain that utterly destroyed and spread evil, and what better than a God of Destruction for that role?
I get that what came out of the Gods of Destruction was just to make it somewhat fleshed out for it to work, but it expended the totem pole unnecessarily when there was something already there.
Oh, then nevermind. I was under the impression that there was something about that already.TheDevilsCorpse wrote:No. There's speculation about her, but nothing official on the matter.
Full checklist of all Xenoverse clothing pieces, accessories and Z-Souls (Many thanks to jrdemr for the Z-Souls sheet): https://www.dropbox.com/s/u8vxc8m0fehev ... .xlsx?dl=0
- TheDevilsCorpse
- Moderator
- Posts: 11378
- Joined: Sun Jun 20, 2010 4:34 am
- Contact:
Re: Gods of Destruction vs Makaioshin
We can't really do anything by speculate on all this. The SEG information was provided after the series ended, so I'm guessing Toiryama was considering the lack of Kaioshin when he made the statement? Maybe the Kaioshin are fairly outnumbered, but Kibitoshin greatly overpowers all of the Makaio(shin) after the fusion?Rukura wrote:Though, going back to that point of the Kaioshin being currently stronger than the Makaioshin, it would be very shonen to suddenly have one that breaks the mold and makes them a serious threat. And, at this point, we have the Kaioshin count down to 2 so you gotta wonder how much of an upper hand they ACTUALLY have
Yeah, they could have. But the Hakaio spell causes different traits than the regular spell, so it seems to be different from the regular one used to enslave Dabra, Zangya, Raichi, etc. I can see why they might've wanted a different title, though they didn't do a very good job with it. I guess maybe the blame should be placed on Vegeta though, as he was coined "Hakaioji (Prince of Destruction)" long before Hakaishin Beerus or the Hakaio...though Vegeta displays half the normal traits and half the Hakaio traits.Rukura wrote:Yeah, it's weird and might get someone who's not in the know to make wrong assumptions. They could've just called them, dare I say it, freaking Majin.
Yeah, that first part was sarcasm. The Makaio(shin) could have easily filled the original role of Watanabe's Hakaishin. They are at least technically gods via their title, they are evil, etc. The only issue was the Kaioshin supposedly being stronger, but Toriyama could have written a reason for one of them to become strong enough to be a threat to Goku in the film or something.Rukura wrote:If only Toriyama had created some kind of evil faction that Watanabe could've pulled from? lol
I get that what came out of the Gods of Destruction was just to make it somewhat fleshed out for it to work, but it expended the totem pole unnecessarily when there was something already there.
I REALLY love both the Hakaishin and Beerus info though. Some of the better world building and character additions to the franchise in a while. So I don't mind the expansion. But this is all in hindsight.
- Rukura
- I'm, pretty, cozy, here...
- Posts: 1848
- Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2011 4:29 pm
- Location: Space Lisbon, Space Portugal
Re: Gods of Destruction vs Makaioshin
True. That's a good point, though it makes it a bit weirder to consider. Well, then we end up going back to wondering how strong Kibitoshin is in comparison to Kaioshin (and how strong any existing Makaio(shin) might be). Going by the manga, that team's a Kaio already outclassed before Namek, a fused Kaioshin that can maybe take down Dabra and an older Kaioshin that doens't fight. They must be gag characters, if the Kaioshin have the upper handTheDevilsCorpse wrote:We can't really do anything but speculate on all this. The SEG information was provided after the series ended, so I'm guessing Toiryama was considering the lack of Kaioshin when he made the statement? Maybe the Kaioshin are fairly outnumbered, but Kibitoshin greatly overpowers all of the Makaio(shin) after the fusion?![]()
Do we know that it's at all different and not just the same spell, but improved to the point of making them mindless killing machines? Totally forgot about Hakaioji. We'd have the same issue, but I wonder why they used "king" for all the others while keeping Vegeta as "prince". Sure, prince of the Saiyans blah blah blah but he kinda gets outranked for no reason.TheDevilsCorpse wrote:But the Hakaio spell causes different traits than the regular spell, so it seems to be different from the regular one used to enslave Dabra, Zangya, Raichi, etc. I can see why they might've wanted a different title, though they didn't do a very good job with it. I guess maybe the blame should be placed on Vegeta though, as he was coined "Hakaioji (Prince of Destruction)" long before Hakaishin Beerus or the Hakaio...though Vegeta displays half the normal traits and half the Hakaio traits.
Exactly. Even if that's the case, it wouldn't be surprising to see them pull a "they were generally weak...but there was this one guy...which is why we never told you about them until now" kinda thing.TheDevilsCorpse wrote:Yeah, that first part was sarcasm. The Makaio(shin) could have easily filled the original role of Watanabe's Hakaishin. They are at least technically gods via their title, they are evil, etc. The only issue was the Kaioshin supposedly being stronger, but Toriyama could have written a reason for one of them to become strong enough to be a threat to Goku in the film or something.
I REALLY love both the Hakaishin and Beerus info though. Some of the better world building and character additions to the franchise in a while. So I don't mind the expansion. But this is all in hindsight.
But that's why I get torn on that, I really like Beerus and Whis, more than the info around them (which isn't really that much, if you think about it) and end up being more than okay with it in the end.
Full checklist of all Xenoverse clothing pieces, accessories and Z-Souls (Many thanks to jrdemr for the Z-Souls sheet): https://www.dropbox.com/s/u8vxc8m0fehev ... .xlsx?dl=0
