apex_pretador wrote:LowRyder2005 wrote:apex_pretador wrote:
We see that when RoSaT blew up, vegeta was in base. The most fair and logical assumption is that he was in base. To assume that he was in SS or SSB, and then reverted at the exact same moment when RoSaT blows up is speculation. We see no aura fading away, no indication that he was in transformed state before.
Now, I am not saying that him being in base is confirmed (read above), but it is by far the most likely scenario.
I still don't really see how this is less of a speculation than the other theory of Vegeta going Blue. I don't think it even constitutes an Occam's Razor like you are indirectly suggesting: Saiyans deprived of ki revert to base, usually,
and Vegeta appeared quite tired. It's not like the scenario some have theorized necessitates added preconditions that make it less preferable.
If vegeta was tired due to blowing up the RoSaT, it would confirm that he was in base. He should have no difficulty in destroying RoSaT in blue form.
And again, for the 5th time, I am not saying that we can certainly say that he blew it in base, but that it is much more likely (because he is seen in base instantly after RoSaT is destroyed), and considering how it looks like he destroyed it in a fit of rage, it is unlikely he will revert at the exact same moment when RoSaT blew up.
This makes little sense: we have quite literally no idea on what kind of power output is ultimately needed to blow up the ROSAT like that. The only reference available is that someone like Super Buu/ SS3 Gotenks needed considerable effort to create a tear in the dimensional barrier. Who's to say that a Super Saiyan God wouldn't
struggle to destroy the room? We can only assume Vegeta
probably exerted a force on a much greater magnitude compared to what happened in Z, but since the process happens entirely off panel it's painfully obvious that there's an inherent speculation to
any conclusion on the "how" he did that.
Of course, I entirely agree that there is the
possibility Vegeta did that in base form since feats would at least partly corroborate this hypothesis, but as many others pointed out (and you yourself did) it's just that: a hypothesis. By itself, though, I can't help but finding your argument not that much different than seeing base Gohan at the end of his Kamehameha struggle with Cell (without any notion of where everyone stood in power, that is) and claiming that he "probably" was in base all along. If anything, I think that to you it appears that Vegeta was "most likely" in base because you've already internalized the idea that Vegeta must be on a level far, far beyond Gotenks' and Super Buu's. Which is not exactly unlikely, anyway.