[spoiler]
[/spoiler]
[/spoiler]Quick question, which voice do you like better, Rose or Base? I'm gonna go with Rose, because God the base voice gives me nightmares. It sounds scary as hell.Scsigs wrote:I just had this thought. If Xenoverse 2's anything to go by, then how Goku Black is portrayed in the dub of Super is influenced by people possibly knowing that plot twist going in, which is how you DON'T handle a dub. You're supposed to present the information as it is & do similar portrayals as the Japanese version, just in another language, regardless of if people have seen it before. This isn't the 90s-early 2000s anymore.
What Xenoverse 2 does that leads me to this conclusion is first, have Goku Black have the deep grovel that Schemmel initially gave the character (which, by the way, hinders his acting ability if you watch the cutscenes), then switches gears to a British accented version of his Goku voice (which makes absolutely NO sense, given Zamasu doesn't even remotely have one at the point Black does, even though his actor's played a British character before), when all Sean needed to do was use his 'cocky' Goku voice where he lowers his register to a more serious tone, like in Resurrection F when Goku tells Frieza, "You'd make a good sparring partner."
Whether you like either voice or not, you cannot deny that neither voice makes NO sense, especially when played back-to-back. Maybe they'll explain it in the dub, but given the animation, I highly doubt it.
I mean, just watch the cutscenes yourself & tell me I'm wrong with my assertions.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e9QPr6MQTIM
Out of the 2 we got, the British one is better to the ear for me.Dragon Ball Gus wrote:Quick question, which voice do you like better, Rose or Base? I'm gonna go with Rose, because God the base voice gives me nightmares. It sounds scary as hell.
Missed the opening but the ending was in english.Dragon Ball Gus wrote:Let me guess, the opening and ending are back in Japanese?
Nope, both were still in EnglishDragon Ball Gus wrote:Let me guess, the opening and ending are back in Japanese?
That's what I'M saying!MagmonKai wrote:It makes zero sense for him to have two different voices for the base and rose form. They are the same dude. He's not split personality.
Because each planet has its own hell. Freeza's area is part of Earth's Hell.Scsigs wrote:Why do they call it Earth's Hell? I kinda was ok with Frieza saying it, but then Beerus did the same. Why? It's the same Hell as anyone else would experience, isn't it? Or at least Frieza's own private version of Hell?
That makes no sense, though.Sailor Haumea wrote:Because each planet has its own hell. Freeza's area is part of Earth's Hell.Scsigs wrote:Why do they call it Earth's Hell? I kinda was ok with Frieza saying it, but then Beerus did the same. Why? It's the same Hell as anyone else would experience, isn't it? Or at least Frieza's own private version of Hell?
I don't like both voices. Sean sounds too nice with that British accent.Dragon Ball Gus wrote:Quick question, which voice do you like better, Rose or Base? I'm gonna go with Rose, because God the base voice gives me nightmares. It sounds scary as hell.Scsigs wrote:I just had this thought. If Xenoverse 2's anything to go by, then how Goku Black is portrayed in the dub of Super is influenced by people possibly knowing that plot twist going in, which is how you DON'T handle a dub. You're supposed to present the information as it is & do similar portrayals as the Japanese version, just in another language, regardless of if people have seen it before. This isn't the 90s-early 2000s anymore.
What Xenoverse 2 does that leads me to this conclusion is first, have Goku Black have the deep grovel that Schemmel initially gave the character (which, by the way, hinders his acting ability if you watch the cutscenes), then switches gears to a British accented version of his Goku voice (which makes absolutely NO sense, given Zamasu doesn't even remotely have one at the point Black does, even though his actor's played a British character before), when all Sean needed to do was use his 'cocky' Goku voice where he lowers his register to a more serious tone, like in Resurrection F when Goku tells Frieza, "You'd make a good sparring partner."
Whether you like either voice or not, you cannot deny that neither voice makes NO sense, especially when played back-to-back. Maybe they'll explain it in the dub, but given the animation, I highly doubt it.
I mean, just watch the cutscenes yourself & tell me I'm wrong with my assertions.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e9QPr6MQTIM
Well, Hell needs to be capable of holding just as many people as the living realm does, right? You wouldn't fit all the evil souls in the universe onto a single regular planet, so perhaps by "Earth's Hell" it's more like "Earth's sector of Hell" as opposed to "A Hell reserved specifically for Earthlings"?Scsigs wrote:That makes no sense, though.Sailor Haumea wrote:Because each planet has its own hell. Freeza's area is part of Earth's Hell.Scsigs wrote:Why do they call it Earth's Hell? I kinda was ok with Frieza saying it, but then Beerus did the same. Why? It's the same Hell as anyone else would experience, isn't it? Or at least Frieza's own private version of Hell?