Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Discussion regarding the entirety of the franchise in a general (meta) sense, including such aspects as: production, trends, merchandise, fan culture, and more.

Moderators: Kanzenshuu Staff, General Help

User avatar
Banana
Not-So-Newbie
Posts: 65
Joined: Sat Mar 31, 2018 10:02 pm

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by Banana » Thu Apr 05, 2018 4:39 am

Bruma rabu wrote:
Banana wrote:I honestly had no idea Kai was that bad... I've taken the Z route both times in me watching the show because I do want to see everything. I do feel as if Namek especially dragged on, and I felt like it was dragged on too much just like everyone else was. I was getting bored there. Android saga, though, not so much and now I'm in the Buu saga and it's fine. Still worth watching though!
I wouldn't say Kai is as awful as Kunzait is make it out to seem. If you enjoy the dub Kai its really good and i would suggest it. Ill let know right now, nothing in dragon ball is perfect when it comes to the anime. No perfect release exist, it really is pick your poison.
Lol well I go Japanese all the way- started the series around the time I began studying Japanese actually. I can't stand many of the English voices actually. Maybe I'll give Kai a watch for the hell of it when I'm done with Z, GT and Super just to get an idea of what it's like. I saw a few episodes long ago around when it came out and I remember playing the Dragon Soul song on the taiko drum arcade game when I was visiting Hiroshima years ago. Good times! And true I know the show is far from perfect in either form, and even just the animation quality in certain parts of it, but now having the broadcast audio of Z makes it all the more worth watching. I cried the first time I heard how good it is and even rewatched monumental scenes like when Goku went SSJ on Namek and when Gohan went SSJ2 fighting Cell. And then got kicked right in the feels later when Vegeta died in the Buu saga, and just the clarity of the sound allows me to appreciate it so much more. I know Kai was re-recorded, but I'm not sure how I'd be okay with certain things like the unavoidable recasting of Roshi (I wonder if he in Kai is the same actor as the one in the Path to Power movie, as I didn't like his replacement) and to my memory, it sounded like Nozawa was showing her age when voicing young Goku. It felt a little off, though don't get me wrong, I'm incredibly grateful for the continuing work she's put into the series. At the time it didn't make sense for me to finish Kai either though I did catch a few episodes here and there like Goku en route to Namek in English on TV. It didn't make sense to me because at that time I wasn't finished with the series yet and it only went to Cell. I still needed to see the original Majin Buu arc and that was finished way later when I didn't even care about it anymore.

And about me feeling like Namek was long winded- it was fun in the beginning when Kuririn and Gohan were spying on Frieza, but all of that got old quick, and the "five minutes until Namek explodes" still infuriates me. So much that when I was playing Xenoverse, I was joking with a friend about how "I just beat Frieza and it didn't take 10 episodes!" Haha. Especially how this time around I felt like there were some key monumental scenes so there was nothing I could skip to get to the end. It did catch my attention more when Goku actually began fighting Frieza, and during the interim I would browse this forum reading old threads about power levels and such lol
Goku: Are you a Yoshi?
Piccolo: Yes, Goku, I'm a green ****ing dinosaur.

User avatar
Bruma rabu
Regular
Posts: 517
Joined: Mon Nov 07, 2016 10:12 pm

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by Bruma rabu » Thu Apr 05, 2018 6:05 am

Banana wrote:Lol well I go Japanese all the way- started the series around the time I began studying Japanese actually. I can't stand many of the English voices actually. Maybe I'll give Kai a watch for the hell of it when I'm done with Z, GT and Super just to get an idea of what it's like. I saw a few episodes long ago around when it came out and I remember playing the Dragon Soul song on the taiko drum arcade game when I was visiting Hiroshima years ago. Good times! And true I know the show is far from perfect in either form, and even just the animation quality in certain parts of it, but now having the broadcast audio of Z makes it all the more worth watching. I cried the first time I heard how good it is and even rewatched monumental scenes like when Goku went SSJ on Namek and when Gohan went SSJ2 fighting Cell. And then got kicked right in the feels later when Vegeta died in the Buu saga, and just the clarity of the sound allows me to appreciate it so much more. I know Kai was re-recorded, but I'm not sure how I'd be okay with certain things like the unavoidable recasting of Roshi (I wonder if he in Kai is the same actor as the one in the Path to Power movie, as I didn't like his replacement) and to my memory, it sounded like Nozawa was showing her age when voicing young Goku. It felt a little off, though don't get me wrong, I'm incredibly grateful for the continuing work she's put into the series. At the time it didn't make sense for me to finish Kai either though I did catch a few episodes here and there like Goku en route to Namek in English on TV. It didn't make sense to me because at that time I wasn't finished with the series yet and it only went to Cell. I still needed to see the original Majin Buu arc and that was finished way later when I didn't even care about it anymore.

And about me feeling like Namek was long winded- it was fun in the beginning when Kuririn and Gohan were spying on Frieza, but all of that got old quick, and the "five minutes until Namek explodes" still infuriates me. So much that when I was playing Xenoverse, I was joking with a friend about how "I just beat Frieza and it didn't take 10 episodes!" Haha. Especially how this time around I felt like there were some key monumental scenes so there was nothing I could skip to get to the end. It did catch my attention more when Goku actually began fighting Frieza, and during the interim I would browse this forum reading old threads about power levels and such lol
Since you prefer the original audio and have the broadcast audio there really is no need for you to check out Kai. I've seen a lot of people here say that Japanese version just isn't as good as the original run, not bad mind you just not as good. Unless you want a faster paced show Kai will probably not be as good for you.
Bulma is awesome... but chi-chi is best waifu :wink:

User avatar
KBABZ
I Live Here
Posts: 4645
Joined: Sun Feb 26, 2017 9:38 pm
Location: The tallest tower in West City

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by KBABZ » Thu Apr 05, 2018 6:37 am

Banana wrote:Lol well I go Japanese all the way-
Ah! Therein lies the deciding factor. The original Z performances by the Japanese cast are much better than in Kai because with Z they were in their prime. In Kai, actor changes aside, they're just not as sharp and in their prime as they used to (Cell being a particular stickling point). In English however the situation is reverse: with a more accurate script and a decade's worth of practice, Kai is the definitive way to get into the show in English and lemme tell you, it really holds up.

User avatar
szopman
Beyond Newbie
Posts: 142
Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2016 9:56 am
Location: Poland

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by szopman » Thu Apr 05, 2018 6:56 am

The last time I rewatched DB series was 2-3 years ago and it took me almost 1,5 year. I watched DB, then DB Kai (with some DBZ fillers episodes and movies that fit into the series timeline for eg. Garlic Saga, DBZ Movie 9) and DBGT + specials. Of course, all in Japanese with subtitles.

Lately I've been thinking about rewatching the show again sometime, but this time I would watch it differently (with DBS of course). If I rewatched it now, I would do it this way: DB, DB Kai 1-99 [+ some additional DBZ episodes and movies]. Then DBZ Buu Saga (since it's only 10 (?) eps longer and the music is superior to that of Kai, it's pointless watchin DBKai Buu Saga, in my opinion]. Then I would watch DBZ Movies 13-15 [with or without DBS fillers from the first 2 DBS sagas]. I think I'd watch RoF in Trunks edition. Then DBS from U6 saga until the end. In case of DBS I'd watch anime + read manga, since both of them include a lot of material exclusive only for each medium. Then the last 3 eps of DBZ (with Uub) and GT.
And here's the biggest change :) I literally hate (a lot) English dubbing, but this time I'd watch the US special that retells the first 16 episodes of GT, and then i would start from ep 17 [Jap dub] :)
I always watch specials and OVAS too. The Bardock Special, after the episode when Goku arrives to fight Frieza. Trunks Special - when Cell appeares. And Goku Jr special, after Baby Saga. Plan to Destroy Saiyans - in the ten days waiting before Cell Games. Goku and Friends... - between movies 13 and 14. Episode of Bardock is non-canon to me so it doesn't count ;D

User avatar
ABED
Namekian Warrior
Posts: 17720
Joined: Thu Jan 31, 2013 10:23 am
Location: VA
Contact:

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by ABED » Thu Apr 05, 2018 8:09 am

What material from the manga did Kai cut?
The biggest truths aren't original. The truth is ketchup. It's Jim Belushi. Its job isn't to blow our minds. It's to be within reach.
"You miss 100% of the shots you don't take - Wayne Gretzky" - Michael Scott
Happiness is climate, not weather.

User avatar
szopman
Beyond Newbie
Posts: 142
Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2016 9:56 am
Location: Poland

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by szopman » Thu Apr 05, 2018 11:50 am

I don't think Kai cut anything from the manga :P I'd even say it left some fillers from Z that weren't present in the manga version.

User avatar
Robo4900
I Live Here
Posts: 3754
Joined: Mon Oct 03, 2016 2:24 pm
Location: In another time and place...

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by Robo4900 » Thu Apr 05, 2018 1:35 pm

Kunzait_83 wrote:either just use Kikuchi or something that's relatively close in spirit to it
If you can't get Kikuchi, don't try to imitate him; you'll just make fans angry, and wish they really were listening to Kikuchi. So, unless they were planning on reusing Kikuchi tracks from the start, going with someone with a similar sound would not be a good idea.
Plus, Kai's whole deal is that it's got a more modern feel to it. Plagiarism aside, Yamamoto's soundtrack did have a "Dragon Ball, but with a modern spin" feel to it, which made him a good choice.
Kunzait_83 wrote:make sure to get the best out of the Japanese cast
[...]
the depressingly (and very uncharacteristically) phoned-in performances from much of the Japanese cast
They did make sure to get the best out of the Japanese cast.
Given how much people criticise their performance in Kai, I would be pretty shocked Super doesn't get any flak for that...
... Except I'm not, because it's obvious the only reason people get upset about it is because they can compare it to Z.

Ultimately, the Japanese cast did a good job, it just wasn't as good as the stuff they did in Z. And of course it wouldn't be; they're all ~20 years older, and a few of them had died.

(Though, IMO, Ryusei Nakao lost absolutely nothing. If anything, the clearer sound quality of Kai makes his performance even more enjoyable)
Kunzait_83 wrote: bite the fucking bullet and straight up re-animate the whole damn thing over from scratch.
Reanimating it all would be a bad idea for so many reasons, there's an entire thread about this.
Kunzait_83 wrote:Kai oftentimes would not only leave some bits of filler, it'd even sometimes cut out material from the manga.
Yes, obviously. It's a screen adaptation of the manga. You can't really do a direct 1:1 adaptation from one medium to another, you have to make changes to accomodate the new medium. For a series, a lot of this is to do with the different way a series flows and has to be paced.

Though I don't remember any manga material being cut, unless you're referring to the fact some things happen slightly differently in the manga, like the way Videl finds out Gohan is the Great Saiyaman... Though that's in Boo Kai, so it hardly counts.
Kunzait_83 wrote:the Saban-like censorship
[citation needed]
Kunzait_83 wrote:the inexplicable green filter over the Boo arc eps
Yes, Boo Kai was terribly-done. Few will dispute that. But don't lump that alongside criticisms of Kai 1.0.
Kunzait_83 wrote:For all these reasons (and plenty more), I'm forever dumbfounded as to how anyone can prefer Kai over Z.
Just let people like things.
Kunzait_83 wrote:both feature entire sequences that are glaringly/poorly redrawn
Saban's dub? No, not really. Several pieces had some digital painting over the top, but no entire scenes were ever really redrawn, just some pieces of the frame here and there.
Kunzait_83 wrote:both feature questionable voice acting (outside of the FUNi recasts)
This is where you completely lose me. The Saban/Ocean dub featured exceptional voice acting, and while I would say that Funi's Kai dub seemed to generally be directed to have the entire cast understate their performances to a rather heavy degree, the acting was at least okay within that particular style of delivery. And in the Japanese version, while it doesn't stand up to their old Z performances, they generally did a good/great job.
Kunzait_83 wrote:End of the day, all Kai amounts to for me is Toei's official version of what Saban and FUNi did to the series in the mid/late 90s
You do realise Saban only cut the episode count down by 14 episodes over the course of the entire first 67? Hell, technically it's only 13, since episode 53 ended only about 7 or 8 minutes into uncut #67's footage, so that episode is only lost by the fact the counting was out of alignment by 8 minutes.
And, remember, the Saban dub was still full of filler and such, it just cut the show down by about 13 episodes so it could fit better for TV syndication. The cuts were done based on what worked for censorship and pacing, but ultimately there was never an intent to make it fit the manga or reduce the filler.
Kunzait_83 wrote:And yet what was once sacrilege and awful back then when a U.S. studio does it is now a-ok when Toei does it?
A dubbing company's job is to translate a show into English, yet Saban had them hack it to pieces to suit more convenient TV deals. Kai was a new product produced by the original production company with the express goal of making a shorter version of the show. The situations hardly compare.
Though, I will say that I enjoy both of these things; IMO, the Saban dub gets an unfairly bad rep from some people. It's a lot of fun, and definitely worth a watch.
Kunzait_83 wrote:and who also badly want a version of the English dub where the FUNimation cast "redeems" themselves.
I mean, Kai was that. Sure, Funi Kai isn't perfect -- in fact, I'd argue it was only a bit more than okay -- but it's Funimation's first actually pretty good dub overall of Dragon Ball that's been faithful to the source material, and only the third time we've had something like that in English Dragon Ball dubbing at all.
Kunzait_83 wrote:I see almost no value or merit in its existence outside of I suppose grabbing more new/younger fans into the fold.
If that is the case, then I would say that's a lot of value and merit.
Kunzait_83 wrote:Beyon that, all it succeeds in being is a watered down ADHD version for short attention spans.
That's a very insensitive way of phrasing that, so shame on you.
A somewhat self-indulgent thesis on my current outlook on Dragon Ball fandom, which I feel should be below every post I make from now on:

User avatar
MasenkoHA
I Live Here
Posts: 2383
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2017 9:38 pm

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by MasenkoHA » Thu Apr 05, 2018 6:31 pm

Robo4900 wrote:[
Plus, Kai's whole deal is that it's got a more modern feel to it. Plagiarism aside, Yamamoto's soundtrack did have a "Dragon Ball, but with a modern spin" feel to it, which made him a good choice.
I feel like I'm the only one who prefers the Yamamoto score.



Though I don't remember any manga material being cut, unless you're referring to the fact some things happen slightly differently in the manga, like the way Videl finds out Gohan is the Great Saiyaman... Though that's in Boo Kai, so it hardly counts.
I understand "Advertised as a truer to the manga edition but really just an excuse to make a cheap cash-in for Dragon Ball Z's 20th anniversary " is a legitimate grievance toward Kai but what did it cut that was super important? If anything it left more than it needed too.

Saban's dub? No, not really. Several pieces had some digital painting over the top, but no entire scenes were ever really redrawn, just some pieces of the frame here and there.
They also weren't really poorly done. Like frothy mug of water aside Funimator's paint editors were good at what they did.
This is where you completely lose me. The Saban/Ocean dub featured exceptional voice acting, and while I would say that Funi's Kai dub seemed to generally be directed to have the entire cast understate their performances to a rather heavy degree, the acting was at least okay within that particular style of delivery. And in the Japanese version, while it doesn't stand up to their old Z performances, they generally did a good/great job.
I'm convinced the reason most people bash the Ocean cast is because A. They started with the Japanese voices and the Ocean cast was different than what they were used to B. They were more accustomed to the Funimation voices (after the Funi cast stopped being poor imitators) and the Ocean cast sounded different or C. They lumped in the heavy censorship with the voice work as if the two are connected. The entire Ocean cast, at least in those first two seasons, were all proficient even if some of them may not have sounded right. Even Pauline Newman's Freeza, while totally incorrect, did a good job with the performance.

And even with the Funimation cast much improved performances in Kai I'd take Ian Corlett, Terry Klassen, Scott Mcneil, and Saffron Henderson over their Funi counterparts.

And, remember, the Saban dub was still full of filler and such, it just cut the show down by about 13 episodes so it could fit better for TV syndication. The cuts were done based on what worked for censorship and pacing, but ultimately there was never an intent to make it fit the manga or reduce the filler.
They should have skipped more tbh, choosing to end the second season as Goku shows up on Namek in the smack middle of the Ginyu sub-saga was an odd choice. Even Sailor Moon's stopping point for its syndicated run made way more sense. Their choice of what to keep was odd. Why did Bulma's pointless two parter with the crab even need to be kept other than some vain hope to attract a female audience with the token girl episode(s)?
Though, I will say that I enjoy both of these things; IMO, the Saban dub gets an unfairly bad rep from some people. It's a lot of fun, and definitely worth a watch.
Saban's dub is infinitely more enjoyable if you just watch it as a dumb saturday morning cartoon in the vein of Power Rangers.

PacificOceanDub
Beyond Newbie
Posts: 144
Joined: Thu Dec 08, 2016 8:56 pm
Location: San Antonio, TX

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by PacificOceanDub » Thu Apr 05, 2018 6:44 pm

I think the fact that as I’m rewatching the series (I’m on Gotenks vs Boo right now) and already thinking about how I’m going to rewatch it again NEXT time is a testament to the entertainment value of the anime.

I think next time I’m gonna bust out my Funi Singles and rewatch Z in it’s U.S. broadcast incarnation, with the movies/specials peppered in.
You shouldn’t have to (Cell.) your soul!

User avatar
MasenkoHA
I Live Here
Posts: 2383
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2017 9:38 pm

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by MasenkoHA » Thu Apr 05, 2018 6:48 pm

PacificOceanDub wrote:I think the fact that as I’m rewatching the series (I’m on Gotenks vs Boo right now) and already thinking about how I’m going to rewatch it again NEXT time is a testament to the entertainment value of the anime.

I think next time I’m gonna bust out my Funi Singles and rewatch Z in it’s U.S. broadcast incarnation, with the movies/specials peppered in.
That's a good point there's like a bazillion ways to watch Dragon Ball Z just between Japanese and English

User avatar
ABED
Namekian Warrior
Posts: 17720
Joined: Thu Jan 31, 2013 10:23 am
Location: VA
Contact:

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by ABED » Thu Apr 05, 2018 6:50 pm

Like frothy mug of water aside Funimator's paint editors were good at what they did.
They really weren't. You can easily tell what's painted.

I don't think the Saban dub cut material for pacing. I think they had to cut due to limited funds and the number of episode that were ordered. Season 1 (the Saiyan arc) had 26 episodes and Season 2 (27-53) is 27 episodes.
The biggest truths aren't original. The truth is ketchup. It's Jim Belushi. Its job isn't to blow our minds. It's to be within reach.
"You miss 100% of the shots you don't take - Wayne Gretzky" - Michael Scott
Happiness is climate, not weather.

User avatar
Kunzait_83
I Live Here
Posts: 2783
Joined: Fri Dec 31, 2004 5:19 pm

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by Kunzait_83 » Fri Apr 06, 2018 12:45 am

ABED wrote:
Like frothy mug of water aside Funimator's paint editors were good at what they did.
They really weren't. You can easily tell what's painted.

I don't think the Saban dub cut material for pacing. I think they had to cut due to limited funds and the number of episode that were ordered. Season 1 (the Saiyan arc) had 26 episodes and Season 2 (27-53) is 27 episodes.
They did at least in part cut for pacing as well as to fit in the above episode numbers. There's a bunch of early interviews with Gen and Cindy Fukanaga (and Barry Watson as well I think) where they go into candid detail about changes they made specifically to cater to "shorter attention spans" in American children, per several test audiences they showed the series to. Pacing was indeed one of the concerns for that reason when it came to editing the series back then (and this was also the primary motive for their changing the music: the excuse about paying royalties and whatnot didn't come up till much later on).
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote:either just use Kikuchi or something that's relatively close in spirit to it
If you can't get Kikuchi, don't try to imitate him; you'll just make fans angry, and wish they really were listening to Kikuchi. So, unless they were planning on reusing Kikuchi tracks from the start, going with someone with a similar sound would not be a good idea.
Plus, Kai's whole deal is that it's got a more modern feel to it. Plagiarism aside, Yamamoto's soundtrack did have a "Dragon Ball, but with a modern spin" feel to it, which made him a good choice.
Kikuchi's score, wonderful as it is, was hardly singularly unique: the whole idea was that it reflected a specific style of Chinese-derived music often used in and historically/culturally linked with classic martial arts cinema. DB is basically a Toriyama-ified Shaw Bros./Golden Harvest wuxia movie done at an epic length and with tons of 80s and 90s flourishes thrown in: Kikuchi's score tends to reflect that aspect of the series.

When I said "or something that's relatively close in spirit" I meant close in spirit to that of classic martial arts film scores, not necessarily Kikuchi's take on that style of music specifically. I didn't get a "Dragon Ball but with a modern spin" feel AT ALL from Yamamoto's Kai score: I got a very generic action score feel from it (and considering some of the recent summer blockbuster films he lifted from, that's hardly surprising). And that's all the more frustrating to me because I'm a DIE HARD fan of Yamamoto's Butouden-era DBZ video game music, so much so I put it on almost the same level as Kikuchi's score in terms of both general execution and iconic connection to DB itself.

I walked into Kai when it first began INCREDIBLY psyched as all hell for a new Yamamoto score made specifically for a new cut of the DBZ anime thinking he was the absolute IDEAL choice to replace Kikuchi... and I ended up very exceedingly underwhelmed with what ultimately resulted. Even now going back to it, the score only seems to get blander, duller, and more non-descript than I last remembered it, with one of the few truly distinctive cues being the various Dragon Soul riffs... and those are mainly distinctive due to Dragon Soul being an unbearably obnoxious song, indicative of the general overwrought and insufferable emotional histrionics of modern Shonen.
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote:make sure to get the best out of the Japanese cast
[...]
the depressingly (and very uncharacteristically) phoned-in performances from much of the Japanese cast
They did make sure to get the best out of the Japanese cast.
Given how much people criticise their performance in Kai, I would be pretty shocked Super doesn't get any flak for that...
... Except I'm not, because it's obvious the only reason people get upset about it is because they can compare it to Z.

Ultimately, the Japanese cast did a good job, it just wasn't as good as the stuff they did in Z. And of course it wouldn't be; they're all ~20 years older, and a few of them had died.

(Though, IMO, Ryusei Nakao lost absolutely nothing. If anything, the clearer sound quality of Kai makes his performance even more enjoyable)
I'll agree with you on Nakao for sure: the dude remains a powerhouse to this day. At the end of the day, I don't really want to harp on the Japanese cast too much since 1) as noted, most of them are getting up there in years, 2) even at their worst, they still act rings around most of their English counterparts, and 3) ultimately its a case by case issue.

On the one hand you have people like Nozawa and Nakao who seem to be superhumanly bulletproof no matter the circumstances, on the other you have people like Horikawa and Tsuru, who NORMALLY in even recent video games and in Super have still been doing solid work but for whatever reason were just... not on their A game at various points in Kai (but again, still relatively fantastic actors even at their worst), then you have folks like Yanami who's deterioration is 1000% understandable and excusable, and then lastly folks like Wakamoto, who in some instances just plain seem to not be giving a fuck.

Again, ultimately its among the least of Kai's sins, since even when not at peak capacity, the Japanese cast are all seasoned, class-act professionals, who still bring tons of natural charisma and gravitas to these roles, even when they're not performing to the very best of their abilities.
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote: bite the fucking bullet and straight up re-animate the whole damn thing over from scratch.
Reanimating it all would be a bad idea for so many reasons, there's an entire thread about this.
I haven't seen or read that thread, but that sounds like it'd be an interesting read. If a fully re-animated version was an outright impossibility for whatever reason, then I still maintain that the re-editing of the old footage for Kai could've unquestionably been MUCH better and more carefully handled than it was. As it stands, it comes across like a sloppy cash grab with little thought or care put into its editing and creative choices.
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote:Kai oftentimes would not only leave some bits of filler, it'd even sometimes cut out material from the manga.
Yes, obviously. It's a screen adaptation of the manga. You can't really do a direct 1:1 adaptation from one medium to another, you have to make changes to accomodate the new medium. For a series, a lot of this is to do with the different way a series flows and has to be paced.
Of course its not possible to go exactly 1:1 with the manga. All the more so if you're going to be working with pre-existing footage from the old anime. That wasn't my point or issue.

The issue was that the choices in what to keep and what to edit seem to have been very poorly thought out and done with little care or concern not only with regards to the manga, but also with regards to original directorial intent with the original anime footage. There are countless shots and cuts that aren't at all in the manga, but work within the anime to help establish things like location and geography, dramatic tension and build-up, etc. To lose those robs many scenes of how they're clearly intended to flow as an anime; and thus standout moments from Z that once carried dramatic weight and impact are now neutered and feel hastily rushed through.

Goku and Piccolo vs Raditz is my usual go-to example, but even stuff like the Ginyu fights, Zarbon and Vegeta, Piccolo vs Freeza, etc. while still having their moments, feel thousands of times more lifeless when they're chopped and edited so tightly that nothing has a chance to register and you have such dull, generic action music just sitting there without punctuating or adding anything to the scene. Losing some of the more egregious and pointless cutaways is certainly welcome of course, but that hardly counter-balances against how hobbled everything else now comes across.

Part of what made the original Z anime so effective was that it was framed, blocked, and paced in a VERY cinematic fashion. Every episode felt like you were watching a snippet from the some spectacularly deranged and weird gem of a vintage kung fu movie on a week by week basis. What Kai has in common with English adaptations like the Saban dub is that it makes the anime feel MUCH more in line with a more generic Shonen action show in terms of not only its pacing, but its tone, atmosphere, and so on. And yeah, I get that generic Shonen action shows are the beloved bread and butter to a LOT of folks here: sorry, but I'm just not one of them.

I think the DB anime worked so well in large part because of how very much NOT like a typical kids action show (of the Eastern OR Western variety) it felt or played out as, but rather how much it resembled its source inspiration of nutty fantasy martial arts films from the 60s through early 90s. The more you homogenize it to resemble shows like TMNT and Transformers and G.I. Joe and the like in a Western sense (as the Saban and FUNi dubs did) or shows like Full Metal Alchemist, One Piece, Naruto, and so on on a Japanese end (as Kai does) the less interested and more put off I am. I'm not here because DB is a Shonen/kids' series: I'm here despite it being a Shonen/kids' series. I don't think being a kids' series is part of its inherent charm: I think that's something it OVERCAME and managed to be good in spite of.

Again, that's not to overrate the original Z anime as some untouchable masterwork: it has more than its share of flaws (generally filler-related), flaws that a manga-fied re-edit certainly could've fixed. But Kai didn't fix those flaws in my view: rather it created a whole set of new ones that drain the life out of what made the anime so appealing (even to someone who normally doesn't give a solid flying fuck about Shonen generally) in the first place.
Robo4900 wrote:Though I don't remember any manga material being cut, unless you're referring to the fact some things happen slightly differently in the manga, like the way Videl finds out Gohan is the Great Saiyaman... Though that's in Boo Kai, so it hardly counts.
No I'm not talking about examples like that. I don't have a full list of edits on hand, but there are a number of scenes from the manga that were edited from Kai. Off the top of my head, I remember a bunch of random bits like Raditz realizing he can't break out of Goku's full nelson because Gohan's attack had damaged him too badly, or Goku warning Muten Roshi and Kuririn that they've already been wished back once before by the Dragon Balls, meaning their lives are susceptible if they accompanied him to fight Raditz.

There's a LOT of stuff like that, and it adds up over time and pokes a lot of weird logic holes in the story that were never an issue in the manga or the original Z anime. If you already read the manga or saw Z or just generally know the story very well, then this isn't as much of an issue: but its not exactly ideal for someone who's getting into the series for the first time this way.
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote:For all these reasons (and plenty more), I'm forever dumbfounded as to how anyone can prefer Kai over Z.
Just let people like things.
Do you see me going around door to door and taking people's Kai Blu Ray's at gunpoint?

People are free to like whatever the hell they want to like. But this is a discussion forum, one where people are supposed to express their opinions about DB maters and (ideally) back them up with substance. So that's what I'm doing. If my simply having a different take on a Japanese children's cartoon causes people to get defensive or uncomfortable or feeling like they're somehow personally under attack, then that's entirely on them to take this shit less seriously and not wrap up their personal identity in their favorite anime so much.

I said that I'm at a loss at understanding other's favorable look towards Kai. I didn't say they were wrong, I didn't say they were stupid, or lesser than, or anything of the sort (nor WOULD I say that, because I DON'T think that): I simply said, effectively, "I don't get the love/appeal". That's it.

This hyper-defensiveness over someone saying something even MILDLY challenging (and not even remotely combative) towards someone else's taste has long, LONG ago since gotten immensely tiresome.
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote:both feature entire sequences that are glaringly/poorly redrawn
Saban's dub? No, not really. Several pieces had some digital painting over the top, but no entire scenes were ever really redrawn, just some pieces of the frame here and there.
That's all that I was referencing: that footage had been tampered with in ways that were glaringly obvious and distracting. Kai redrew various cuts entirely, Saban meanwhile added their own touchups for censorship reasons. But the net result of either is obviously-laid-in-after-the-fact newer artwork that badly clashes against the old artwork, and is thus a distracting eyesore most of the time that does the visuals no real favors.
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote:both feature questionable voice acting (outside of the FUNi recasts)
This is where you completely lose me. The Saban/Ocean dub featured exceptional voice acting, and while I would say that Funi's Kai dub seemed to generally be directed to have the entire cast understate their performances to a rather heavy degree, the acting was at least okay within that particular style of delivery. And in the Japanese version, while it doesn't stand up to their old Z performances, they generally did a good/great job.
"Exceptional voice acting" is soooooooooooorely pushing it. There were SOME decent voices. Ted Cole made an affable enough Yamucha. Scott McNeil had some great moments as Piccolo (and some not-so-great moments as well). Drummond had a VERY shaky start, but grew into the role. Kelamis was astoundingly good that one time in that one DBZ movie, but otherwise... gyah. Not so much.

PLENTY of other characters though were just miserably, miserably handled from the jump. Kaio, Muten Roshi, Karin, Gohan, Freeza, and so on.... these were badly cast with horrendous interpretations of how those roles should be played by voice directors who obviously didn't understand the material or the characters in question. Thus you end up with PAINFULLY bad cartoon stereotypes for almost half the cast; stereotypes who's abrasiveness would only be increased tenfold once in-house FUNi stepped in.

If the Ocean cast had anything over the in-house FUNi case, it was professionalism and experience: but the root of the problem ran MUCH deeper than that. The root of the problem was that the Saban dub, from the getgo, was directed to be acted like an over the top silly children's cartoon. Now granted of course, Dragon Ball IS exactly that: an over the top, silly children's cartoon. Here's the thing though: by and large, the Japanese cast NEVER plays it that way. The vocal direction in the Japanese versions skews HEAVILY naturalistic, and with some rare exceptions (your occasional Babidi and Pilaf and the like), the overwhelming majority of the Japanese cast takes these colorful and ridiculous characters and plays them strikingly grounded and organic.

This has a profound impact on how it balances out the overall tone of the whole thing, both with the comedy and the drama alike. Taking these broad characters and acting them with natural, conversational voices grounds almost every scene by a VAST margin. You're able to get actual bits of subtlety in some of the humor (sarcastic slyness, deadpan dryness) as well as IMMENSE gravitas in the dramatic moments. When Kuririn first reacts to Yamucha's death against the Saibaiman... that scene is played in a soberingly real way that NONE of the English dubs come within lightyears of approaching. There's countless examples beyond that.

This series, by its very nature, is already PLENTY wacky and weird and wild enough as it is innately with just its core concepts and visual style. It does NOT need any extra "help" in driving home that wacky, zany craziness into the viewer's skulls by having both the music and the character's voices be so obvious, broad, and caricatured. Adding non-stop droning music and obnoxious, over the top cartoon voices dripping with shtick.... its WAY too much. It takes the show from "charmingly weird and demented" into "obnoxiously intolerable and gratingly punchable". The wackiness of the story, ideas, and visuals are offset and balanced out by the (relatively) grounded realism of the general/overall acting style and the heavily cinematic, genre-appropriateness of the score.

The point is, the earnestness and grounded approach to the Japanese voice acting is instantly disarming to the viewer, and allows you to take these otherwise silly and ludicrous characters with a level of seriousness that its flat out IMPOSSIBLE to have when they're being directed to sound like over the top obnoxious caricatures. Now combine those abrasively obnoxious cartoon stereotype voices with the nonstop droning generic "action" music, the carelessly fast editing (that hacks out far more than just the pointless filler: half the time the pointless filler is LEFT IN anyway), and what you're ultimately left with is a take on DBZ that feels in NO way like a wacky, trippy, vintage Golden Harvest wuxia serial, but instead something that's FAR more in line with much more typical children's action cartoons.

And once more: I get that there are a LOT of people here on this forum to whom that very notion (of DB being packaged and presented to them as a more generic kids' action cartoon) is a SELLING POINT, the feature rather than the bug: but I'm NOT one of those people. I can't stand and detest those kinds of shows generally, and DB/Z was always an exception for how much it thoroughly did not conform to those kinds of kids' animation norms.

The Saban dub was DBZ as reinterpreted through a lens that was endemic to 80s and 90s U.S. kids cartoons like TMNT or Spider-Man, X-Men, G.I. Joe, or something even like Pirates of Dark Water or Mighty Max. Again, that may be a part of the charm to a lot of people here: but when the whole point of getting into anime is to find animation that's NOT like any of those kinds of shows (as it was for myself and a great majority of other anime fans of my era), then DB/Z resembling less Shaw Bros. and more Fox Kids Network sort of soundly defeats the entire purpose.

So no, by that metric, the acting in the Saban dub was anything but "exceptional". The Ocean cast, while consisting of seasoned professionals who've taken part in actual legit quality anime dubs elsewhere, took on these roles here in DBZ no different than they would shows like the U.S. cartoon Mega Man and Street Fighter. In other words, this was treated not as an anime dub, but as work on a typical U.S. kids action cartoon series. If you like those kinds of shows, then cool, you're right at home here. If you don't... then this type of shit is generally absolute water torture to listen to.

An ideal DB/Z dub to me, one that's faithful to the source, would have FAR more grounded and naturalistic acting across the overwhelming majority of the characters: where if you closed your eyes, you'd largely think you were hearing performances from a live action film rather than a cartoon show. There's room for SOME more broad caricaturing here or there (certainly characters like Shen Long should sound supernaturally otherworldly, and the Ocean voice for him did a FANTASTIC job at that and is one of the very best and most fitting voices), but that should largely be kept to a minimum. Just have most of the actors, in most cases, talk like regular-ass human beings most of the time, and let their natural charisma and acting ability do the heavy lifting, as opposed to having them put on some silly and stupid kind of overwrought shtick.

And the ONLY way you'd ever get something like that is a from the ground-up recasting from total scratch of at least 98% of the voices from top to bottom. Which I know isn't ever going to happen in reality: that's just my purely hypothetical "ideal scenario".
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote:End of the day, all Kai amounts to for me is Toei's official version of what Saban and FUNi did to the series in the mid/late 90s
You do realise Saban only cut the episode count down by 14 episodes over the course of the entire first 67? Hell, technically it's only 13, since episode 53 ended only about 7 or 8 minutes into uncut #67's footage, so that episode is only lost by the fact the counting was out of alignment by 8 minutes.
And, remember, the Saban dub was still full of filler and such, it just cut the show down by about 13 episodes so it could fit better for TV syndication. The cuts were done based on what worked for censorship and pacing, but ultimately there was never an intent to make it fit the manga or reduce the filler.
Yes, and I'm arguing that this is ultimately how Kai's editing comes across: like it wasn't done to better fit the manga or reduce filler, but just to better fill out a specific episode count. I'm saying that whether it be Kai or Saban, the editing done was INCREDIBLY careless, was murder on the pacing (in the exact opposite wrongheaded extreme from the original Z anime's more egregious pacing sins: too rushed as opposed to too lethargic) and had little in the way of respect for the manga or the original anime footage's directorial choices. It was slapdash and done in an artless and mercenary manner so as to fit within a predetermined episode count. Nothing more. Hence why I draw the comparisons between Kai and Saban.
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote:And yet what was once sacrilege and awful back then when a U.S. studio does it is now a-ok when Toei does it?
A dubbing company's job is to translate a show into English, yet Saban had them hack it to pieces to suit more convenient TV deals. Kai was a new product produced by the original production company with the express goal of making a shorter version of the show. The situations hardly compare.
Agree on that first point wholeheartedly.

But ultimately its hard for me to call Kai a "new show" when it relies so heavily on old footage from a preexisting show. This is part of why I said it would've been a LOT easier to accept this as its own separate thing if it were just reanimated from scratch: because the show doesn't really conform itself to the manga per-se (it sees fit to both leave in filler as well as do away with bits from the manga willy nilly) thus sacrificing the whole "manga cut" aspect, it ultimately cannot help but come across as virtually almost eerily identical to what Saban ended up doing to the series. That it was done not by a foreign production company but by the original owners/creators is of incredibly little condolence when the end results are so painfully obviously comparable to one another.

Certain aspects were indeed even WORSE on Saban's end (the script and the censorship especially), but generally speaking... these two edits aren't miles apart from one another. And yeah, sorry/not sorry, but Toei being the guys behind it rather than Saban doesn't make the net result suck any less or feel any more like genuine Dragon Ball.

At a certain point, the difference that separates Kai and the Saban dub almost becomes one of pure semantics.
Robo4900 wrote:Though, I will say that I enjoy both of these things; IMO, the Saban dub gets an unfairly bad rep from some people. It's a lot of fun, and definitely worth a watch.
Don't think I need to clarify at this point why I couldn't possibly disagree more with this statement.
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote:and who also badly want a version of the English dub where the FUNimation cast "redeems" themselves.
I mean, Kai was that. Sure, Funi Kai isn't perfect -- in fact, I'd argue it was only a bit more than okay -- but it's Funimation's first actually pretty good dub overall of Dragon Ball that's been faithful to the source material, and only the third time we've had something like that in English Dragon Ball dubbing at all.
Going from "unlistenable" to "meh, passable" is hardly the most winning endorsement. This is something that fans of the FUNi cast have been guilty of doing in almost every discussion of them: grading on a curve. Ultimately I'm not interested in giving them an A for Effort simply because they've pulled themselves up - after what, more than a decade of voicing these roles? - from absolute garbage to moderately decent-ish. By ANY other objective standards, that'd be seen as pathetic and "spitshining a turd to maximum sleekness".

The only reasons I can think of for why anyone would go so far as to grant them THIS much leeway and grade on such a steep, steep curve is if there's A) strong sentimental attachment biasing one's view (and lets face it, most FUNi dub fans are hardly shy about admitting up front that this is generally their main driving motive for remaining so loyal to this cast) and B) a strongly held desire to "prove the haters wrong" and show them that these actors - who many here dearly love primarily because "childhood" despite most of them being woefully awful for the VAST majority of their tenures in these roles over countless many years now - can indeed rise to the level of mere mediocrity.

Well, coming from the view of someone who DOESN'T share the sentiment and couldn't give two shits less whether or not these people can "prove" themselves to me or anyone else - generally speaking as someone who has absolutely ZERO dog in this race whatsoever... the fact that these bad performers have gone from "terrible" to "meh, so-so" is in NO way any sort of ringing endorsement that makes Kai in any which way worth its while.

"But its the first time the FUNimation case have ever sounded KIND OF ALMOST OKAY in these roles!" - this presumes up front that I, or everyone that is a DB fan in some unspoken unanimous hivemind, cares one whit about the FUNimation cast enough that we hold any sort of investment in seeing them be "not entirely terrible just this once!"

Throw the bums out, all of them, or else I don't really care.
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote:I see almost no value or merit in its existence outside of I suppose grabbing more new/younger fans into the fold.
If that is the case, then I would say that's a lot of value and merit.
Some mixed feelings about the overall state of the fandom aside, I generally also agree with this sentiment.
Robo4900 wrote:
Kunzait_83 wrote:Beyon that, all it succeeds in being is a watered down ADHD version for short attention spans.
That's a very insensitive way of phrasing that, so shame on you.
Its an immensely vanilla, benign, and widely used turn of phrase that is quite clearly and obviously in NO way intended with any real malice or ill will towards anyone who actually has ADHD (unless I missed that part of AP History where there was a concerted, historically and systemically ingrained, and deeply oppressive culture of hate and bigotry against kids with ADHD). That includes myself, since I too actually have ADHD and grew up with it from an early age. So from someone who actually has the disorder, by all means, calm down and don't be a stereotypically oversensitive PC police.

There's INFINITELY worse and more deeply hideous and grotesque shit being said every single day about people of different ethnicities, sexual and gender orientations, religious beliefs, severe crippling disabilities, etc. and getting carried away and nitpicking at people over milquetoast figures of speech with even the most MILDEST of "edge" to them is genuinely damaging to instances of REAL insensitivity and hate by playing "boy who cried wolf" over even the most microscopically trivial of infractions and thus lending undue credence to the whole "Social Justice Warrior" strawman that actual hatemongers love to trot out.

No sane or reasonable person would be offended by that sentence, and if someone is, I'd advise that person to get way thicker skin.
Last edited by Kunzait_83 on Fri Apr 06, 2018 1:27 am, edited 1 time in total.
http://80s90sdragonballart.tumblr.com/

Kunzait's Wuxia Thread
Journey to the West, chapter 26 wrote:The strong man will meet someone stronger still:
Come to naught at last he surely will!
Zephyr wrote:And that's to say nothing of how pretty much impossible it is to capture what made the original run of the series so great. I'm in the generation of fans that started with Toonami, so I totally empathize with the feeling of having "missed the party", experiencing disappointment, and wanting to experience it myself. But I can't, that's how life is. Time is a bitch. The party is over. Kageyama, Kikuchi, and Maeda are off the sauce now; Yanami almost OD'd; Yamamoto got arrested; Toriyama's not going to light trash cans on fire and hang from the chandelier anymore. We can't get the band back together, and even if we could, everyone's either old, in poor health, or calmed way the fuck down. Best we're going to get, and are getting, is a party that's almost entirely devoid of the magic that made the original one so awesome that we even want more.
Kamiccolo9 wrote:It grinds my gears that people get "outraged" over any of this stuff. It's a fucking cartoon. If you are that determined to be angry about something, get off the internet and make a stand for something that actually matters.
Rocketman wrote:"Shonen" basically means "stupid sentimental shit" anyway, so it's ok to be anti-shonen.

User avatar
KBABZ
I Live Here
Posts: 4645
Joined: Sun Feb 26, 2017 9:38 pm
Location: The tallest tower in West City

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by KBABZ » Fri Apr 06, 2018 1:26 am

Kunzait_83 wrote:I don't have a full list of edits on hand, but there are a number of scenes from the manga that were edited from Kai. Off the top of my head, I remember a bunch of random bits like Raditz realizing he can't break out of Goku's full nelson because Gohan's attack had damaged him too badly, or Goku warning Muten Roshi and Kuririn that they've already been wished back once before by the Dragon Balls, meaning their lives are susceptible if they accompanied him to fight Raditz.
Huh, I swear that, at least in the Funi dub, that Goku mentioned this to Krillin.

Anyway, I'm not gonna comment on the rest since it isn't my discussion, but I agree that it was pretty stupid of Toei to market Kai like it was a new show when clearly it wasn't. One of my primary issues with Kai is that it seems to actively resist how old the actual content is; things like the title cards, credits, redrawn shots and even the intro animation clash with the old footage because they're so clearly modern. It kinda smacks of what Funimation was doing by pretending that DBZ was the hot new shit and marketed it as such.

I personally have always seen Kai as a derivative, an edit, of Z, because that's exactly what it is. Funimation had the right idea by sticking the Z in the title for their releases.

User avatar
8000 Saiyan
I Live Here
Posts: 2709
Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2016 9:03 am

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by 8000 Saiyan » Fri Apr 06, 2018 1:39 am

I'd argue that the lady who was cast as Gohan in the Ocean dub was well-cast, she sounded quite close to Nozawa.
"It was deemed to be too awesome." - Scott McNeil on Dragon Ball Kai not being aired yet in Canada.

User avatar
Banana
Not-So-Newbie
Posts: 65
Joined: Sat Mar 31, 2018 10:02 pm

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by Banana » Fri Apr 06, 2018 5:56 am

8000 Saiyan wrote:I'd argue that the lady who was cast as Gohan in the Ocean dub was well-cast, she sounded quite close to Nozawa.
Nozawa's got such a unique quality to her voice that I don't think there's anyone who could come similar to her, but despite that being said, in terms of the ocean dub, I like Gohan's voice from the clip I just heard- it's actually quite decent and I can stand it. Actually though, this clip I just listened to was from when he was an adult fighting Buu, so how old were you referring to? I could tell in the clip I saw that Gohan was sounding like he had finally gone past puberty lol. Scary thought.

I guess that what makes things different in English vs Japanese in how it feels is that Goku still sounds like he did when he was a kid to me at times in Z at least, but he does have a more stronger quality and sometimes goes deeper in his voice though not all the time. But it's not inconsistent either- it's like Nozawa knew exactly how to adjust the pitch of her voice to Goku's character in exactly the right moment which speaks to her talent. Gohan is the same. The shrillness of the kids go away but the voicing is largely familiar and the same like a gradual change and not like "and one day, Goku's balls dropped." (I can't stop laughing now, omg I'm so immature, sorry!! Haha)

My friends and I were talking about the English vs the Japanese today and while they largely prefer English and I prefer Japanese, they pointed out the "gravelly-ness" of many English voices and that's honestly *exactly* what irritates me about the English. The Ocean Gohan doesn't have that which is why I think I could stand it.

It's still sad though that Z or Kai aside, I walked right past Sean Schimmel at Comic Con (yes I've seen him in person) and had no desire to formally meat him- he's not my Goku, Nozawa is. Kinda makes me feel guilty as hell. I do feel bad about it. I wish I had more respect for the guy, but I just can't stand his acting... *braces self for incoming tomatoes and trash due to my unpopular opinion*
Goku: Are you a Yoshi?
Piccolo: Yes, Goku, I'm a green ****ing dinosaur.

User avatar
8000 Saiyan
I Live Here
Posts: 2709
Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2016 9:03 am

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by 8000 Saiyan » Fri Apr 06, 2018 6:03 am

Banana wrote:
8000 Saiyan wrote:I'd argue that the lady who was cast as Gohan in the Ocean dub was well-cast, she sounded quite close to Nozawa.
Nozawa's got such a unique quality to her voice that I don't think there's anyone who could come similar to her, but despite that being said, in terms of the ocean dub, I like Gohan's voice from the clip I just heard- it's actually quite decent and I can stand it. Actually though, this clip I just listened to was from when he was an adult fighting Buu, so how old were you referring to? I could tell in the clip I saw that Gohan was sounding like he had finally gone past puberty lol. Scary thought.

I guess that what makes things different in English vs Japanese in how it feels is that Goku still sounds like he did when he was a kid to me at times in Z at least, but he does have a more stronger quality and sometimes goes deeper in his voice though not all the time. But it's not inconsistent either- it's like Nozawa knew exactly how to adjust the pitch of her voice to Goku's character in exactly the right moment which speaks to her talent. Gohan is the same. The shrillness of the kids go away but the voicing is largely familiar and the same like a gradual change and not like "and one day, Goku's balls dropped." (I can't stop laughing now, omg I'm so immature, sorry!! Haha)

My friends and I were talking about the English vs the Japanese today and while they largely prefer English and I prefer Japanese, they pointed out the "gravelly-ness" of many English voices and that's honestly *exactly* what irritates me about the English. The Ocean Gohan doesn't have that which is why I think I could stand it.

It's still sad though that Z or Kai aside, I walked right past Sean Schimmel at Comic Con (yes I've seen him in person) and had no desire to formally meat him- he's not my Goku, Nozawa is. Kinda makes me feel guilty as hell. I do feel bad about it. I wish I had more respect for the guy, but I just can't stand his acting... *braces self for incoming tomatoes and trash due to my unpopular opinion*
I was actually talking about Kid Gohan's Ocean voice.
"It was deemed to be too awesome." - Scott McNeil on Dragon Ball Kai not being aired yet in Canada.

User avatar
Banana
Not-So-Newbie
Posts: 65
Joined: Sat Mar 31, 2018 10:02 pm

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by Banana » Fri Apr 06, 2018 6:14 am

8000 Saiyan wrote:
Banana wrote:
8000 Saiyan wrote:I'd argue that the lady who was cast as Gohan in the Ocean dub was well-cast, she sounded quite close to Nozawa.
Nozawa's got such a unique quality to her voice that I don't think there's anyone who could come similar to her, but despite that being said, in terms of the ocean dub, I like Gohan's voice from the clip I just heard- it's actually quite decent and I can stand it. Actually though, this clip I just listened to was from when he was an adult fighting Buu, so how old were you referring to?
I was actually talking about Kid Gohan's Ocean voice.
Actually now you're right, I can see it somewhat. Found a clip where Gohan meets Tao Pai Pai for the first time and I can hear it, who would have thought? (Couldn't find anything younger on YouTube but that's interesting.)

https://youtu.be/IJY1lw2W3HI
Goku: Are you a Yoshi?
Piccolo: Yes, Goku, I'm a green ****ing dinosaur.

User avatar
Dr. Casey
OMG CRAZY REG
Posts: 758
Joined: Sat Aug 11, 2007 7:05 pm

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by Dr. Casey » Fri Apr 06, 2018 8:29 am

KBABZ wrote:
Banana wrote:Lol well I go Japanese all the way-
Ah! Therein lies the deciding factor. The original Z performances by the Japanese cast are much better than in Kai because with Z they were in their prime. In Kai, actor changes aside, they're just not as sharp and in their prime as they used to (Cell being a particular stickling point). In English however the situation is reverse: with a more accurate script and a decade's worth of practice, Kai is the definitive way to get into the show in English and lemme tell you, it really holds up.
Hm, I'm not sure whether or not age would make a dramatic impact here, especially given how widespread the cast is in years - 2009 Hiromi Tsuru was about the same age as 1986 Masako Nozawa. My theory was always a lack of motivation (retreading the exact same steps being a lot less exciting and fulfilling than creating a story for the first time, if not perhaps outright surreal - I'm just speaking for myself here, but I do think it would be a weird experience to take a trip to the past and return to a series from 13 to 20 years before, the same way as if I was expected to take some classes at the middle school that I graduated from in 2002), and in some cases maybe even anxiety for being expected to match or exceed their original performances when the bar had already been set so high.
Princess Snake avatars courtesy of Kunzait, Chibi Goku avatar from Velasa.

User avatar
ABED
Namekian Warrior
Posts: 17720
Joined: Thu Jan 31, 2013 10:23 am
Location: VA
Contact:

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by ABED » Fri Apr 06, 2018 9:56 am

They did at least in part cut for pacing as well as to fit in the above episode numbers. There's a bunch of early interviews with Gen and Cindy Fukanaga (and Barry Watson as well I think) where they go into candid detail about changes they made specifically to cater to "shorter attention spans" in American children, per several test audiences they showed the series to. Pacing was indeed one of the concerns for that reason when it came to editing the series back then (and this was also the primary motive for their changing the music: the excuse about paying royalties and whatnot didn't come up till much later on).
Fair enough, though it seems odd that the bulk of the edits come out of the Saiyan arc. With the exception of some scenes after Vegeta's defeat and before they get to Namek, most cuts in the Freeza arc are almost imperceptible.
The biggest truths aren't original. The truth is ketchup. It's Jim Belushi. Its job isn't to blow our minds. It's to be within reach.
"You miss 100% of the shots you don't take - Wayne Gretzky" - Michael Scott
Happiness is climate, not weather.

User avatar
sintzu
Banned
Posts: 13583
Joined: Fri Sep 02, 2011 1:41 pm

Re: Re-watching the entire anime, do you get bored?

Post by sintzu » Fri Apr 06, 2018 10:05 am

ABED wrote:What material from the manga did Kai cut?
I don't think it cut anything apart from what wasn't animated to begin with like Piccolo being shown watching Goku and Raditz talk on Roshi's island.
July 9th 2018 will be remembered as the day Broly became canon.

Post Reply