Skar wrote:Wasn't there also an anime only scene with SSJ1 Gohan putting up a decent fight against SSJ1 Goku?
Yeah but Goku also admitted to holding back and it was a casual sparring session anyway so even if he didn't state it, it should be obvious he brought himsellf down to Gohan's level.
This is a Gohan who lost so much power that he questioned if he could even turn SSJ in RoF.
This is not the same Gohan. This is factually incorrect. While presumably not extremely frequently or intensely, he had been training since RoF as he stated after the arc adn as we see in the opening of the episodes during this time. This Gohan is stronger than the one in RoF. Even so, his Base must have had significant strength because it was stronger than Piccolo when this obviously wasn't the case in the Buu arc. He was weaker than he was as Ultimate Gohan but still strong enough that he's 50+ times stronger than Piccolo as a SSJ even during RoF and he got stronger since then.
In DBZ, there were times when anime-only scenes contradicted the manga so I don't know why that can't be applied to DBS
That can't be done because the circumstances are entirely different. During DBZ, the anime was based on the original manga by the original creator. This is no longer the case in which each are their own continuity and are equally valid or "canon." The power scaling is completely different in the anime than the manga so it makes zero sense to disregard scenes that aren't in the manga, because they are each their own continuities that handle power scaling differently.
I don't think there are any scenes in the manga that imply base Goku and Vegeta are stronger than Buu saga characters
Well yes this is true, but this is exactly what I mean when I say that the scaling between the manga and anime is totally different. The scene where Goku retained the same level of power as SSG in his SSJ didn't exist in the manga and the scene where Vegeta trains for 6 months while Goku is farming and achieves power that is "completely unrecognizable from what it was on Earth." Neither of these things happened in the manga and they establish this enormous boost that happened in the anime and not the manga.
Sorry but I don't think something like this constantly happened in the series
Well, yeah it is actually, even fodder of the current arc is equal or stronger than what was the big bad from the previous arc. Raditz being stronger than Piccolo Daimao, Dodoria, Zarbon, Cui and the entire Ginyu force are all stronger than the main villain of the previous arc, all of the Androids that weren't even the main villain during their arc(obviously being cell) were vastly superior to Freeza who was the main villain of the previous arc, In the Buu arc a henchman was as strong as the previous arc's main villain. This is power creep. It has been happening constantly throughout the series and I don't know how you came to the conclusion that this doesn't constantly happen in the series.
Cabba outperforming all of Goku and Vegeta's training combined while also surpassing their fusion is a far greater power-up than anything that has happened in the original manga
It is simply a consequence of the power creep in the DBS anime. Characters have to be scaled up to compete with Goku and Vegeta because otherwise it wouldn't make for much of a story.
If a fan comic decided to have a base Saiyan kid surpass SSJ1 Vegetto and the only explanation is that "he's from a different universe and evolved differently" then that would considered OC wanking. That's more wanking than I've ever witnessed in a fan comic!
Yeah, no offense but this is irrelevant to the discussion.
I would prefer to assume Saiyan Beyond God was retconned and Goku and Vegeta's normal base didn't improve that much than for Cabba to out-train them and rival/surpass than SSJ1 Vegetto.
Well "Saiyan Beyond God" was retconned from the movies to the DBS anime. In the movie continuity they had a new form that was essentially their new Base form that they could use God Ki in, and it had surpassed SSG, and this form had rendered SSJ and SSG to be obsolete. This is not the case in the DBS anime, they were just stated/shown to have super strong base forms and it's that simple.