Now I know that the Future Trunks TV special is basically an adaption of the Trunks the Story special chapter. But in my honest opinion, with how much the TV special rotates the plot for certain events and expands on the narrative, I see it as its own unique entity.
So, let's do this.
===
Trunks the Story –A Lone Warrior–:
Spoiler:
Anyways, on the story itself. Well, actually, I tell a lie. This sidestory suffers from the problem as Dragon Ball minus does: there really isn't much of story. It feels more like bullet point of certain events masked with Toriyama's artwork. It's an exposition of events that the audience are fully aware of. Such as #17 and #18 causing havoc, Future Trunks being trained by Future Gohan, Bulma building the time machine for Future Trunks to go back in time and Future Trunks deciding to go back in time. The biggest issue with this sidestory is the pacing. This sidestory moves a break-neck speed. To the point where there's not even any fighting shown. This ironically works in the favour of when Future Gohan confronts #17, with #17 revealing that he hadn't been using any more than half of his power in any of their confrontations, leading to a shocked Future Gohan realising his fate is sealed and with #17 charing right at him and #18 eerily smiling knowing what will come of battle between her brother and Future Gohan.
The reveal of Future Trunks finding Gohan's bloodied corpses is quite subdued but palpable. It's a moment that doesn't linger on longer than it should, which actually adds the emotional weight of emphasising what a hopeless war it feels like against #17 and #18. As Gohan, despite all his significance in the main story, from the perspective of Future Trunks story, is just seen another casual casualty of a conflict that threatens all of mankind. His death, from Toriyama's perspective, doesn't lead to anything, which makes it all the more tragic and poignant.
Future Trunks then goes off to fight the #17 and #18 in a battle that feels redundant. I mean, the very first fight in this chapter is basically SSJ Future Trunks sparring against a one-armed Gohan... in his base form. And considering that Future Gohan knocks out Future Trunks to prevent him from getting involved in the battle against #17 and #18, it's very clear to see that Future Trunks, despite his strength, if any confrontation were to happen with Future Trunks and #17 and/or #18, Future Trunks would lose terribly. And that's not even taking into consideration the dramatic reveal #17 made to Future Gohan about how much power he had been holding back in their previous battles and the fact that Bulma is already building a time machine so that Future Trunks can go back in time to aid in changing the events of their crapsack of a future world.
However, I do feel as though as redundant at that battle may have been to moving the plot forward, it still could have felt wholesome to nature of the chapter. What I mean by this is that by showing the skirmish between #17 and #18, we could have gotten a much better insight into the personal struggle that Future Trunks goes through with his world. This is actually something that chapter just fails to capture. There's no sense of urgency after Gohan's death. Three years pass and you never get the feeling the that world is any closer to the total apocalypse that Future Gohan alluded would happen if Future Trunks were to die.
The chapter just doesn't do enough really make you feel invested in Future Trunks hardships. I mean, yes, we know that Future Trunk's world is a hellhole but the chapter doesn't really do enough to sell that image. I hate to bring up this comparison, but given that this is the film where Toriyama obviously took great inspiration for Future Trunks' story in the Cell arc, the comparison must be made. Let looks at how Terminator 2: Judgment Day handled this. Straightway we’re treated to a dark, foreboding, deserted landscape, with an eerily hopeless background with the longing shot of destruction of highways, playgrounds and just bone remains of the corpses of those were obviously caught in the middle of war there were not ready for. Made all the more apparent you can see some of the bones and corpses still remaining in cars of roads that was most certainly gridlocked with traffic. Then you cut to the human resistance trying its hardest to fight against the omniums, overwhelming threat of the machines created by Skynet, as they lose countless soldiers despite managing to fight back. And in response to this seemingly endless stalemate of a war, both the human resistance and Skynet send terminators in the past to protect the man who would spearheard the resistance against Skynet and provide hope for mankind, John Connor. Right off the bat, there's a sense of urgency, importance, and drama. This chapter just lacks that.
Future Trunks is already a Super Saiyan by the time chapter begins, removing any kind of additional context to what kind hard work and/or emotional grief Future Trunks went through to attain the form -- which could have worked as good character building for Future Trunks as well -- Future Gohan's death contributes nothing to the chapter or the Future Trunks character, and the battle between himself and #17 and #18, and battle that happens three years after Gohan dies, happens off-screen and ends with Future Trunks losing. This goes back to one of my first complaints, this chapter has no sense of pacing because everything move too damn quick and certain elements are left unexplored.
This is meant to be Future Trunks' story but Toriyama seem quite uninterested in, well, telling the story itself. It's not enough, at least from Future Trunks perceptive to tell audience how much of struggle it is against #17 and #18, you need to actually show the audience that. Get them emotionally invested. Because it's going to have adverse effect of how much people get satisfaction on the payoff to Future Trunks curb-stomping #17 and #18, if the audience never get a proper window into how much of a struggle it was for Future Trunks initially to combat the threat of #17 and #18. That's how tell a emotionally gripping story. When you make the audience feel what the characters are feeling. And this chapter just doesn't cut the mustard in that regard.
It's not enough for the chapter to tell us that Future Trunks was lucky to survive against #17 and #18 when goes off to fight them -- which in itself is terrible fucking writing -- the chapter needs to show the conflict so the audience can be more invested in Future Trunks eventually overcoming the walls in front of him. It's doubly an issue considering that is that conflict that lead to Future Trunks deciding to go back and becoming the no-nonsense pragmatist in battle that his revered for in-universe and loved for out-of-universe.
This isn't a bad sidestory per se. But... it's just doesn't do enough to justify its existence. Yes, it's a backstory. But it doesn't feel important in terms of characters, plot, or even the case of world building. It falls into the trap that most prequels stories fall into: It's has nothing significant to say. To the point where I'd even question whether Future Gohan should have been in this chapter at all. I mean, this chapter tries to paint the image that Future Gohan played this important teacher role to Future Trunks, but you don't really see the fruits of that tutelage. Future Trunks is already a Super Saiyan and it's never explained how he attained the form, Future Gohan prevents SSJ Future Trunks from battling #17 and #18 as he feels Future Trunks would die against them in his current state, but as we later see Toriyama has no problem giving Future Trunks a healthy dose of Plot Armor when he goes off to fight them on his own three years later and somehow doesn't die, and Future Gohan's death in itself leads to nothing. With the last scenario, as I pointed out before, you could use Future Gohan's off-screen bloody fate as a way of further emphasizing the nihilistic and hopeless tone of the chapter by treating Future Gohan's death as just another fatality of war. But my counterargument to this would be that the chapter never made the effort to feel as though this was a war to begin with.
There's just nothing from this chapter that feels essential to read and find out about. This is a chapter that mostly regurgitates already known information. And when it came for the chapter to provide its own unique events, it chooses not to. This chapter is fluff material. The greatest successes in life are born from the greatest setbacks. And this chapter wasn't interested in giving more insight into the setbacks that moulded Future Trunks journey. Which is a big shame. This chapter isn't inherently good or bad because of its purpose is, which is basically glorified window dressing for the Cell arc, the problem is that this chapter is that its just... kinda... there. As something that exists, but, consequently, doesn't bear much importance.
5.5/10
===
Defiance in the Face of Despair!! The Remaining Super-Warriors: Gohan and Trunks:
Spoiler:
Right out of the gate, this TV special sorts out the biggest issue I had with the chapter Toriyama wrote: we have proper context for how desperate the situation is for Future Trunks. The story starts off with showing the passing of Goku, and we're given brief but impactful reaction shots from the remaining Z-Fighters upon the discovery of Goku's passing from the heart virus. The story then cuts to showing the remaining Z-Fighters trying the failing to defeat #17 and #18 and dying the process.
We then get treated to the very instance #17 and #18 start wreaking havoc as they blow up a city. There's even more of insight into their characterisation, that is all the while wonderfully intertwined with the innate desire for chaos and destruction, as #18 goes clothes shopping in this midst of their genocide of mankind, exhibiting her materialistic nature, and then #17 destroying the store she done getting new clothes, and we later see #17 joyriding while mowing down countless people, and then we see #17 and #18 having a gay old time at an amusement park, which then then quickly reduce to rubble once they're done having fun in it.
All those scenes may seem like padding, but it serves as great characterisation for two characters, who lacked really any kind of personality in the special chapter Toriyama wrote. It fleshes out their characters, while providing the perfect juxtaposition of the down-to-earth and innate whimsical human nature while showcasing their spontaneous destructive capabilities and thirst for bloodshed. It's that wonderful balance of terror and humour that really only one other story arc in Dragon Ball managed to capture perfectly. Majin Boo arc ftw.
One other thing the TV special does exceptionally well is build up Future Trunks as a character, and well as develop a great bond with Future Gohan and Future Trunks. Future Trunks in the TV special actually gets an arc. You see him training with Gohan from the ground up, trying his hardest to attain the power that his mentor has so that he can perhaps use that strength, or build on top it, to defeat the artificial humans. But all the attempts in training prove to vain. This is further hammed home with Future Trunks and Future Gohan teaming up to fight #17 and #18 and it's made very apparent that without SSJ, Future Trunks is even more hopelessly outmatched against #17 and #18 than his mentor is, despite the fact his mentor has SSJ.
The battle ends with a beaten and bloodied Future Trunks and Future Gohan, with Future Gohan losing an arm in the process, answering the enquiry as how Gohan has only one arm in the original special chapter from Toriyama's manga. And while that detail may seem minor, it adds a layer of desperation to what Future Gohan and Future Trunks are going through, as well as giving more context of the journey for the characters through their struggles. Gohan's loss of an arm isn't treated as some negligible event. It's treated as a major deal with regards to how he will be able to defend himself in future confrontations against #17 and #18. Something that is made wonderfully very obvious when he fights #17 and #18 on his own later in the TV special as he's put at an even further disadvantage in fantastic 2 on 1 battle that has great direction and animation, and is personally one of my favourite fights in the franchise.
Not only do I love one armed Gohan vs #17 and #18 for its unique fight choreography of having a one armed person in battle, but I also love the fight for having the most sombre and tragic death in all of Dragon Ball. It's one of very few fights I've ever come across that actually has the knowledge of knowing the outcome of the battle and having it work to its advantage from a storytelling perspective. You know that Gohan is going to die but the circumstances were never made clear. And after witnessing Gohan perish in literal rain of Ki blasts, then accompanied by the downpour of the thunderstorm in the background of the battle, it feels so cumulative. And while the original special chapter simply alluded to how Gohan died in battle shown and managing to still make it work for dramatic effect, Gohan's death in the TV special feels so much more punctuated.
The TV special really gives Future Trunks the "coming-of-age" kind of story. You see a strong-willed young half-breed Saiyan push himself as hard as he can to attain a power he feels would make a difference battle against a threat that endangers billions of people, but always comes up short when it matters. You also see that underneath that resolute attitude is an emotionally fragile boy whose continuous battles against a seemingly invincible foe, combined with the endless destruction being caused and the feeling of hopelessness to stop it from happening, has slowly started to drain the hope from him and reduce him to tears at the situation at hand. And it was only through the death of his beloved mentor that he managed to break through the glass ceiling and attain the power he so desperately tried to attain since the beginning training sessions of the TV special. But now that the moment has happened, the question ultimately arises... can this new strength be enough? And the TV special swiftly responds, "no".
The next major battle features Future Trunks, three years after the death of Future Gohan, has him go into battle against #17 and #18 despite being made very apparent that his charging into a battle he can't win. This battle is fantastic for several reasons. The first reason being that this battle marks the subtle but swift development of Future Trunks' character. After miraculously escaping death at the hands of #17 and #18, gone is the brash, bull-headed feisty Saiyan who goes head first into battle hoping for a different outcome and in his place is the more mature, cool-headed and pragmatic Saiyan the character in the main story would be come to know better as.
The second reason is just how perfectly the battle captures the overall grim and hopeless tone of Future Trunks world. How Future Trunks decides to run for his life after seeing he can't do anything to #17 and #18. How #17 and #18 hunt him down like a classic slasher movie villain. How Future Trunks staggers around punching in vain at #17 and #18 who don't move an inch, until they feel they've had enough "fun" and decide to end the battle. It not only wonderfully encapsulates the terror of the #17 and #18 as the sick and twisted antagonists they are, but wonderfully moulds Future Trunks' character. He grows ups. And comes to the realisation that he must think more cautiously before jumping into the fray or it may cost him his life and his world. It's all so heartbreakingly tragic. And all this character building it comes to its natural conclusion with Future Trunks deciding to go to the past.
This is a phenomenal story. It takes a barebone outline and fleshes it out into something meaningful. Nearly every action in the TV special carry some degree of emotional weight. Future Trunks, Future Gohan, #17 and #18 feel like more fleshed-out characters. Future Gohan works extremely well as the stern but loving mentor, with his death having a wonderfully ironic dramatic effect and being arguably as the most emotionally impactful death in the series, #17 and #18 feel more like layered villains that still carry enough charm to make you love to hate them and Future Trunks' gets a genuine character arc.
But the most important thing is that this TV special actually made me emotionally invested in Future Trunks world. Something the special chapter in the original managsimply didn't do. You see how the world crumbles from the very moment #17 and #18 first appear, to how much it has a mental and physical burden for those who chose to fight back (Future Gohan, Future Trunks and Earth's Army), you witness the destruction, the terror and anxiety that mankind goes through because of #17 and #18. The brief cameos from Roshi, Oolong, Puar, Gyūmaō and Chi Chi do a good service to the story by illustrating just how far-reaching the effects of how much the deaths of those close to them have affected their lives. With Roshi relenting the fact that he can't do anything and Chi Chi going into a solitude over the depression for the loss of her husband and her only son fighting the artificial humans. They're all brief moments, but incredibly tragic went put together. And with how sadistic #17 and #18 are in their genocide of the human race, there is already a great amount of catharsis being built up for the inevitable downfall of #17 and #18 which will make Future Trunks killing them in the main story all the more satisfying.
I really could on and on about what I loved about the TV special. Like how fantastic the animation and direction are, how Shunsuke Kikuchi's score adds so much atmosphere to certain scenes, and how Takeshi Kusao delivers the performance of a lifetime, with special mention to his anguish skyward scream upon finding Gohan's corpse in the rain.
This is essential Dragon Ball viewing. Every Dragon Ball fan owes it to themselves to watch this TV special. This is Toei at their best with Toriyama's work.
10/10
===
Dragon Ball Super - Future Trunks arc:
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
I'm not going to lie, when this arc was first announced, I was against the idea of Future Trunks coming back as felt his character had reached a natural conclusion following the events of the Cell arc and should have been permanently shelved. I also felt that Dragon Ball didn't have a good track record when it came to bring back characters from the original story. *cough*Bardock*cough* So I went into this arc with a lot trepidation.
But I was willing to give this arc a shot. I mean, it's a no-lose situation at this stage, given that despite Toriyama's involvement in the creative process of Super in general, whether it's concerning the narrative or the character designs, it's effect on the original run is tangible at best. It's not like Dragon Ball Minus where this is a Dragon Ball story that is written and drawn solely by Toriyama and is based around the backstory of the main character of Dragon Ball. This is ultimately an extension, albeit and pretty artificial one, of a side character who's significance in the main story stems from one arc for one moment. No harm no foul, right?
Right off the bat with the arc, we get presented with the (initial) central antagonist Goku Black. Whose debut, in my opinion, is the best of any Dragon Ball villain ever. The three things that I feel are key to a villain debut being memorable and effective are that the villain in question establishes themselves as a major threat, brings an aura of mystery and has an instant personal connection with the central cast. Goku Black's initial appearance ticks every one of those boxes effortlessly and flawlessly. He arrives, murders Bulma in front of Future Trunks, kills Mai (but not really) and threatens to end Future Trunks’ life. All the while looking exactly like Goku. It’s simple, to-the-point, and incredibly effectively. Unfortunately, Toyotaro’s version of the same events in the manga loses major points for glossing over Future Bulma’s death and having it happen off-screen. And unlike Future Gohan’s death in the original manga where this would had been effective given Future Gohan’s minimal and somewhat inconsequential role the Trunks The Story special chapter, Future Bulma actually plays a major role in how Future Trunks’ story plays out. So really, skipping over the death of a character like her is a very stupid narrative decision to make, given it robs the story the further emotional weight the narrative in general.
Future Trunk’s skirmish with Goku Black before escaping to past is great in both medium, but when it comes to him being treated by main cast for his injuries and awaking to see Goku in front him, this is where, in my opinion, the difference in handling of certain scenes between the anime and manga start to become very apparent. While Future Trunks attacking Goku is treated with the dramatic effect is deserves in the anime, as everyone looks in shock at what just happened, in the manga, it's treated more like a gag. And just doesn’t work with the tone the arc set ups or the events just previously witnessed. This is a man who’s literally seen his mother dying at the hands of man who like just like Goku, and is very clearly going through a heavy case of PTSD. You don’t follow up a serious moment like this with a “Oh, that old Trunks” kind of tone. It’s just so jarring and plays down the emotional significance of Future Bulma’s death.
The next element of the story has Goku sparring with Future Trunks, in call-back to the initial sparring contest in the Cell arc. And credit where it’s due, in both mediums this fight is really good. But this is where Toyotaro takes in the extra step to make the fight more meaningful for Future Trunks. Despite how much Goku has grown as fight, Future Trunks never rested on his laurels and found a way to tap into a more powerful version of Super Saiyan 2 that manages to equal Goku’s strength as a Super Saiyan 3, but with the stamina baggage that comes with it. I love this reveal. Because not only does it display wholesome growth in Future Trunks power, but emphasizes his pragmatic nature in combat how he ventures into area of strength and transformation run less of a “high risk high reward” like Super Saiyan 3 does. Future Trunks seeks to become stronger, but is smart about as he doesn’t want any of the Super Saiyan forms he uses in high stakes battle to be liability for him. And this reveal in the manga leads to Goku having to use a bit of Super Saiyan God power to defeat him. Which just hammers home how far Future Trunks has come with own devices and his world falling apart. These are small changes but they make a big difference to how you view the character.
After this point is where Toei with the anime and Toyotaro with the manga take very different routes in how the story progress, and we really get two quite different stories, excluding how the arc definitively ends.
In the anime, we have Goku Black travelling to the past to fight Goku. It’s fun, but it doesn’t lead to anything, other than giving the know of how Goku Black grows stronger the more he fights and/or takes damage. In the manga, we have more of an insight into Future Trunks training with Kaioshin and Kibito. Which is nice to know, but again, like Goku Black fighting Goku in Episode 51 of the anime, it serves no real purpose for the narrative other than to expand of the backstory element of Future Trunks interactions with Kaioshin and how he dealt with Babidi, Dabra and all the Majin minions when they arrived to Future Trunks’ world. But I’m going to be honest, I’ve always wondered what would have happened in that kind of scenario for years, so I’m personally glad to get a more detail answer to that question compared to brief flashback in the anime.
Episode 52 to 56 of the anime and chapters 16 to 18 in the manga are more or less the downtime and investigation period for the Future Trunks arc, and I find these episodes and chapters to be the most wholesome of the entire arc.
There’s a wonderful down-to-earth nature with how Future Trunks becomes adjusted and learns to deal with how the cast have grown and changed since he last encountered them. Visiting Gohan to realize he doesn’t have the killer warrior instinct to him and has no settled down with a family bring about a heart-breaking contrast to how Future Trunks covertly idealizes to have the regular and peaceful life like Gohan. And I can’t deny the moment where Future Trunks hypothesizes of a normal life with Future Mai and Future Bulma only to realise that kind of reality is now not possible is quite tragic. Despite how the fanbase fawn over Future Trunks for handsome he is, or powerful he’s become, deep down, he just wants a regular life surrounded by the people he loves and care for. It’s in that moment we see what Future Trunks really wants out of life. And it’s so down-to-earth that it’s equally sad and relatable.
I also must say that I find Future Trunks’ quizzical reaction to the realisation that #18 and Krillin ended becoming a couple and having a child as quite hilarious. Another equally funny scene is when, as Future Trunks is about to spar with Vegeta, Future Trunks asks Vegeta to transform into Super Saiyan 3 as Goku did, and Vegeta just laughs in response and transforms in Super Saiyan Blue. On the flip-side, the manga takes an equally nice approach with Future Trunks playing a Mario Kart knock-off videogame with Goku, Vegeta, Beerus and other members of the cast. It’s basically filler but it’s quite fun to see Beerus rage quit after losing.
Then the investigation period begins, and I’m in two minds about with how Toei and Toyotaro handle this. With the anime, the mystery is stretched out a bit, but it makes for a more interesting narrative. The story presents the obvious solution but then throws a huge curve ball in the form Episode 56. As Zamasu literally descends from the heavens and joins Goku Black at his side. I can’t express how great of plot twist that was when I first saw it. And still hold up extremely well with repeated viewings. I can’t unfortunately say the same for the manga. The mystery is never really made to create suspense in the narrative as it’s quickly deduced in a quite clunky exposition dump that Zamasu is Goku Black. This sudden reveal suffers from the exact same issues as Cell’s exposition dump reveal have in the manga. From where there could have been intrigue and wild massing guessing as to who Goku Black, it’s just conveniently and casually dropped that Zamasu is Goku Black. It was incredibly anticlimactic when Toriyama did this with Cell and it’s incredibly anticlimactic when Toyotaro did this with Goku Black.
Future Trunks’ involvement in the major battles with Goku Black and Zamasu is where his significance in the story truly does contrast. In both the anime and manga, Vegeta is first to combat Goku Black. In the anime, Goku and Vegeta fighting Goku Black is treated more like an exercise, with them wanting to take turns in fighting, akin to how they acted in Resurrection F when they fought Freeza. And I didn’t like Resurrection F or how Goku and Vegeta were written in that movie, so that should tell you what I think about Goku and Vegeta’s first encounter with Goku Black in the manga. Naturally, Goku Black manages to turns the tables on Vegeta. With Goku Black working tandem with Zamasu to abuse the near death/beaten up badly power up in the manga. Whereas the anime takes a more unconventional route and has Goku Black not only get stronger the more he fights, which is something stated by in manga and by Toriyama himself in later interviews as Saiyan specific trait, but he also seems to get stronger from taking damage in general. That method of getting stronger is… unconventional, to say the very least.
With Goku Black ascending to Super Saiyan Rose, as result of Zamasu mastering Goku’s power in the anime (which is far too vague of a reason for my liking), or as the result of a deity surpassing the realm of the power of Super Saiyan God in the manga (which is a dumb reason that can’t work in any other context beyond Goku Black specifically), Vegeta as a Super Saiyan Blue takes the major loss as newly transformed Goku Black and Goku and Future Trunks step in against Goku Black and Zamasu. Well, at least in the anime they do. Future Trunks plays more of a distraction role in the manga. Which I can also appreciate given it’s made very apparent he’s out of his depth in the battle against Goku Black. It’s certainly fitting for his character to think strategically and know what kind of battle he takes part in and what kind of battles he should take the more cautious approach with. But I can’t deny it though, seeing Goku and Future Trunks team up, for the first time in Dragon Ball history to battle Goku Black and Zamasu in Episode 57 of the anime was so wonderfully directed, animated and written. And considering in the original story we see Future Trunks jump into the battle with #18 and Super Saiyan Vegeta, when he realises that Vegeta is great distress, it would certainly be consistent for Future Trunks, despite knowing the dangers, to throw himself into the battle when he realises that his family and close allies are in great peril.
Now, I what the complaints are going to be with how the anime originally handled this scenario in Episode 57… “Future Trunks has no right to fight Super Saiyan Rose Goku!”, “Super Saiyan Future Trunks fighting Super Saiyan Rose Goku Black is bad power scaling” To which my response is, well, it would be a major issue if that episode ended with Super Saiyan Future Trunks actually defeating Super Saiyan Rose Goku Black and/or Zamasu. Neither of those scenarios happen. Super Saiyan Future Trunks kicking Super Saiyan Rose Goku Black into a building is ultimately an extremely brief moment that really doesn’t have any kind of bearing on the outcome of the fight. Goku and Future Trunks still lose badly against Goku Black and Zamasu. It’s the same deal in the manga. I don’t mind that Super Saiyan 2 Future Trunks was able to suck punch Super Saiyan Rose Goku Black into a building and then beat him up briefly because the battle was already lost, and it was just a case of Goku and Vegeta escaping to the past.
Unfortunately, Future Trunks being the sacrificial lamb to allow Goku and Vegeta to escape to the past, is pretty much where is peaks for Future Trunks in active combat. After that point, his role is to save Gowasu’s life, provide commentary in battle and heal Goku before he has to fight Merged Zamasu. And… that’s it. Well, I will give credit to where it’s due, Future Trunks certainly performed to limit of his capabilities. He hits a brick wall and Toyotaro doesn't provide him with any kind of spontaneous or random means to overcome it.
That is a compliment I can't share with the Toei approach in this are in the story the anime. As upon the main casts second skirmish with Goku Black and Zamasu, Future Trunks attains a new Super Saiyan form through rage. What the Super Saiyan form is, is never explained. The form is never named. There’s never any payoff to it. And it just looks dumb. If there was some kind of build-up to this Super Saiyan form, I wouldn’t have minded. But it just sticks out for the wrong reasons. There’s no justification for Future Trunks having this unique Super Saiyan form beyond the supposed rationale, which was most likely, “Well… we need to find a way for Future Trunks to still be in the major battles.” It’s so cliché and such a superficial and inorganic fashion to insert a character back into the central conflict of the plot. There are many ways you could keep Future Trunks relevant to the plot that still retain the cohesion of the narrative. But Toei had to go with the cheapest and dumbest option possible. It’s just very lazy writing in general.
Following Future Trunks initial defeat against Goku Black and Zamasu in the anime, despite having Goku and Vegeta to back him up, the story takes a break to have some personal contemplation for the ramifications the outcome of that had battle had the psyche of Future Trunk as we're treated to a very solemn and downtrodden Future Trunks quietly angst over his inability overcome the walls of Goku Black and Zamasu and protect what he's has left and Kid Trunks call him out on having that attitude. Seeing Kid Trunks confront him about needlessly moping around is honestly one of my favourite bits of character interactions in all of Super because it feels genuine.
For most of the arc, Kid Trunk has been a quite a lose over the how the handle the introduction of his future and older self. Most of Kid Trunks reactions to Future Trunks are centred around aura of inferiority at his vastly more impressive looking adult, alternate timeline counterpart. Then he sees, what could be himself in the future, wallowing in self-pity following a defeat. And it stokes a fire inside of Kid Trunks. From Kid Trunks perspective, he wouldn't act like this after losing. And calls, well, himself out to act more like a Saiyan. And while the battle between Future Trunks and Kid Trunks happens off-screen in the anime, the fight itself isn't what's important. It's the general lesson that Kid Trunks was trying to instil with Future Trunks by antagonizing him: And that was keep fighting, regardless of who the enemy is. It's nice sentiment to share in the story and compliments Future Trunk's character arc, and even Kid Trunks general characterization, quite well.
This is the part of the story where the Toyotaro with his take of the arc in the manga drops the ball. As I mentioned before, Future Trunks' mental trauma relating to his very recent horrific personal experiences with Goku Black are trivialized to the point where it's treated like a gag. There is a time and place for a joke. And the follow up off of Future Trunks acting attacking Goku in unintentional spontaneous out-of-character should have been treated with more levity. Have the cast react shocked at the very least. Or perhaps use that very apparent mental trauma to are more layers to Future Trunk's character by exploring just how mentally fractured Future Trunks has become from the conflict with Goku Black.
As much as I railed on random nature of Super Saiyan Rage, it at least felt like some that was birthed from the emotional instability the arc dipped its toe into with Future Trunks characterization. Goku Black and Zamasu remonstrated Future Trunks for his use of time travel, and how all the casualties ensued are his burden to live and deal with for his actions in trying to save his world. An already mentally fragile character exploded with anger as a coping mechanism when contemplating the possibility that perhaps the responsibility of everything that is happening to his dying world does indeed rest on his shoulders. The execution wasn't the best but the intent was there.
Then there's climax of the arc. It's the most divisive ending in any Dragon Ball arc by a wide margin.
Let's just address the elephant in the room right out of the gate regarding a crucial part of the climax of this arc in the anime: The Genki Dama sword. Long story short: It's really fucking stupid in practice. And even worse than Super Saiyan Rage, as this actually plays a significant factor in the shift of the narrative. It really is one of the most nonsensical things I've ever seen in Dragon Ball -- which is really saying something -- and the epitome of what I think is Super's greatest issue when it comes to writing. In the fact that Super will at times rely solely on "Rule of Cool" to coast from one story and/or character beat to another without any shred of consideration of the unfortunate implication this method of storytelling can have on the emotional investment from the viewer towards the events unfolding the narrative. I mean, what more can be said about that moment other than, "Okay, that looked cool. But what the fuck just happened?"
However, I think in thematic sense, the Genki Dama sword moment -- with the proper build up and the explanation -- works and doesn't seem too out of place. From the beginning of the arc to the end of the arc, Future Trunks was fighting valiantly for what remained of humanity in his world, and every step of the way, the humans that remained on Earth in his world, as well the allies from the main cast (Goku, Vegeta and Bulma) supported him every time things looked grim and he was looked up as the hope bringer for his timeline. So, I find the idea of the humans that were left urged Future Trunks on so much that they innately gave him their power to slay an extreme misanthrope like Merged Zamasu is a very cathartic and wonderfully ironic demise for a character for him. This is all of course speaking hypothetically. The scene itself, as it is presented, while visually stunning, is painfully contrived, and only has some redeeming artistic value if you turn your brain off and decide you like a fireworks display.
Toyotaro thankfully takes a more grounded and sensible approach to the final battle. But unfortunately like the anime, there a few story beats that don't get the build-up they need to make their appearance in the narrative seem less like a "We need this to happen right now" moment. Goku spontaneously learning to prevent the Ki leakage of Super Saiyan and Goku using Hakai are two moments that I feel with a bit more build up could have served as moments that complimented the story rather than an impressive visual moment that feels like it was written a vacuum.
Taking into consideration the hard work the main cast went through when it came to fighting Goku Black, Zamasu and eventually and the combined sum of their parts in the form of Merged Zamasu, it seems like a bit of disservice that Zamasu, through mean which only really described as an “Diabolus Ex Machina". The appearance of infinite Zamasu in the anime and the clone army of Merged Zamasu are both very problematic narrative scenarios. There's no coherent justification given for why the antagonists appear in the fashion they do in either medium. Which makes their significance in the fate of Future Trunks timeline all the more frustrating.
Even more infuriating is the casual erasure of the Future Trunks entire timeline at the hands of Zeno. Because, you're left asking, what has Future Trunks got left? Why was all that hard work he made to save his world made in vain? Future Trunks is a character that has already gone through so much pain and misery that seeing him still fail in such a grand manner like this can be disheartening. Probably the worst aspect of this ending is the jarring tone shift. Following the loss of Future Trunks' entire timeline, and remaining survivors going back to the main timeline, and you know how the cast handle this epic and tragic fallout? They have a motherfucking barbecue. This is so at odds with the events that transpired. Zamasu basically won. And this is how they respond to this revelation?
And although Zamasu suffered a fate worse than death in the end, the collateral damage that ensued through that process has robbed Future Trunks of everything he holds dear to him. The cast shouldn't be a having a barbecue in the aftermath of an events like this as if it's a botched wedding or party. Both the anime and manga fumbled this part of the ending so goddamn hard. But the anime is very much the lesser of two evils in this regard. The anime, despite it being brief, has the vital character beats of Future Mai's anguished cries over Infinite Zamasu wiping out all the remaining earthlings in her world and Future Trunks tearfully lamenting that he let Gohan down and couldn't protect their world. There's nothing like that in manga. Just everyone going about their business as if nothing happened. As if Future Trunks timeline wasn't just erased. There's no emotional resonance over the fact that Future Trunks' lost everything and has to go to completely new timeline in the manga. Let's just have a barbecue and all the troubles will go away, right? Fucking awful storytelling.
But the most important aspect of this ending -- at least from my perspective -- is what can be taken away from this kind of conclusion to compliment Future Trunks character. And it's really the final shot in the anime that catapults the ending from seemingly meaningless to a bittersweet yet somehow wholesome conclusion of Future Trunks character. Even after all the misery created by the Androids, Cell, Goku Black and Zamasu, and while Future Trunks lamented -- while referring to Future Gohan -- the fact he could protect his world, the story provides the moment of Gohan rushing to bid Future Trunks farewell and wanting the best for him. And Future Trunks responding enthusiastically with tears in his eyes, while thinking of Future Gohan, as he leaves is all so painfully bittersweet but works so damn well. Future Trunks was a man who moulded from the hardship of his work and tutelage of Future Gohan. And although this isn't the Gohan that he had grown accustomed to from his upbringing, just the sight of the man who is visually identical of the one who he looked up was enough to provide the emotional support in Future Trunks darkest hour. Future Trunks' world is gone, but there is still hope he can recover.
For the purposes of evolving his character, despite the major writing fumble regarding Super Saiyan Rage and the Genki Dama-esque attack that deal the (supposed) fatal blow to Merged Zamasu, I find that anime version of events made more of effort to advance Future Trunks' character, despite its shortcomings. Future Trunks, at least in the Super anime, is no longer "a lone warrior", as the title of special chapter concerning his backstory is concerned from Toriyama's perspective. He's a full-grown adult, who long hardships will battling with his future have led to him becoming mentally exhausted and emotionally unhinged. We see his struggles with PTSD, as just the mere vision of main timeline Goku causes him to snap and lash out at him from pure instinct from his mentally and psychically draining war against Goku Black. The other scene of how his mindset blurs from the reality of world he lives to idyllic world the main cast inhabit in the episode where he goes to visit Gohan, and visiting Gohan and his family, as I discussed earlier, are other moments that does a good job of establishing the parallels between the crapsack world that Future Trunks inhibits and how it has personally affected him and relative tranquillity that the main cast enjoy with their loved ones. It's a nice contrast that compliments the characterization of Future Trunks quite well -- even if it's a bit too on the nose.
Future Trunks in the anime is viewed as a paragon of hope. What's left of humanity in his world are emotionally dependent on him. As updates of his condition constantly create worry among Earth's last resistance to Goku Black. He has people who look up to him as a big brother figure and a leader to a new hope for the world. He doesn't take the backseat that he does most of the Cell arc or in Toyotaro's creative take of the Future Trunks arc in the manga and doesn't solely rely on the actions of others to determine his fate. Instead, he leads by example. He is the one taking charge.
Speaking the Earth's last resistance in Future Trunks' timeline, I really like the addition of them in the story. They themselves work very well in being the moral support for Future Trunks, while also proving themselves vital in the survival of the main cast against Goku Black and Zamasu. It's also really nice to actually see regular people in Dragon Ball willingly put themselves in harm’s way to fight against a threat that is made very apparent that they no chance against. Some people may chalk that kind of effort as a fool's errand, but I feel the tenacity from mankind to fight their hardest as an endearing trait.
One scene I loved in particular with regarding the remaining Earthling survivors in the anime was in Episode 65. In that episode, after witnessing one of the human’s venture outside, following their underground hideout collapsing on itself, they witness first hand that human being killed by Merged Zamasu's lightning, and despite that, all the survivors still volunteer to go outside. But what truly set that scene apart from the rest is one of the earthlings falls to his knees in despair, calling himself a fool for thinking he could actually help knowing how out of their depth they are against Merged Zamasu, and solemnly admitting he doesn't want to die yet. With another Earthling telling him that they have to do something to fight against the threat. It's simple, yet incredibly effective in emphasising the dire situation facing the people that Future Trunks want to protect, while showing the varied reaction of the ever-changing conflict. It adds a lot to how you connect to the story when you see how much the dynamics of the characters are spread across the board when facing seemingly hopeless situation.
When Toyotaro decided to have Goku Black murder every single human excluding Future Trunks and Future Mai off-screen, I was at odds with this. On one hand, it empathizes extremely well the pragmatic approach of Goku Black with his Zero mortals plan. On the other hand, this leaves Future Trunks with a barren world and nothing left to fight for. There's no real added incentive to get invested in the fate of Future Trunks, because, well, there's nothing left of Future Trunks left to fight for beside Future Mai. Which is barely a consolation prize in itself.
The events of the Future Trunks arc in the anime compose a more fleshed out character, who has matured to the point where despite the odds, he's more than willing to take charge. He has more to fight for, and consequently, more to lose. Which makes the circumstances of Future Trunks' timeline being erased -- while a difficult pill to swallow -- resonate far more on an emotional level. It also helps that Future Trunks and Future Mai react in such a distraught fashion in the fallout of the events. It's just a shame that for the climatic episodes of the Future Trunks arc, Toei would use some of the worst, most overdone and hackneyed plot devices possible to ensure Future Trunks role in active combat would be sustained, despite the ever-growing battle power of Goku Black as he attained Super Saiyan Rose.
The only time I find the convenience of Future Trunks capabilities in combat acceptable with the ever-escalating increase of the power ceiling is with him and Future Mai sealing Zamasu in the Mafuba. It's just so wonderfully cathartic to see the pompous, racist, asshole that Zamasu get put in his place by Future Trunks and what basically account to a muggle in the Dragon Ball world in the form of Future Mai. Plus, Future Trunks learning the Mafuba from watch a phone recording of Piccolo doing it is one of the most surreally hilarious things Dragon Ball has ever done.
Future Trunks in the manga falls back to putting his fate in others. Which while it isn't an inherently bad thing, feels a bit to stagnant for possible evolution of his character. He goes through tutelage once again, this time under the Kaioshin and Kibito of his world, that while serves a decent reveal to the circumstance of the survival of Future Mai and Gowasu at the hands of Goku Black, provides no extra layers for Future Trunks' character. That's not say him saving the lives of Future Mai and Gowasu, and healing Goku, with his newly attained healing power given to him being the disciple of a Kaioshin, having no meaning, it just doesn't feel wholesome to Future Trunks' character for him to play the role of brief support in what's ultimately his conflict with Goku Black and Zamasu. His apprenticeship as a Kaioshin being nullified at the conclusion of the conclusion of the arc is probably the only instance of Toyotaro's take on the arc I feel that Future Trunks' characters has natural evolution. Beyond that brief moment, Future Trunks in the Super manga is the same person we see in the Cell arc. And that's not what I wanted out of and arc like this given the time that had elapsed for the conclusion of the Cell arc to the beginning of the conflict with Goku Black.
To quickly cover the other Future Trunks non-related material of the arc, I'll just quickly say this:
- The best battle in the anime was Super Saiyan Blue Vegetto vs Merged Zamasu.
- The best battle in the manga was Ki-Controlled Super Saiyan Blue Goku vs Merged Zamasu.
- Toyotaro wrote Goku better for the most part.
- Toei's rendition of Goku Black and Zamasu are great. And I think Zamasu, in general in the anime, is a fantastically written villain and one of Dragon Ball best written characters.
- Both mediums did a good job with the character writing for Vegeta, Merged Zamasu, Gowasu, Future Mai, Bulma, Beerus and Whis.
- The time travel aspects of the arc are very weird.
- Zeno can go fuck himself.
The Future Trunks arc has a lot mileage which will vary from person to person. From Future Trunks' perspective, it will seem like a lot, if not all, of the hard work he put into saving his world was undone by a deity. And that is quite unfortunate to think about. But for Future Trunks' character, at least more-so in the anime, there's wonderful nuanced depth that's provided that makes the arduous journey not seem like a complete waste of time. Future Trunks feels more like a truly evolved person, than just this tag-along by-product of the plot all those years ago.
I feel as though both the anime and manga do a good job of telling a good story, that just how happens to have Future Trunks in it. But I feel only one medium did a good job, or at least tried to do a good job, of elevating Future Trunks to another platform to characterisation. Although, both mediums suffer from a general lack coherency of the plot shifting towards the climax of the arc, I feel both the manga and anime still have very good rewatch value, despite their specific storytelling issues.
I just can't shake the feeling that if the best from Toyotaro from the manga was combined from the best of Toei in the anime, the Future Trunks arc would have been thoroughly amazing and one of, if not the best, Dragon Ball arc ever. C'est la vie.
Anime - 8.5/10
Manga - 7/10



