Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Discussion specifically regarding the "Dragon Ball Super" TV series premiering July 2015 in Japan, including individual threads for each episode.

Moderators: Kanzenshuu Staff, General Help

User avatar
cantwaitanymore
Not-So-Newbie
Posts: 71
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2019 4:33 am

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by cantwaitanymore » Tue Jan 29, 2019 12:38 am

ekrolo2 wrote:Can we use Gogeta's performance in the movie to definitively say Base fusion, no matter which, is above God now?
Potara isnt anywhere near that multiplier. Broken anime scalling for Kefla. In manga SSJ Kefla = Gohan. They dont even know Goku and Vegetas base power in anime. They literally made Vegito into a joke. In the anime they have Base Cabba able to fight Base Vegita (SSG absorbed) who stomped SSJ3 Gotenks. They first went with Goku and Vegeta having absorbed SSG, and now they seem to have ditched it. Kefla even uses Legendary SSJ 1 and 2 in the anime. Goku doesnt even fight Kefla at all, especially not in UI Omen form in which he doesnt fight at all as it runs out instantly, but in anime they had him fight in it 2 times.
And as far as anime goes we have a direct statement that says its the their powered added together and then multiplied tens of times. Potara isnt anywhere near fusion as far as multiplier.

Pefected SSJ Blue Goku (FT arc) is equal to Fused Zamasu, further confirmed as Vegeta stated it. So thats a fact.
In the manga Vegito STOMPED Fused Zamasu.

PSSB Goku = Fused Zamasu (Super Saiyan Rose)

Now in the movie we had Base Gogeta > PSSB Goku(post ToP).
which means hypothetical Base Gogeta ( FT arc) > PSSB Goku ( FT arc)

Now Vegito Blue vs Fused Zamasu (SSJ Rose)
How much stronger was he?
Well first of lets see who makes the fusions.
We have Goku Black And Future Zamasu.
Lets say base Vegeta and Goku are 2x stronger than base Goku black
So we have:
Base Goku Black - 1
Base Vegeta - 2
Base Goku - 2

and last Future Zamasu. Now he has been stated to be weaker than base Future Trunks. Hes generally a weakling so we are just going to ignore his power.

And last we have the good old rival boost. Now lets say rival boost makes the Fusion 5x stronger.

Zamasu and Vegito are both using Potara fusion, And SSJ Blue = SSJ Rose forms.

That would mean that Vegito Blue is 20x stronger than Fused Zamasu.

But lets pretend magically that Vegito Blue is somehow 50 x stronger than Fused Zamasu.

Now where does Gogeta fit into this.

Well Perfected SSB Goku and Perfected SSB Vegeta are drawn and shown fighting SSJ Broly in the manga. The manga adopted the events movie and skipped the entire arc while showing us
that they are using PSSB forms.So literally no difference.

Now in the movie we have Base Gogeta>PSSB Goku, but just to make people happy and not get into longer debates I'm gonna say Base Gogeta = PSSB Goku.

So ill put it on a scale.

Fused Zamasu(Super Saiyan Rose) = PSSB Goku (FT arc) - 1
Vegito Blue ( Ft arc) - 50
Base Gogeta (Ft arc) - 1
SSJ Gogeta ( Ft arc) - 50
SSJ2 Gogeta ( FT arc) - 100

But lets satisfy all the people. Zombie Vito keeps insisting that SSJ Broly is only 5x stronger than Ikari Broly. So basically he has it like this : SSJ Gogeta = SSJ Broly.
That would mean that Base Gogeta is 10 times weaker than PSSB Goku as Ikari Broly= PSSB Goku.
Ok, no problem.

The scale would then go like this:

Fused Zamasu(Super Saiyan Rose) = PSSB Goku (FT arc) - 1
Vegito Blue ( Ft arc) - 50
Base Gogeta (Ft arc) - 0.1
SSJ Gogeta ( Ft arc) - 5
SSJ2 Gogeta ( FT arc) - 10
SSJ3 Gogeta ( FT arc) - 40
SSG Gogeta (Ft arc) >>>> Blue Vegito ( I'm not gonna use the 50x ssj3 multiplier, but we can agree i think, that it is more than 1.25 x ssj3)

Note: This is NOT PSSB Vegito in the scale just REGULAR BLUE Vegito, the one which fought Zamasu . PSSB Vegito >>>>>>>>>>SSB Vegito.


That shows that as far as power goes, Fusion is worlds above Potara.

User avatar
ZombieVito
Banned
Posts: 6222
Joined: Wed Mar 13, 2013 12:18 pm

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by ZombieVito » Tue Jan 29, 2019 2:13 am

PFM18 wrote:
ekrolo2 wrote:Can we use Gogeta's performance in the movie to definitively say Base fusion, no matter which, is above God now?
Well, referencing God specifically is kind of arbitrary. It seems the Base fusion is just stronger than the fusee's max power. In this case, Base Gogeta>SSB Goku/Vegeta
I guess if the fusion truly is perfect than this boost can be applied.

Gotenks clearly doesn't get this boost.

User avatar
PFM18
Banned Alternate Account
Posts: 3701
Joined: Sun Feb 04, 2018 2:23 pm

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by PFM18 » Tue Jan 29, 2019 2:44 am

ZombieVito wrote:
PFM18 wrote:
ekrolo2 wrote:Can we use Gogeta's performance in the movie to definitively say Base fusion, no matter which, is above God now?
Well, referencing God specifically is kind of arbitrary. It seems the Base fusion is just stronger than the fusee's max power. In this case, Base Gogeta>SSB Goku/Vegeta
I guess if the fusion truly is perfect than this boost can be applied.

Gotenks clearly doesn't get this boost.
Well the same concept applies to Gotenks. Base Gotenks>SSJ Trunks/SSJ Goten

Nothing to do with a perfect fusion. If the fusion isn't perfect, then you won't fuse. It's a prerequisite to have the fusion in the first place.

User avatar
cantwaitanymore
Not-So-Newbie
Posts: 71
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2019 4:33 am

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by cantwaitanymore » Tue Jan 29, 2019 2:51 am

ZombieVito wrote:
PFM18 wrote:
ekrolo2 wrote:Can we use Gogeta's performance in the movie to definitively say Base fusion, no matter which, is above God now?
Well, referencing God specifically is kind of arbitrary. It seems the Base fusion is just stronger than the fusee's max power. In this case, Base Gogeta>SSB Goku/Vegeta
I guess if the fusion truly is perfect than this boost can be applied.

Gotenks clearly doesn't get this boost.
What boost are you talking about?
SSJ Gotenks Pre Rosat > SSJ3 Goku , STATED multiple times.
Base Gotenks Post Rosat > SSJ Gotenks Pre Rosat. STATED.
Its got nothing to do with their max power in their strongest form.

User avatar
PFM18
Banned Alternate Account
Posts: 3701
Joined: Sun Feb 04, 2018 2:23 pm

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by PFM18 » Tue Jan 29, 2019 3:31 am

cantwaitanymore wrote:
ZombieVito wrote:
PFM18 wrote:
Well, referencing God specifically is kind of arbitrary. It seems the Base fusion is just stronger than the fusee's max power. In this case, Base Gogeta>SSB Goku/Vegeta
I guess if the fusion truly is perfect than this boost can be applied.

Gotenks clearly doesn't get this boost.
What boost are you talking about?
SSJ Gotenks Pre Rosat > SSJ3 Goku , STATED multiple times.
Base Gotenks Post Rosat > SSJ Gotenks Pre Rosat. STATED.
Its got nothing to do with their max power in their strongest form.
What you said doesn't prove or disprove that in the slightest. You just kind of mentioned something completely unrelated. How Gotenks compares to Goku has nothing to do with his relationship between his fusees.

User avatar
cantwaitanymore
Not-So-Newbie
Posts: 71
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2019 4:33 am

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by cantwaitanymore » Tue Jan 29, 2019 4:02 am

PFM18 wrote:
cantwaitanymore wrote:
ZombieVito wrote: I guess if the fusion truly is perfect than this boost can be applied.

Gotenks clearly doesn't get this boost.
What boost are you talking about?
SSJ Gotenks Pre Rosat > SSJ3 Goku , STATED multiple times.
Base Gotenks Post Rosat > SSJ Gotenks Pre Rosat. STATED.
Its got nothing to do with their max power in their strongest form.
What you said doesn't prove or disprove that in the slightest. You just kind of mentioned something completely unrelated. How Gotenks compares to Goku has nothing to do with his relationship between his fusees.
Wow i guess things need to be spelled out.
If Base Fusion was their max power in the strongest form ( (SSJ Goten + SSJ Trunks) x Y amount) it would be impossible for their Fusion to be stronger than their Fusions SSJ previously.
Since Gotenks got over 50 times stronger in 1 hour of outisde time which is 15 days inside, their ``max power in their strongest form`` would also need to be that much stronger which is literally impossible.

Its also impossible as we have been shown Fused Zamasu = PSSB Goku and SSJ Kefla = Gohan

If it was like you are suggesting it then all of these fusions would be hunders of thousands of times stronger than they are.

The only reason why that theory exists is because the anime doesnt even know how strong base Goku, Caulifla and Kale are.

User avatar
Sora Saiyan
Advanced Regular
Posts: 1084
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2015 7:19 am
Location: Destiny Islands

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by Sora Saiyan » Tue Jan 29, 2019 4:14 am

cantwaitanymore wrote: Base Trunks couldnt move in 100x gravity in base thats A FACT, clearly showing how low his base was. I was never comparing Gotenks and his feats to Vegito. Just saying that its a fact that Base Gotenks post Rosat > SSJ Gotenks pre Rosat, which claerly shows that fusion IS a multiplication, as it it is IMPOSSIBLE for them individually to get more 50+ times stronger in 15 DAYS.
Base Trunks was in 150g, and either way, the way he made Vegeta struggle was testament to his power. His muscle strength wasn't even worth mentioning there. He straight up made Vegeta struggle, and there's no way that Vegeta was caught off guard as is clearly presented in the manga by him gradually trying harder to the stage where he uses his hands to block, and in the end was pressured enough to stop the onslaught with a instinctive punch.
Anyway dude, it doesn't matter if it's multiplication or not (though I disagree), nothing that you've presented in the manga proves that the dance gives a greater boost than the Potara, as you even failed to provide a reason as to why Vegetto doesn't yield to same increase as Gotenks, Vegetto can be argued to be higher than ban Gotenks boost, but a lower boost is really hard to prove. Also if the dance is a multiplication, how the hell does Goku seemingly catch up to Gotenks in BoG pre god? There power would be multiplying millions together, apparently Goku is below Freeza in base, so millions being multiplied together would never allow Gokus measly 400x transformation come even the tiniest bit close to catching them. Furthermore, why is base Gotenks weaker than SSJ3 Goku when he first goes at Buu? It's pretty clear that they aren't far below there fathers judging by the demonstration against Vegeta, yet Gotenks returns totally pummeled. Again it's the same instance with BoG, millions X by millions would make Goku as a SSJ3 look like a flea in comparison. Hell, even if they were weaker than first form Freeza, and there power was 500k, they would end up with a power level of 250 billion. Goku with a level of 100 million as his base would end up with a level of 40 billion. That's low balling the kids to a degree that isn't even feasible, but let's run with this.. at that multiplier Buu would be an absolute joke. Just so you're aware of how insane that power gap is, just say instead that SSJ3 Gokus power level is now just his regular SSJ form, it would be like him turning SSJ2 then 3 on top, that would be a little over Base Gotenks when he went to fight Buu the first time. Blows have almost been outright tanked with a gap much much less, and we know for sure the boys are much stronger than a measly 500k.
There's multiple cases of the kids showing off there crazy power, Gohan was amazed by how fast base Goten could throw rocks, then in the sparring sessions we see them in Gohan is visually starining in the manga. Trunks tags Vegeta and forces him to retaliate to stop the onslaught, and is later doing 1 finger push ups in the gravity chamber (he probably got used to it as we also see a panel of Vegeta in the chamber too just prior, and he wouldn't be training below 150, though as I've said, that part isn't important) then we see 18 worried by Trunks suppressed blast. It's all impressive truly.

Going a bit deeper with the kids we can look at previous battles. Like how SSJ Goku could causally block and dodge Freeza upon first becoming a SSJ with the risk of no blows slipping through. Super Vegeta could casually dodge Semi Cell, (though he was never attacked with a flurry), yet kid Trunks made Vegeta struggle. At this stage Vegeta was much greater than previous as he must've surpassed Cell arc SSJFP Goku and also accounted for the extra training to be confident in a rematch with him, so Trunks doing that to Vegeta was mighty impressive.
We know that 50% FPSSJ surpassed SSJGr2 Vegeta in the Cell arc. Honestly all this is a massive testament to Vegetas strength, but this also proves that the kids can't possibly be below Freeza when they turn SSJ to do what they did to Gohan and Vegeta. This bit is important, but in the instances I've pointed out, the boys fathers against their foes at the time had to dodge and block blows off of purely reaction time as they had no idea where they were gonna attack from, but Vegeta told Trunks to just attack his face, so he actually should've had an easier time in a sense due to knowing exactly where they were being thrown.
Anyway, this should clearly point out that the kids aren't like 100x weaker than their fathers, and instead not really anymore than a couple X weaker. Even if they were around namek level base Goku, Gotenks would be 100s of X stronger than SSJ3 Goku and thats still keeping a giant gap and giving Goku a PL of 100 mil in base. There's many more instances of people dodging attacks with gaps not too large, but surely I don't need to post every instance for you to get the point.

Something else to add, is that Buu believed fusion wouldn't be enough against him, yet Vegetto can handle him super easily. That part does imply Vegettos boost > Gotenks’ boost
GT is not canon, that statement in GT perfect files is meaningless and it doesnt align as i have previously explained with DBZ.
The Kefla line was added dialogue by Toei, and it matches in with a Toei original product. That's why the Kefla line likely exists.
Fused Zamasu = PSSB Goku. Thats a fact. Base Gogeta was stronger than PSSB Goku so its pretty obvious that its not tens of times stronger than base Goku, its astronomically higher than that.
I agree that base Gogeta is much stronger than base Goku, and much closer, if not even above a fully fresh SSJB Goku. I'm just saying if fusion is multiplication SSJB would have to give a boost in the quadrillions to come close enough to base Gogeta as the gap between the two clearly isn't all that big. And like I said that number was lowballed to pre BoG base levels, and it still ended up being a multiplier in the quadrillions for SSJB. It's not feasible. Also, Vegetto in the manga was definitely above regular SSJB Goku, and who knows how be would've fared against M Zamasu, but it doesn't matter, he decided to destroy an immortal being, so even if he was stronger than CSSJB in base he needed to be at a level where he could totally embarrass him and override his immortality. That big blast against Zamasu that destroyed his arm seemed to be him testing the waters on what he needs to do in the battle, and his comments just after confirm such. Also, that was a base Vegetto before taking a senzu and recovering to FP. That Senzu part then must extend to Kefla and make people wonder how powerful she would actually be at FP, as she was made up by a being who was out cold, and a weakened warrior. Pretty scary really.
Last thing i forgot, Daizenshuu from 1995 i remember for a FACT that it had Potara entry and it didnt say what D7 says about potara creatting a stronger warrior.
I believe that was the Daizenshuu 4…Even so it's implied there, as it says the “effect is greater than with fusion. Furthermore the union cannot be cancelled it doesn't have the weakness of running out of time” So the effect that's greater than fusion isn't referring to it being permanent as that's addressed in the sentence immediately following, so honestly it just seems that Daizenshuu 7 clears that part up. Like I pointed out, 7 went into more detail regarding these sort of things. Just read the Kanzenshuu page I linked and you'll understand the different Daizenshuu better.
Message about WSJ article.
Ken Xyro translated the part I'm gonna talk about now by saying “equally good, strongest trump cards” Herms says “equally matched, ultimate trump cards”
And like I pointed out, the techniques aren't equally matched ultimate trump cards, or equally good, strongest trump cards if it's not in regards to power. One technique is clearly superior when it comes to anything outside of power. Potara has ease of use, no failure, and lasts longer. It's not equally matched, I don't know what you aren't understanding? We know as a technique they aren't equally matched because Elder Kaioshin tells us such in the original series, and also the other points I've pointed out. The main term there is equal. nothing can be equal when one clearly outperforms the other in almost every way possible, and the fact the article is comparing the two would mean that the user has both means at their disposal, so the potara then loses the weakness of not having it on hand. Truthfully speaking it's basically impossible to argue that the fusion dance is equal to the Potara solely as a technique. Now in a power sense it's not an issue at all, it would then make sense that they're equally good.

Honestly a technique in DB is probably only seen as useful when it's in regards to power anyway, especially when the form of fusion being used is only to increase your power.
Anyway the article as a whole seems to be talking about Vegetto and Gogeta, the results of the fusions, and not the means to get there (the technique). So the characters Gogeta and Vegetto wouldn't be equal at all if one doesn't stand a chance against a foe the other could defeat.

If this argument continues people need to just realise there isn't enough modern information to pick one over the other. Because truthfully it seems to be cherry picking to get the answer people want to atm. Hell the past information is conflicting anyway. At some point we may get something super concrete from Toriyama, and when we do we'll know for sure because they slap his name on anything he accidentally locks eyes on regarding DB.

User avatar
cantwaitanymore
Not-So-Newbie
Posts: 71
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2019 4:33 am

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by cantwaitanymore » Tue Jan 29, 2019 4:20 am

Sora Saiyan wrote:
cantwaitanymore wrote: Base Trunks couldnt move in 100x gravity in base thats A FACT, clearly showing how low his base was. I was never comparing Gotenks and his feats to Vegito. Just saying that its a fact that Base Gotenks post Rosat > SSJ Gotenks pre Rosat, which claerly shows that fusion IS a multiplication, as it it is IMPOSSIBLE for them individually to get more 50+ times stronger in 15 DAYS.
Base Trunks was in 150g, and either way, the way he made Vegeta struggle was testament to his power. His muscle strength wasn't even worth mentioning there. He straight up made Vegeta struggle, and there's no way that Vegeta was caught off guard as is clearly presented in the manga by him gradually trying harder to the stage where he uses his hands to block, and in the end was pressured enough to stop the onslaught with a instinctive punch.
Anyway dude, it doesn't matter if it's multiplication or not (though I disagree), nothing that you've presented in the manga proves that the dance gives a greater boost than the Potara, as you even failed to provide a reason as to why Vegetto doesn't yield to same increase as Gotenks, Vegetto can be argued to be higher than ban Gotenks boost, but a lower boost is really hard to prove. Also if the dance is a multiplication, how the hell does Goku seemingly catch up to Gotenks in BoG pre god? There power would be multiplying millions together, apparently Goku is below Freeza in base, so millions being multiplied together would never allow Gokus measly 400x transformation come even the tiniest bit close to catching them. Furthermore, why is base Gotenks weaker than SSJ3 Goku when he first goes at Buu? It's pretty clear that they aren't far below there fathers judging by the demonstration against Vegeta, yet Gotenks returns totally pummeled. Again it's the same instance with BoG, millions X by millions would make Goku as a SSJ3 look like a flea in comparison. Hell, even if they were weaker than first form Freeza, and there power was 500k, they would end up with a power level of 250 billion. Goku with a level of 100 million as his base would end up with a level of 40 billion. That's low balling the kids to a degree that isn't even feasible, but let's run with this.. at that multiplier Buu would be an absolute joke. Just so you're aware of how insane that power gap is, just say instead that SSJ3 Gokus power level is now just his regular SSJ form, it would be like him turning SSJ2 then 3 on top, that would be a little over Base Gotenks when he went to fight Buu the first time. Blows have almost been outright tanked with a gap much much less, and we know for sure the boys are much stronger than a measly 500k.
There's multiple cases of the kids showing off there crazy power, Gohan was amazed by how fast base Goten could throw rocks, then in the sparring sessions we see them in Gohan is visually starining in the manga. Trunks tags Vegeta and forces him to retaliate to stop the onslaught, and is later doing 1 finger push ups in the gravity chamber (he probably got used to it as we also see a panel of Vegeta in the chamber too just prior, and he wouldn't be training below 150, though as I've said, that part isn't important) then we see 18 worried by Trunks suppressed blast. It's all impressive truly.

Going a bit deeper with the kids we can look at previous battles. Like how SSJ Goku could causally block and dodge Freeza upon first becoming a SSJ with the risk of no blows slipping through. Super Vegeta could casually dodge Semi Cell, (though he was never attacked with a flurry), yet kid Trunks made Vegeta struggle. At this stage Vegeta was much greater than previous as he must've surpassed Cell arc SSJFP Goku and also accounted for the extra training to be confident in a rematch with him, so Trunks doing that to Vegeta was mighty impressive.
We know that 50% FPSSJ surpassed SSJGr2 Vegeta in the Cell arc. Honestly all this is a massive testament to Vegetas strength, but this also proves that the kids can't possibly be below Freeza when they turn SSJ to do what they did to Gohan and Vegeta. This bit is important, but in the instances I've pointed out, the boys fathers against their foes at the time had to dodge and block blows off of purely reaction time as they had no idea where they were gonna attack from, but Vegeta told Trunks to just attack his face, so he actually should've had an easier time in a sense due to knowing exactly where they were being thrown.
Anyway, this should clearly point out that the kids aren't like 100x weaker than their fathers, and instead not really anymore than a couple X weaker. Even if they were around namek level base Goku, Gotenks would be 100s of X stronger than SSJ3 Goku and thats still keeping a giant gap and giving Goku a PL of 100 mil in base. There's many more instances of people dodging attacks with gaps not too large, but surely I don't need to post every instance for you to get the point.

Something else to add, is that Buu believed fusion wouldn't be enough against him, yet Vegetto can handle him super easily. That part does imply Vegettos boost > Gotenks’ boost
GT is not canon, that statement in GT perfect files is meaningless and it doesnt align as i have previously explained with DBZ.
The Kefla line was added dialogue by Toei, and it matches in with a Toei original product. That's why the Kefla line likely exists.
Fused Zamasu = PSSB Goku. Thats a fact. Base Gogeta was stronger than PSSB Goku so its pretty obvious that its not tens of times stronger than base Goku, its astronomically higher than that.
I agree that base Gogeta is much stronger than base Goku, and much closer, if not even above a fully fresh SSJB Goku. I'm just saying if fusion is multiplication SSJB would have to give a boost in the quadrillions to come close enough to base Gogeta as the gap between the two clearly isn't all that big. And like I said that number was lowballed to pre BoG base levels, and it still ended up being a multiplier in the quadrillions for SSJB. It's not feasible. Also, Vegetto in the manga was definitely above regular SSJB Goku, and who knows how be would've fared against M Zamasu, but it doesn't matter, he decided to destroy an immortal being, so even if he was stronger than CSSJB in base he needed to be at a level where he could totally embarrass him and override his immortality. That big blast against Zamasu that destroyed his arm seemed to be him testing the waters on what he needs to do in the battle, and his comments just after confirm such. Also, that was a base Vegetto before taking a senzu and recovering to FP. That Senzu part then must extend to Kefla and make people wonder how powerful she would actually be at FP, as she was made up by a being who was out cold, and a weakened warrior. Pretty scary really.
Last thing i forgot, Daizenshuu from 1995 i remember for a FACT that it had Potara entry and it didnt say what D7 says about potara creatting a stronger warrior.
I believe that was the Daizenshuu 4…Even so it's implied there, as it says the “effect is greater than with fusion. Furthermore the union cannot be cancelled it doesn't have the weakness of running out of time” So the effect that's greater than fusion isn't referring to it being permanent as that's addressed in the sentence immediately following, so honestly it just seems that Daizenshuu 7 clears that part up. Like I pointed out, 7 went into more detail regarding these sort of things. Just read the Kanzenshuu page I linked and you'll understand the different Daizenshuu better.
Message about WSJ article.
Ken Xyro translated the part I'm gonna talk about now by saying “equally good, strongest trump cards” Herms says “equally matched, ultimate trump cards”
And like I pointed out, the techniques aren't equally matched ultimate trump cards, or equally good, strongest trump cards if it's not in regards to power. One technique is clearly superior when it comes to anything outside of power. Potara has ease of use, no failure, and lasts longer. It's not equally matched, I don't know what you aren't understanding? We know as a technique they aren't equally matched because Elder Kaioshin tells us such in the original series, and also the other points I've pointed out. The main term there is equal. nothing can be equal when one clearly outperforms the other in almost every way possible, and the fact the article is comparing the two would mean that the user has both means at their disposal, so the potara then loses the weakness of not having it on hand. Truthfully speaking it's basically impossible to argue that the fusion dance is equal to the Potara solely as a technique. Now in a power sense it's not an issue at all, it would then make sense that they're equally good.

Honestly a technique in DB is probably only seen as useful when it's in regards to power anyway, especially when the form of fusion being used is only to increase your power.
Anyway the article as a whole seems to be talking about Vegetto and Gogeta, the results of the fusions, and not the means to get there (the technique). So the characters Gogeta and Vegetto wouldn't be equal at all if one doesn't stand a chance against a foe the other could defeat.

If this argument continues people need to just realise there isn't enough modern information to pick one over the other. Because truthfully it seems to be cherry picking to get the answer people want to atm. Hell the past information is conflicting anyway. At some point we may get something super concrete from Toriyama, and when we do we'll know for sure because they slap his name on anything he accidentally locks eyes on regarding DB.
So you speak better japanese than these translators?
As far as Potara vs Fusion in DBS, read my post i just made at the top of the page.

User avatar
Sora Saiyan
Advanced Regular
Posts: 1084
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2015 7:19 am
Location: Destiny Islands

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by Sora Saiyan » Tue Jan 29, 2019 4:37 am

Right, I'm leaving that there. It's already been translated. It's deduction skills at this point.
Also, what I posted answers a lot of the crap mentioned previously. Choose to read it or not. This isn't worth continuing.

Edit: When I say a lot of the "crap" mentioned, I don't mean that in an insulting way, it's just my way of saying "stuff". Just clearing that up.

User avatar
PerhapsTheOtherOne
I Live Here
Posts: 2717
Joined: Mon Apr 03, 2017 5:55 pm

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by PerhapsTheOtherOne » Tue Jan 29, 2019 8:15 am

So, assuming that the theory of the fusees max shared forms/strength as the base of the resulting Fusion is indeed true, where does that put Kefla?

Technically speaking, whilst Kale didn't have a "normal" SS2 form, it still is being referred to as "SS2" by post-release material. So, for the purposes of the Fusion, I guess it counts as "strong as SS2 in base". Looks like it was close enough to close the gap and become as strong as SSG.

Going by the jumps in power in Broly's movie, SSG isn't that much of a jump from SS3's level. It'd make sense then that Kefla could end up as strong as SSG in her base form, since Kale in SS2 was probably close to if not at SS3 and approaching SSG.

User avatar
cantwaitanymore
Not-So-Newbie
Posts: 71
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2019 4:33 am

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by cantwaitanymore » Tue Jan 29, 2019 8:28 am

PerhapsTheOtherOne wrote:So, assuming that the theory of the fusees max shared forms/strength as the base of the resulting Fusion is indeed true, where does that put Kefla?

Technically speaking, whilst Kale didn't have a "normal" SS2 form, it still is being referred to as "SS2" by post-release material. So, for the purposes of the Fusion, I guess it counts as "strong as SS2 in base". Looks like it was close enough to close the gap and become as strong as SSG.

Going by the jumps in power in Broly's movie, SSG isn't that much of a jump from SS3's level. It'd make sense then that Kefla could end up as strong as SSG in her base form, since Kale in SS2 was probably close to if not at SS3 and approaching SSG.
You do realise that SSJ Kefla = Gohan right?

User avatar
PerhapsTheOtherOne
I Live Here
Posts: 2717
Joined: Mon Apr 03, 2017 5:55 pm

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by PerhapsTheOtherOne » Tue Jan 29, 2019 9:06 am

cantwaitanymore wrote:
PerhapsTheOtherOne wrote:So, assuming that the theory of the fusees max shared forms/strength as the base of the resulting Fusion is indeed true, where does that put Kefla?

Technically speaking, whilst Kale didn't have a "normal" SS2 form, it still is being referred to as "SS2" by post-release material. So, for the purposes of the Fusion, I guess it counts as "strong as SS2 in base". Looks like it was close enough to close the gap and become as strong as SSG.

Going by the jumps in power in Broly's movie, SSG isn't that much of a jump from SS3's level. It'd make sense then that Kefla could end up as strong as SSG in her base form, since Kale in SS2 was probably close to if not at SS3 and approaching SSG.
You do realise that SSJ Kefla = Gohan right?
I do realize that was the case in the manga. I also realize that I'm using the anime as a basis since most of the major production staff hail from the anime and that the movie's story was designed as a sequel to the Tournament of Power (presumably the anime since that was the one that the production staff had just finished working on at the time), and until we get confirmation otherwise of an adaptation down the line, I'm perfectly fine in using it.

User avatar
cantwaitanymore
Not-So-Newbie
Posts: 71
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2019 4:33 am

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by cantwaitanymore » Tue Jan 29, 2019 9:20 am

PerhapsTheOtherOne wrote:
cantwaitanymore wrote:
PerhapsTheOtherOne wrote:So, assuming that the theory of the fusees max shared forms/strength as the base of the resulting Fusion is indeed true, where does that put Kefla?

Technically speaking, whilst Kale didn't have a "normal" SS2 form, it still is being referred to as "SS2" by post-release material. So, for the purposes of the Fusion, I guess it counts as "strong as SS2 in base". Looks like it was close enough to close the gap and become as strong as SSG.

Going by the jumps in power in Broly's movie, SSG isn't that much of a jump from SS3's level. It'd make sense then that Kefla could end up as strong as SSG in her base form, since Kale in SS2 was probably close to if not at SS3 and approaching SSG.
You do realise that SSJ Kefla = Gohan right?
I do realize that was the case in the manga. I also realize that I'm using the anime as a basis since most of the major production staff hail from the anime and that the movie's story was designed as a sequel to the Tournament of Power (presumably the anime since that was the one that the production staff had just finished working on at the time), and until we get confirmation otherwise of an adaptation down the line, I'm perfectly fine in using it.
They cant be both canon. I dont see how Kefla has anything to do with the movie.
Also Kefla in the anime is incosistent to anime itself. They made Vegito pretty much equal to Fused Zamasu and then they enabled regular blue goku to fight him and zamasu even lost some beam struggle vs Vegeta and Trunks. Also if you want to go by the anime, its stated that its A+B x tens of times. That statement is consistent with the previous anime Potara fight with Vegito vs Zamasu , but is completely off in terms of Kefla. And again as i have shown in previous posts, its impossible for it to be like (Strongest form X + Strongest form Y) x tens of times = base fusion.

User avatar
PerhapsTheOtherOne
I Live Here
Posts: 2717
Joined: Mon Apr 03, 2017 5:55 pm

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by PerhapsTheOtherOne » Tue Jan 29, 2019 10:03 am

cantwaitanymore wrote:
PerhapsTheOtherOne wrote:
cantwaitanymore wrote:
You do realise that SSJ Kefla = Gohan right?
I do realize that was the case in the manga. I also realize that I'm using the anime as a basis since most of the major production staff hail from the anime and that the movie's story was designed as a sequel to the Tournament of Power (presumably the anime since that was the one that the production staff had just finished working on at the time), and until we get confirmation otherwise of an adaptation down the line, I'm perfectly fine in using it.
They cant be both canon. I dont see how Kefla has anything to do with the movie.
Also Kefla in the anime is incosistent to anime itself. They made Vegito pretty much equal to Fused Zamasu and then they enabled regular blue goku to fight him and zamasu even lost some beam struggle vs Vegeta and Trunks. Also if you want to go by the anime, its stated that its A+B x tens of times. That statement is consistent with the previous anime Potara fight with Vegito vs Zamasu , but is completely off in terms of Kefla. And again as i have shown in previous posts, its impossible for it to be like (Strongest form X + Strongest form Y) x tens of times = base fusion.
Some misnomers you got there.

First of all, you never "proved" that your weird formula doesn't work because I'm not even using it. Second, I saw that Vegito struggled against Merged Zamasu AFTER he pumped himself up with extra power due to Goku blasting him and killing his mortal half; even then, Vegito actually had to put in effort against Merged Zamasu's corrupted half, which showcased the majority of strength in its lopsidedly stronger arm, and not Merged Zamasu as a whole. Third of all, I use the anime because, while I personally prefer it, objectively speaking I believe that the entire production side of things and the greater brand recognition of the anime favours it as the primary continuity for the movie to serve as a continuation to; ergo, manga doesn't come into play except to clarify things that apply to both it and the anime.

Fourth, your formula is off because it's not "A+B" followed by becoming tens of times stronger, it's stated as JUST tens of times stronger; this still makes sense if you believe that SSG itself is only tens of times stronger than base form, which isn't a hard assumption to make given how base Broly, who became stronger than SS Vegeta, was able to become stronger than SSG via powering up with the strength of an Oozaru.

User avatar
cantwaitanymore
Not-So-Newbie
Posts: 71
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2019 4:33 am

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by cantwaitanymore » Tue Jan 29, 2019 10:32 am

PerhapsTheOtherOne wrote:
cantwaitanymore wrote:
PerhapsTheOtherOne wrote: I do realize that was the case in the manga. I also realize that I'm using the anime as a basis since most of the major production staff hail from the anime and that the movie's story was designed as a sequel to the Tournament of Power (presumably the anime since that was the one that the production staff had just finished working on at the time), and until we get confirmation otherwise of an adaptation down the line, I'm perfectly fine in using it.
They cant be both canon. I dont see how Kefla has anything to do with the movie.
Also Kefla in the anime is incosistent to anime itself. They made Vegito pretty much equal to Fused Zamasu and then they enabled regular blue goku to fight him and zamasu even lost some beam struggle vs Vegeta and Trunks. Also if you want to go by the anime, its stated that its A+B x tens of times. That statement is consistent with the previous anime Potara fight with Vegito vs Zamasu , but is completely off in terms of Kefla. And again as i have shown in previous posts, its impossible for it to be like (Strongest form X + Strongest form Y) x tens of times = base fusion.
Some misnomers you got there.

First of all, you never "proved" that your weird formula doesn't work because I'm not even using it. Second, I saw that Vegito struggled against Merged Zamasu AFTER he pumped himself up with extra power due to Goku blasting him and killing his mortal half; even then, Vegito actually had to put in effort against Merged Zamasu's corrupted half, which showcased the majority of strength in its lopsidedly stronger arm, and not Merged Zamasu as a whole. Third of all, I use the anime because, while I personally prefer it, objectively speaking I believe that the entire production side of things and the greater brand recognition of the anime favours it as the primary continuity for the movie to serve as a continuation to; ergo, manga doesn't come into play except to clarify things that apply to both it and the anime.

Fourth, your formula is off because it's not "A+B" followed by becoming tens of times stronger, it's stated as JUST tens of times stronger; this still makes sense if you believe that SSG itself is only tens of times stronger than base form, which isn't a hard assumption to make given how base Broly, who became stronger than SS Vegeta, was able to become stronger than SSG via powering up with the strength of an Oozaru.
its stated that its A SUM of their powers multiplied by tens of times. Do you know what sum means? Its not my formula as thats what Vados stated in the anime. I'm saying anime made Vegito into a joke, and that in manga he STOMPS Zamasu. People here are arguing that Base Fusion is equal to their power at their strongest forms added together and then multiplied tens of times, which i said is impossible and i provided evidence as to why that is.. I dont care to argue about anime Vegito vs Zamasu, I'm just saying that their power is consistent to that statement Vados made later and Kefla isnt.
If you prefer anime thats your thing, but manga is and always has been canon, and anime filler is not.

Also are you saying SSG is tens of times base form?????????

User avatar
PerhapsTheOtherOne
I Live Here
Posts: 2717
Joined: Mon Apr 03, 2017 5:55 pm

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by PerhapsTheOtherOne » Tue Jan 29, 2019 11:08 am

cantwaitanymore wrote:
its stated that its A SUM of their powers multiplied by tens of times. Do you know what sum means? Its not my formula as thats what Vados stated in the anime. I'm saying anime made Vegito into a joke, and that in manga he STOMPS Zamasu. People here are arguing that Base Fusion is equal to their power at their strongest forms added together and then multiplied tens of times, which i said is impossible and i provided evidence as to why that is.. I dont care to argue about anime Vegito vs Zamasu, I'm just saying that their power is consistent to that statement Vados made later and Kefla isnt.
If you prefer anime thats your thing, but manga is and always has been canon, and anime filler is not.

Also are you saying SSG is tens of times base form?????????
You should brush up on sum reading comprehension.

First of all, there is no definitive "canon", much as I like the idea. Namekian Book of Legends? Anime only, yet reference again by Toriyama directly in the interview where he reveals the story of Yamoshi the legendary Super Saiyan. Production staff and story? Anime-based. Primary product driving the franchise forward right now? Anime. Right now, there's a stronger case to be made that the movie was designed to continue the anime's story than the manga; the manga just so happens to also use the Broly movie in its continuity, the only point when the 2 mediums have the same set of events happen the same way. Therefore, unless we get an anime adaptation down the line, we can comfortably substitute any continuity into the movie.

Second of all, in the manga, Merged Zamasu never got stronger after the initial Potara Fusion; anime Zamasu did, twice in fact. The first time, his arm got pumped enough to require SSB Vegito to put effort in. The second time, he became stronger overall and yet Vegito still outclassed him in speed and matched him in strength. So, we can't use the manga's version of events as a metric because Merged Zamasu remained at the level he initially started at and didn't get strong enough and hax enough to contend with SSB Vegito.

Third of all, Vados said that Kefla's body and personality were greater than the sum of her parts, with her power increasing tens of times. The only noted power-statement is the "10s of times"; the "sum of her parts" is vague and could potentially mean power, but the context of the English sub leads me to believe it's more referring to Kefla as an actual individual compared to Kale and Caulifla.

User avatar
cantwaitanymore
Not-So-Newbie
Posts: 71
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2019 4:33 am

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by cantwaitanymore » Tue Jan 29, 2019 11:54 am

PerhapsTheOtherOne wrote:
cantwaitanymore wrote:
its stated that its A SUM of their powers multiplied by tens of times. Do you know what sum means? Its not my formula as thats what Vados stated in the anime. I'm saying anime made Vegito into a joke, and that in manga he STOMPS Zamasu. People here are arguing that Base Fusion is equal to their power at their strongest forms added together and then multiplied tens of times, which i said is impossible and i provided evidence as to why that is.. I dont care to argue about anime Vegito vs Zamasu, I'm just saying that their power is consistent to that statement Vados made later and Kefla isnt.
If you prefer anime thats your thing, but manga is and always has been canon, and anime filler is not.

Also are you saying SSG is tens of times base form?????????
You should brush up on sum reading comprehension.

First of all, there is no definitive "canon", much as I like the idea. Namekian Book of Legends? Anime only, yet reference again by Toriyama directly in the interview where he reveals the story of Yamoshi the legendary Super Saiyan. Production staff and story? Anime-based. Primary product driving the franchise forward right now? Anime. Right now, there's a stronger case to be made that the movie was designed to continue the anime's story than the manga; the manga just so happens to also use the Broly movie in its continuity, the only point when the 2 mediums have the same set of events happen the same way. Therefore, unless we get an anime adaptation down the line, we can comfortably substitute any continuity into the movie.

Second of all, in the manga, Merged Zamasu never got stronger after the initial Potara Fusion; anime Zamasu did, twice in fact. The first time, his arm got pumped enough to require SSB Vegito to put effort in. The second time, he became stronger overall and yet Vegito still outclassed him in speed and matched him in strength. So, we can't use the manga's version of events as a metric because Merged Zamasu remained at the level he initially started at and didn't get strong enough and hax enough to contend with SSB Vegito.

Third of all, Vados said that Kefla's body and personality were greater than the sum of her parts, with her power increasing tens of times. The only noted power-statement is the "10s of times"; the "sum of her parts" is vague and could potentially mean power, but the context of the English sub leads me to believe it's more referring to Kefla as an actual individual compared to Kale and Caulifla.
``The new body and personality born from a Potara fusion are more than the sum of their parts and their power increases tens of times``? What part dont you get exactly? TENS OF TIMES. It says THEIR meaning Cauliflas and Kales. THEIR power. Also there IS a canon, its your problem that you like anime more than manga.

And also for the last time manga adopted the movie events. It showed SSJ Broly vs PSSB Goku and PSSB Vegeta. They skipped the arc entirely. Toriyama is working on the manga. Manga is canon. Toei adds and changes whole bunch of stuff in the anime. All i said was that Regular Blue Goku was fighting Zamasu in the anime, and Trunks and Vegeta overpowered him in a beam struggle. Kaioken Blue Goku also tagged Zamasu. I pointed those out as its consistent with Vados statement about Potaras power in the anime. You are talking about Vegito vs Zamasu, meanwhile I'm replying to the Base fusions is their strongest forms added together and then multiplied tens of times theory, so follow the conversation as I'm definitely not having debates with (only) you.

whooooooah Toriyama referenced it in an interview so it must be canon right?

Actually i think Goten isnt canon since Toriyama didnt remember him in a recent interview...

User avatar
PerhapsTheOtherOne
I Live Here
Posts: 2717
Joined: Mon Apr 03, 2017 5:55 pm

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by PerhapsTheOtherOne » Tue Jan 29, 2019 12:40 pm

cantwaitanymore wrote:
PerhapsTheOtherOne wrote:
cantwaitanymore wrote:
its stated that its A SUM of their powers multiplied by tens of times. Do you know what sum means? Its not my formula as thats what Vados stated in the anime. I'm saying anime made Vegito into a joke, and that in manga he STOMPS Zamasu. People here are arguing that Base Fusion is equal to their power at their strongest forms added together and then multiplied tens of times, which i said is impossible and i provided evidence as to why that is.. I dont care to argue about anime Vegito vs Zamasu, I'm just saying that their power is consistent to that statement Vados made later and Kefla isnt.
If you prefer anime thats your thing, but manga is and always has been canon, and anime filler is not.

Also are you saying SSG is tens of times base form?????????
You should brush up on sum reading comprehension.

First of all, there is no definitive "canon", much as I like the idea. Namekian Book of Legends? Anime only, yet reference again by Toriyama directly in the interview where he reveals the story of Yamoshi the legendary Super Saiyan. Production staff and story? Anime-based. Primary product driving the franchise forward right now? Anime. Right now, there's a stronger case to be made that the movie was designed to continue the anime's story than the manga; the manga just so happens to also use the Broly movie in its continuity, the only point when the 2 mediums have the same set of events happen the same way. Therefore, unless we get an anime adaptation down the line, we can comfortably substitute any continuity into the movie.

Second of all, in the manga, Merged Zamasu never got stronger after the initial Potara Fusion; anime Zamasu did, twice in fact. The first time, his arm got pumped enough to require SSB Vegito to put effort in. The second time, he became stronger overall and yet Vegito still outclassed him in speed and matched him in strength. So, we can't use the manga's version of events as a metric because Merged Zamasu remained at the level he initially started at and didn't get strong enough and hax enough to contend with SSB Vegito.

Third of all, Vados said that Kefla's body and personality were greater than the sum of her parts, with her power increasing tens of times. The only noted power-statement is the "10s of times"; the "sum of her parts" is vague and could potentially mean power, but the context of the English sub leads me to believe it's more referring to Kefla as an actual individual compared to Kale and Caulifla.
``The new body and personality born from a Potara fusion are more than the sum of their parts and their power increases tens of times``? What part dont you get exactly? TENS OF TIMES. It says THEIR meaning Cauliflas and Kales. THEIR power. Also there IS a canon, its your problem that you like anime more than manga.

And also for the last time manga adopted the movie events. It showed SSJ Broly vs PSSB Goku and PSSB Vegeta. They skipped the arc entirely. Toriyama is working on the manga. Manga is canon. Toei adds and changes whole bunch of stuff in the anime. All i said was that Regular Blue Goku was fighting Zamasu in the anime, and Trunks and Vegeta overpowered him in a beam struggle. Kaioken Blue Goku also tagged Zamasu. I pointed those out as its consistent with Vados statement about Potaras power in the anime. You are talking about Vegito vs Zamasu, meanwhile I'm replying to the Base fusions is their strongest forms added together and then multiplied tens of times theory, so follow the conversation as I'm definitely not having debates with (only) you.

whooooooah Toriyama referenced it in an interview so it must be canon right?

Actually i think Goten isnt canon since Toriyama didnt remember him in a recent interview...
Tell me, do you have PROOF that the manga is, quote on quote, "canon"? Tell me, do you have proof that Toriyama himself stated that the anime is an adaptation of the manga story serving as the primary continuity and thus it should be disregarded? Do you have that evidence? Because I just provided a whole bunch of evidence that says otherwise, that the movie is canon to BOTH continuities but is designed to serve as a continuation of the primary medium that is also animated first and foremost.

Aside from that, you just proved yourself wrong by saying that the manga adapted events, since that means that the movie is canon to the anime since that scene in the manga didn't actually play out as shown in the movie.

Your logic on the translations is also flawed because the context implies that Kefla's "greater than the sum of her parts" applies to Kefla as a PERSON, rather than in power. Her body and PERSONALITY is more than the sum of her parts, and THEN her power increases tens of times. Neglecting the "personality" part; her power is only referenced increasing in the second part of the phrase. Also, yes, Toriyama referencing it in an interview makes it canonical since it ONLY ever showed up in the anime and no other medium; your own fallacious response is flawed because Toriyama never specifically brought up Goten's non-existence, so you have no grounds to stand on with that argument.

User avatar
ZombieVito
Banned
Posts: 6222
Joined: Wed Mar 13, 2013 12:18 pm

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by ZombieVito » Tue Jan 29, 2019 1:58 pm

PFM18 wrote: Well the same concept applies to Gotenks. Base Gotenks>SSJ Trunks/SSJ Goten

Nothing to do with a perfect fusion. If the fusion isn't perfect, then you won't fuse. It's a prerequisite to have the fusion in the first place.
Wouldn't work. A lot of things say that Gotenks isn't impressive until he reaches SS3.

Hell, Daizenshuu says he's weaker than Vegeta before the RoSaT and Kuririn implies twice that Boo is stronger than SS Gotenks in the RoF arc.

User avatar
PFM18
Banned Alternate Account
Posts: 3701
Joined: Sun Feb 04, 2018 2:23 pm

Re: Dragon Ball Super Strength Discussion Thread

Post by PFM18 » Tue Jan 29, 2019 3:37 pm

ZombieVito wrote:
PFM18 wrote: Well the same concept applies to Gotenks. Base Gotenks>SSJ Trunks/SSJ Goten

Nothing to do with a perfect fusion. If the fusion isn't perfect, then you won't fuse. It's a prerequisite to have the fusion in the first place.
Wouldn't work. A lot of things say that Gotenks isn't impressive until he reaches SS3.

Hell, Daizenshuu says he's weaker than Vegeta before the RoSaT and Kuririn implies twice that Boo is stronger than SS Gotenks in the RoF arc.
Gotenks in Base is stronger than the SSJs of his fusees. All indications show that to he true. How he compares to Vegeta is irrelevant. And Gotenks obviously isn't competing with Super Buu until he hits SSJ3, but that doesnt mean his Base cant be stronger than the SSJ of his fusions.

Post Reply