JulieYBM wrote: Fri Jun 25, 2021 10:09 pm
Piccolo's kick should have dealt lasting, deliberating damage there, actually. Knock out Freeza's vosion or something nasty so that he isn't just getting away without a struggle.
I wanted to mention this as my anti-contribution to this thread: DBS really gave up on anything to do with physical damage. Most injuries are shown off as characters weakly holding their arm or something similar. Even when they're obviously tired, they don't feel tired. Badly drawn "weakly letting their arms fall" notwithstanding. I'm just always thinking back to, say, the Goku vs. Vegeta fight when Goku's body was broken and Vegeta was limping around from his injuries, barely able to run when necessary. If that happened in DBS, Goku would probably be stiff and flat on the ground and Vegeta would be a little dusty and seem fine save for a couple scenes here and there.
At that particular point in the manga, Freeza not having any lasting damage makes sense narratively to sell just how outrageously stronger he was than both Son Goku and Piccolo, that even a cheap sneak attack like that wouldn't faze him. After all, the bastard was about to tank a Genki Dama in the ensuing pages as well as roughly hold his own against the legendary Saiyajin himself. Freeza is just too powerful, freakishly powerful. Especially against a weakened Piccolo, no sucker punch like that would even tickle him. And at the time it made sense.
Against someone like, say, Vegeta (or even second-form Freeza) it would have been interesting to see some real-ass physical damage.
Or in other words, the laser beam nearly killing Goku was bullshit. The most contrived reason to turn the tides we've seen yet in the series. And let's not forget, in the manga, we also saw Muten Roshi effortlessly dodge Jiren's attacks as a preliminary showing of what Ultra Instinct could do. No matter how little Jiren was trying, I can't buy that. I
can't buy that. I refuse. I want a refund. I want to speak to your manager, Toriyama. Even against Raditz, that'd have been too stupid to take seriously. Dragon Ball has always been silly and rarely took itself seriously, but it's always maintained some sense of consistency. Heck, even Dr. Slump did, and that was a story that would will the physical manifestation of a fuck into its pages just so it could pocket it instead of giving a fuck. Dragon Ball ever since Battle of Gods has played fast and loose with itself, mostly to its own detriment. I'd like to say that it's always been this way and that I'm just older now and more aware of the series' flaws, but it really is sloppier than DB and DBZ were.
Anyway, nowadays a total weightlessness to combat is the norm. Attacks that would have broken bones or really stunned characters into a double-vision concussion (or just flat-out knocked them out) in DB or early Z end the same way nowadays, coincidentally the same way it'd work in a video game. Weightless combat is already the norm in xianxia stories, but it feels so lame here because DB didn't start out this way.
I loved Caulifla's reaction from getting gut-flattened by Goku— that sort of injury, action, reaction, that's what I'm talking about. That's how fights work! If modern DB wasn't so sterile, video gamey, and plastic (or squishy, depending on who's the animation director), we'd see more of that.
Coincidentally, one of the things I liked in the DBS anime was Caulifla. Even though I like the manga's "Song Jiang" Caulifla more.
Similarly, Goku and Freeza at Baba's place. That whole scene, the second half of that episode, that was brilliant. We finally got a flash of what DB Super could have been after so long.