First of all, let me get this out of the way first:goku the krump dancer wrote: Wed Sep 22, 2021 5:09 pmThat's exactly what it sounds like though.Kunzait_83 wrote: Mon Sep 20, 2021 5:49 am We're all just NOT into the same series, period, because the sheer gulf of difference between them is just THAT stark and overpowering.
There was a user on this forum some years ago named PenguinTruth who used to shout the same thing.
Granted I'm not saying there's no merit to the claim ( btw I enjoyed both growing up and yes I prefer the modern dubs with a more faithful script or just the original JP broadcasting overall) but what I AM saying is that I cant imagine walking into a break room at work and I overhear some dudes listening to the SS3 Goku theme or Cell's theme while they reminisce over the show, I walk up to them and go "Oh Naw, that's not the real DBZ, y'all like that goofy English shit, The Kikuchi score is far superior and fits the tone of the series more". Even though that's true, it also absolutely REEKS of poindexter.. and no one likes a poindexter.
This isn't a "true fan" thing. Particularly in my case, since I'm about as vehement a person as you'll find who finds the whole "true fan" notion to be laughably fucking idiotic and childish/infantile.
I'm not accusing anyone of not being a "real Dragon Ball fan". I 1000% believe, clearly, that dub fans are absolutely sincere and dedicated to their version and are absolutely heartfelt in their love and devotion to it. That's wonderful for them. Genuinely.
Rather what I'm saying is... the Akira Toriyama and FUNimation takes on Dragon Ball share a name and a face, but not an identity. I don't doubt whatsoever that fans of the latter version are anything other than totally genuine and passionate, and that is, I cannont stress this enough, perfectly fine and lovely for them: but end of the day we don't like the same fucking thing as one another. We just don't.
This isn't a "you're not a real Dragon Ball fan!" thing and this certainly isn't a "I'm a better Dragon Ball fan than you are!" thing (which I cannot stress enough is beyond idiotic and silly). Rather this is more a "we don't really have any actual common ground to meet together on" thing. This is a "why are we even talking to one another like we're talking about the same thing, when we're obviously not?" thing. I don't look down my nose at these folks, rather I'm just wondering "why are we even in the same fucking building together?"
So that's the first part. Secondly though is... why are you inventing some ridiculous, absurd scenario that is in no way relevant to anything that's being said or is actually happening here? Not to state the obvious here or anything but... we're not in the breakroom at wherever you work or at where whomever else here works: we're on a Dragon Ball internet forum full of Dragon Ball uber nerds.
This isn't some "casual chat" between work buddies who happened to casually watch a few episodes of this old TV show years and years ago (which, I cannot stress this enough, I really, REALLY couldn't care less about): this is literally a place where the whole point of being here is to go super nuanced and detailed about anything and everything related to this series and its broader history in as hyper specific and meticulously as possible.
This forum is literally about as FAR removed and as polar diametric opposite of an environment as the one you laid out in that scenario as can conceivably be. You're making a ludicrous false equivalence between two entirely different scenarios with entirely different contexts. Hypothetically speaking, if I worked where you worked and that conversation you described was going on, would I then butt into it and go "Well ackshully in the original Manga, Cell and Goku said..."
Uh... no. No I would not. I honestly probably wouldn't even say anything and would just ignore the conversation entirely and mind my own fucking business. I don't give two shits ultimately what it is that people are into or like. That's on them and I've got FAR more than enough of my own shit to deal with frankly.
All I said was, there are more than enough differences in both the nuts and bolts core being of the material itself as well as what it is within it that primarily draws these different sets of fanbases to it, that I think we can make a reasonably strong case that the differences between versions are so stark and run so deep, that when you throw together the fanbases who's sphere of focus is firmly fixed on one versus the other that we're all fundamentally just not talking about the same series, and certainly in many cases not even the same characters.
Are we really going to sit here and pretend like Schemmel's Goku for example is the same guy as Toriyama/Nozawa's Goku? With a straight face, we're SERIOUSLY going to pretend like we're all talking about the same character here much of the time? And pretend that time and time again countlessly, someone at some point has no choice but to pipe up and remind people "Yeah uh, actually he didn't say or do this here in this particular version. That was only in X or Y version." And that these are oftentimes big character defining things, not just trivial nerd details.
We all like something that is called Dragon Ball and shares its art style and VERY broad beats (though sometimes not even then in some cases): but we don't like the same work ultimately. I'm sorry, I've been here at Kanz for 17 years, and in DB fandom broadly for...fuck, 29 years now (egads!): I'm more than beyond certain at this point that personally I don't have almost ANY common ground, and I mean whatsoever, in terms of DB-related topics with someone for whom DB is "The Greatest Action Cartoon of All Time!" from Cartoon Network's "glory years". I think I've given it more than long enough time to make that appraisal.
We're not fans of the same thing, we don't share the same interest as one another. Period. That doesn't mean that I "look down" on them or that I "condescend" to them or think that I'm "above" them for it. Why the fuck would I? That makes ZERO sense. This isn't an RPG, there are no "tiers" or "levels" to any of this stupid, stupid crap.
All it means is that we simply don't like nor are we interested in the same thing as one another: so why are we collectively in a community talking about these two different things like they're the same thing when they clearly, obviously are not? And furthermore when our whole point of reference for them is so CLEARLY detached from one another to the point of being almost wholly unrelated?
And since this more than likely needs to be spelled out yet again for the cheap seats: I put absolutely NONE of the blame for this divide on ANY of the fans in EITHER camp. The blame for this divide is 1000% ENTIRELY on FUNimation itself, period, end-of. They created this splinter, and completely needlessly: everyone else are just, for the most part anyway, reacting to it accordingly.
The only thing that I WILL put on fans however, is for constantly going out of their way to make all of this shit so stupefying personal so much of the time, and for constantly interpreting criticism of a work of fucking fiction as a personal slight on themselves.