Marz wrote: Sun Dec 19, 2021 2:56 pm
HeroR wrote: Sun Dec 19, 2021 1:46 pm
When Granola first started, there were people who outright said Toriyama wrote it or at least did the outline like he did for most of Super. It isn't until later that we learned that Granola is in the same vain as Moro where Toyo wrote the arc. What was different was Toriyama had more involvement. I am not cherry-picking anything. Am going by what people said when the arc first started.
Toyotaro said that Toriyama wrote ''the best draft'' for this arc last year. Which is in line with what he said later about him being the one who fleshed out the story, so there wasn't anything wrong with people claiming that he did the outline in the beginning, but you just want to be obtuse about it. Even then, no one was arguing that it was 100% Toriyama, just the usual for the rest of the Super. What is wrong is claiming the opposite like you is doing when I just showed two statements proving it.
HeroR wrote: Sun Dec 19, 2021 1:46 pm
If it's ignoring, then don't engage. People are going to be bias and it isn't on you to tell people from stop being bias. Especially when they write down their reasons why certain story elements don't work and I would have these same complaints even if Toriyama created them. Like I don't like the new Dragon Balls Toriyama created because it feels like lazy plot convenience.
I'm engaging because I'm specifically discussing the Toyo-Tori involved in the arc/previous arcs and not whatever you keep talking about in the rest of the post (like, I don't care about your beef with Vegeta or whether you think Vegetto is fanservice man, it wasn't my point but you clearly can't understand it). I'm not discussing their role in the story, I'm discussing how the idea not coming from Toriyama himself changes jackshit because the same goes for all of Super (and because Toriyama himself continues to use these non-original concepts n his own story, when I said fusion I meant he used Gogeta later, just like he did with God Vegeta). You are just taking the opportunity to cherry pick things and discredit them because you don't like the manga. Like, I don't understand why some of you folks keep following things that you don't like. You don't like the manga or do you want it to die? Just stop following that and follow whatever media you enjoy, rather than continue to come a here and talk crap in threads you don't like. At the same time, don't get mad when people complain about the new movie saying they want it to flop for example, acting as if this is petty attitude (as if these same folks didn't act same way with other media), because some were acting exactly like that. Sounds (and is) hypocritical
HeroR wrote: Sun Dec 19, 2021 1:46 pm
That said, for the most part, I was able to guess correctly what came from Toyo because he's write like a fanfic writer.
Yes, because fake evil Goku and Red / Blue haired Super Saiyan forms totally aren't ''fanfic'' ideas...
Toriyama must have stolen this ideas from Toyo or other fanfic writers I guess
"Toyotaro said that Toriyama wrote ''the best draft'' for this arc last year. "
Which is why people thought Toriyama wrote the original draft like he did with the Future Trunks and the Universal Survival Saga. People thought Toriyama wrote an outline and Toyo adapted it while adding his own flair to it. We then learned Toyo wrote the original draft and then sent it Toriyama who made changes to it. So this arc is very similar to Moro, except Toriyama added more stuff to the plot.
"so there wasn't anything wrong with people claiming that he did the outline in the beginning, but you just want to be obtuse about it."
Not really since I detailed what happened. People outright said that Toriyama drafted this story like the other Dragon Ball Super arcs, but that wasn't the case. You can be mad about it and call me obtuse all you want, but that is exactly what happened.
"What is wrong is claiming the opposite like you is doing when I just showed two statements proving it."
Because it's really no different than what happened with Moro. Like Merus being an angel and the angel lore came from Toriyama, but everyone agrees that Moro is Toyo's love child. This arc is more cooperate, but a lot of the massive plot points come from Toyo.
"I'm engaging because I'm specifically discussing the Toyo-Tori involved in the arc/previous arcs and not whatever you keep talking about in the rest of the post (like, I don't care about your beef with Vegeta or whether you think Vegetto is fanservice man, it wasn't my point but you clearly can't understand it). "
You brought up Vegito in discussion and I discussed why it doesn't really work.
"and because Toriyama himself continues to use these non-original concepts n his own story, when I said fusion I meant he used Gogeta later, just like he did with God Vegeta"
Super Saiyan God Vegeta isn't non-original concept since Toriyama outright said any Saiyan can become a Super Saiyan God if they have a righteous heart when Battle of Gods came out and Vegeta said he wanted to become a Super Saiyan God next in the movie. It isn't something Toyo created outright by giving Vegeta the form. And Toriyama was going to used Gogeta for his manga, but when he learned about Fusion Reborn, he changed his mind and created the Potara Fusion because he didn't want to step on the movie's toes.
"You are just taking the opportunity to cherry pick things and discredit them because you don't like the manga."
How am I cherrypicking when stuff Toryama created I don't like for the manga. The biggest issue I have with the manga is Toriyama being a crap editor.
"Like, I don't understand why some of you folks keep following things that you don't like."
I don't follow it. I stopped reading the manga for over a year before I bothered reading again. Heck, I haven't posted in this thread for months. The only reason I know what is going in the manga despite not reading it because since I am a following Dragon Ball, stuff get spoiled for me. Like I learned about the UE spoilers from the Dokkan Battle Discord. And Twitter was filled with people complaining how UI Goku lost to Granola since I follow Herms and get updates from Dragon Ball Hype. So even when I don't follow the manga, it still find out what happens.
"You don't like the manga or do you want it to die?"
How is not liking something means I want it to die?
"Just stop following that and follow whatever media you enjoy"
So the old, 'don't like, don't watched'. Yeah, I honestly hate this mentality since people have the right to follow something and give their opinions. Then again, it seemed to believe not liking a media means the person wants it to die.
"At the same time, don't get mad when people complain about the new movie"
Have you been in the movie thread? I have gotten on people for complaining about the plot for Super Heroes when we don't know the plot yet. Especially the theory that they're hiding the plot because it's thin. I also scoffed at people saying FighterZ looks better because that is 'everything looks like PS2' nonsense. You don't even to go into the thread. My post history speaks for itself.
" they want it to flop for example, acting as if this is petty attitude"
That is petty. People wanting a movie to flop because they don't like is stupid. I said the same thing when people collectively lost their shit when Broly was made canon.
"Yes, because fake evil Goku and Red / Blue haired Super Saiyan forms totally aren't ''fanfic'' ideas..."
Evil Goku is fanfic, but a fake one actually isn't that common. And most Super Saiyan forms before Battle of Gods was based on some version of Super Saiyan 4, not a recolors. I should know since I read almost every Dragon Ball fanfic from 90s to the late 2000s. Even the Evil Goku concept isn't the same since most used the plot line 'Goku hits his head and become Kakarot'. Not, Evil Goku shows up in the future timeline wearing black like an edge lord.
"Toriyama must have stolen this ideas from Toyo or other fanfic writers I guess"
If you read Dragon Ball AF, most of Toriyama's ideas are not reflective outside of 'evil Supreme Kai'. That and isn't ideas that are fanfic. It's the way Toyo executes those ideas and his general writing style that are very common among fanfic writers.