Miracles wrote: ↑Sun Aug 06, 2023 6:13 pm
Why wouldn't the wish count Broly when he is indeed
in universe 7? Freeza was
only exempted from being subject to Toronbo's wish because he was
out of the universe. Now people saying Broly doesn't count is making up rules for the titan Saiyan.
Of course Broly counts, but only as much as he is capable of by the time the wish was made, which was even below Goku and Vegeta. The thing is Broly can’t be weaker and stronger than Granolah at the same time. Goku wouldn’t ask if there was someone stronger than him out there if he knew Broly was superior back then. Now in Super Hero, Goku and Vegeta are stronger than Granolah and for some reason Broly is implied to be stronger than them.
HeroR wrote: ↑Sun Aug 06, 2023 8:16 pm
In 'Super official content', god-level is a vague term. It has been used to described Battle of Gods' Super Saiyan God Goku, Super Saiyan 2 Goku from the Future Trunks Saga, SSB Vegeta before the TOP in the manga, SSBE Vegeta when he fought Toppo, and Dragon Ball Super Broly to describe Post-USS Goku.
SS2 was never implied to be on the level of the gods. The first Super Saiyan stage to enter that realm is SSG, unless you are talking about the infamous Saiyan Beyond God state that appeared in Ressurrection of Freeza. Not sure what you mean by USS.
The way the fandom used 'God-level' just means 'Beerus' level'. Which is why I called it a fan-term, because that is what you guys really mean while Super will changed what 'god-level' is depending on what they're hyping. Unless you really believed Gowasu when he called Super Saiyan 2 Goku's power on the level of a God of Destruction.
I don’t know with whom you are talking about, but so far god-level in Super is not restricted to Beerus’ level. It’s a wide range starting with SSG and ending with the Omni-king. This is the realm of power that was firstly introduced in Battle of Gods (hence the word “god” being used in the film title and in the transformation). Gowasu obviously had no clue about what happened between Beerus and Goku. There is nothing to infer from his claim.
"Most likely Nagamine is talking about ultra instinct (the technique of the gods)"
Honestly, you really shouldn't assume anything because UI wasn't even mentioned in the movie not even in a throwaway or a clip like Jiren was and the movie was being scripted even before the TOP. To assume he meant UI is like debating if Toriyama was thinking of UI Goku or Blue Goku when he said Piccolo was on Goku's level. Or when he said Gohan was stronger than anyone was he considering the Super manga.
“Goku broke past his limits and evolved to Ultra Instinct, so we should follow suit and have the look evolve as well.” Besides, the way Nagamine compares Goku, Vegeta and Freeza suggests he thinks Goku is stronger than Vegeta, and Freeza is aiming to surpass the gods. So, it’s very easy to figure out what evolution he is talking about when he says Goku is approaching the gods. It’s all coming together. There is no reason to think he is talking about Blue since Vegeta already caught up that form.
Also, if he was talking about UI, all material for UI has it beyond the gods, not just on the level of them or approaching the gods. In all media, UI was on par with Jiren who is continuously stated even now to be just as strong if not stronger than the Gods of Destruction. And before someone say it, him only being stronger than Belmond was only in the manga. I checked every material related to Jiren and not one of them outside of the manga relates Jiren's power to just Belmond.
This is not a consensus in all of them. I had seen it called “state of the gods”, “technique of the gods”. So, technically it would be beyond gods of destruction in the anime, but not beyond angels.
"Also, when Goku manages to use ultra instinct properly against Moro,"
While true, that wouldn't have anything to do with Nagamine. Or even Super Hero since we don't even know if the movie used any manga lore. Chances are, it doesn't since the Super manga is doing its own version of Super Hero.
Nagamine seems to be well aware of Freeza’s ambitions and he described Freeza’s steady increase in strength well in advance, something that wasn’t included in the Broly movie. Dragon Room is there exactly for that, to make further developments work with each other. Most likely he had access to the story drafts beforehand. Super Hero manga adaptation is following suit with the film with minor differences as well.
"The thing is, if Goku had surpassed Beerus’ threshold and Granolah could become stronger than him"
But you haven't answered is why. Using quotes from the manga this is what the dragon said:
"It is possible for you to become stronger than you already are, but I cannot increase your power beyond your latent potential."
So if Granolah had the potential to surpassed Beerus by releasing all his latent potential in exchanged for most of his life, why is the wish limited to the "most powerful life-form apart from the Gods themselves"? Especially since he had the potential to leapfrog over beings confirmed to be stronger than Gods of Destruction like Jiren since Goku should have surpassed that version of Jiren since manga Jiren was only about even with TOP UI Goku who's at least stronger than Belmond. So it's okay to surpassed that level of God of Destruction, but Beerus is off-limits.
I don’t see why this question matters, because the dragon has no say about gods other than Beerus and Whis. There is no problem with assuming that Granolah has surpassed other gods of destruction either. If anything this only reinforces that Beerus and Quitela are far stronger than Vermoud.
"naturally the bottomline would switch to the next god above, Whis."
But why? Why is the Gods supposedly off-limits, but you can still be stronger than a god if some random mortal happened to be stronger than a god. What is even the point of limiting to the gods if it really doesn't matter as long as some random dude can smoke Beerus.
The power hierarchy of the gods is pretty vast. If god-level is the roof, then you must only figure out by subtext which type of god is being referred. There is always a god or a bunch of them stronger than Goku, even if he someday he manages to surpass Beerus.
"If Whis were surpassed then Great Priest and so on"
I have to call BS because Toyo gave himself an out in the next panel after he introduced the god condition. Namely, Granalah could only get as strong as his maximal lifetime wish his full latent potential. Basically, Gohan's Ultimate form +100 years of training. So Granaloh could never be as strong as Whis unless he had the latent potential to reached that level in his lifetime according to the dragon. So the whole idea that Granalah would have been closed to Whis if Goku happened to be stronger than Beerus isn't what Toyo wrote.
I’m absolutely fine with how Toyotaro wrote that scene. I frankly don’t need him to be more specific because subtext is a thing, my friend. The moment Granolah made the wish Goku was #1 in the universe, but Toyotaro and Uchida themselves gave a non-exhaustive list of people that are stronger than Goku, including non-gods like Broly, who curiously should count but somehow didn’t (or he did? Who knows) Of course, this tidbit won’t add up for everyone but for me is very basic writing level.