This reads bizarrely to me. It's not like Toriyama had a 100% win streak with character designs from the start, or even in any given arbitrary era.The Monkey King wrote: Sat Dec 07, 2024 12:50 pmThis is the same Toriyama who gave us horrible designs like Zeno, Cabba and Califula.SHINOBI-03 wrote: Sat Dec 07, 2024 10:17 am Okay but seriously, was Majin Kuu designed by Toriyama or somebody else did it?
His designs became hit-or-miss a decade ago.
Some of the main characters in Dragon Ball are literally just the same character designs from Dr. Slump (Yamcha is Tsukutsun, the Turtle Hermit is God...). Some of his one-shot character designs are literally just those recycled again (see: Sonchoh, which adds in Bulma). He did the Xenomorph at least four different times...?
And the stuff for ancillary products? Ozotto is hilarious in retrospect, but that design? Some of his Dragon Quest boss designs? They're Ozotto rejects!
(I say this as someone who adores his designs, and thinks that a bad Toriyama design beats the snot out of most other designs any day of the week!)
I think a lot of people, perhaps yourself included, don't have (or are unwilling to entertain?) the perspective that nostalgia and accepted knowledge/familiarity has tinted your viewpoint on the past. I'd be willing to bet that if certain folks weren't a certain age when they saw certain characters in the Z-era, they'd have a strong negative reaction to it.
For example, Freeza looks terrible here on first reveal. He's a little cross-eyed, his mouth has a strange movement to it... I don't actually think the almost goofiness of him contrasts with the violence surrounding him that Toriyama actually intended to portray here. I see what he's going for, but the way Freeza's drawn, it doesn't work for me. It dos the opposite. Can you imagine what the reaction in this thread would be if this was completely new?

Don't mistake this for another drive-by "Goku was always stupid" kind of post: I genuinely hope, wish, and ask that some of you (including the individual I'm quoting here) reflect on this a bit:
Can we wait longer than 24 hours before declaring all of Toriyama's character designs shit? Can we learn a little bit more about who designed him in the first place, too? Was it Toriyama? Was it Nakatsuru? Was it by committee? What else does the writer have in store for us with this character? Is it a red herring entirely?
There's thoughtful criticism, and there's being loud/obnoxious/hyperbolic with rage. More of the former, less of the latter.
(And I'm in agreement on the fist-bump discourse. I thought it stood out. In yet another episode were Glorio begrudgingly goes along with a Panzy suggestion earlier in the episode for the 800th time, it stood out.)











