I think an unfortunate caveat with early DB being problematic is that it's still pretty fucking funny. The story was undoubtedly more tightly-written when Torishima was Toriyama's editor, and that's unfortunately where Roshi is the most prominent. Yeah, you could skip what is in a way DB at its strongest to avoid the problematic content, but then you're skipping DB at its strongest.
That said, I don't really like how Toriyama's comedic talent is being propped up as "DB's true heart and charm" at the expense of the cool action that later came to define it. I think the truth is that DB's heart and charm is the
marriage of these things. Toriyama made a silly thing, shaped that silly thing into something increasingly cool as hell, and then flipped that cool thing into being silly again before wrapping it up. That's structurally awesome, and if you don't start at the beginning you won't be able to experience it.
It's true that a lot of people will start at some random place with a lot of shows, and that's fine. But if you are interested in checking a thing out
and have the ability to start from the beginning, you might as well. If you wanna watch a show,
watch the show, rough and problematic parts and all. They're a part of the show too, for better or for worse.
If you want to give someone a disclaimer about problematic content, absolutely do so, but a great many people
can handle that stuff even if we'd rather it was simply never written that way in the first place. Just as I'm not gonna project my own wish fulfillment of watching Bruce Lee movies and reading Dr. Slump before starting DB onto a first time viewer, we shouldn't project our own lack of a stomach for problematic content onto others (particularly if they're already grown adults).
JulieYBM wrote: Mon Mar 31, 2025 9:57 amThis entire franchise is "roll with the punches" central.
Exactly. Even if you skip the early Roshi antics, it's not long before you're introduced to the God of Blackface. With DB you're either willing to accept a problematic ride, or you're not. If you are, then buckle up and start from the beginning. If you're not, then probably skip the whole thing and do something else. Of course, not every sort of problematic content is going to get under everyone's skin to the same degree. Which means there's a whole "It Depends" in the room here.