Comparisons to Dragon Ball Super (2015) are largely irrelevant, though. They can be viewed separately from one another and their broadcasts exists largely separate from one another. More importantly, better than something that isn't good doesn't make this series automatically good, especially when it drops the balls in areas that Dragon Ball Super (2015) at least created a largely smooth experience in—like being properly scripted and properly storyboarded.The Dark Knight wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 11:16 amThere is a clear improvement though over what came before it. You may still not like it for whatever reason, and that's fine, but you can't really look at episode 5 (2015) and episode 2 (2026) and say things aren't vastly better in terms of looks.JulieYBM wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 11:07 am The animation and directing aren't good, though.
Like, the writing isn't good, either, of course, but Dragon Ball Super: Beerus does not work on any level whatsoever.
Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
Boring first half, interesting second half.
Some things are literally being put together from scratch, right? I know BoG doesn't have any of that "sleepy" exchange, but I can't remember if DBS 15 had any. It's so confusing with so many versions of the same thing. What remains constant is how unimpressive the final fight is in every iteration. This time it looks nice, at least.
Also, dropping the pride-swallowing aspect of the SSG transformation is not a good call. That scene goes hand in hand with Vegeta's moment (bingo/eggs). It speaks volumes about just how powerful this form is and how uneasy Goku feels about using it. It's a cheatcode that makes even fusion look like a legitimate fighting technique by comparison.
At least there aren't so time outs to ask how things are going, but then again, the fight wasn't originally anything to write home about, so it couldn't rely on the action alone.
The hyaku-pasento remark is an odd addition. I mean, as an existing audience, we know Beerus is just lying through his teeth, and it's funny when you contextualize the whole "fighting you at full power would make me look bad, but I'd rather do that than lose" quote. What he actually means is going from 0.001 to 0.002... But in order to do that you must be familiar with what comes later, otherwise this story is told as if there's nothing following it up. Seems like there won't be any tweaks to stop Beerus from looking like he's selling himself short in every single arc.
Some things are literally being put together from scratch, right? I know BoG doesn't have any of that "sleepy" exchange, but I can't remember if DBS 15 had any. It's so confusing with so many versions of the same thing. What remains constant is how unimpressive the final fight is in every iteration. This time it looks nice, at least.
Also, dropping the pride-swallowing aspect of the SSG transformation is not a good call. That scene goes hand in hand with Vegeta's moment (bingo/eggs). It speaks volumes about just how powerful this form is and how uneasy Goku feels about using it. It's a cheatcode that makes even fusion look like a legitimate fighting technique by comparison.
At least there aren't so time outs to ask how things are going, but then again, the fight wasn't originally anything to write home about, so it couldn't rely on the action alone.
The hyaku-pasento remark is an odd addition. I mean, as an existing audience, we know Beerus is just lying through his teeth, and it's funny when you contextualize the whole "fighting you at full power would make me look bad, but I'd rather do that than lose" quote. What he actually means is going from 0.001 to 0.002... But in order to do that you must be familiar with what comes later, otherwise this story is told as if there's nothing following it up. Seems like there won't be any tweaks to stop Beerus from looking like he's selling himself short in every single arc.
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
That’s a bingo.JulieYBM wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 11:21 amComparisons to Dragon Ball Super (2015) are largely irrelevant, though. They can be viewed separately from one another and their broadcasts exists largely separate from one another. More importantly, better than something that isn't good doesn't make this series automatically good, especially when it drops the balls in areas that Dragon Ball Super (2015) at least created a largely smooth experience in—like being properly scripted and properly storyboarded.The Dark Knight wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 11:16 amThere is a clear improvement though over what came before it. You may still not like it for whatever reason, and that's fine, but you can't really look at episode 5 (2015) and episode 2 (2026) and say things aren't vastly better in terms of looks.JulieYBM wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 11:07 am The animation and directing aren't good, though.
Like, the writing isn't good, either, of course, but Dragon Ball Super: Beerus does not work on any level whatsoever.
A lot of the “positive” sentiment seems to be based exclusively on comparisons with the base Anime. That because Beerus is “better” looking than the original Super anime, then this shows that DBS: Beerus is a success. The problem is two fold: 1. The bar is so low as the original production for Super was so catastrophic and infamous, that merely having slightly better visuals than the original Super anime is not the achievement that people seem to think it is. Again, as I’ve personally said, this is the bare minimum of expectation. And I’d even go as far as to say that these enhancements are just not worth the price of admission. It just seems like all they really did was make Super what it “should”’have looked like back in 2015. Again—not a compliment. It’s just not impressive in any real way, especially when looking at something like Daima: the anime that some of y’all were claiming would kill Dragon Ball.
2. I don’t believe Beerus is a good anime on its own merits. Take away Super, and all that’s left is a fairly bog-standard shounen that’s just so stripped down that there’s barely anything that one would consider “Dragon Ball” remains. And unfortunately, there is a sizable audience that wants exactly that.
True to my word, I did not see last week’s episode because I see no point. My reaction will largely be the same, where the only variance is to the degree of “it’s shit” I’ll feel each episode ends up being.
- The Dark Knight
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1037
- Joined: Tue Nov 04, 2025 10:48 am
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
You have to admit that the location of the fight constantly changing in the movie was a nice touch. That is something I really miss from Super, as the ocean and space are just not that interesting on their own.Koitsukai wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 12:02 pmWhat remains constant is how unimpressive the final fight is in every iteration. This time it looks nice, at least.
That's because this story is based on a story that was indeed written as if nothing would follow it up.Koitsukai wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 12:02 pmWhat he actually means is going from 0.001 to 0.002... But in order to do that you must be familiar with what comes later, otherwise this story is told as if there's nothing following it up.
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
Okay, one thing I'll have to disagree about some of the criticisms here is that the animation or the art isn't good. That is insane to me. I think these episodes look much better than the movie, for the most part at least. The art is overall better and the composition is great. I much prefer the linework here too.
The weird saturation levels have been hit or miss, though, I'll give you that.
The weird saturation levels have been hit or miss, though, I'll give you that.
- SHINOBI-03
- I Live Here
- Posts: 2682
- Joined: Fri Oct 10, 2008 7:47 am
- Location: United Arab Emirates, Dubai
- Contact:
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
My biggest sticking point about the series is the lack of music. Why is it done this way? It's like it was edited to be made for YouTube edits but they left the music out so it won't get claimed by UMG or other music owners. It's weird.
My Dragon Ball Story (500th post)
My Anime List
My Manga List
My Anime List
My Manga List
Big Momma wrote:This is Daizex. There's gonna be complaints and groaning no matter what. ;)
Anime Insider magazine wrote:If police officers in the future dress like prostitutes, then what do prostitutes in the future wear?
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
How so? I thought it was pretty much a consensus here that BoG, compared to the original DBZ movies we had way before 2013, was one of the best movies ever.JulieYBM wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 12:31 am The movie is pretty awful, it's just slightly less awful than either television arc.
乃亜
Dragon Ball: The Others Discussion Thread
Are we too old to enjoy new Dragon Ball movies/series?
Dragon Ball: The Others Discussion Thread
Are we too old to enjoy new Dragon Ball movies/series?
Spoiler:
- VegettoEX
- Kanzenshuu Co-Owner & Administrator
- Posts: 17881
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2004 3:10 pm
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
The Kanzenshuu forum community is not a monolith -- there are a wide range of people here who like and dislike things in different ways, because every person is unique.
:: [| Mike "VegettoEX" LaBrie |] ::
:: [| Kanzenshuu - Co-Founder/Administrator, Podcast Host, News Manager (note: our "job" titles are arbitrary and meaningless) |] ::
:: [| Website: January 1998 |] :: [| Podcast: November 2005 |] :: [| Fusion: April 2012 |] :: [| Wiki: April 2026 |] ::
:: [| Kanzenshuu - Co-Founder/Administrator, Podcast Host, News Manager (note: our "job" titles are arbitrary and meaningless) |] ::
:: [| Website: January 1998 |] :: [| Podcast: November 2005 |] :: [| Fusion: April 2012 |] :: [| Wiki: April 2026 |] ::
- The Dark Knight
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1037
- Joined: Tue Nov 04, 2025 10:48 am
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
Personally speaking, I think it's leaps and bounds better than everything that came out before and after it.Noah wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 2:37 pmHow so? I thought it was pretty much a consensus here that BoG, compared to the original DBZ movies we had way before 2013, was one of the best movies ever.
It had interesting new characters.
It had character development for the old characters.
It had diverse locations.
It had great action scenes.
It had great new world building.
It had a good balance of action and comedy.
It didn't feel too long (Broly) or too short (RF).
It really did everything right; everything one could want from a DB story was present in that movie. Then RF came out and went out of its way to get just about everything wrong.
Last edited by The Dark Knight on Mon Nov 09, 2026 3:45 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
This episode had little soul, if any at all.
Who would have thought this story would suck without any of the interesting characterization the movie had?
It's all completely pointless. The movie not only showed Goku struggling with his pride because of how he attained the form (with Vegeta's gestures also motivating him to swallow his pride for the greater good); it also made a subtle point of showing the difference between Goku and the first Super Saiyan God, who was defeated after the form expired. Here, Shenron doesn't retell that story. So Goku "earning" the God powers after the form expires, thanks to his past training and fighting prowess, has no substance at all.
The dialogue between Goku and Beerus about fighting, pride, and Goku having to admit defeat is also missing. (I don't remember whether it happens later, but if it does, it doesn't have much substance either.) Beerus isn't interesting at all.
I'm aware this is also a complaint about the original Super's retelling, but I was hoping Beerus could have fixed something. So much for sticking to Toriyama's vision…
Who would have thought this story would suck without any of the interesting characterization the movie had?
It's all completely pointless. The movie not only showed Goku struggling with his pride because of how he attained the form (with Vegeta's gestures also motivating him to swallow his pride for the greater good); it also made a subtle point of showing the difference between Goku and the first Super Saiyan God, who was defeated after the form expired. Here, Shenron doesn't retell that story. So Goku "earning" the God powers after the form expires, thanks to his past training and fighting prowess, has no substance at all.
The dialogue between Goku and Beerus about fighting, pride, and Goku having to admit defeat is also missing. (I don't remember whether it happens later, but if it does, it doesn't have much substance either.) Beerus isn't interesting at all.
I'm aware this is also a complaint about the original Super's retelling, but I was hoping Beerus could have fixed something. So much for sticking to Toriyama's vision…
悟 “Vincit qui se vincit”
What I consider canonical
What I consider canonical
Spoiler:
- The Dark Knight
- Advanced Regular
- Posts: 1037
- Joined: Tue Nov 04, 2025 10:48 am
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
This version is all style and 0 substance. The focus is entirely on the action while everything related to the actual characters was removed.
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
Yamamuro Tadayoshi's character designs still look really ugly, even if they're being animated with a little bit more time than there will in the 2010s. Yamamuro himself is not a great animation supervisor, let alone a good director. Visual mediums require more skill than, "Well, it looks on model, at least." Even in the few spots where the animation is being handled by a good key animator, those shots still suffer from Yamamuro corrections, or being animated based on bad character models, or from simply not having a lot of time and drawings allowed to create interesting movement.Caulifor wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 12:38 pm Okay, one thing I'll have to disagree about some of the criticisms here is that the animation or the art isn't good. That is insane to me. I think these episodes look much better than the movie, for the most part at least. The art is overall better and the composition is great. I much prefer the linework here too.
The weird saturation levels have been hit or miss, though, I'll give you that.
Then, you have to factor in the overall effect. I wouldn't say that Dragon Ball Super: Beerus is a well-animated series, simply because it has a few less rushed shots. Part of using animation effectively is having the discipline of a good storyboard artist and episode director, to know how to weave together a project that flows, both visually and through the use of sound. Dragon Ball Super: Beerus doesn't have that. It's awkward, disjointed, and lacks and sort of personality. Which, again, as we see with the lack of a properly credited series director, is by design of the series. Someone knew that they were getting assigned this project and they knew that they were going to get fucked over into oblivion, and that's likely why their real name isn't credited for Series Composition and Series Director.
And that isn't even getting into the colors and the photgraphy being all sorts of inconsistently ugly lol.
Like Mike said, the forum community isn't a monolith.Noah wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 2:37 pmHow so? I thought it was pretty much a consensus here that BoG, compared to the original DBZ movies we had way before 2013, was one of the best movies ever.JulieYBM wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 12:31 am The movie is pretty awful, it's just slightly less awful than either television arc.
Dragon Ball Z: Battle of Gods looks terrible and has a terrible music score, but a fun script with actors that were really engaged with the project. Unfotunately, a fun script and solid performances from actors are only two of the many parts of making a good film. Arguably, 'fun' scripts aren't necessarily 'good' scripts, although I would say that the writing for Goku, Beerus and Vegeta are the best parts of the film, even if they're not super fleshed-out and could be improved upon.
If we really want to invite comparisons to the older films, Dragon Ball Z: The Strongest Guy in the World isn't too shabby a film for something made with the creative and time restrictions that it was made under. There's an interesting idea for antagonists, sick backgrounds and character designs, really good acting performances and a music score that is gorgeous and haunting. It's the kind of movie you watch and think to yourself, "This was a fun of fun, but I wish it fleshed out some of its ideas more" while still being the kind of film that's easy to return to.
And, again, it's not an experience of staring at super ugly animation character designs, CG animation, and ugly coloring and compositing for 85-105 minutes, like Battle of Gods is.
Or listening to a truly terrible music score, either lol
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
I agree that Yamamuro's designs are ugly, but that applies just as much to the movie, doesn't it? At least here the line art is better, the characters don't have that excessive shine on them, and some of the corrections feel like he's learned his lesson and is actually tapping into his classic style rather than his stiff modern work.JulieYBM wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 3:48 pmYamamuro Tadayoshi's character designs still look really ugly, even if they're being animated with a little bit more time than there will in the 2010s. Yamamuro himself is not a great animation supervisor, let alone a good director. Visual mediums require more skill than, "Well, it looks on model, at least." Even in the few spots where the animation is being handled by a good key animator, those shots still suffer from Yamamuro corrections, or being animated based on bad character models, or from simply not having a lot of time and drawings allowed to create interesting movement.Caulifor wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 12:38 pm Okay, one thing I'll have to disagree about some of the criticisms here is that the animation or the art isn't good. That is insane to me. I think these episodes look much better than the movie, for the most part at least. The art is overall better and the composition is great. I much prefer the linework here too.
The weird saturation levels have been hit or miss, though, I'll give you that.
I'm definitely not saying it looks amazing or anything, but I definitely prefer this to the movie, in terms of art direction. Sure, it's mostly just okay with occasional flashes of good, but that's how Z was week-to-week anyway.
I'll admit though, the only reason I think this looks better than the movie is 'cause it looks a biiiiiit closer to what Z looked like.
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
Yeah gonna get off the “Kemuri agrees with Julie” train to say: hogwash on Battle of Gods being “awful.” It was what it needed to be. A fan service heavy DBZ feature, premiering over 10 years after the last DBZ film. Having a fun script is all it really needed, and while I’ve never been a fan of how modern DBZ (which I classify as post GT to today) looks, at the time—meh. Nothing amazing but also not the worst thing ever.
Again, claiming that Super: Beerus looks better than a film that released 13 years ago? Not a flex.
Again, claiming that Super: Beerus looks better than a film that released 13 years ago? Not a flex.
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
With every shot they enhance, there seems to be some glaring editing mistake that completely breaks my immersion. As a result, I can never really see the end product as an engaging story, but rather as a fan-made re-edit, with all the limitations that entails.
I don't consider Dragon Ball Kai to be a particularly well-edited series, but even so, I could comfortably watch an entire episode without constantly being reminded that I was watching a re-edited version of something that had already existed. And the problem lies precisely in how aggressively they've cut things down. Yes, the movie is around 80 minutes long, but the thing is, they're not working with the footage from the movie itself. They're working with footage from the original anime, whose narrative was designed around a very specific pacing. Unless you redid everything from scratch, there would be no way to change the original timing.
Dragon Ball Z had a considerably slower pace than Dragon Ball Super. Even so, Dragon Ball Kai generally followed a ratio of roughly two edited episodes for every original episode, which helped maintain a more natural rhythm while respecting the original series' direction and staging. Dragon Ball Super: Beerus, on the other hand, sometimes condenses the equivalent of three or four episodes into a single one, as if the 2015 Dragon Ball Super had pacing issues comparable to the worst stretches of the Freeza Saga in Dragon Ball Z. And that's simply not the case.
I get the impression that Dragon Ball Super: Beerus was originally intended to be a little longer, but that, at the last minute, they had to reduce the episode count, stripping away virtually every moment of breathing room in the process.
Honestly, adding just two more episodes to the new version would have been a much better decision, allowing the narrative room to breathe and better preserving the original series' direction and staging.
I don't consider Dragon Ball Kai to be a particularly well-edited series, but even so, I could comfortably watch an entire episode without constantly being reminded that I was watching a re-edited version of something that had already existed. And the problem lies precisely in how aggressively they've cut things down. Yes, the movie is around 80 minutes long, but the thing is, they're not working with the footage from the movie itself. They're working with footage from the original anime, whose narrative was designed around a very specific pacing. Unless you redid everything from scratch, there would be no way to change the original timing.
Dragon Ball Z had a considerably slower pace than Dragon Ball Super. Even so, Dragon Ball Kai generally followed a ratio of roughly two edited episodes for every original episode, which helped maintain a more natural rhythm while respecting the original series' direction and staging. Dragon Ball Super: Beerus, on the other hand, sometimes condenses the equivalent of three or four episodes into a single one, as if the 2015 Dragon Ball Super had pacing issues comparable to the worst stretches of the Freeza Saga in Dragon Ball Z. And that's simply not the case.
I get the impression that Dragon Ball Super: Beerus was originally intended to be a little longer, but that, at the last minute, they had to reduce the episode count, stripping away virtually every moment of breathing room in the process.
Honestly, adding just two more episodes to the new version would have been a much better decision, allowing the narrative room to breathe and better preserving the original series' direction and staging.
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
Rewatched last night, so full thoughts on the actual episode rather than just the series trajectory as a whole:
This is not better than the fight in Battle of Gods, but once you're on board with that and the limitations of this project, it is far better than Super '15, and a fine choice if you need to go through Super in serialized, animated form or are just a casual fan getting caught back up.
I do miss Goku's lines about resenting how he obtained the power in this version of the story (also missing from '15 and the manga), but accepting that Super reframes the entire Beerus episode as more of a prelude to its later events than a stand-alone story, I don't feel missing them is a fatal blow. You have to make the prelude quick though, in terms of series runtime, which this this doing.
Instead we get a bit more characterization on Beerus' side, which was also present in '15, but benefits from compression. We get his interest, his fatigue at his own strength, and why he's invested in Goku despite the entire fight being (in retrospect) a motivating fib on his part. It also justifies the start-stop nature of the action here--Beerus is constantly in control, constantly the teacher and trying to find his own amusement, with Goku's personality drawing his investment out further. What action we do get, while it feels smaller in scope than the movie's fight zipping through cities, forests, and wastelands, limited by '15 keeping the action in one spot, manages some fun cuts and a bit of scale with the trip up to the stratosphere despite it. Beerus' headbutting Goku all the way up and the barrage of catch-if-you-can blasts near the end sell both scale and Beerus' approach to the battle, again both benefitting from compression vs. the pacing of '15. I can, for what it's worth, visually believe that we're seeing a battle above the Super Saiyan 3 tier.
I think the pacing honestly flows just fine, constructing the episode around several progressive beats for Beerus' character and Goku learning to use the power. I cannot imagine anything here being more successful stretched back out to its original...four?...episode runtime, and I think transitions flowed well enough that a new viewer would not sense anything had been chopped up.
What we've lost is mostly padding--crowd reaction shots--and momentary nonsense and melodrama that goes nowhere like the ki dragons, Goku's healing powers, and the universal shockwaves. The key beats of the battle are kept and actually feel more coherent here for removing the excess, with small bits of new footage to bridge them. We've condensed it all into one episode of focused battle that gives us a little insight into Goku and particularly Beerus as it goes.
If anything, my issue, aside from choices already made by '15, is that we could stand to be even tighter here. Mid-way through I'd forgotten that we still needed to get to the Super Saiyan portion of the battle, and was mentally expecting it to just end with a final blast and push of power from Goku as in the manga, and indeed it felt paced like it could have.
Given all the headaches it causes later, I do wish they'd just cut the Super Saiyan portion of the fight for this version, but I understand that's maybe too nitty-gritty a fan issue to register for the basic goal of this project--just taking the base '15 footage and making a more inviting series out of it. Fair enough. We continue to have a serialized anime version of Super that is not, uh, completely terrible. Asking for more would have been asking for a different project, which might be a fair criticism, especially with the movie to compare it to, but I'm not sure it warrants repeating each week.
FWIW, I think all five episodes so far have been far smoother in their recutting than the bulk of Kai, and not even the much-criticized Episode 3 would raise an eyebrow for me viewed on its own.
"Less is more" is a phrase '15 didn't seem to know, but it's one that's making quite a bit of difference for me in Beerus even with the same base content.
This is not better than the fight in Battle of Gods, but once you're on board with that and the limitations of this project, it is far better than Super '15, and a fine choice if you need to go through Super in serialized, animated form or are just a casual fan getting caught back up.
I do miss Goku's lines about resenting how he obtained the power in this version of the story (also missing from '15 and the manga), but accepting that Super reframes the entire Beerus episode as more of a prelude to its later events than a stand-alone story, I don't feel missing them is a fatal blow. You have to make the prelude quick though, in terms of series runtime, which this this doing.
Instead we get a bit more characterization on Beerus' side, which was also present in '15, but benefits from compression. We get his interest, his fatigue at his own strength, and why he's invested in Goku despite the entire fight being (in retrospect) a motivating fib on his part. It also justifies the start-stop nature of the action here--Beerus is constantly in control, constantly the teacher and trying to find his own amusement, with Goku's personality drawing his investment out further. What action we do get, while it feels smaller in scope than the movie's fight zipping through cities, forests, and wastelands, limited by '15 keeping the action in one spot, manages some fun cuts and a bit of scale with the trip up to the stratosphere despite it. Beerus' headbutting Goku all the way up and the barrage of catch-if-you-can blasts near the end sell both scale and Beerus' approach to the battle, again both benefitting from compression vs. the pacing of '15. I can, for what it's worth, visually believe that we're seeing a battle above the Super Saiyan 3 tier.
I think the pacing honestly flows just fine, constructing the episode around several progressive beats for Beerus' character and Goku learning to use the power. I cannot imagine anything here being more successful stretched back out to its original...four?...episode runtime, and I think transitions flowed well enough that a new viewer would not sense anything had been chopped up.
What we've lost is mostly padding--crowd reaction shots--and momentary nonsense and melodrama that goes nowhere like the ki dragons, Goku's healing powers, and the universal shockwaves. The key beats of the battle are kept and actually feel more coherent here for removing the excess, with small bits of new footage to bridge them. We've condensed it all into one episode of focused battle that gives us a little insight into Goku and particularly Beerus as it goes.
If anything, my issue, aside from choices already made by '15, is that we could stand to be even tighter here. Mid-way through I'd forgotten that we still needed to get to the Super Saiyan portion of the battle, and was mentally expecting it to just end with a final blast and push of power from Goku as in the manga, and indeed it felt paced like it could have.
Given all the headaches it causes later, I do wish they'd just cut the Super Saiyan portion of the fight for this version, but I understand that's maybe too nitty-gritty a fan issue to register for the basic goal of this project--just taking the base '15 footage and making a more inviting series out of it. Fair enough. We continue to have a serialized anime version of Super that is not, uh, completely terrible. Asking for more would have been asking for a different project, which might be a fair criticism, especially with the movie to compare it to, but I'm not sure it warrants repeating each week.
FWIW, I think all five episodes so far have been far smoother in their recutting than the bulk of Kai, and not even the much-criticized Episode 3 would raise an eyebrow for me viewed on its own.
This was a choice I particularly liked. It lets the scale speak for itself and dovetails with the battle not living up to Beerus' expectation. There's still spectacle, but it's a series of character beats rather than two characters giving their all.SHINOBI-03 wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 12:44 pm My biggest sticking point about the series is the lack of music. Why is it done this way? It's like it was edited to be made for YouTube edits but they left the music out so it won't get claimed by UMG or other music owners. It's weird.
"Less is more" is a phrase '15 didn't seem to know, but it's one that's making quite a bit of difference for me in Beerus even with the same base content.
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
I mean, yeah. I am proposing that, speaking in overall terms, Dragon Ball Z: Battle of Gods, Dragon Ball Z: Ressurection F, Dragon Ball Super (2015) and Dragon Ball Super: Beerus (2026) look bad, in large part due to Yamamuro Tadayoshi's animation character designs and his work as animation director on those projects, to say nothing of scheduling effecting those productions, too. All these projects share a major, root issue, being that they're overseen by a guy who, for brevity's sake, sucks at his job. I don't see the controversy in saying "better doesn't mean good," especially for the series that is clearly being produced with a metaphorical gun to somebody's head.Caulifor wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 6:27 pmI agree that Yamamuro's designs are ugly, but that applies just as much to the movie, doesn't it? At least here the line art is better, the characters don't have that excessive shine on them, and some of the corrections feel like he's learned his lesson and is actually tapping into his classic style rather than his stiff modern work.JulieYBM wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 3:48 pmYamamuro Tadayoshi's character designs still look really ugly, even if they're being animated with a little bit more time than there will in the 2010s. Yamamuro himself is not a great animation supervisor, let alone a good director. Visual mediums require more skill than, "Well, it looks on model, at least." Even in the few spots where the animation is being handled by a good key animator, those shots still suffer from Yamamuro corrections, or being animated based on bad character models, or from simply not having a lot of time and drawings allowed to create interesting movement.Caulifor wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 12:38 pm Okay, one thing I'll have to disagree about some of the criticisms here is that the animation or the art isn't good. That is insane to me. I think these episodes look much better than the movie, for the most part at least. The art is overall better and the composition is great. I much prefer the linework here too.
The weird saturation levels have been hit or miss, though, I'll give you that.
I'm definitely not saying it looks amazing or anything, but I definitely prefer this to the movie, in terms of art direction. Sure, it's mostly just okay with occasional flashes of good, but that's how Z was week-to-week anyway.
I'll admit though, the only reason I think this looks better than the movie is 'cause it looks a biiiiiit closer to what Z looked like.
Having sat through the first two episodes of Dragon Ball Super: Beerus and taken a look at the highlights, I'm just really not seeing anything to be excited about.
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
I agree. I think the problem with the original anime fight wasn't necessarily that it lasted five episodes, but that, from episode 11 onward, it kept revolving around essentially the same idea.Cipher wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 9:09 pm If anything, my issue, aside from choices already made by '15, is that we could stand to be even tighter here. Mid-way through I'd forgotten that we still needed to get to the Super Saiyan portion of the battle, and was mentally expecting it to just end with a final blast and push of power from Goku as in the manga, and indeed it felt paced like it could have.
Given all the headaches it causes later, I do wish they'd just cut the Super Saiyan portion of the fight for this version, but I understand that's maybe too nitty-gritty a fan issue to register for the basic goal of this project--just taking the base '15 footage and making a more inviting series out of it. Fair enough. We continue to have a serialized anime version of Super that is not, uh, completely terrible. Asking for more would have been asking for a different project, which might be a fair criticism, especially with the movie to compare it to, but I'm not sure it warrants repeating each week.
Whether it's Gokū falling into the ocean and regaining his motivation to keep fighting in episode 11, managing to match Beerus in their clash of power in episode 12, or absorbing the power of Super Saiyan God into his regular Super Saiyan form in episode 13, all these moments serve the same narrative purpose: portraying Gokū as someone talented and persistent, capable of impressing Beerus and making him see his worth.
In this new edit, they could have chosen one of these three options, but they went with the worst one for this particular context. Not only because the idea of Super Saiyan God being a temporary transformation has become obsolete in retrospect, but also because it loses some of its impact by disregarding the payoff to Gokū's frustration over not having achieved that power on his own.
They simply should have removed the whole Super Saiyan aspect and kept Gokū in his Super Saiyan God form until the end of the battle.
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
Agreed with all that as well, re: it losing its role as a narrative payoff without the lines about having to use others' power.taikufuru wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 9:59 pm I agree. I think the problem with the original anime fight wasn't necessarily that it lasted five episodes, but that, from episode 11 onward, it kept revolving around essentially the same idea.
Whether it's Gokū falling into the ocean and regaining his motivation to keep fighting in episode 11, managing to match Beerus in their clash of power in episode 12, or absorbing the power of Super Saiyan God into his regular Super Saiyan form in episode 13, all these moments serve the same narrative purpose: portraying Gokū as someone talented and persistent, capable of impressing Beerus and making him see his worth.
In this new edit, they could have chosen one of these three options, but they went with the worst one for this particular context. Not only because the idea of Super Saiyan God being a temporary transformation has become obsolete in retrospect, but also because it loses some of its impact by disregarding the payoff to Gokū's frustration over not having achieved that power on his own.
They simply should have removed the whole Super Saiyan aspect and kept Gokū in his Super Saiyan God form until the end of the battle.
And I think Beerus' interest in Goku is already well-justified in Episode 5 as it is, watching Goku remain excited in the face of danger and continue to adapt to SSG's power and push himself further. We see how that draws out more and more investment from Beerus, who's been lacking challenge and stimulation. (Again, this is all the manga gives us, and while it's definitely a digest version of the film, that works well enough on its own, especially in setting up the rest of Super.)
It was probably asking a little too much that the team cut an entire stage of the fight from '15 like that, and what we have is...fine, but they probably could have done it, especially cutting down on content a bit in Episode 4 to start the fight earlier. I was misremembering earlier that '15 ended with Goku going God again to take out the final blast, which would have made a cut easier, but... He doesn't, huh? Still, with just a little new animation...
But I'm not holding my idea for what it could have been against it too much here, accepting the reality of the project. I haven't had a bad time with any of the episodes so far, whereas I was rarely having a good one with '15, so there's that.
Re: Dragon Ball Super: Beerus - Episode 5 - Official Discussion Thread
The Dragon Ball Super (2015) version of Goku vs Beerus reminds me a lot of what would eventually become of the battle with Gomah in Dragon Ball Daima. Basically, there's not enough character beats going on to really push the characters' development forward, so it just feels like stuff is happening. I think this is an issue that largely stems from Yashima, Komaki and Kakihara Yuuko not adding a ton in the way of their own ideas. I imagine this is due to either Toriyama or Iyoku's influence, but it seriously hampered the emotional resonance of the episodes.
Contrast this to the later Dragon Ball Super (2015) arcs' scripts, where it seemed like the series directors and writers were at least adding in their own ideas, building up their own internal logic for how these things were meant to fit together. For all its flaws, the Tournament of Power arc at least feels like someone put their foot down and said, "This is the end game for characters x, y and z and this is how we are going to build to it." That's the sort of approach that needs to be taken, and I feel like that was basically missing from the original Dragon Ball Super's take on this fight.
God, I would love to know what the hell Chioka Masatoshi was going through during that arc in his own words.
Contrast this to the later Dragon Ball Super (2015) arcs' scripts, where it seemed like the series directors and writers were at least adding in their own ideas, building up their own internal logic for how these things were meant to fit together. For all its flaws, the Tournament of Power arc at least feels like someone put their foot down and said, "This is the end game for characters x, y and z and this is how we are going to build to it." That's the sort of approach that needs to be taken, and I feel like that was basically missing from the original Dragon Ball Super's take on this fight.
God, I would love to know what the hell Chioka Masatoshi was going through during that arc in his own words.



