WittyUsername wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 11:34 pm
Yeah, she mentions when the characters return to Earth in episode 28 that they’d need to use the Black Star Dragon Balls to restore Goku to his adult self and everyone agrees that they’d rather not do that, because it would mean having to collect them all over again.
The logic clearly seems to be that because the Black Star Dragon Balls are stronger , the weaker Dragon Balls can’t be used to undo their effects. Now that I think about it, though, that logic gets a wrench thrown in it when the Namekian Dragon Balls are later used to restore Earth in episode 40.
See, the problem is what I said, though. Where did Pan learn that information? If it's given for the first time in episode 28, then King Kai never gave it, nor did Piccolo, nor possibly Old Kai, the only 3 characters in the show that feasibly
could. Considering King Kai gave the exposition about the Black Star Dragon Balls in the first episode, Piccolo's the one who MADE them before he separated into 2 people, & Old Kai clearly knows SOMETHING about the multiple sets of Dragon Balls in-universe & reads them the riot act when the regular Earth ones crack & expel evil energy after the first arc, why did they write Pan giving that exposition instead of 1 of
them? That's bad writing. Hell, giving that early on when King Kai's explaining that the Earth's gonna blow up if they don't get them back there in a year would also add more stakes to the journey Goku, Pan, & Trunks go on to get them & a more personal one for Goku.
As for the Namekian Dragon Balls bringing back Earth after it blows up, I view that as the writers taking every bit of remaining tension, stakes, & emotional weight that the Earth blowing up had & throwing them into a fire by reminding us that those Dragon Balls existed. It's very similar to when Super had Piccolo die defending Gohan from Freeza's blast for cheap fanservice only for Goku to be like, "Ok, I'mma go to Namek now to bring him back to life, be right back!" at the end of that arc. Something that SHOULD have more impact than it ends up having gets undercut with the writers not being careful about what they put into their work. Hell, Toriyama at least had the threat of Buu underpin Dende & Supreme Kibito Kai using the Namekian Dragon Balls with how dire the situation is, plus how the Earth Dragon Balls still needed months of recharge time, so there were still stakes & tension with the fight & Dende doesn't think to have Porunga recharge Goku's ki until the literal last second when they were all desperate & he'd been racking his brain trying to think of what else they could do to help Goku & Vegeta.
But, to your point, there's nothing in the series stating that the Earth blowing up can't be undone with another set of Dragon Balls, so of course that can be undone. Unless I'm misremembering, they never established that the Earth blowing up was specifically because of the Black Star Dragon Balls' magic. It's just a side effect of using them on a planet. My assumption is that it's a monkey's paw type thing where, because you made a wish on them & they don't turn to stone afterwards, the side effect is that the planet you made the wish on will explode in a year afterwards. I'm really splitting hairs & it's stupid, but that's about it from my perspective. GT is full of contradictions, shitty logic, & bad writing, so chalk this up to that.