Puto wrote:TonyTheTiger wrote:Good point. But the question is what we would get of the original print that we didn't get from the lossy but still awesome DVD encode. At some point, based on how the cels were captured, there will be diminishing returns. It might look better but it might not be "buy the show again" better.
Of course, I am basing this on the assumption Pony Canyon didn't opt for an HD resolution during the remastering process, which I am now starting to question given that despite hearing that a few times I can't quite place where that info originally came from.
I think the Dragon Boxes were made before HD became common, so I don't see Toei "we do everything as cheaply as we can" randomly choosing to do the remastering in HD way back in 2001 or whenever the DBoxes were made.
Original Dragon Box came out in 2003, so work likely started in 2002, or possible in 2001 (which is roughly a year or so after Toei first started doing 'normal' TV anime on DVD and was sure it could sell.)
Plenty of classic films that came out on DVD around that time period had extended delays for their BD releases later on because the film had to be rescanned, because remastering was done at 1080i (good enough for HDTV and DVD.) These were films that had large remastering budgets and the studios.
Let us go so far as to say there is no evidence it was only done at 1080p.
The truth is, it wouldn't have been done at 1080p back then, especially with the only plans being a DVD release.
Remastering at higher resolutions 'for the future' and 'for archiving' is relatively recent. It wasn't done at the time, hard drive space wasn't nearly as cheap as it was now, and they were at a premium for space.
There are shows drawn digitally as vectors from the last few years, that were output at 480i/p, that will never be 1080p, because they didn't have the spare space to stick higher resolution master copies.
Is it technically possible they did? Sure. But then I'm sure that if you consider certain theories of the universe and reality that there is an infinitesimally small chance that if I tap my cell phone and say beam me up Scotty, I'll vanish and appear on the bridge of the Enterprise.
'taps cell phone and says it anyways' Oh... still here.
....We can dream though...
edit- And oh yeah I forgot one thing... any remaster of that era wouldn't be up to the standards of modern releases. So it'd be tossed anyways. Remastering back then wasn't done how it is nowadays... so even if it was done back then at 1080p, it'd be trashed now due to issues with the quality of the remastering. But maybe if I put a pin on and tap it Geordi could beam me up to the Enterprise-D...