Dyno wrote:Mystic Tenshinhan wrote:Raditz passed them coordinaties and all information before he died. That's why they knew where Earth was located. Raditz had a scouter. Vegeta and Nappa had a scouter. Bardock had a scouter. But Gine didn't have a scouter, how she may possibly learn where Earth is now with Bardock being dead and without a scouter?
Tarble had a scouter. As well as a ship. Gine doesn't have.
That's, plus again, she most likely thinks that Goku destroyed the Earth, and that he isn't there anymore, so there is no need to fly there anyway.
No, it is explicitly said Vegeta and Nappa only knew/heard what happened in Earth, we don't see Raditz telling them the coordinaties, actually we don't see any contact among them before he died.
Bardock's scouter is nowhere to be seen in Dragon Ball Minus and Chapter 307. And how do you know Gine does not have one? And even if that is the case, why Gine couldn't steal one?
You are claiming things with no foundation, sorry. The same way I can find reasons for this situation, you can find problems, so it's pointless to keep colliding these ideas without any further information.
They did. But Raditz should have given them coordinates, if not when he approached the Earth, fought Goku or before him dying, then before he went to Earth. He didn't go there just to reunite with his brother, he went there to recruit him, and the whole thing was broadcasted to Vegeta and Nappa, so they should have had a pretty good idea where he went. Not only that, but they had a ship, given to them by Frieza's men. It is pretty possible, that you don't need to put needed coordinates, rather than only choose the planet, and as they knew from Raditz that Goku was on Earth, they could pretty easily get there.
All shown saiyans had a scouter. Raditz (low-class warrior) had it, Nappa had it, Vegeta had it, even the kid (!) Raditz in DBM had it, and the guy which was with Bardock in DBM had it, and took it off right before landing on Planet Vegeta, because Bardock told him to do so, to prevent Frieza from hearing their conversation. Bardock most likely did the same, but earlier.
By the way Gine asked Bardock why they couldn't go with Goku, and he answered that they would find them with
scouters. So it is possible to use scouters for searching people who don't even have scouters, either by finding their pods or power levels. They most likely contained coordinates as well then. Don't know about the distance though.
Gine didn't have one, because she was specifically said to not be a combatant, when Bardock arrived, she didn't wear it without anyone telling her not to do it, and most importantly, even if she had one, her planet was destroyed by Frieza, so she had no way to retrieve one from somewhere, and if she did, Frieza would have pretty easily learned/heard where she was, so it makes no sense for her deliberately taking scouter from somewhere even if she could.
I just make the logical conclusions. Of course there are no definite statements from manga. And I don't even believe that she is alive. All I say is that even if she was alive, it wouldn't have been any problem that she didn't visit the Earth.
Pretty much the only possibility for Gine to go to Earth is if she fled in one of saiyan's pods. But if she did it, then as DBM suggest, Frieza would have most likely learned about it one way or another, so it is very not likely. So even if she survived (which is already highly unlikely), it is even more unlikely for her to flee in saiyan's pod. And it is the only way for her (without scouter) to learn where Goku is and get there. Her knowing that Goku is on some mysterious planet called Earth won't help her to get there without proper coordinates. And I highly doubt that even if she got to hear/see those coordinates at all, that she memorized them.
This, and just as I earlier said, Goku was supposed to destroy this planet anyway, so Gine didn't have a single way to learn where Goku really was without a scouter.
I actually read this when it first came around with BoG, but I got lost on this thread and didn't realise what people were talking about. Thanks again 
