Saiga wrote:Actually there is plenty of evidence that Goten and Trunks are stronger than Goku was on Namek.
[*]They have the features of "full power" Super Saiyans. Not just physically, but they can also control their power.
[*]Goten spars evenly with Gohan, who is FAR stronger than Namek arc Goku. Gohan can be seen sweating from the effort.
[*]Trunks can land a punch on Vegeta and take a punch in return.
[*]Their power freaks 18 out even when suppressed, and she chooses not to fight them directly. Trunks holds back his blast so he doesn't kill her, and it is made clear that Goten and Trunks know how strong she is.
[*]When Vegeta dies and Gohan is presumed dead, Piccolo calls them "Earth's last hope" without knowing about fusion.
[*]Their full power shocks Piccolo.
[*]The guidebooks have various comments that put them at least on par with 18, ranging all the way up to Gohan's level.
Yes, Goku had gone through a lot when he first became a Super Saiyan... but he also went through a lot when he won the 23rd Budokai, and yet Gohan was able to surpass that level a four years old, with a year of training. The half-breed children are really strong, and were never that far behind the others.
Some of your points are acceptable, but #18 fights the two of them at the same time (as in, 1 against 2) and manages to hold her own, while back in the Jinzouningen arc she was just slightly above Super Saiya-jin Vegeta, who in turn was only slightly above Super Saiya-jin Goku on Namek.
Piccolo (and Vegeta, and Gohan, for that matter) are astonished not exactly at their power, but at the fact that they're able to turn Super Saiya-jin at such a young age.
When they're in the gravity room early in the Majin Buu arc training for the upcoming Tenkaichi Budokai, If Vegeta had been training/fighting to his fullest, Trunks wouldn't even come close to him and would defeated Trunks in a matter of seconds.
Being able to control their power and keep their fighting instincts under control is one feature of the Super Saiya-jin Full Power stage, sure, but, apart from that, on what basis do you say they're on that stage, or, even better, are you suggesting they're as strong or nearly as strong as Goku and Gohan as Super Saiya-jin Full Power against Cell?
Gohan is training with a kid who can become Super Saiya-jin. He's not in his Super Saiya-jin 2 form, most likely in his SSJ Full Power state. Someone as strong as a Super Saiya-jin, even as a kid, could present him with problems, taking into account his lack of training and resulting decrease in terms of reflexes, agility, power and velocity. Hence the trouble he had and the sweat you mentioned.
In fact, Tenshinhan, Krillin, Yamcha and even Chaozu show up stronger against the Saiya-jin than Goku was when he fought and beat Piccolo in the Piccolo Jr. arc. Of course half-breed Saiya-jin have a natural talent or ability to be massively powerful. Even in the first episodes of DBZ. on the planet he just conquered along with Nappa, Vegeta speculates that the offspring of a Saiya-jin with a non-Saiya-jin could produce a better result than a pure Saiya-jin. That shouldn't mean Goten and Trunks possess that ability to the same degree Gohan does, and/or that it's an inevitable and automatic thing. Natural abilities vs training: which one provides the fighter with the most power? If we went by that, Goku would be a joke from the beginning. He was born with a fighting power of 2, and by Saiya-jin standards even his power level when he fought Piccolo Daimao or Piccolo was laughable, and yet he went on to surpass not even Nappa and Vegeta, and actually overcame even that through intense and massive training to become stronger than the Ginyu Tokusentai, and then went on to overcome Freeza, and then #17 and #18, then Cell, then Gohan in his Super Saiya-jin 2 stage, then Majin Buu at least in his fat form, and more recently ANY version of Super Buu, Gotenks or Vegitto. I'm not defending Goku because I'm a huge fan of his. I actually prefer Vegeta and Piccolo, for that matter. However, if there's an instance in which I admire Goku (and there's more than one, obviously), that's when he took revenge on Freeza by being the first one to become a full-fledged Super Saiya-jin to once again save the day. The kids haven't really accomplished anything, either on their own or indeed fused, and if we took into account GT, they're pretty much like Gohan, skipping training all the time and neglecting to develop and build up on their massive power.
Goku and Vegeta, as pure Saiya-jin, are the only ones willing to overcome their limits and reach new stages of power, and they do it successfully, despite a few instances here and there when Gohan went beyond Vegeta. That was already/will soon be fixed, though.
Can you really imagine a fight between a full-powered angry fighting-machine Super Saiya-jin Goku on Namek against each of those two brats? Sorry, but I'll keep my position and I'll still hold SSJ Goku on Namek stronger than each of them (not to mention his improvements later on, against Mirai no Trunks, #19 and all the subsequent SSJ stages, obviously).