Post
by Gyt Kaliba » Tue Aug 11, 2015 10:07 am
I've said it before and I'll say it again - if anyone is at fault for the way Yamcha is perceived now, it's more so certain fans taking TFS's jokes to heart, not TFS themselves.
The way I see it, TFS isn't so much making fun of Yamcha, so to speak, so much as they're making fun of Yamcha's 'treatment' in the series. I mean, let's face it - the character gets a bum treatment in the source material. Even the most ardent Yamcha fan would probably agree that Toriyama pretty quickly decided just to use the guy as a measuring stick for Goku's opponents. He's used in the first two tournaments as early proof of how powerful Goku's final opponent is going to be. He's demoted from that position to being used as a measuring stick for Kami in disguise as a measuring stick against Piccolo. He loses to Baba's fighter that Goku one-shots effortlessly. And as a final degradation, he pretty much has his love life ripped away from him by the author, for no reason other than to introduce another half-Saiyan to the mix (he could have just as easily used Gohan coming from the future. In retrospect, given where the arc as a whole ends up, that wouldn't have worked as well, but it doesn't make it any less pointless at the start really).
So yeah, even in the source material, Yamcha gets crapped on constantly sadly. But somehow, people that just go 'LOLZ YAMCHA' seem to forget that in-between all that, there are hidden gems of good material with the character, that really doesn't need to be forgotten as much as it does. In his fight with Jackie Chun at the first tournament, Roshi in disguise may defeat him with relative ease, but he compliments him for his skill none-the-less. Tenshinhan may not respect Yamcha by any means at first, but Yamcha's skills are enough to take Tenshinhan back a bit compared to his early thoughts on him, as well as making him assume that Yamcha must be the strongest of the Turtle school students. Oh yeah, and let's not forget, that Yamcha was good enough to be taken on as a third student by Roshi, a guy who barely wanted to take on the two students he already had. Yamcha is again complimented for his skills by Kami himself, and later taken in to be trained by him along with the others. And then he goes on to train under Kaio too. Say what you will about his lack of standout moments with these skills, all of this sounds like elements far from being a loser to me.
Yamcha's place is made all the worse by the fact that he's sidelined even earlier in the story than the other non-Saiyan characters, so people tend to overlook the fact that he was relevant in the past even when they cry out for the same return to relevancy for people like Piccolo or Tenshinhan. Yamcha is also a victim of being the most visible character with his 'lack of achievements'. Chaozu does far, far, far less than Yamcha, and yet nobody ever really seems to bash him much...by virtue of the fact that he's barely even a character to begin with.
I'm not even really that big a fan of Yamcha - he's just a character that's there, that I would like to see more of, yeah, but I'm not clamoring for more moments for him like I do for my favorite, Kuririn. But at the same time, the mindless hate for him gets old, and fast - but again, I don't think anything about it is really TFS's fault in the end.
AniManga Travelogue - Currently Reviewing: Dragon Ball (Z)
Twitter
Switch Friend Code: SW-0745-6427-7791 (let's play some Dragon Ball: The Breakers!)