Doctor. wrote:Actually, we do needed those slice of life episodes. #1 is necessary because, well, it's the pilot episode. We need to know what everyone is doing, and it already establishes the main villain of the arc. #2 is necessary because instead of saying "Vegeta's a decent dad", it shows us that Vegeta is a decent dad. Beerus lying around for half an episode wondering about Super Saiyan God happened in Battle of Gods as well.
Not necessary for two separate episodes, though, especially since the Goten & Trunks gift quest is completely superfluous as seeing them interact with their dads shows us what kind of dads they are and where the characters are at this point. As for Beerus, it works in the movie because this is our introduction to him and it's the movie giving you an idea for who this guy is, Supers version would work if we learned anything knew about his backstory or personality, but it doesn't do either. It also doesn't help that the Super version lacks any atmosphere to it that BoG had.
Episode 7 was a really well-done episode. It built-up tension and drama in a way that Battle of Gods didn't bother to do so. You keep complaining about Super being too slow, but Battle of Gods was too damn fast.
BoG gives you a perfectly fine and quick way of showing how outclassed everyone is just fine without needing 20 minutes of everyone gawking at Beerus to do it. He takes out Goku with no effort than in the movie proceeds to one shot the next people on the pecking order such as Buu, Gohan and Gotenks (though Toyotaro's the only guy who makes the last one actually work the best) effortlessly. This works in showing you why the situation is severe both before and during the party without resorting to stupid ER MAH GURD! faces from everyone involved.
Then they made the most hilariously overdramatic thing happen by stretching out the slap to an absurd degree. I was laughing my ass off throughout all of it and the "tension" went out the window. Not helped since Episode 8 boils the whole thing down to a 15 minute game of rock, paper, scissors. The only meaningful thing they added was Dende sensing that Beerus' is a God, but they had to drag that out too and botch it by not having Piccolo sense it too.
Episode 9 created a transformation sequence that feels like Dragon Ball. It's like comparing the Super Saiyan transformation in the manga to the one in the anime. Can you really say "OH THE ANIME VERSION WAS TOO LONG, THEREFORE IT SUCKS"?
Nothing tells us the Super Saiyan God backstory won't be expanded upon in the future.
You're right that the SSJ transformation in the manga completely pales in comparison to the anime one and I like the sequence in Super but once again, it got dragged out to much. I didn't need several separate group shots of everyone gawking at Goku, I didn't need multiple types of energy pouring into Goku and it didn't need constant close-ups of the characters wonky faces. Its a 2 and a half minute sequence dragged out to almost twice its length.
That's fine and dandy, but why isn't it here? They're tripling the goddamn run time of BoG and in the moment where Goku's asking Shenron about the Super Saiyan God, they cut everything out about it? Why? That's literally one of the few things that actually warranted expansion and they decide to cut it out? Why's Toyotaro getting free reign to smash different arcs together but the animation team can't or won't?
I don't really see how episode 10 and 11 are padded out, they had very good pacing. And again, being longer doesn't inherently mean it's worse.
If the added length was used to actually showcase more of Goku's issues with the way he's attained the form and Beerus' borderline boredom induced insanity, I'd agree. The thing is, Goku's arc is completely cut, likely so RoFs "Whis wisdom" doesn't come off as a blatant retcon like the movies was while Beerus' is only hinted at.
The rest is them doing stupid gags on each other with Goku commenting over and over and over how amazing Beerus is and how incredible it is to be a God. The fight in BoG might've been faced, but it felt impactful like every punch mattered and every line of dialogue served an actual purpose. Nothing in Super's fight feels like this. They could've at least made it visually awesome to behold but again, it's really not. The animation constantly feels slow and janky, they simply can't keep themselves from breaking it up every time it's starting to pick up the pace with more reaction shots or Pilaf gang "jokes" or Goku telling Beerus once again how amazing he is!
The only things about Supers expansion that I like are seeing more of dick Beerus, his hinted at motivation that basically doesn't exist in the movie and everything with Vegeta that's not his derp face reactions to the slap. Everything else is either too long or unnecessary. Between BoG, Super and the Toyotaro manga, there's a perfect version of this story in there somewhere that the movie comes the closest too but none of them are perfect imo.