The All-Purpose "Versus" Thread

[Kakashi]

Majin Vegeta Vs. Fat Buu after he expelling the Grey Buu.

Good Boo is stronger but not by much so Vegeta can win if he uses an amplified Final Flash

[RandomGuy96]

Majin Vegeta Vs. Fat Buu after he expelling the Grey Buu.

You mean Good Buu? He smashes Vegeta with no less ease than Fat Buu did. I believe the Good Buu here is weaker than the Mr. Buu that fought Pure Buu, but not by all that much.

[Kid Buu]

Majin Vegeta Vs. Fat Buu after he expelling the Grey Buu.

You mean Good Buu? He smashes Vegeta with no less ease than Fat Buu did. I believe the Good Buu here is weaker than the Mr. Buu that fought Pure Buu, but not by all that much.

So basically

[RandomGuy96]

Nah, more like:

[Kakashi]

Majin Vegeta Vs. Fat Buu after he expelling the Grey Buu.

You mean Good Buu? He smashes Vegeta with no less ease than Fat Buu did. I believe the Good Buu here is weaker than the Mr. Buu that fought Pure Buu, but not by all that much.

Why? That was never implied

[RandomGuy96]

Pure Buu and Pure Evil Buu aren't the same being. Logically, Mr. Buu and Good Buu shouldn't be the same either.

[TheGmGoken]

No he is not and why any comment of you makes me think you can't think logically? I meant "most" Pure Evil Boo is weaker than Fat Boo who is weaker than Pure Boo. Pure Boo was toying with Good Boo

So because we don't share the same opinion I can't think logically? That seems fair .

Majin Vegeta Vs. Fat Buu after he expelling the Grey Buu.

Good Boo fins this. I don't think he got that much weaker. So the battle would be the same. Except Vegeta will cry cause that's one more good guy that's stronger than him. Which makes the gap between Goku and himself bigger

[Kakashi]

Pure Buu and Pure Evil Buu aren't the same being. Logically, Mr. Buu and Good Buu shouldn't be the same either.

Good Boo is Good Boo. I don't know what you are talking about

[Kakashi]

No he is not and why any comment of you makes me think you can't think logically? I meant "most" Pure Evil Boo is weaker than Fat Boo who is weaker than Pure Boo. Pure Boo was toying with Good Boo

So because we don't share the same opinion I can't think logically? That seems fair .

Majin Vegeta Vs. Fat Buu after he expelling the Grey Buu.

Good Boo fins this. I don't think he got that much weaker. So the battle would be the same. Except Vegeta will cry cause that's one more good guy that's stronger than him. Which makes the gap between Goku and himself bigger

Your understanding skills seem to be low when it comes to me

[DBZGTKOSDH]

I also believe that Mr. Boo (the one Pure Boo expelled) is stronger than Good Boo (the one that expelled Pure Evil Boo). Pure Evil Boo had Kaioshin influence in him, but after he absorbed Good Boo (and turned into Evil Boo), the Kaioshin influence from Pure Evil Boo was transfered to Good Boo, making him stronger, which is why Evil Boo reverted to S. Kaioshin Boo & then immediately into Pure Boo.

[TheGmGoken]

Your understanding skills seem to be low when it comes to me

So...since we don't share the same opinion I lack understanding skills?

[DBZAOTA482]

I also believe that Mr. Boo (the one Pure Boo expelled) is stronger than Good Boo (the one that expelled Pure Evil Boo). Pure Evil Boo had Kaioshin influence in him, but after he absorbed Good Boo (and turned into Evil Boo), the Kaioshin influence from Pure Evil Boo was transfered to Good Boo, making him stronger, which is why Evil Boo reverted to S. Kaioshin Boo & then immediately into Pure Boo.

None of what you said makes any sense.

[DBZGTKOSDH]

I also believe that Mr. Boo (the one Pure Boo expelled) is stronger than Good Boo (the one that expelled Pure Evil Boo). Pure Evil Boo had Kaioshin influence in him, but after he absorbed Good Boo (and turned into Evil Boo), the Kaioshin influence from Pure Evil Boo was transfered to Good Boo, making him stronger, which is why Evil Boo reverted to S. Kaioshin Boo & then immediately into Pure Boo.

None of what you said makes any sense.

Then you didn't understand what I said.

[rereboy]

I also believe that Mr. Boo (the one Pure Boo expelled) is stronger than Good Boo (the one that expelled Pure Evil Boo). Pure Evil Boo had Kaioshin influence in him, but after he absorbed Good Boo (and turned into Evil Boo), the Kaioshin influence from Pure Evil Boo was transfered to Good Boo, making him stronger, which is why Evil Boo reverted to S. Kaioshin Boo & then immediately into Pure Boo.

I understood what you meant. But like it has been said, doesn't make any sense. Good Buu never changed and there's not any reason to believe he changed.

[RandomGuy96]

It makes perfect sense. Also, there is a very simple and obvious reason to think he changed: Evil Buu changed. It actually wouldn't make any sense if Good Buu DIDN'T change. Clearly something had to be different for his removal to result in Pure Buu instead of Pure Evil Buu again. It's the simple question that has plagued fans for years:

Evil + Good = Super

Super - Good =/= Evil

[KentalSSJ6]

Just wanna get a quick confirmation on this.

Super Buu > SSJ3 Goku right?

[rereboy]

It makes perfect sense. Also, there is a very simple and obvious reason to think he changed: Evil Buu changed. It actually wouldn't make any sense if Good Buu DIDN'T change. Clearly something had to be different for his removal to result in Pure Buu instead of Pure Evil Buu again. It's the simple question that has plagued fans for years:

Evil + Good = Super

Super - Good =/= Evil

I explain that by saying that Good Buu and Gray Buu are like Kami and Piccolo Daimao and that they even probably shared a spiritual connection, basically being the same person. However, when Gray absorbed Good, that connection broke, because they became one again, just with the evil side on top. But, when Good Buu is forcibly removed from Super Buu again, the remaining Buu can't revert back to Gray Buu, because Gray Buu exists as a counter part of Good Buu and to revert back, their spiritual connection would have to be reforged... So, Buu undergoes a sort of "reset" mode where he reverts gradually back to his most basic origin and form.

So, the only thing that "changed" in regards to Good Buu was the fact that he no longer has any connection with any other Buu. Nothing else changed. He got absorbed. He got freed. Always the same Buu.

To me this makes a lot more sense than Good Buu somehow changing.

[TheGmGoken]

Just wanna get a quick confirmation on this.

Super Buu > SSJ3 Goku right?

Does that even need to be confirmed? Super Boo of course. Unless sonmeone is going by the anime.

[RandomGuy96]

It makes perfect sense. Also, there is a very simple and obvious reason to think he changed: Evil Buu changed. It actually wouldn't make any sense if Good Buu DIDN'T change. Clearly something had to be different for his removal to result in Pure Buu instead of Pure Evil Buu again. It's the simple question that has plagued fans for years:

Evil + Good = Super

Super - Good =/= Evil

I explain that by saying that Good Buu and Gray Buu are like Kami and Piccolo Daimao and that they even probably shared a spiritual connection, basically being the same person. However, when Gray absorbed Good, that connection broke, because they became one again, just with the evil side on top. But, when Good Buu is forcibly removed from Super Buu again, the remaining Buu can't revert back to Gray Buu, because Gray Buu exists as a counter part of Good Buu and to revert back, their spiritual connection would have to be reforged... So, Buu undergoes a sort of "reset" mode where he reverts gradually back to his most basic origin and form.

So, the only thing that "changed" in regards to Good Buu was the fact that he no longer has any connection with any other Buu. Nothing else changed. He got absorbed. He got freed. Always the same Buu.

To me this makes a lot more sense than Good Buu somehow changing.

That's simply what you think. I think that makes significantly less sense than these just being different Buus, considering their respective feats and the origin of Mr. Buu. It just seems so much simpler; one Buu is significantly different, so something must have changed with the other Buu as well for this to be the case. Your theory relies on a whole lot of stuff that was never stated or even lightly implied, and therefore doesn't objectively make more or less sense than any other. Going purely by what we saw, Gray Buu absorbs Good Buu and turns into Super Buu, then Super Buu loses Mr. Buu and turns into Pure Buu.

Just wanna get a quick confirmation on this.

Super Buu > SSJ3 Goku right?

Yes, that is stated over a dozen times.

[rereboy]

That's simply what you think. I think that makes significantly less sense than these just being different Buus, considering their respective feats and the origin of Mr. Buu. Your theory relies on a whole lot of stuff that was never stated or even lightly implied, and therefore doesn't objectively make more or less sense than any other.

Of course its what I think, no need to say that like I'm telling you I'm Toriyama or whatever.

However, my opinion is based on examples that we see on the series and the similarities between the situation with Kami and Piccolo Daimao (Kami expelling his evil side) and Good Buu and Gray Buu (Buu expelling his evil side).

There being two Good Buus just kind of falls out of the sky and a fan would never think about that unless to somehow explain there being a Kid Buu. What I stated also explains there being a Kid Buu, but it follows naturally from the similarities between the two examples I mentioned and answers questions regarding them that would exist even if Good Buu had never been freed.