MasenkoHA wrote: Tue Jun 22, 2021 11:59 am
It aired while the Z series was at its most exciting, climactic portion
It aired concurrent to the Buu saga.Not exactly sure if that’s the most exciting climatic portion.
I thought it began airing during the Cell saga.
Still, if it did begin airing in the Boo saga, that's still basically airing the first three seasons of a show for the first time at the same time as you're airing the final two seasons. Any idiot with half a braincell should have been able to see this was a bad idea, and yet...
MasenkoHA wrote: Tue Jun 22, 2021 11:59 am
If anything the real damage is having already aired the first 2/3rds of Z before Dragon Ball. That basically murdered two potential audiences
1. Those who didn’t like Z but might have liked the original Dragon Ball. If someone thought Z was stupid why even bother watching Dragon Ball?
2. Those who would have preferred Z regardless but might have enjoyed Dragon Ball on its own terms. No Super Saiyans. No Vegeta. No Trunks. No Gohan. Probably a deal breaker for a number of Toonami Ball Z fans, an issue that would have been avoided if Funimation ran on all of Dragon Ball first. Can’t be upset Vegeta isn’t in this one if you’re not aware he exist.
I'd agree, however I'd also argue they could have somewhat mitigated this by airing DB after GT. GT didn't go down great with American audiences but Americans never lost their appetite for more Dragon Ball, so introducing them to the original series as the new primary iteration of Dragon Ball after GT would have been smart.
Toonami UK and YTV had this as a result of picking up the Westwood dubs, and it worked to great effect; DB's ratings were quite strong, from what I recall.
MasenkoHA wrote: Tue Jun 22, 2021 11:59 am
the dubbing style was flat and boring (the dull performances, poorly-paced dialogue, and the lack of overly-active music to compensate for this hurt it a lot),
Of it’s many things I wouldn’t call the dubbing style flat and boring. Hokey and obnoxious and well bad but not boring. The dialog and acting really isn’t any different than Z.
And keeping the original music did not hurt Dragon Ball’s dub. That’s as silly as implying Z would have failed without Faulconer or Wasserman. It’s telling that the hate for Kikuchi’s score from American fans is only
applied to Z. Most of them will at least say something dumb to the effect of “The music fit Dragon Ball but
not Z! Z was serious sci fi!!!!!”
You misunderstand.
The pace of the dialogue was really bad in the DB dub, loads of dead air in the middle of conversations, and the main star, Stephanie Nadolny, had very, very flat, dull delivery.
The original music was good, but the problem is, it's not completely blowing out the sound like the American score for Z and GT tended to. Those scores are not good, but they achieve the goal of compensating for the dull performances of many of the cast. DB doesn't have this, the music leaves loads of room for the actors to perform, and they do nothing with that room (granted, a lot of this is probably down to bad direction, since it's everyone in the cast). DB has it worse because Nadolny was especially bad.
Basically, what I'm saying is that while it is a positive change that they switched to the original score, the original score exposes how poor the performances of Funimation's cast tended to be to a greater extent than if you watch with the overactive US score (as can be found to be the case on the "Remastered" Z dub).
Meanwhile, when you hear the Funi cast's work on Kai, or the Ocean cast's work on the Pioneer dub, the actors' performances are given room to breathe by the less intrusive original score, and they come off way better than they did with replacement scores.
So, IMO there's a sort of paradoxical situation that the original score is better and improves the show, but it also makes the OG Funi dub's flaws even more stark and intolerable, especially in DB which for some reason has several really weird moments of dead air during conversations, as if the scriptwriters couldn't quite fill out the conversation, so they just have an awkward pause now and then in many episodes.
Silence is often a good thing, but in the middle of a conversation, in a scene that was so full of dialogue before and after, it's odd.
Just my two cents on the OG Funi dub of DB.
MasenkoHA wrote: Tue Jun 22, 2021 11:59 am
and in general it always played second-fiddle to DBZ, basically it was played as a "DBZ Babies" spinoff that aired alongside the later run of Z, rather than being a full-on entry in the franchise, which is how Z, GT, Kai, and Super were treated.
That is fair. Pretty much only the King Piccolo saga got to run without another Dragon Ball series already airing.
Yeah. IMO, this is the main reason DB failed in the USA when it finally aired in full. It was playing second fiddle.
The point of Dragon Ball is to enjoy it. Never lose sight of that.