MrGohanks wrote: Tue Aug 09, 2022 4:05 pm
No offense, but you sound like a really butthurt Vegeta hater.
Not going to lie. Yes, yes I am. He's a character who served his purpose after Namek and who after being revived, did nothing but hog the spotlight from characters who I found far more interesting like Krillin, Yamcha, Tien and Piccolo, each of whom had redeeming qualities before joining the Z-Fighters and who didn't commit genocide on a planetary scale multiple times. (Not to mention him killing innocent civilians in the tournament because "I wAnNa FiGhT mUh KaKaRrOt!") Him still hanging around after Namek is like Darth Vader chilling with the rebels at the end of Return of the Jedi. I may be neutral to lukewarm on him as he is now, but after seeing how much better Zuko's redemption was handled in Avatar: The Last Airbender, I don't like how his redemption was handled at all and therefore, don't like him in the Cell or Buu Sagas.
MrGohanks wrote: Tue Aug 09, 2022 4:05 pm
First of all, Yamcha's character wasn't assassinated, he was always a memetic loser and a joke character even when he was a villain.
I'm not talking about his status as a memetic loser, I'm talking about the fact that Toriyama made Yamcha a cheater to justify Bulma sleeping with Vegeta. Yamcha is characterised early on as a romantic in nature who wants to get married, so the idea that he would cheat on the only steady girlfriend he ever had is nothing but as dbz_raza put it, unbelievable exposition that contradicts his character. It's something bad fanfiction writers do to get their favourite couples together, not something you'd expect from a professional writer
MrGohanks wrote: Tue Aug 09, 2022 4:05 pm
2nd, Bulma has a history with liking evil men and when she was with Yamcha she would constantly hit on other men even in front of him.
Except all the other times that Bulma hit on men, it was played for laughs. We don't even get any foreshadowing that Bulma had a thing for Vegeta, even on Namek. There is no organic reason that they got together except that Toriyama needed an available womb to produce Trunks. Even the voice actors of the three characters involved thought it made no sense. Here's an interview of the interview in the Daizenshuu:
Tsuru (Bulma): One day, all of a sudden, she married Vegeta and gave birth to Trunks… “Huh? What just happened here?” is how it felt.
Horikawa (Vegeta): There wasn’t even any sort of foreshadowing.
Furuya (Yamcha): At that time, I just wanted to leave the studio and go home.
Tsuru (Bulma): However, after that, I tried to bring myself to love Vegeta, but… it was a struggle.
Retrieved from
https://www.kanzenshuu.com/translations ... ice-talks/
MrGohanks wrote: Tue Aug 09, 2022 4:05 pm
3rd, there was no actual shift in Vegeta's character after Namek. The reason why he acted pragmatic in Namek was because he was dealing with an army of fighters that he knows from the start that are stronger than him, which wasn't the case in every other arc including the Saiyan saga.
This may be true, but I like it when characters are forced to act outside their comfort zones and I find Vegeta acting like a tactical strategist who tries to survive, even resorting to teaming up with Gohan and Kuririn against the Ginyu Force and Frieza while also acting like a wild card far more interesting than the bland anti-hero who screws everything up and gets away with it without so much as a slap on the wrist. The fact that he can't sense when villains are stronger than him in the Cell and Buu Saga and the story doesn't let him use any sort of tactics is disappointing to me.
MrGohanks wrote: Tue Aug 09, 2022 4:05 pm
Also, when other characters make stupid decisions in the show they get far less hate for it than Vegeta does, even though those other characters are actively going against their interests and goals in protecting the Earth while Vegeta (until the later half of the Buu saga) had zero interest or care in saving the world so he shouldn't have been expected to make responsible choices in the first place.
See, if the Z-Fighters knew that Vegeta couldn't be trusted with protecting the world in the Cell Saga going onwards, why would they trust him with the info that the Androids were going to show up? Why would they trust him with anything after he let Cell become perfect? If you think the Z-Fighters have a vested interest in protecting the Earth, then they should also care about getting Vegeta to piss off, since he was a direct threat to Earth in the Saiyan Saga and an indirect threat to it in the Cell and Buu Sagas. I mean, it's not like they needed him around any more after Namek since Goku was there.
Also, the motive behind a lot of the Z-Fighter's stupid decisions doesn't come across as arrogant and petty as Vegeta's do. Vegeta made his stupid decisions because of some vague poorly defined "Saiyan pride," that just seems to be the default excuse for whenever he decides to do something stupid. (E.g. letting Cell become Perfect because of his raging ego or letting Babidi control him to have a dick-measuring contest with Goku because he's still so insecure about the fact he can't catch up to him.) Piccolo's decision to go to Namek, while dumb is something I can understand because he wanted Freeza to pay for slaughtering his people. Krillin stomping the remote to avoid killing 18 I can understand because as an Android, she hadn't done anything wrong and didn't appear evil. Goku throwing Cell a Sensu Bean is something I can understand because he saw Gohan's power in the Time Chamber, he wanted Cell to have a fair fight and he genuinely believed in his son that much. (It still fits his characterization during the end of the Piccolo Jr Arc, too.) All of those decisions, dumb as they are come across as a lot more understandable and nuanced than Vegeta selfishly screwing everyone over with his own ego
MrGohanks wrote: Tue Aug 09, 2022 4:05 pm
"VeGeTa OnLy ExIsT tO MoVe ThE pLoT fOrWaRd", that's what a character in a story is supposed to do lol, he is the only non-protagonist fighter beside Future Trunks who's actions actually matter and have any real consequences to them. The rest of the supporting cast most of the time could be removed from a Saga's plot and nothing would change, which is a massive red flag that suggests that they are a nothing character.
I mean, sure, but it makes Vegeta come across as a moron and it makes the Z-Fighters come across as morons for putting up with his shit for so long. Just like how Dragon Ball Super anime Goku comes across as a moron for his actions even if they move the plot forward. To me, Vegeta's idiocy don't make Cell or Babidi look better as villains, it just makes Vegeta look worse for falling for such obvious ploys. So yes, Vegeta does move the plot forward, but moving the plot forward because of your own incompetence is not a good look for a character imo. (See DBS Goku.)
MrGohanks wrote: Tue Aug 09, 2022 4:05 pm
And no, TFS has zero influence on the DragonBall franchise. DBZ Abriged is just an obscure online parody series that's only known among North American fans, the vast majority of DB fans worldwide has never even heard of it, especially Japan. Hell, even most of the English dub voice actors never heard of DBZ Abridged until fans told them about it.
Could have fooled me between Mr Popo's stare when Vegeta breaks the Hyperbolic Time Chamber and Goku being a dumbass and bad father being exaggerated up to eleven, but whatever.
MrGohanks wrote: Tue Aug 09, 2022 4:05 pm
And I wasn't even mainly talking about transformations in my first post, I'm talking about the fact that all of Vegeta's abilities and techniques prior to RoF was self-taught, while all of Goku's even now is stolen or learned from others. Needing outside help for what others can do on their own is a bad look, and "he got it through exposition" is a dumb argument because it doesn't change the facts of how exactly how he got it in-universe.
Vegeta "stole" Kuririn's Kienzan to use against Gohan in the Saiyan Saga. If you're going to get mad at Goku for "stealing" the Kamehameha or Taiyoken, Vegeta has used an unoriginal technique against the Z-Fighters before.
Even then, all of Vegeta's original attacks pre Moro Arc (Galick Gun, Big Bang Attack, Final Flash) are just based on overpowering your opponent with a beam or ball, something that any other Z-Fighter can do while he doesn't have any moves that could help him against a stronger opponent. This just further proves dbz_raza and I's point that Vegeta just tries to brute force all his enemies and isn't a good strategist before the Moro Arc.