Diccolo-420 wrote: Fri Dec 26, 2025 10:01 pm
I will never understand this obsession with x264. The excuse of better compatibility is complete BS as most modern devices support x265. 1tb for a bunch of 480p episodes is absolutely inexcusable.
I was looking forward to it, even though I prefer Kai, but I'll be skipping this sadly.
Like, I watch MKV files with VLC anyways, so whether they're 264 or 265 makes absolutely no difference to me. Like, I get the argument if it were compressing as low as it'll go because if you do that, there's diminishing returns because then you start to suffer legit quality loss, but if you only do it the once, it doesn't really matter, especially for animation that's somewhat upscaled from a compressed DVD rip source. The compression on these files is probably better than the compression they suffered to be put on the DVDs years ago so it's not even that bad. It's really dumb.
vanner64 wrote: Fri Dec 26, 2025 11:35 pm
Yeah I'm glad the quality remains as "near master" with the encode settings. This allows anyone to re-encode to whatever x265 settings they want for the level of quality they deem acceptable. Want to remove some audio tracks you'll never listen to? Want to convert them to a lossy format to save more space? You're free to do so.
You can't "undo" any quality loss, blocking, etc. problems from a lower bitrate x265 encode. I'm not sure where this idea came from that Seed of Might uses x264 over x265 for compatibility in 2025. x265 doesn't handle lower res or grainy sources as well as it handles modern 4K sources. It seems kinda silly to skip watching something because the encode is "too high quality". Those happy with the high quality settings, and even those who want to adjust the release to their preferred settings, have the right attitudes.
As I said, there's no real quality loss I noticed on some episodes. If there is, it's not readily noticeable to me. If people wanna keep the files as-is, more power to you, but I can't justify it right now.
Diccolo-420 wrote: Sat Dec 27, 2025 12:13 am
I might have a lot of space on my storage drive, but i shouldn't be wasting an entire terabyte for one show, not even a show I love, especially at 480p per episode. Asking people to do that is ridiculous, particularly those who can't or don't know how to convert them over to x265. I don't see how x265 is a problem, but compatibility is usually the excuse for using x264.
Like I said, no excuse for not using x265 in 2025.
At the very least, an alternate torrent for x265 would be nice.
ThunderMite42 wrote: Sat Dec 27, 2025 12:16 am
They plan to put out a "DLC" release sometime early next year with extra audio tracks that were excluded from the main release to cut down on bloat. I've been informed that these tracks will include "pretty much any English related stuff that's synced that we didn't include":
- Speedy Video (Malaysian English) dub
- Creative Products (Filipino English) dub
- Orange Bricks dub mix (the main release uses the BD season sets mix (except for one line fixed in the 30A edition) because it's overall better despite the brickwalling)
- Raw DBox audio*, because someone's inevitably gonna want it
- Ultimate Uncut Edition (DVD rips for 1–27* and TV caps of 28–67)
- Isolated Faulconer Productions scores for certain episodes*
- Faulconer Re-Mix, if it's done
- possibly the Latin American Spanish dub
- anything else that gets R2J DBox-synced between now and then
*stuff from the previous merge release that was removed from the CC
The only one of those I give even a remote shit about is a track with the fixed lines (which, I hope they fix more than that 1 because Totally Not Mark's shown more examples than that one in that video). Otherwise, don't care. Good for those who want them, though.