godofchaos wrote:I'm not comparing the set to a release we may or may not get, nor a foreign release that had numerous video problems.
I review for what it is.
It's a Dragon Ball boxset. We have no news about a Dbox of it in the USA, so I'm not bringing it up, because it's not relevant to it.
And 96k isn't odd either. It's standard for Funi mono tracks on DVD, their 5.1 tracks are generally 448k, which averages to about 90 per channel.
You're trying to find issues that don't exist.
I have no problems with calling Funi on shit, and complaining about YOUR feelings on a dub when the Japanese track is there, uncut, with subtitles, is the worst kind of nitpicking.
I'm reviewing what there, is based on what I know, and what's available to the average person.
Going, 'oh shit, this sucks, cause there's a better release in Japan' doesn't do, or mean anything for the average person.
I love the Dragon Boxes as much as plenty of other people. This set is exactly what is demanded of Funi, so I'm not gonna knock them based on what may or may not happen.
The DB/Z/GT fan's wanted 4:3 footage, Japanese version subbed, and all the episodes in order.
I only bring up foreign/alternate releases of a show when there is an obvious, and notable problem in ours.
If it's not good enough, then go wait for the Dbox, it's not what I reviewed.
This is what we wanted, asked for, and demanded, at a great price.
Alright you wont compare it to a foreign release, but will you compare it to Funi's previous release?, because when you say in the review that there is rarely any details lost in the remastering process. Then we need some kind of comparison picture with Funi's Dragonball dvd releases. I think it's very important to show this. We should be able to see what was improved.
Especially, if you want to disregard something about the dragon box. You can disregard it, but I guarantee in this forum, Daizex people will not disregard it. That's why we need to know how it compares to the dragon box. If it is almost as good as the dragon box. Then people may buy it. But we need screen shots to show that. If there is too much detail lost, I don't think people will buy it. Or they won't buy it anyways, because the fact that Funi may release another dragon box for Dragonball.
And furthermore I wasn't asking you to nitpick. When I said is it more uncut. I just wanted to know whether or not they actually went and redubbed some lines to make the audio more uncut. I wanted to know if they changed anything. If they didn't then that is not necessarily a bad thing.
And also, did they change anything to improve the subtitles? Were they improved? Again, I'm not asking for a nitpick. I'm just asking for information. The whole point of your review, was I felt it was incomplete and I was not informed enough.
This part is not your fault. But Funimation should be informing their fan base whether or not they are going to release the dragon box for Dragonball. Otherwise I doubt people want to continue wasting their money, and then waiting longer and longer to buy more stuff. I mean we had the previous Dragonball dvd releases, then we have this release, and now a potential dragon box in the future. How much more money does Funimation want their fan base to waste? When they don't inform us what they are going to do next.
Well, as for me I'm going to wait. If someone wants can we get some comparison pictures in this thread? Either way, I probably will wait.