You're ignoring a hell of a lot old bad blood between FUNimation and YTV, as well as the fundamental concept of "Cancon." Having a Canadian company credited makes the product significantly more marketable in Canada.RazorX wrote:Ocean Productions being credited for video post production in the TV broadcast version has brought about discussions in various topics.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-9lI82zt5JM
At around 0.18 you can see Ocean Productions Inc being credited for the video editing and post production. This has increased the chances of an Ocean dub of Kai. Why? Allow me to explain. This will be a bit lengthy which is why I started this topic:
First of all, think back to Dragon Ball Z. From the Android episodes onwards, there have been 2 dubs, one by The Ocean Group (original voice actors from the Saiyan and Namek episodes) and the other by Funimation Productions. (With their in house cast, taking over from the Ginyu episodes)
Now the video for the episodes was the same for both versions. It was assumed that Funimation did the video editing for the TV broadcasts of Dragon Ball Z and that video was used for the Ocean Group dub, which was recorded at Westwood Studios, Airwaves studios and had its post production done at Ocean Studios.
We may assume that Ocean edited those DBZ episodes and Funimation used them, but there's a slight problem with this theory. In the last few episodes of Z, Ocean's dub did not use the same video as the Funimation dub, they got video for those episodes from AB Groupe. (European license holders of the Dragon Ball franchise who are believed to have hired Ocean for the DBZ Android-Buu episodes) The most likely reason was that those episodes were not done in time and Ocean didnt want to wait, so if Ocean really did the video editing for the TV episodes of DBZ, why would they have got AB's videos for those final few episodes?
Now, the fact that Funimation's TV version of Kai has credited Ocean for the video post production raises some questions, one of which being, why would Funimation go all the way to Canada just for the video post production? Surely its cost effective to use a local company, plus Ocean are likely to be more expensive even without all the travel costs (And Funimation split with Ocean originally to avoid those travel costs as well as the expensive talent of the Ocean actors)
If Funimation did the video editing for the DBZ episodes themselves, they could've done so again with Kai.
So here's one explanation. The Ocean Group, now known as Ocean Productions, are indeed producing their own dub of Dragon Ball Kai for TV broadcast. And as we know, they have to edit the video in order to meet the requirements of TV stations wanting to aim the show at a certain market. So Ocean have to do editing and video post production either way you look at it. Funimation must've seen this and thought, well if Ocean are editing the episodes, why don't we use their video instead of going through the whole editing and post production process ourselves, and pay Ocean for using their video. Now you must be thinking that I mentioned earlier that Ocean are likely to be more expensive than a local company even excluding the travel costs, but lets look at it from Ocean's perspective.
Ocean have to go through the recording, editing and post production process for whoever may have hired them to produce a dub of Kai. They have (or will have) the finished product sitting there with them and Funimation comes along. Funimation and Nicktoons are going to broadcast that exact same show, so Funimation negotiate a deal with Ocean which is likely to be cheaper than if Ocean had to edit the episodes from scratch. So for Ocean, its basically money for doing very little extra, bring the costs, and thus the price, down to a level which is probably cheaper than if Funimation edited the video themselves or hired a local company to do it. You dont get these situations every day (2 companies producing different dubs of the exact same show at the same time), so when they arise, you take advantage of it.
Ocean gets additional revenue for a product they had to produce for someone else, Funimation gets a finished product cheaper due to the product already being pretty much fit for broadcast, it works out for both of them.
Of course, they may have had to get the permission of whoever are hiring Ocean to produce a dub of Kai to use it (Most likely AB Groupe or perhaps even Toei Animation themselves)
Now, Sean Schemmel, Funi's voice actor for Goku, mentioned the Ocean dub and some elements of it. Some people are saying that Sean may have been talking about the TV broadcast of the Funimation dub which Ocean edited, but this doesnt make sense. Aside from the points already mentioned above, I'll explain why.
Sean mentions replaced music, and his dislike for it. The broadcast version of Funi's Kai dub uses the original Japanese music, so Sean cant have been referring to the Funi TV version. Some people suggest Sean was talking about Vic's opening, but thats also very unlikely. Sean says "shitty" and I dont think he'd openly describe a fellow voice actor's opening song as shitty before it was even shown, even if he hates it. Plus he specifically mentions "Canadian" music. The music Ocean used for their Westwood Studios DBZ dub could be classed as "Canadian" because it was made in Canada. Sean stated that he has heard the music and he said that Ocean are dubbing the episodes the same time as Funimation.
Another thing, Sean also mentions that the Ocean dub of Kai has additional sound effects, he specifies "doins" and "boings" and a "whoosh" as Bulma walks past or turns her heard. Clearly those added sound effects are not in either of Funi's dubs. And those of us who have seen the Westwood Ocean dub, know that it has added sound effects, quite a lot of them actually. So that fits in with a possible Ocean dub like a glove.
So, in my view, the fact that Ocean Productions are credited for the video post production actually increases the likelihood of an Ocean dub of Dragon Ball Kai with the Vancouver voice cast for stated reasons. The fact that Ocean did the editing and post production of the Kai episodes for Funimation may explain how Sean Schemmel was able to sample some of Ocean's own dub of Kai.
Edit: Sean also mentions that his criticisms of the Ocean dub have nothing to do with its cast, whom he has great respect for. Why would he go out of his way to clarify that if the dub was the Funi dub and not Ocean dub?
Edit Edit: Sean also says its all about the money, even for Toei. If Toei can get license money for 2 versions of the same language for their DB Kai Anime, thats pretty good for them, that itself may have been one of the attractions of having 2 English DBZ dubs as well.
Edit Edit Edit: I noticed that the TV broadcasts of Funi's dub of Kai are brighter more saturated than their DVD/Blu Ray releases. If Funimation had asked Ocean to edit the video from scratch, why would they have brightened it up? This also suggests that Funi simply used Ocean's video for TV broadcast and used their own video for their DVD/Blu Ray releases. (Yeah the points keep coming once you think about it)
Sean may also have come across works in progress pending FUNimation's approval, which could even imply that the Canadian version of this Kai would have said sound effects in order to count as more Cancon. Plus the themes were redone in English, as opposed to the "original, uncut" version he cherishes, and we haven't seen the entire series, yet; more changes may be en route.
As for more money for TOEI, you're absolutely right. But any Canadian broadcast company hiring Ocean to make a dub strictly for Cancon isn't going to bother if there's a version Ocean already made available for sale. IE: This version of Kai.
Regarding the TV version being different from the home release version... Well... Yeah. That's the whole purpose of the editing being done at all.
Meanwhile, Sean made a note of saying he wasn't bashing the Ocean VAs because he was initially bashing Ocean as a whole, whereas the VAs had nothing to do with what he was insulting.








