SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Discussion, generally of an in-universe nature, regarding any aspect of the franchise (including movies, spin-offs, etc.) such as: techniques, character relationships, internal back-history, its universe, and more.
User avatar
Low Tone G
I'm, pretty, cozy, here...
Posts: 1711
Joined: Tue Feb 04, 2014 8:34 am

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Low Tone G » Tue Oct 07, 2014 3:28 pm

Hitiro wrote:
Low Tone G wrote:I guess I can see your point, but Base Goku was also capable to fight Beerus on par, and he could also keep up with his incresed speed.(of course he used IT too, but he could dodge Beerus' attacks in Base)

Your theory can make sense if the absorbing process wasn't instantaneous, but a relatively slower one, and Goku was run of most power when he powered up to SSJ when the rocks of the cave were about to beat him down. In that case he should be able to sense Beerus' with that low God Ki remnant too, but that wouldn't explain the fact that Goku was able to transform once again into SSJ God, and able to overpower Beerus' attack, if he has run out of that much Ki. The only way that Goku was able to do that that he made reverse process and transformed that SSJ based normal Ki into a Godly one. But Goku didn't know how he did that. I personally would remain with the theory that Goku had Godly Ki during the whole fight.

So,I see it more like this:
First SSJ God Goku 100%:6
SSJ God Goku 80%: 5
Base Goku 95%: 5.4 (taking the fight a bit more seriously, but still didn't fight at 100% of power)
SSJ Goku 100%: 5.9 (taking the fight seriously and put up a better fight)
SSJ God Goku 100% (2nd transformation): 7.1(zenkai or some of latent power unleashed as Super Saiyan God, or both)

I personally see that Goku has absorbed and made his own the God Ki's 90%+ as Beerus said Goku power didn't drop much in power after loosing that form. Maybe he should have added that after transforming into SSJ Goku's power was mostly restored, but he did not say such a thing. As Goku was able to read Beerus' power level using his SSJ form in space makes me think that Goku should have God Ki then, because otherwise he couldn't sense him.
Think you need to re-read my post. I actually said that the absorbing process wasn't instantaneous. :D

Perhaps I didn't make it clear enough? Goku held his own in base while the God Ki was in the process of vanishing. It only completely went away and was absorbed into his regular Ki by the time he went SSJ. Obviously, otherwise SSJ Goku would probably be marginally stronger than SSJGod Goku if the Ki hadn't transferred. Unless you believe that the SSJ form doesn't amplify God Ki. In which case by the time Goku had finished absorbing all the God Ki into his regular Ki he was 50x weaker than his SSJGod form. Which is practically the same whether he kept some God Ki and that got amplified or he just lost it all and it was converted to regular Ki instead.
I assume I see more simple the whole issue.... I think that we can rely on the facts. Goku was able to continue fight Beerus on par after he lost the form. So in that case I can imagine that Goku had the most of God Ki absorbed into his Base form. Going SSJ it didn't increrase his power, only he gone to 100%(he believed that it's time to take the fight seriously). Practically I see like a power-up to 100% power not a real upgrade to SSJ. Because Goku was totally unaware what he did earlier untill Beerus said that he was lack of God from. So I think Goku did not know that he had gone through a Super Saiyan transformation when wanted to take the fight more seriously. Being that I think that he didn't feel that was running of(God) Ki being in Base form, only wanted to somehow overcome Beerus and to take him by surprise. That's exactly what happened while he was fighting as a Super Saiyan, he put up better fight than earlier as a Super Saiyan God. And Goku did notice afterwards that Beerus still has some ways to go even higher and said that there was still a huge gap between them in favor of Beerus, and then he was only a Super Saiyan. So that's why I can not accept that God Ki was transformed into regular one, because he could sense and read Beerus's power level, and it's sated that one who does have God is able to sense another God being, so Goku had to have that God Ki.
English is not my first language!
I'm still waiting for Dragon Ball in Super...

User avatar
Hitiro
I Live Here
Posts: 3433
Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2011 8:43 pm

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Hitiro » Tue Oct 07, 2014 4:11 pm

Low Tone G wrote:I assume I see more simple the whole issue.... I think that we can rely on the facts. Goku was able to continue fight Beerus on par after he lost the form. So in that case I can imagine that Goku had the most of God Ki absorbed into his Base form. Going SSJ it didn't increrase his power, only he gone to 100%(he believed that it's time to take the fight seriously). Practically I see like a power-up to 100% power not a real upgrade to SSJ. Because Goku was totally unaware what he did earlier untill Beerus said that he was lack of God from. So I think Goku did not know that he had gone through a Super Saiyan transformation when wanted to take the fight more seriously. Being that I think that he didn't feel that was running of(God) Ki being in Base form, only wanted to somehow overcome Beerus and to take him by surprise. That's exactly what happened while he was fighting as a Super Saiyan, he put up better fight than earlier as a Super Saiyan God. And Goku did notice afterwards that Beerus still has some ways to go even higher and said that there was still a huge gap between them in favor of Beerus, and then he was only a Super Saiyan. So that's why I can not accept that God Ki was transformed into regular one, because he could sense and read Beerus's power level, and it's sated that one who does have God is able to sense another God being, so Goku had to have that God Ki.
But Goku never says anything about being able to sense Beerus when he transformed back to a base Saiyan. The fact that Goku teleports around him may just be down to Goku using other Ki sources to move about. I've always seen his teleports as waypoints he can distance himself from or get as close to them as he needs. As Goku demonstrates in the movie itself he can position himself wherever he wants as long as he has a Ki source to judge from. Whether he is using someone else's Ki or Beerus is unclear because we don't know the functionality of his teleport technique other than it relies on a Ki source. But I still believe that Goku could use one of his friends if he wants and work around their Ki position to fight an opponent.

I don't know how accurate the subs are on the movie I watched but Beerus says Goku lost his SSJGod powers. I would assume he lost the God abilities to sense other God Ki too.

User avatar
Tectorman
Regular
Posts: 600
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 8:19 pm

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Tectorman » Tue Oct 07, 2014 5:28 pm

Then when Goku teleported himself and Cell to the Other Dimension, wouldn't he have put as much distance between himself and King Kai as possible?
Twilight: My library?! My library!! Do you have any idea how many books I had in there?!
Lord Tirek: How many, little princess?
Twilight: Over NINE THOUSAND!!!

User avatar
Low Tone G
I'm, pretty, cozy, here...
Posts: 1711
Joined: Tue Feb 04, 2014 8:34 am

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Low Tone G » Wed Oct 08, 2014 10:54 am

Hitiro wrote:
Low Tone G wrote:I assume I see more simple the whole issue.... I think that we can rely on the facts. Goku was able to continue fight Beerus on par after he lost the form. So in that case I can imagine that Goku had the most of God Ki absorbed into his Base form. Going SSJ it didn't increrase his power, only he gone to 100%(he believed that it's time to take the fight seriously). Practically I see like a power-up to 100% power not a real upgrade to SSJ. Because Goku was totally unaware what he did earlier untill Beerus said that he was lack of God from. So I think Goku did not know that he had gone through a Super Saiyan transformation when wanted to take the fight more seriously. Being that I think that he didn't feel that was running of(God) Ki being in Base form, only wanted to somehow overcome Beerus and to take him by surprise. That's exactly what happened while he was fighting as a Super Saiyan, he put up better fight than earlier as a Super Saiyan God. And Goku did notice afterwards that Beerus still has some ways to go even higher and said that there was still a huge gap between them in favor of Beerus, and then he was only a Super Saiyan. So that's why I can not accept that God Ki was transformed into regular one, because he could sense and read Beerus's power level, and it's sated that one who does have God is able to sense another God being, so Goku had to have that God Ki.
But Goku never says anything about being able to sense Beerus when he transformed back to a base Saiyan. The fact that Goku teleports around him may just be down to Goku using other Ki sources to move about. I've always seen his teleports as waypoints he can distance himself from or get as close to them as he needs. As Goku demonstrates in the movie itself he can position himself wherever he wants as long as he has a Ki source to judge from. Whether he is using someone else's Ki or Beerus is unclear because we don't know the functionality of his teleport technique other than it relies on a Ki source. But I still believe that Goku could use one of his friends if he wants and work around their Ki position to fight an opponent.

I don't know how accurate the subs are on the movie I watched but Beerus says Goku lost his SSJGod powers. I would assume he lost the God abilities to sense other God Ki too.
I never sad that Goku told anything about Beerus' power when he transformed back to Base form, but he did it being a regular Super Saiyan, when he was struggling with Beerus attack. He said that there was still a huge gap between his power and of Beerus. So I suppose he could sense Beerus in Super Saiyan form too.

To quote that dialog of Beerus the sub told that something like this:
Beerus: I think you didn't notice.
Goku: Noticed what?
Beerus: Your Super Saiyan God transformation wore off ages ago!
Goku: It did?....But...
Beerus:It looks as if while you were fighting in the God-form, you ended up absorbing all of that power into your body. Which is why, despite returning to normal, your power didn't drop very much. Quite impressive. A rare fighting prodigy, I'd say!
Goku: If that's true, then great...
Beerus: Then why not just happy about it? Isn't that what you wanted?
Goku: I can't... The biggest problem is... there is still a huge gap in strength between us!
Beerus: Then give up and accept your defeat!
Goku didn't notice anything about what has happened before, he just had the fight against Beerus, believing that he can save the Earth using his God powers. If he would sense that he is not weaker than before, but he can not sense Beerus, he certainly would say something that he missed Beerus. But he right said that he knows that Beerus was still stronger than he was by a significant margine, a margine that is too big for him to jump through. I suppose he spoke about 70% power of Beerus, because he could not sense the full power of him, because Beerus didn't use it during the whole fight. So that why I'm assuming that Goku was as a Super Saiyan a 6 against Beerus, when he used his 70% of power. As a second transformed Super Saiyan God, he must overpower Beerus' attack in a way to be enough to absorb it.

This way:
SSJ Goku's level against Beerus' Ultimate attack: 6(he was about to loose against that huge ball)
2nd SSJ-God Goku's level against Beerus' Ultimate attack: 7.1(he must be quite a bit stronger than the attack, so I can see there a zenkai or latent power to come to surface, or both a bit.)
English is not my first language!
I'm still waiting for Dragon Ball in Super...

User avatar
Hitiro
I Live Here
Posts: 3433
Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2011 8:43 pm

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Hitiro » Wed Oct 08, 2014 11:45 am

Low Tone G wrote:I never sad that Goku told anything about Beerus' power when he transformed back to Base form, but he did it being a regular Super Saiyan, when he was struggling with Beerus attack. He said that there was still a huge gap between his power and of Beerus. So I suppose he could sense Beerus in Super Saiyan form too.

To quote that dialog of Beerus the sub told that something like this:
Beerus: I think you didn't notice.
Goku: Noticed what?
Beerus: Your Super Saiyan God transformation wore off ages ago!
Goku: It did?....But...
Beerus:It looks as if while you were fighting in the God-form, you ended up absorbing all of that power into your body. Which is why, despite returning to normal, your power didn't drop very much. Quite impressive. A rare fighting prodigy, I'd say!
Goku: If that's true, then great...
Beerus: Then why not just happy about it? Isn't that what you wanted?
Goku: I can't... The biggest problem is... there is still a huge gap in strength between us!
Beerus: Then give up and accept your defeat!
Goku didn't notice anything about what has happened before, he just had the fight against Beerus, believing that he can save the Earth using his God powers. If he would sense that he is not weaker than before, but he can not sense Beerus, he certainly would say something that he missed Beerus. But he right said that he knows that Beerus was still stronger than he was by a significant margine, a margine that is too big for him to jump through. I suppose he spoke about 70% power of Beerus, because he could not sense the full power of him, because Beerus didn't use it during the whole fight. So that why I'm assuming that Goku was as a Super Saiyan a 6 against Beerus, when he used his 70% of power. As a second transformed Super Saiyan God, he must overpower Beerus' attack in a way to be enough to absorb it.

This way:
SSJ Goku's level against Beerus' Ultimate attack: 6(he was about to loose against that huge ball)
2nd SSJ-God Goku's level against Beerus' Ultimate attack: 7.1(he must be quite a bit stronger than the attack, so I can see there a zenkai or latent power to come to surface, or both a bit.)
But this is just an assumption like mine. Doesn't mean he could sense Beerus as a SSJ. For all we know Goku was comparing himself to what he last sensed of Beerus. Goku "had" sensed Beerus at some point. So Goku knows how strong he is. If Goku loses his power to sense Beerus Goku is still going to know how strong Beerus is compared to him. He isn't going to suffer from amnesia after losing the ability to sense someone. Goku knew probably the whole fight that Beerus is stronger than him. Why should that change if he lost the ability to sense Beerus power? Beerus isn't going to get weaker than he is.

User avatar
Low Tone G
I'm, pretty, cozy, here...
Posts: 1711
Joined: Tue Feb 04, 2014 8:34 am

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Low Tone G » Wed Oct 08, 2014 12:09 pm

Or course not, Goku didn't suffer of any disease.(LOL). But Goku didn't notice anything that he lost any of his God abilities during the whole fight. He did not miss Beerus, he could read his movement(more or less, because Beerus was in the whole fight stronger and faster the he was). Toriyama right said in an interview that Goku doesn't need to transform into SSJ-God anymore, so I can make the assumption that Goku has all the benefits of God Ki even if he won't have its appearance anymore. So I think Base Goku should be able to read the power of a God being in the next movie too, even if he doesn't take the appearance of SSJ-God. Goku has all the unic abilities of the God himself although he isn't that God anymore like he was for 5(?) minutes against Beerus.

So should we really think that Toriyama will allow Goku to loose some abilites when he is a fighting genius? I don't think that Goku will not be able to read the power level of the next villain(if that will be also a God just like Beerus is, and I definitely beileve that he will be). I really think Goku can sense enough well a God being even if he won't transform into SSJ-God anymore.

Not to mention that in the end of the movie it's implied quite well that Whis watched that whole fight and also offered Goku the Job of the next God of Destruction, I suppose he counts Goku a God like Beerus.

Personally I'd like to think Goku doesn't have any disadvantage of loosing the God form. So he should be able to fight as a God and sense as a God from now on continuously.

Please, decide yourself what Goku was saying following the Eng dub of the movie. The relevant part is at 9:30. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PRzzCuB2iQU
English is not my first language!
I'm still waiting for Dragon Ball in Super...

User avatar
Hitiro
I Live Here
Posts: 3433
Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2011 8:43 pm

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Hitiro » Wed Oct 08, 2014 2:42 pm

Low Tone G wrote:Or course not, Goku didn't suffer of any disease.(LOL). But Goku didn't notice anything that he lost any of his God abilities during the whole fight. He did not miss Beerus, he could read his movement(more or less, because Beerus was in the whole fight stronger and faster the he was). Toriyama right said in an interview that Goku doesn't need to transform into SSJ-God anymore, so I can make the assumption that Goku has all the benefits of God Ki even if he won't have its appearance anymore. So I think Base Goku should be able to read the power of a God being in the next movie too, even if he doesn't take the appearance of SSJ-God. Goku has all the unic abilities of the God himself although he isn't that God anymore like he was for 5(?) minutes against Beerus.

So should we really think that Toriyama will allow Goku to loose some abilites when he is a fighting genius? I don't think that Goku will not be able to read the power level of the next villain(if that will be also a God just like Beerus is, and I definitely beileve that he will be). I really think Goku can sense enough well a God being even if he won't transform into SSJ-God anymore.

Not to mention that in the end of the movie it's implied quite well that Whis watched that whole fight and also offered Goku the Job of the next God of Destruction, I suppose he counts Goku a God like Beerus.

Personally I'd like to think Goku doesn't have any disadvantage of loosing the God form. So he should be able to fight as a God and sense as a God from now on continuously.

Please, decide yourself what Goku was saying following the Eng dub of the movie. The relevant part is at 9:30. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PRzzCuB2iQU
Goku not noticing he lost the abilities can be merely down to the heat of battle. Toriyama did say Goku doesn't need to transform into a SSJGod anymore. But that doesn't mean he has all the benefits of God Ki. That can just simply mean Goku has absorbed the God Ki into his regular Ki to the point that he is strong enough to rival a SSJGod without the being one. As we know in the fight Goku can still fight as well as a SSJGod as a regular SSJ. So if Goku can be as strong as his SSJGod self as a SSJ then SSJGot isn't needed anymore, right?

You say the "next" villain. But the gods of destruction aren't villains. It is their job to destroy to maintain the balance in their universes. If a villain does come along then chances are the villain isn't going to use God Ki. Because any being with God Ki is rare. Because of this I don't think Goku is going to be needing the abilities of a God and God Ki to defeat his next opponent.

Well, offering Goku a job as God of Destruction means nothing really. It's just a job. Why does Goku have to be classed as a "God" to have the job? Surely all Goku needs is the strength of a God. The jobs only requirement is that the person be strong enough to destroy planets and such.

I'm not arguing the Goku doesn't know Beerus is too powerful. But that doesn't mean he can still sense him. Goku can find it strange that he can't sense Beerus yet still think he has the SSJGod power. In fact, how do we know that Goku can even sense him even after he goes SSJGod? Because Goku actually asks Beerus if he is a SSJGod. Surely if he can sense a God then he should know he is a God himself? We've seen in the manga that Goku and the gang can determine how strong a character is through movement alone. Like Dabra. Why is it that we have to assume Goku can sense Beerus? Goku and the gang have also proven that they can track an opponents movement even without sensing Ki. Goku has said before that he can track an opponent by relying on air-currents and can tell what an enemy is doing. Popo has demonstrated this too. So it isn't like Goku or a majority of the cast can't fight an opponent that doesn't have Ki. In fact, Piccolo put up a fight against #17 and had no problems fighting him even though #17 lacks a Ki signature.

User avatar
Tectorman
Regular
Posts: 600
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 8:19 pm

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Tectorman » Wed Oct 08, 2014 8:05 pm

@Hitiro:

All the rest of what we were going back and forth about was getting into IMO too many tangents. Here is where I think we're finally communicating.
Hitiro wrote:The fact of the matter is that Gohan "is" stronger than Gotenks. You can debate by how much but he is still above Gotenks. Also. It would be 1.x times more powerful. Not 1x. Because 1x1 = 1. If you were to say he's 1.1x more powerful then that is a valid number.
Yes, SSJ Gotenks IS more powerful than SSJ2 Goku AND you cannot say by how much. Gohan IS more powerful than SSJ3 Gotenks AND you cannot say by how much. That's what I was trying to convey this whole time. Some people might call the "how much" a x2 multiplier, others x1.5, others x1.2, others more, others less. I'm saying those numbers cannot go further down, but certainly they can and do go up, but the degree by which they go up depends solely on the person's feeling of what's necessary to feel like whatever change the story's illustrating.

So, here's my revised claim:

"SSJG is more than 800 times stronger than Goku's SSJ abilities as of the Buu Saga, going by the anime."

Expanded:

SSJG is more than...
(SSJG is stronger than SSJ Vegetto)
...50 times...
(SSJ Vegetto is 50x Vegetto)
...more than...
(Vegetto is stronger than Gohan)
...more than...
(Gohan is stronger than SSJ3 Gotenks)
...8 times...
(SSJ3 Gotenks is 8x SSJ Gotenks)
...more than...
(SSJ Gotenks is stronger than SSJ2 Goku)
...2 times stronger than SSJ Goku, going by the anime.

Or, SSJG is more than more than more than more than 800 times as strong as Buu Saga SSJ Goku, going by the anime.

When I say "at least", I mean "including how ever many 'more thans' of whatever degrees of magnitude you feel necessary".

And here is where I own up to being unfair. I low-end my estimates because I feel I have to acknowledge the difference between my own gut feelings about how much stronger one character is over another and someone else not cutting the characters as much leeway as I am. Ex: I think SSJ Gotenks is a 3.5 compared to SSJ Goku being a 1, but all I put in my estimate is "2+X, where X is greater than 0".

Which means I have to acknowledge the argument that Vegetto, by the manga, might not have been as strong as Gohan.

So, going by the manga, my claim is this: "SSJG is more than 16 times stronger than Buu Saga SSJ Goku."

Expanded:

SSJG is more than...
(SSJG is stronger than SSJ Vegetto)
...more than...
(SSJ Vegetto is stronger than Buuhan)
...more than...
(Buuhan is stronger than Buutenks)
...more than...
(Buutenks is stronger than Gohan)
...more than...
(Gohan is stronger than SSJ3 Gotenks)
...8 times...
(SSJ3 Gotenks is 8x SSJ Gotenks)
...more than...
(SSJ Gotenks is stronger than SSJ2 Goku)
...2 times stronger than SSJ Goku, going by the manga.

Or, SSJG is more than more than more than more than more than more than 16 times as strong as Buu Saga SSJ Goku, going by the manga.

As for Hirudegarn, it occurs to me that it's actually not necessary to show Goku's progress in between the Buu Saga and BoG. Originally, I did so (even if only for the sake of those fans that include the movies or aspects of them in their consideration of the storyline) because I was comparing SSJG to SSJ Vegetto back then.

Goku's line in the movie that even merging with Vegeta probably wouldn't work makes this irrelevant, as that's a comparison to the hypothetical SSJ Vegetto of today. Assuming both Goku and Vegeta trained similarly and assuming the "rival boost" stays the same, Vegetto would still have been as proportionally stronger as five years ago in-universe.

...

Catching up to the current conversation:

I think Toriyama isn't thinking in terms of "Well, technically..." to nearly the degree we fans do. He established that Gods have God Ki that cannot be sensed by mortals. He also established Goku becoming a God through the ritual, absorbing that world of power into his own and no longer needing the SSJG form. Occam's Razor says Goku can sense God Ki.

A point against Goku still having that ability: if you're not under the impression that Beers and Whis are the only two Gods in the 7th universe, then there should be others. They have phenomenally more Ki than a SSJ3, which could be sensed as far away as the Supreme Kai's world. So shouldn't Goku have started commenting on all the great powers he could now sense out there?

Rebuttal: Goku was a God and could sense Beers's Ki, so he should have also noticed Whis's Ki. But he doesn't realize the unassuming attendant to be as strong as he is until Beers tells him. So maybe Gods, when they're asleep or by virtue of the rank, are phenomenally good at suppressing their Ki.
Twilight: My library?! My library!! Do you have any idea how many books I had in there?!
Lord Tirek: How many, little princess?
Twilight: Over NINE THOUSAND!!!

User avatar
Hitiro
I Live Here
Posts: 3433
Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2011 8:43 pm

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Hitiro » Wed Oct 08, 2014 9:29 pm

Tectorman wrote:So, going by the manga, my claim is this: "SSJG is more than 16 times stronger than Buu Saga SSJ Goku."
This does not make much sense. Are you saying SSJGod is a 800x for the multiplier from base? Or are you saying it is 800x 50x Base battle power(Meaning that SSJGod is a 40,000x base battle power)? In the first example I think you are trying to say. SSJGod is only 2x the SSJ3 multiplier. In the second one SSJGod is 100x SSJ3 multiplier.
Tectorman wrote:Or, SSJG is more than more than more than more than more than more than 16 times as strong as Buu Saga SSJ Goku, going by the manga.
By this quote I am assuming that you are actually saying SSJGod is 2x Boo Saga SSJ3 Goku if you are saying SSJG is only 16x Boo Saga SSJ Goku? In which case that would be absurd. Because if SSJ Gotenks is 2x stronger than SSJ2 Goku then in SSJ3 Gotenks is 4x stronger than SSJ3 Goku. And if we were to assume just for a moment that Gohan is around the same level as Gotenks. Lets just say he is and we'll put Boohan at their level too. Then Boohan would be 8x (4+4 from Boo and Gohan) SSJ3 Goku. SSJ Vegetto is at least 2x that because he wouldn't be able to kick Boo around like he did with anything less. That makes SSJ Vegetto 16x Boo Saga SSJ3 Goku.

In which case, SSJ Vegetto would be stronger than SSJGod Goku if you believe that SSJGod is only 16x Boo Saga SSJ Goku. I assume you actually meant 16x SSJ3 as SSJGod would not be strong at all. Even if you increase Goku's Battle Power by 2x SSJ Vegetto is 50% of SSJGod Goku. And that is if we ignore how strong Gohan was compared to Boo and Gotenks. And how strong SSJ Vegetto was compared to Boohan. For all we know Vegetto could be something like 50% Boohan which would mean that SSJ Vegetto is more along the lines of 200x Boo Saga SSJ3 Goku. Just using the most probably minimum figures though, SSJ Vegetto would not be weak in your scenario of having SSJGod as 16x Boo Saga SSJ Goku.
Tectorman wrote:Goku's line in the movie that even merging with Vegeta probably wouldn't work makes this irrelevant, as that's a comparison to the hypothetical SSJ Vegetto of today. Assuming both Goku and Vegeta trained similarly and assuming the "rival boost" stays the same, Vegetto would still have been as proportionally stronger as five years ago in-universe.
I don't know if this is a fair assumption considering the only possible fusion they can make in this movie is with the fusion dance. They can't do Potara fusion anymore because there are no more sets of Potara earrings.

So wouldn't this be "hypothetical SSJ Gogeta" rather than "hypothetical SSJ Vegetto"? Pretty sure the Potara fusion is a stronger fusion than the fusion dance.
Tectorman wrote:I think Toriyama isn't thinking in terms of "Well, technically..." to nearly the degree we fans do. He established that Gods have God Ki that cannot be sensed by mortals. He also established Goku becoming a God through the ritual, absorbing that world of power into his own and no longer needing the SSJG form. Occam's Razor says Goku can sense God Ki.
Why does Goku need to be able to sense God Ki just because he has God Ki? Let me ask you. Could Freeza sense regular Ki even though he has regular Ki? Could Raditz? Could Nappa? Could Vegeta originally? No. None of them could. Vegeta, and the Z-senshi, had to learn how to do this. Just because Goku has gained God Ki doesn't mean he can all of a sudden sense a new type of Ki. Nothing is explicitly stated in the movie that a person with Regular Ki can't learn a method of sensing God Ki. All we get in the movie is that because Beerus has God Ki they couldn't sense him. And we don't know whether Beerus was saying whether Goku absorbed the God Ki into his regular Ki somehow or whether Goku still maintained God Ki afterwards.
Tectorman wrote:A point against Goku still having that ability: if you're not under the impression that Beers and Whis are the only two Gods in the 7th universe, then there should be others. They have phenomenally more Ki than a SSJ3, which could be sensed as far away as the Supreme Kai's world. So shouldn't Goku have started commenting on all the great powers he could now sense out there?
Well, one of my points was that Goku asks Beerus if he was a SSJGod. I mean, if Goku could sense Beerus now. And him sensing God Ki was tied to him having God Ki. Why would he ask that?
Tectorman wrote:Rebuttal: Goku was a God and could sense Beers's Ki, so he should have also noticed Whis's Ki. But he doesn't realize the unassuming attendant to be as strong as he is until Beers tells him. So maybe Gods, when they're asleep or by virtue of the rank, are phenomenally good at suppressing their Ki.
Or... Goku never sensed Beers' Ki. Goku could have determined how strong Beers was through his movement and the way he fights. In the Boo saga, because Dabra wasn't using Ki; he was using magic, Goku and Vegeta determined that Dabra was around the same level as Cell purely based on his movements.
Strength Checker wrote:Chapter: 450 (DBZ 256), P2.5, P3.1-4
Context: after Kaioshin again warns against unleashing Boo
Vegeta: “Hmph…The way things are going, this ‘Majin Boo’ guy isn’t going to be anything special, is he? Just like that ‘Dabra’ jerk…[ ] I’m saying that this ‘Dabra’ guy doesn’t seem as bad as you two feared. Looking at his attacks and movement outside earlier, it seems that if we just watch out for his spit, then we should manage something. I can’t call Kibito anything but a bumbler for getting done-in like that…”
Kaioshin: “…Is-is that true, Son Goku?...”
Goku: “Yeah…Well, even if that wasn’t him at full force…I think that before he would have been a frightening opponent, but…7 years ago there was a guy called ‘Cell’…[Dabra]’s probably about as strong as him…”
But obviously Goku would not be able to tell Whis is a strong guy considering he hasn't shown what he is capable of. So this scene makes perfect sense if you remove Goku being able to sense. We also know that the characters don't need to rely on sensing Ki to fight an opponent. Goku and the other members of his gang had long learnt ways of detecting what an opponent was doing without sight. Even before they learnt how to sense Ki. And as we see with Piccolo fighting #17 who has no Ki to be sensed. He doesn't struggle to fight an opponent without Ki sensing.

As I also brought up, the fact that Goku can use his teleport can merely be down to him using other sources of Ki as waypoints. As I don't think Goku needs to use his opponent as a Ki source to teleport. He could, for instance, use Gohan or Vegeta and teleport in regards to their position.

User avatar
Low Tone G
I'm, pretty, cozy, here...
Posts: 1711
Joined: Tue Feb 04, 2014 8:34 am

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Low Tone G » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:27 am

Goku asked Beerus if he has that power which made him a God. Obviously, he didn't know before what it feels like being a God. And Beerus can suppress himself very well, otherwise when he slapped Bulma, he could kill him as an instant, if he could render SSJ3 Goku unconscious by only touching him, right before that.

As for Whis... Of course Whis suppressed himself immensly as none of Gods can sense him being stronger than the God Of Destruction, and Whis is a Martial Arts Master, after all.

As it was mentioned by an earlier post, Toriyama takes the issue in the simpliest way... Goku doesn't need the SSJ-God form because Goku simply replaced it with his SSJ(respective Base) form. On the poster of the new movie Goku is touching his forehead to access some distant place, he smiles as finally having a good fight again( for me that is what it suggests), the new villain should a be formidable one if Goku smiles to face him. I think he can be really powerful(Godly powerful) if excites Goku, and none of former villains are a challenge now for Goku.
English is not my first language!
I'm still waiting for Dragon Ball in Super...

User avatar
Hitiro
I Live Here
Posts: 3433
Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2011 8:43 pm

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Hitiro » Thu Oct 09, 2014 5:27 am

Low Tone G wrote:Goku asked Beerus if he has that power which made him a God. Obviously, he didn't know before what it feels like being a God. And Beerus can suppress himself very well, otherwise when he slapped Bulma, he could kill him as an instant, if he could render SSJ3 Goku unconscious by only touching him, right before that.

As for Whis... Of course Whis suppressed himself immensly as none of Gods can sense him being stronger than the God Of Destruction, and Whis is a Martial Arts Master, after all.

As it was mentioned by an earlier post, Toriyama takes the issue in the simpliest way... Goku doesn't need the SSJ-God form because Goku simply replaced it with his SSJ(respective Base) form. On the poster of the new movie Goku is touching his forehead to access some distant place, he smiles as finally having a good fight again( for me that is what it suggests), the new villain should a be formidable one if Goku smiles to face him. I think he can be really powerful(Godly powerful) if excites Goku, and none of former villains are a challenge now for Goku.
Even suppressed Goku would have still sensed something from Beerus. So there is no reason for Goku to ask if he has become a SSJGod if he could indeed sense Beerus, even if Beerus was suppressed. It is fair enough that he can't tell how strong Whis is in regard to Beerus, sensing-wise or not. And it's not like an enemy that doesn't have God Ki can't still be powerful enough to provide a Goku a challenge either.

User avatar
Tectorman
Regular
Posts: 600
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 8:19 pm

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Tectorman » Thu Oct 09, 2014 2:38 pm

Hitiro wrote:This does not make much sense. Are you saying SSJGod is a 800x for the multiplier from base? Or are you saying it is 800x 50x Base battle power(Meaning that SSJGod is a 40,000x base battle power)? In the first example I think you are trying to say. SSJGod is only 2x the SSJ3 multiplier. In the second one SSJGod is 100x SSJ3 multiplier.
Well, considering Goku was fighting Beers about as well in Saiyan form as in SSJG, it's better called improvement than multiplier. Multiplier connotes that the base will remain the same after all this and we don't know God Mode works that way. But yes, the improvement is more than x40,000 over Base. I'm including the "more than" because it goes up from my 40,000 assumption, but by how much depends on the given person's impressions on how much it needs to.

Using the manga example, it's way way way more than 16x SSJ, with all the "more than"s doing as much or more work as the x16.
Hitiro wrote:By this quote I am assuming that you are actually saying SSJGod is 2x Boo Saga SSJ3 Goku if you are saying SSJG is only 16x Boo Saga SSJ Goku? In which case that would be absurd. Because if SSJ Gotenks is 2x stronger than SSJ2 Goku then in SSJ3 Gotenks is 4x stronger than SSJ3 Goku. And if we were to assume just for a moment that Gohan is around the same level as Gotenks. Lets just say he is and we'll put Boohan at their level too. Then Boohan would be 8x (4+4 from Boo and Gohan) SSJ3 Goku. SSJ Vegetto is at least 2x that because he wouldn't be able to kick Boo around like he did with anything less. That makes SSJ Vegetto 16x Boo Saga SSJ3 Goku.

In which case, SSJ Vegetto would be stronger than SSJGod Goku if you believe that SSJGod is only 16x Boo Saga SSJ Goku. I assume you actually meant 16x SSJ3 as SSJGod would not be strong at all. Even if you increase Goku's Battle Power by 2x SSJ Vegetto is 50% of SSJGod Goku. And that is if we ignore how strong Gohan was compared to Boo and Gotenks. And how strong SSJ Vegetto was compared to Boohan. For all we know Vegetto could be something like 50% Boohan which would mean that SSJ Vegetto is more along the lines of 200x Boo Saga SSJ3 Goku. Just using the most probably minimum figures though, SSJ Vegetto would not be weak in your scenario of having SSJGod as 16x Boo Saga SSJ Goku.
Nope. Not what I'm saying.

Never minding my low-ending, for the manga example, let's say I go with SSJ Gotenks being 1.75x SSJ2 Goku, Gohan being 1.2x SSJ3 Gotenks, Buutenks being 1.333x Gohan, Buuhan being 1.1x Buutenks, SSJ Vegetto being 2x Buuhan, and SSJG being 3x SSJ Vegetto.

That would give us 16x1.75x1.2x1.333x1.1x2x3. Or 16x18.47538. Which is 295.6; that is to say almost 300x SSJ.

BUT, except for the 16, everything that I put up there was guesstimating. Understand this: I'm not going to pass off my guesstimating as anything other than that. I'm not saying SSJG is 16x SSJ. I'm saying it's a lot more, but the bulk of the work is done by gut feeling.

The anime example also uses gut feeling, just less of it, and it still conveys the magnitude of the difference without needing all the "more than"s.

Get it? I needed to correct myself in making sure to spell out the "more than"s and that they are there in the first place, but I'm unwilling to impose, say, my impression of SSJG being 3x SSJ Vegetto when someone else could say it only needs to be 2.5x.
Hitiro wrote:I don't know if this is a fair assumption considering the only possible fusion they can make in this movie is with the fusion dance. They can't do Potara fusion anymore because there are no more sets of Potara earrings.

So wouldn't this be "hypothetical SSJ Gogeta" rather than "hypothetical SSJ Vegetto"? Pretty sure the Potara fusion is a stronger fusion than the fusion dance.
Three sets of earrings: Kibito's, the Supreme Kai 's, and the Elder Kai's. Kibito and the Supreme Kai each took off one and became Kibitokai (also demonstrating that Potara earrings apparently don't have to be from the same set). The Elder Kai gives Goku his earrings, which later get broken. When Vegeta and Goku get back to the Supreme Kai's world, Kibitokai gives them his earrings (one from Kibito, one from the Supreme Kai), and the two dinguses (dingi?) crush them as well. Leaving two more to go.

Vegetto is still canonically possible. The movie subtitle says "merge with Vegeta", though I'll give you the English dub line, which is "perform fusion with Vegeta". Which allows Gogeta, but considering Beers is said to be stronger than any character in the manga, it's much more likely that this is talking about Vegetto.
Hitiro wrote:Why does Goku need to be able to sense God Ki just because he has God Ki? Let me ask you. Could Freeza sense regular Ki even though he has regular Ki? Could Raditz? Could Nappa? Could Vegeta originally? No. None of them could. Vegeta, and the Z-senshi, had to learn how to do this. Just because Goku has gained God Ki doesn't mean he can all of a sudden sense a new type of Ki. Nothing is explicitly stated in the movie that a person with Regular Ki can't learn a method of sensing God Ki. All we get in the movie is that because Beerus has God Ki they couldn't sense him. And we don't know whether Beerus was saying whether Goku absorbed the God Ki into his regular Ki somehow or whether Goku still maintained God Ki afterwards.
What's the difference between "absorbing God Ki into his Regular Ki" and "maintaining God Ki"?

As far as the characters learning how to sense God Ki via the conventional method, every single thing about this movie says nothing short of a SSJG would be able to do anything about Beers. It's presented as the only possible solution for everything else, so it seems like introducing too many extra parts to say that sensing God Ki is the exception.
Hitiro wrote:Well, one of my points was that Goku asks Beerus if he was a SSJGod. I mean, if Goku could sense Beerus now. And him sensing God Ki was tied to him having God Ki. Why would he ask that?
Because there's a difference between Goku knowing something and we-the-audience knowing something. Goku's never been a god and he wouldn't know whether being able to sense Beers's Ki is part of a failed transformation (albeit, more successful than the non-Videl try) or a successful transformation.
Hitiro wrote:Or... Goku never sensed Beers' Ki. Goku could have determined how strong Beers was through his movement and the way he fights. In the Boo saga, because Dabra wasn't using Ki; he was using magic, Goku and Vegeta determined that Dabra was around the same level as Cell purely based on his movements.
I never got the impression that Dabra was solely using magic. Using magic? Yes. Not using Ki? Not necessarily. After all, Buu uses magic and Ki.
Hitiro wrote:As I also brought up, the fact that Goku can use his teleport can merely be down to him using other sources of Ki as waypoints. As I don't think Goku needs to use his opponent as a Ki source to teleport. He could, for instance, use Gohan or Vegeta and teleport in regards to their position.
And I want to why, if Goku can put such distance between himself and his waypoint guides, he put himself and the exploding Semi-Perfect Cell twenty feet away from King Kai.

Throughout the entire manga, we never see him demonstrate such distance. In fact, I think the most distance we ever see between an Instant Transmission user and the nearest people is Cell teleporting back to earth and lasering Trunks through the heart before anyone knows what's up.

The only instance I can think of where Goku could be using Instant Transmission like that is in GT during his fight with Super 17. And even then, we don't know that Super 17 doesn't have "sense-able" energy, even if we know that at least one of his component parts (the original 17) doesn't.
Twilight: My library?! My library!! Do you have any idea how many books I had in there?!
Lord Tirek: How many, little princess?
Twilight: Over NINE THOUSAND!!!

User avatar
Low Tone G
I'm, pretty, cozy, here...
Posts: 1711
Joined: Tue Feb 04, 2014 8:34 am

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Low Tone G » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:49 pm

Hitiro wrote:
Low Tone G wrote:Goku asked Beerus if he has that power which made him a God. Obviously, he didn't know before what it feels like being a God. And Beerus can suppress himself very well, otherwise when he slapped Bulma, he could kill him as an instant, if he could render SSJ3 Goku unconscious by only touching him, right before that.

As for Whis... Of course Whis suppressed himself immensly as none of Gods can sense him being stronger than the God Of Destruction, and Whis is a Martial Arts Master, after all.

As it was mentioned by an earlier post, Toriyama takes the issue in the simpliest way... Goku doesn't need the SSJ-God form because Goku simply replaced it with his SSJ(respective Base) form. On the poster of the new movie Goku is touching his forehead to access some distant place, he smiles as finally having a good fight again( for me that is what it suggests), the new villain should a be formidable one if Goku smiles to face him. I think he can be really powerful(Godly powerful) if excites Goku, and none of former villains are a challenge now for Goku.
Even suppressed Goku would have still sensed something from Beerus. So there is no reason for Goku to ask if he has become a SSJGod if he could indeed sense Beerus, even if Beerus was suppressed. It is fair enough that he can't tell how strong Whis is in regard to Beerus, sensing-wise or not. And it's not like an enemy that doesn't have God Ki can't still be powerful enough to provide a Goku a challenge either.
Goku had no experience how to use the God Ki and how to sense, so he I can imagine that he was little bit confused what he was sensing then. Whis was the one to say that he managed to become a God, he didn't know that he managed or not. It's easy to understand Goku's reaction after a failed attempt. It's isn't exlucded that can had to get used to the world of Gods, so he did not know what did he feel from Beerus, he had to learn how to comperend the world being a totally new being. I can imagine that his learning period lasted till he finally realised that there was gap of strength between him and Beerus.

Long story short, I think we should get a something in the new movie how did Goku feel in the whole fight against Beerus... I really hope Toriyama will give us more about Goku's experiences.
English is not my first language!
I'm still waiting for Dragon Ball in Super...

User avatar
Hitiro
I Live Here
Posts: 3433
Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2011 8:43 pm

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Hitiro » Thu Oct 09, 2014 4:51 pm

Low Tone G wrote:Goku had no experience how to use the God Ki and how to sense, so he I can imagine that he was little bit confused what he was sensing then. Whis was the one to say that he managed to become a God, he didn't know that he managed or not. It's easy to understand Goku's reaction after a failed attempt. It's isn't exlucded that can had to get used to the world of Gods, so he did not know what did he feel from Beerus, he had to learn how to comperend the world being a totally new being. I can imagine that his learning period lasted till he finally realised that there was gap of strength between him and Beerus.

Long story short, I think we should get a something in the new movie how did Goku feel in the whole fight against Beerus... I really hope Toriyama will give us more about Goku's experiences.
There should be no confusion. If he can sense something from Beerus then that would be a sign that he has God Ki. No? But Goku obviously couldn't sense Beerus here which leads me to believe he couldn't sense. And it was Beerus who said he managed to become a God, not Whis. And Goku long realised the gap of strength between him and Beerus from the previous fight they had. As I said before, Goku and the gang don't need to sense Ki to know how strong someone is. Dabra used magic instead of Ki and they surmised that he was on par with Cell. I'm not saying Goku didn't understand the feeling of being a God. But the movie never suggests Goku can sense Beerus in any way. There are no lines from Goku saying "I have sensed your power and I know I'm still not enough to beat you." Or anything along those lines. All we get from Goku is that he knows Beerus is stronger. Nothing to suggest how he knows that. Whether its through movement and the way Beerus attacks or sensing. So we can't say for certain SSJGod Goku can sense God Ki just at the tip of a hat. The movie also doesn't say explicitly say you need God Ki to sense another God, does it? I would like confirmation on this. A time stamp or screenshot with the dubbed lines. Whatever it is so I can see that it actually says that.

I know they say they can't Sense Beerus because he is using God Ki. But that can merely mean they haven't learnt how to sense God Ki as opposed to regular Ki. It doesn't mean that people with regular Ki can't sense people with God Ki.

User avatar
Low Tone G
I'm, pretty, cozy, here...
Posts: 1711
Joined: Tue Feb 04, 2014 8:34 am

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Low Tone G » Sun Oct 12, 2014 1:52 pm

Hitiro wrote:
Low Tone G wrote:Goku had no experience how to use the God Ki and how to sense, so he I can imagine that he was little bit confused what he was sensing then. Whis was the one to say that he managed to become a God, he didn't know that he managed or not. It's easy to understand Goku's reaction after a failed attempt. It's isn't exlucded that can had to get used to the world of Gods, so he did not know what did he feel from Beerus, he had to learn how to comperend the world being a totally new being. I can imagine that his learning period lasted till he finally realised that there was gap of strength between him and Beerus.

Long story short, I think we should get a something in the new movie how did Goku feel in the whole fight against Beerus... I really hope Toriyama will give us more about Goku's experiences.
There should be no confusion. If he can sense something from Beerus then that would be a sign that he has God Ki. No? But Goku obviously couldn't sense Beerus here which leads me to believe he couldn't sense. And it was Beerus who said he managed to become a God, not Whis. And Goku long realised the gap of strength between him and Beerus from the previous fight they had. As I said before, Goku and the gang don't need to sense Ki to know how strong someone is. Dabra used magic instead of Ki and they surmised that he was on par with Cell. I'm not saying Goku didn't understand the feeling of being a God. But the movie never suggests Goku can sense Beerus in any way. There are no lines from Goku saying "I have sensed your power and I know I'm still not enough to beat you." Or anything along those lines. All we get from Goku is that he knows Beerus is stronger. Nothing to suggest how he knows that. Whether its through movement and the way Beerus attacks or sensing. So we can't say for certain SSJGod Goku can sense God Ki just at the tip of a hat. The movie also doesn't say explicitly say you need God Ki to sense another God, does it? I would like confirmation on this. A time stamp or screenshot with the dubbed lines. Whatever it is so I can see that it actually says that.

I know they say they can't Sense Beerus because he is using God Ki. But that can merely mean they haven't learnt how to sense God Ki as opposed to regular Ki. It doesn't mean that people with regular Ki can't sense people with God Ki.
It has not been stated that Normal Ki possessors can not sense the God Ki, but I think that it's obvious they can not. I mean only some deities can sanse Beerus, the Kais, and Supreme Kais(Kaioshins). It's stated that they felt when Beerus woke up. And Whis definitely said that Goku evolved into a God, and after Beerus somewhat confirmed it.
English is not my first language!
I'm still waiting for Dragon Ball in Super...

User avatar
Hitiro
I Live Here
Posts: 3433
Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2011 8:43 pm

Re: SSJG interference with the multipliers and Kaioken

Post by Hitiro » Mon Oct 13, 2014 8:27 am

Low Tone G wrote:It has not been stated that Normal Ki possessors can not sense the God Ki, but I think that it's obvious they can not. I mean only some deities can sanse Beerus, the Kais, and Supreme Kais(Kaioshins). It's stated that they felt when Beerus woke up. And Whis definitely said that Goku evolved into a God, and after Beerus somewhat confirmed it.
Yes, it's obvious that people with regular Ki can't sense God Ki "right now". But nothing is ever said that they can't learn it ever. Just like how Vegeta couldn't sense Ki originally but he eventually learnt how to. It's kind of a given that beings like the Kaio and the Kaioshin should have sensing abilities vastly outstripping other races. I mean Goku would never have found the Namekian's without the help of the Kaio. I don't think gaining God Ki gives you the automatic ability to sense other God Ki possessors. Just because humans have Ki, for example, doesn't mean they can all automatically sense each other. So Goku being a "God" just means he has Godly Ki. He still relies on all his regular abilities and regular sensing. I mean Goku questioning whether he was a "God" is proof enough that he didn't gain anything extra, from his perspective at least, other than a huge Ki boost. If he could sense God Ki just from obtaining God Ki then I doubt he would have questioned whether he was a God because regardless of whether he found this new "world" confusing. He would still be able to notice to new Ki signatures within his vicinity. Even if they're suppressed. We see several examples throughout the manga and anime of characters registering a new Ki signature close-by. Kind of like a spidey-sense. This never happens to Goku after he gained God Ki so I am still of the belief that sensing God Ki is something you must learn not gain straight away.

Post Reply