It's really frustrating to see people in this thread think and act like they know what's better for DragonBall than the industry veteran mangaka who has been writing more stories professionally than most people have ever dreamed of as a hobby.
Whilst your criticisms and personal opinions of his material are of note, they are pretentious at best and utterly disrespectful at worst. They dismiss the attachment and love Akira Toriyama has for his work, it dismisses his own artistic integrity and ability, and it
erroneously suggests you know what's better for the series more than he does. A series that belongs to him, a series that
he made. Almost everything of what you
love and hate about the series came from his mind, in one way or another. So for any of you to act like it's no longer in the best interest of the series for Akira Toriyama to have majority creative control, I think you've completely lost sight of what made it beautiful in the first place.
My favorite parts of DragonBall were never about the fights. Sure, the huge moments of drama were always thrilling, the fights could sometimes be incredibly creative and engaging, and goodness knows he could ramp up the danger. It was the characters, and the moments between them. It was the story, the adventures, the creativity of a wonderfully talented artist with a penchant for poop jokes.
I don't
give a damn about SUPER SAIYANS anymore. I don't care about Gohan going Super Saiyan, I don't care about the look of Golden Freeza, I (
especially) don't care about the inconsistencies with GT. I'm betting the moment with Kuririn and 18 is going to in fact be an adorable scene, Gohan not being a fighter any more makes perfect sense from a character perspective, Freeza's Hell is
utterly perfect with the exception of Momoiro Clover Z's involvement, and no more Super Saiyans is exactly what the series needs at this point, I feel. It took far too much attention away from other characters who couldn't reach the form and has become a stale concept.
Toriyama has never been perfect. We could sit here all day pointing out flaws with the original series. But keep that in mind whilst plenty of you try and act like these movies are breaking from and disrespecting the spirit of the original series, because Battle of Gods felt more like
actual DragonBall than any single of the 13 DragonBall Z movies before it, introduced wonderful new characters, gave some established characters wonderful moments, and even with it's flaws still managed to be a fun, engaging experience for most.
This movie could totally blow, of course. But considering the fun I had with Battle of Gods, I'm certainly willing to give this film a chance.
Kakarot9001 wrote:fadeddreams5 wrote:Wait, so you're saying you feel Linda Young is closer to Nakao's interpretation of the character than Ayres, and thus, you feel that's why she's more accurate?

Yeah, because Nakao dubs Freeza with a effeminate voice and Freeza in fact has a effeminate appearance and that's how I see Linda Young close to his portrayal
Nakao doesn't make Freeza "effeminate", per se. He portrays him as a soft spoken, haughty aristocratic type. The "feminine quality" you see there isn't supposed to be distinctly female, nor should his overall voice be. It undermines the entire concept of the character to have a woman voicing him, as his entire character portrayal is actually, in some ways, dependent on the masculinity behind the subtle flamboyance and condescending demeanor. This is something that, as has been noted by plenty of users on this forum and other places, Christopher Ayres has accomplished on many occasions.
To plenty of folks here and outside the forums, Linda Young's performance is distinctly female and very much lacks that air of aristocratic superiority. It drops the royal demeanor and doesn't touch on any of his more masculine qualities. Not to mention, her acting as the character has always been terribly forced, partially because of her age and the voice itself being rather difficult to emote in properly. For goodness sakes, she couldn't even keep up with the new scripts; scripts that, I might also add, delivered leaps and bounds over it's predecessors. I have no disrespect for Linda Young, but in my personal opinion, she never had any place voicing a distinctly male character such as Freeza. Chris Ayres has time and again delivered upon the core concept of the character. People much closer to the series than you, both in English and Japanese, believe that. Folks who understand Japanese far and away better than you believe that. The
director for the English dub who has worked on the series personally for over 10 years believes that.
Chris Ayres gives a far more accurate representation of Freeza in the English dub than Linda Young ever did or ever will.
It's as close to fact as one can possibly get in this matter.