Why do fans prefer 4:3?
Moderators: Kanzenshuu Staff, General Help
- JoshuaSaiyajin
- Newbie
- Posts: 14
- Joined: Mon Mar 09, 2015 10:02 am
Why do fans prefer 4:3?
After reading forums in this website and seeing how Toonami broadcasts Kai in this format (and receiving praise for it), it seems that fans prefer Dragon Ball to be at 4:3 when released through home media; Why is that? Is it because it is reminiscent of its original format or is something else?
- Metalwario64
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6180
- Joined: Thu Feb 07, 2008 1:02 am
- Location: Namek
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
Because that's how the original series was framed. When you crop it, even selectively, you are messing with, and hurting the original framing of the series. There are also many shots where you can't crop them without losing something important on the top or bottom.
Plus, what's the point in changing it anyway? At best, it doesn't help anything to crop it (so again, why bother?), and at worst, it ruins the framing and intent of the image.
Plus, what's the point in changing it anyway? At best, it doesn't help anything to crop it (so again, why bother?), and at worst, it ruins the framing and intent of the image.
"Kenshi is sitting down right now drawing his mutated spaghetti monsters thinking he's the shit..."--Neptune Kai
"90% of you here don't even know what you're talking about (there are a few that do). But the things you say about these releases are nonsense and just plain dumb. Like you Metalwario64"--final_flash
"90% of you here don't even know what you're talking about (there are a few that do). But the things you say about these releases are nonsense and just plain dumb. Like you Metalwario64"--final_flash
- TheDevilsCorpse
- Moderator
- Posts: 11378
- Joined: Sun Jun 20, 2010 4:34 am
- Contact:
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
Pretty much. Having the original, intended format is always nice. And with 4:3 home media release you give the fans that want the full, original image (some exceptions apply like Kai 2.0) and the people that want to crop it to 16:9 can basically accomplish the same thing by using the zoom function on their TV. Everyone wins.
- KentalSSJ6
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6473
- Joined: Sun Dec 02, 2012 8:03 am
- Location: Chicago, Illinois.
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?

Green outline is 4:3, red is 16:9.
Doesnt take a rocket scientist to know that the amount of picture getting cropped is obscene, and that is just one frame of animation. Whole episodes will suffer from that same exact level of cropping. It also doesnt help that nearly every 16:9 release of DBZ has looked absolutely horrible, ranging from problems such as crushed blacks, over saturation, and blurred lines while the 4:3 releases have almost constantly looked good with releases such as the sadly cancelled level sets and the Kai releases.
But the average Joe just isnt going to know the details of aspect ratios and sometimes even worse, not care in the slightest and only cares about having his screen completely filmed instead of having two black bars on the sides.
So yeah, the general majority of forum users here prefer 4:3 because it doesnt hurt your eyes looking at it.
Deviantart (NSFW) - http://yamato012.deviantart.com/
DBSW Group Page - http://dbsw.deviantart.com/
Still the 1k Sniper - [spoiler]http://orig10.deviantart.net/6a02/f/201 ... 8npe7r.png[/spoiler]
DBSW Group Page - http://dbsw.deviantart.com/
Still the 1k Sniper - [spoiler]http://orig10.deviantart.net/6a02/f/201 ... 8npe7r.png[/spoiler]
-
- Beyond Newbie
- Posts: 210
- Joined: Wed Jul 18, 2012 12:30 pm
- Location: S.E. Michigan
- Contact:
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
I think Funimation did things bass ackwards. The original shows should be presented in 4:3, as they were originally made. I would have no problem with them panning & scanning DBZ Kai for 16:9 presentation, since that version of the show is altered / modernized anyway.
"...It’s still going to be the same sort of easy-to-understand content as always." - Akira Toriyama, on transitioning from DBZ to DBS.
"Just repeat to yourself, It's just a show,
I should really just relax..." - MST3K theme song
"Just repeat to yourself, It's just a show,
I should really just relax..." - MST3K theme song
- KentalSSJ6
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6473
- Joined: Sun Dec 02, 2012 8:03 am
- Location: Chicago, Illinois.
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
The weird thing is that they do this just with DBZ. Eureka 7 was kept in 4:3 with their bluray release. Yu Yu Hakusho was also.Zillamon51 wrote:I think Funimation did things bass ackwards. The original shows should be presented in 4:3, as they were originally made. I would have no problem with them panning & scanning DBZ Kai for 16:9 presentation, since that version of the show is altered / modernized anyway.
Deviantart (NSFW) - http://yamato012.deviantart.com/
DBSW Group Page - http://dbsw.deviantart.com/
Still the 1k Sniper - [spoiler]http://orig10.deviantart.net/6a02/f/201 ... 8npe7r.png[/spoiler]
DBSW Group Page - http://dbsw.deviantart.com/
Still the 1k Sniper - [spoiler]http://orig10.deviantart.net/6a02/f/201 ... 8npe7r.png[/spoiler]
- JoshuaSaiyajin
- Newbie
- Posts: 14
- Joined: Mon Mar 09, 2015 10:02 am
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
Ah alright I see why cropping it to 16:9 is pretty much a bad idea. Thanks for the answers!
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
As others have pointed out, it's not a general preference for 4:3. It's just that 4:3 is the framing of the original series, and cropping it to other aspect ratios is less than ideal. Most fans in support of the 4:3 releases would also have a negative response to cropping 16:9 footage to 4:3.
-
- Banned
- Posts: 439
- Joined: Sun Feb 08, 2015 10:07 pm
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
Most people on this forum are purists even if the original product is crap (e.x. Toei's version of Z). My reason for being against the 16:9 cropping of the series is that it was created with the 4:3 aspect ratio in mind. When it is cropped, there is the loss of 40% of the original image which sometimes creates awkward shots such as the part where the faces of everyone telling Goku to "do it!" when he's about to kill Kid Buu is cut, leaving only the bottom or top half of a character's face visible. It looks bad, unprofessional, and sloppy. I wouldn't mind it if there weren't any issues, but when watching the episode from the Blu-ray remaster, a few faces were cut off due to the cropping. It bothered me.
My guess is that besides fans apparently wanting the series to be cropped for the releases, cutting 40% of the image for every episode saves time and money. If they crop it then there is 40% less image which means 40% less work to do for every frame. That is basically half of the image. If my math is correct it is almost twice as much work remastering the whole series in 4:3 than 16:9. Instead of remastering 291 episodes they basically did the amount of work that 175 episodes would require if remastered in 4:3.
Is that even possible? If the image is created in 16:9? I mean they could zoom in on the image until it covers a 4:3 aspect ratio but....
My guess is that besides fans apparently wanting the series to be cropped for the releases, cutting 40% of the image for every episode saves time and money. If they crop it then there is 40% less image which means 40% less work to do for every frame. That is basically half of the image. If my math is correct it is almost twice as much work remastering the whole series in 4:3 than 16:9. Instead of remastering 291 episodes they basically did the amount of work that 175 episodes would require if remastered in 4:3.
Cipher wrote:cropping 16:9 footage to 4:3.

-
- Regular
- Posts: 589
- Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2009 11:32 pm
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
It's (obviously) not universal as there are people who, regardless of whether the source material is native 4:3 or 16:9 want the picture to fill the entirety of their TV screen, whether that involves cropping of 16:9 to fit a 4:3 TV or cropping of 4:3 to fit a 16:9 TV but when a product is produced in a particular aspect ratio it is intended to be viewed in that format. There is a short featurette on YouTube with Leonard Nimoy explaining how cropping 16:9 affects the framing of shots.JoshuaSaiyajin wrote:it seems that fans prefer Dragon Ball to be at 4:3 when released through home media; Why is that? Is it because it is reminiscent of its original format or is something else?
A misconception some people have is that HD equals 16:9 and while it is true that a blu-ray picture is 16:9, HD is merely the resolution of the picture regardless of aspect ratio. In the same respect, there is a misconception that all movies are 16:9 but there are plenty of movies (such as Citizen Kane) which are 4:3. In fact, 16:9 was popularized due to the saturation of television which was upgraded from 1.25:1 to 1.33:1 to broadcast films.
With the exception of the movies, all Dragon Ball content was animated and intended to be viewed in a 4:3 format (which leads to inevitable pillarboxing on modern HDTVs) and Blu-ray is supposed to be an archival medium and if I am going to spend money on DB, DBZ or GT on Blu-ray, I want to get the absolute best quality possible and cropping it to appease the people who cannot stand letter or pillarboxing is nothing short of butchering the source material and is no longer archival quality. Simply put, it was designed in 4:3, animated in 4:3 and broadcast in 4:3 therefore it should be presented in 4:3 without exception on home media. At the very least, if companies are so hell bent on manipulating stuff to make them appear "modern" they should include the original unaltered version, just like the original Japanese audio is included.
- Kendamu
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6998
- Joined: Wed Nov 23, 2005 10:31 am
- Location: The Martial Arts World
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
Yeah, you can crop 16:9 to 4:3. It used to be a regular practice back in the day on VHS. There would be a thing saying, "This movie has been formatted to fit your screen." Sometimes, they'd artifically scroll the image, too, in order to show an entire shot that's needed but unable to fit in a 4:3 frame.SpiritBombTriumphant wrote:Is that even possible? If the image is created in 16:9? I mean they could zoom in on the image until it covers a 4:3 aspect ratio but....
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
They used to do this back when televisions were all in 4:3. Home video releases of movies like Star Wars, which had a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, would get cropped to 4:3 for home video releases:SpiritBombTriumphant wrote:Is that even possible? If the image is created in 16:9? I mean they could zoom in on the image until it covers a 4:3 aspect ratio but....
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
Last edited by thaman91 on Mon Apr 27, 2015 2:18 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
This is how nearly all theatrical films were released on home media until the advent of DVDs. And even then, most early DVDs were released in an uncropped "Widescreen" version and a cropped "Fullscreen" one (with 4:3 still being the standard aspect ratio for TVs).SpiritBombTriumphant wrote:Is that even possible? If the image is created in 16:9? I mean they could zoom in on the image until it covers a 4:3 aspect ratio but....
Most realeses would also employ "pan and scan" to ensure essential information remained in-frame.
It's actually kind of shocking to realize there are members here who no longer remember this being a regular practice.
- Herms
- Kanzenshuu Admin Emeritus
- Posts: 10550
- Joined: Thu Oct 21, 2004 6:40 pm
- Location: Jupiter
- Contact:
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
Too young, presumably.Cipher wrote:It's actually kind of shocking to realize there are members here who no longer remember this being a regular practice.
Kanzenshuu: Is that place still around?
Sometimes, I tweet things
We might, if they screamed all the time, for no good reason.
Sometimes, I tweet things
We might, if they screamed all the time, for no good reason.
- clutchins
- Beyond-the-Beyond Newbie
- Posts: 412
- Joined: Wed Jun 11, 2014 5:52 pm
- Location: Mt. Paozu
- Contact:
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
We get so caught up in cropping issues because it's thankfully the only aspect ratio problem DBZ has. I know all the Star Wars fans/collectors are plenty familiar with Pan and Scan.Herms wrote:Too young, presumably.Cipher wrote:It's actually kind of shocking to realize there are members here who no longer remember this being a regular practice.
NC's resident Dragon Ball superfan
Episode Guides: [ DB | DBZ Uncut | DBZ Edited | DBGT | Movies/Specials | Kai ]
Episode Guides: [ DB | DBZ Uncut | DBZ Edited | DBGT | Movies/Specials | Kai ]
Kamiccolo9 wrote:I mean, you're pretty open about looking at cartoon porn. Why would you do that? It's fiction. The proportions of these women are not possible to reach in reality.JacobYBM wrote:No, why would it? It's fiction. The strength of the characters is not possible to reach in reality.Original Thread Topic wrote:Did Dragon Ball ever motivate you to exercise?
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
Kendamu wrote:Yeah, you can crop 16:9 to 4:3. It used to be a regular practice back in the day on VHS. There would be a thing saying, "This movie has been formatted to fit your screen." Sometimes, they'd artifically scroll the image, too, in order to show an entire shot that's needed but unable to fit in a 4:3 frame.SpiritBombTriumphant wrote:Is that even possible? If the image is created in 16:9? I mean they could zoom in on the image until it covers a 4:3 aspect ratio but....
Open Matte was also the way it used to be transferred to home video. I used to buy 80s horror movies on VHS to get the open matte versions

Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
FUNimation's old DBZ movie singles would qualify as open matte, for what it's worth.
Blue wrote:I love how Season 2 is so off color even the box managed to be so.
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
It's basically the same as this:


In Japan, that kind of "full screen" practice completely died out during the VHS era, so I was very surprised when I learned that it had been still alive even on DVD in the US.Cipher wrote:It's actually kind of shocking to realize there are members here who no longer remember this being a regular practice.
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
That's interesting. I wonder if it has to do with the fact that, if I understand correctly, home media has always been viewed as more of a luxury item in Japan (thus being more responsive to videophile interests), whereas it's much more commonplace in the U.S. (thus concerned with marketing toward audiences who may not understand aspect ratios that don't fill their screens).kei17 wrote:In Japan, that kind of "full screen" practice completely died out during the VHS era, so I was very surprised when I learned that it had been still alive even on DVD in the US.
Re: Why do fans prefer 4:3?
Yeah, that must be one of the main reasons. Also, in Japan, original aspect ratio tends to be respected on any kind of media. I often see drastically cropped old videotape footage when I watch documentaries from foregin countries, but it rarely happens in Japanese documentaries. Also, old TV shows all air in 4:3 with side bars. The only exceptions I know are some anime produced by Nippon Animation such as Heidi (16:9) and a few dramas from the '90 that air on BS Fuji (cropped down to the action-safe area.) And of course, reversioned shows like Kai don't count here. In addition, their preference for subtitles might have been a major reason. Subtitles are easier to read with a black bar at the bottom of the screen.Cipher wrote:That's interesting. I wonder if it has to do with the fact that, if I understand correctly, home media has always been viewed as more of a luxury item in Japan (thus being more responsive to videophile interests), whereas it's much more commonplace in the U.S. (thus concerned with marketing toward audiences who may not understand aspect ratios that don't fill their screens).kei17 wrote:In Japan, that kind of "full screen" practice completely died out during the VHS era, so I was very surprised when I learned that it had been still alive even on DVD in the US.