Kamiccolo9 wrote:You know, Kunzait, I'm kind of surprised you don't have at least a minor interest in Yugioh. Even beyond the show, there are literally thousands of callbacks and references to various mythologies, historical and cultural events, and pop culture, both eastern and western. I mean, I don't play the game or indulge in the franchise all that much anymore, but the anime artwork alone for a bunch of the things I've spent the last several years studying is interesting, to say the least.
I know about those aspects of it. The one among the bunch that it touches on that's by far the most interesting to me is Egyptian lore, because Egyptian myth is in general WAY too criminally under-utilized and glossed over by a ton of geek media in general. Its a very rich cultural history that by all means should be delved into more often by more stuff in general.
I've been shown some of the anime back in maybe the mid-ish 2000s. Its... not good, to put it charitably. Or less charitably, its kinda hot garbage. I mean yes, it sort of pays lip service to these folkloric creatures & concepts, but it doesn't really DO anything interesting with them or even give them that much real focus as anything more than themes for the cards. Much of the time (based on what I'd seen at least) they're just kind of used as a cheap prop. Mostly its just a shitty, crass commercial for a children's card game. Just like Transformers was never at any point anything more than a shitty, crass commercial for toys.
And the artwork for the anime is... also not in any which way good generally I don't think. It's not in any way visually distinctive, beyond Yugi's absurdly stupid hair at least, and doesn't really do anything to pass itself from any other generic Shonen/Pokemon ripoff thing besides sticking some Egyptian glyphs over some random things. The whole thing has an air of a trashy, chintzy, Wal-Mart-esque cash grab. I file it firmly under "its the nostalgia talking" whenever people hype it up as this defining, classic anime. The same people will often usually hype up other similar stuff like the Pokemon anime or Digimon in a similar fashion. And in all cases, its primarily because they "grew up with it". The case made for these sorts of shows generally always begins and ends there.
Sadly, I've done my time on a bunch of these kinds of "gotta collect em all!" anime shows (mostly back in college, as a consequence of fandom at the time most over-eagerly pushing this crap), even subbed, and (not that this is anything the least bit earth shatteringly revelatory) there's nothing of any value to any of these shows at all, other than placating toddlers for a half hour at a time and selling them plastic shit. The characters are all hollow nothings whose "middle school cool" appeal is not only eye-rollingly lame in itself but also something that's clearly the product of being market/focus group tested to within an inch of its life. The core stories and concepts themselves are vapid nonsense (that occasionally make VERY shallow, featherweight use of actually interesting cultural motifs), and the entire crux of their very existence is very obviously (to the point where your face is suffocatingly rubbed in it) to hype you up to mindlessly buy and collect garbage.
Yes, there's vague allusions & connections to some cool bits of mythical folklore in some of them, but you can EASILY do WAY infinitely fucking better at finding vastly more worthwhile material out there that puts said-folklore to vastly,
vastly better use. Like without even having to try that hard.
The Yu Gi Oh manga I know is in most respects a
totally different story from the anime. I didn't really have any intention of looking through it for a long while (I'd already seen things like the Pokemon manga and suchlike and didn't think YGO's would be much different), but Rocketman sold me pretty thoroughly on at least trying it out anyway awhile back. Still haven't quite gotten around to that, but its somewhere on the back burner. Apparently it supposedly does a LOT more with the occult/folkloric angle than the anime ever does (and Rocketman wasn't the first person I've heard say that either, lending a bit more veracity to the claim), particularly the Egyptian stuff. Hopefully its worth a look, but its not at the top of my priority list by any stretch. I'm exceedingly wary of this sort of thing in general by this point.
But either way, having references to fascinating international mythology and folklore is all perfectly well and good, but that alone in itself isn't very interesting if you're not actually
using them well. I'll reserve judgement on the YGO manga, but the anime is a sack of awful just like the rest of its "collectible Shonen" brethren.
For all its many numerous faults, I give Dragon Ball this much credit: not only does it actually make WAY more creative use of its cultural roots than a ton of Shonen after it generally tends to, but no matter how popular or commercial it became, the core series (the manga, most of everything pre-GT basically) is just about always clearly the product of a singular author with a singular creative voice (silly and flighty as that voice was) and the freedom to do with it whatever he pleases. The marketing tail rarely ever wags the dog, which considering the level of kiddie sales juggernaut the series became is honestly kind of astounding. Its almost a unicorn in that particular regard.
TL;DR - Chintzy children's toy commercial show turns out to have little to no artistic or creative value. Who knew?