Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Discussion, generally of an in-universe nature, regarding any aspect of the franchise (including movies, spin-offs, etc.) such as: techniques, character relationships, internal back-history, its universe, and more.

Moderators: Kanzenshuu Staff, General Help

User avatar
MasenkoHA
Born 'n Bred Here
Posts: 6924
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2017 9:38 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by MasenkoHA » Thu Feb 27, 2025 8:01 am

Luso Saiyan wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 6:14 am

That very sentence (bolded for emphasis) is the basis of my remark that it's their Saiyan pride talking. It's not about him being stronger or weaker. It's about them doing things by themselves, with their own skills. In addition, Pure Buu is also not relying on anyone else.
And once again we are all pointing out that Goku's Saiyan pride didn't apply to any Boo stronger han Fat Boo or Pure Boo.

Bootenks? Gohan you need to fuse with me!

Booccolo? Eh Gohan you can take him on your own

Boohan? - Fuck fuck I need to fuse with someone! Dende? Mr.Satan? I guess Satan is technically a martial artist it might help . Oh good Vegeta is here. Vegeta set aside your Kami-sama damn pride for 5 seconds and fuse with me! We are so fucked if we don't!

Inside Boo after Vegetto defused? Fuck Vegeta you idiot! Now we have to restore him to his original form to beat him. Oh shit see what I mean we could have stopped Super Boo if we were still fused. Wanna Fusion Dance? Ugh nevermind bitch

Pure Boo, with a new chance to fuse? - eh we don't need it. He's not fused either anymore.



If he can set his pride aside for the Boo fusions but decided he could 1 v 1 Pure Boo, What. Do. You. Think. That. Means?

Eu sou Perfeito
Temporarily Banned
Posts: 30
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2023 2:28 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by Eu sou Perfeito » Thu Feb 27, 2025 9:52 am

Luso Saiyan wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 6:14 am
MasenkoHA wrote: Wed Feb 26, 2025 5:28 pmIf we completely ignore him scolding Vegeta TWICE for destroying the potara earring.
Huh?! How am I ignoring it when I have acknowledged that twice in my comments?
MasenkoHA wrote: Wed Feb 26, 2025 5:28 pmKid Boo being the most dangerous because he's impulsive and unhinged doesn't make him the strongest.
Ah! I'm glad that at least him being the most dangerous is not a point of contention.
Zephyr wrote: Wed Feb 26, 2025 6:39 pmHis pride as a martial artist/Saiyan is not mentioned. I suppose you could interpret his refusal as his pride as a martial artist/Saiyan, but you can just easily interpret that as his pride as an individual and his absolute contempt for Goku as a person. The latter interpretation squares more easily with everything else Vegeta does inside of Boo.
Pride is pride.
Zephyr wrote: Wed Feb 26, 2025 6:39 pmNext chapter, when Boo shows up inside himself, Goku again yells at Vegeta for not keeping the Potara on. After Goku fails to blast a hole out of Boo's head, Vegeta smugly clings to the pod that contains the Good Boo, and says:
"What happens if I tear this one off? Will you turn back to fat Boo? Or skinny Boo? Either way, you'll be weaker."
And Super Buu gets afraid not because he would be weaker, but because he would cease to be himself. Power is not a factor. Consciousness is.
Zephyr wrote: Wed Feb 26, 2025 6:39 pmNext chapter, after he's reverted back to the pure Boo, Vegeta laughs, and then smugly says "Look at our little friend!"
Goku says: "Yeah! We can take him!"
That's their superficial, cocky remark based on how he looks, which is specifically contrasted with Kibitoshin's reaction, who knows more than them.
Zephyr wrote: Wed Feb 26, 2025 6:39 pmNext chapter, in the Kaioshin Realm, Kibitoshin throws them a new set of Potara, and says "Here!! Before any more planets get destroyed!!"
Goku says: "......no thanks. We'll do without 'em. ...Sorry...it's not our style...we like to rely on ourselves. Boo's on his own now, too."
That very sentence (bolded for emphasis) is the basis of my remark that it's their Saiyan pride talking. It's not about him being stronger or weaker. It's about them doing things by themselves, with their own skills. In addition, Pure Buu is also not relying on anyone else.
Eu sou Perfeito wrote: Wed Feb 26, 2025 6:19 pmEu queria incluir um item nessa discussão que é o: fator narrativo. Todos nós mesmos sabemos que depois da Saga Cell, Akira que Gohan assumisse o manto de protagonista, porém nós sabemos que no final quem terminou a saga como sendo herói principal foi: Goku. Nas sagas anteriores(Saiyan e Freeza) terminaram com Goku sendo o guerreiro Z/herói mais forte, a partir das Saga Cell, quase perto de seu final, Gohan assume o papel de herói e se torna o guerreiro Z mais poderoso superando até mesmo o seu pai, o arco do Majin Buu teria essa mesma fórmula: Gohan + Protagonista = O Guerreiro mais forte. Goku dentro da trama seria um personagem secundário que teria um pouco de destaque e teria o propósito de treinar a nova geração guerreiros(Goten e Trunks) que enfrentariam o vilão principal.
No, that's not true at all: https://www.kanzenshuu.com/intended-end/boo/

In the interview itself, Akira intended to leave Gohan with the role of main character.
Interviewer: And then the Cell arc ended. Did you think that everyone felt you would put Gohan into the leading role?

Akira Toriyama: I intended to put Gohan into the leading role. It didn’t work out. I felt that compared to Goku, he was ultimately not suited for the part.

In this interview she says something similar:

https://www.kanzenshuu.com/translations ... b-version/
At the time Son Gohan was turning into the main character, wasn’t he?
Toriyama:
Yeah! I figured Goku was getting old, and it was time to switch over to the next generation.
Toyotarō:
That’s what Goku himself said in the Majin Boo arc.

Toriyama:
But drawing Gohan’s daily life made me gradually realize he likes studying more than fighting (laughs). Later on he even lost his dōgi (laughs).


Toriyama had plans for Gohan to be the protagonist/the strongest, and this happened for a short period of time, Gohan unlocks his hidden powers, becomes the strongest warrior and return to being the main hero of the story, the one who would defeat the villain of the saga, but this happened because the author was not satisfied with Goku's son being the protagonist and much less being the one who would defeat the main villain of this arc.

I had already spoken about this item before in my previous answer.
Os planos inicias do Toriyama era que Gotenks e Gohan fossem os principais e os mais fortes da Saga(Gohan ocupando 1° posição) e Goku só seria um personagem que daria ajudaria os personagens principais (foi por esse motivo ele que colocou Goku como sendo incapaz de derrotar Good Buu), mas aí por volta dos penúltimos capítulos, ele decide de mudar porque na sua visão como autor Gohan não era adequado para ocupar o papel de herói da narrativa assim como seu pai, então, Goku voltar a ter o protagonismo, Akira faz com que ele volte age como ele, resgatando a sua personalidade de sempre querer lutar contra oponentes fortes em 1vs1, ele mudar o nível de poder do personagem, deixando de ser: <Fat Buu, para: >Fat Buu e também têm todo aquele monólogo do Vegeta dizendo que somente ele(Goku) pode vencer Kid Buu Buu e que ele é o Número 1 esse "Número 1" reflete do pensamento do autor, Akira já disse que Goku é o mais puro mais forte do universo, ele é o número 1.

User avatar
Zephyr
I Live Here
Posts: 4348
Joined: Sat Mar 27, 2010 9:20 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by Zephyr » Thu Feb 27, 2025 11:03 am

Luso Saiyan wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 6:14 am
Zephyr wrote: Wed Feb 26, 2025 6:39 pmNext chapter, in the Kaioshin Realm, Kibitoshin throws them a new set of Potara, and says "Here!! Before any more planets get destroyed!!"
Goku says: "......no thanks. We'll do without 'em. ...Sorry...it's not our style...we like to rely on ourselves. Boo's on his own now, too."
That very sentence (bolded for emphasis) is the basis of my remark that it's their Saiyan pride talking..
Yes, but a convincing case that Saiyan pride influenced Vegeta's words and actions inside of Boo remains to be made.

Fighting somebody 2v1 isn't "Saiyan pride". Deliberately and happily weakening your opponent isn't "Saiyan pride". Refusing to fuse with Goku could be read as "Saiyan pride", but it is more straightforwardly read as hating Goku's guts, based on what he actually says in all of the surrounding context. These two things aren't unrelated, but it's important to be clear about what is the more direct and explicit thing motivating Vegeta's words and actions. Vegetto's entire existence is bookended by Vegeta's hatred of Goku.

In Chapter 503 (Viz 309):
Goku says: "Vegeta!! Put this Potara earring on your right ear!! Please!!"
Vegeta says: "...Why...?"
Goku says: "So we can combine!! We'll be unbeatable!!"
Vegeta says: "Combine? You actually think I'd combine with you...? Don't make me laugh!"
Goku says: "Arrgh! I knew you'd say that! But it's the only way to beat Boo!!"
Vegeta says: "In that case...I'd rather die.
Goku says: "Please, Vegeta! You've gotta put it on!!! This is no time for pride!! This is doomsday!!"
Vegeta says: "......I hate you for it... When you fought me--you hid your true strength!! Were you manipulating me--or mocking me?! I saw it all in the afterlife! "Super Saiyan 3"!!? You turn my stomach!! You think I want to be one with you?!"
Goku says: "...I-I'm sorry, there was a limit to how long I could transform...I had to save it for later, just in case..."
Vegeta says: "Don't make excuses. The facts don't change. You mocked me..."

Then Goku explains how Boo absorbed everyone, and Vegeta begrudgingly caves and get Vegetto. Then we get all of the stuff inside of Boo, such as Vegeta saying, multiple times, that he does not want to share a body with Goku again.

Vegeta hates Goku during this section of the story, more than usual. And no, pride isn't pride. You put pride in something. You are proud of something. And pride in one thing is not pride in another thing. That's not how language works. Vegeta's "pride" that Goku explicitly refers to here is the pride that he trampled all over in holding back during their earlier fight. It is because Goku did not respect Vegeta's pride as a warrior enough to go all out against him that Vegeta is so angry with Goku. It is because he is so angry with Goku that he refuses to share a body with him. It's not about Vegeta trying to avoid dishonoring himself by relying on the strength of another for a cheap advantage, it's about Vegeta being angry about Goku previously dishonoring him, to the point that he'd rather die than share a body with the guy.

Nothing that Vegeta says here, or inside of Boo, is evocative of what Goku says in the Kaioshin Realm.

---

Finally, you aren't acknowledging the point that Goku also has martial artist/Saiyan pride. This is the guy who gave Piccolo a free hit at the tournament. This is the guy who spared Vegeta to get a rematch. This is the guy who let Freeza power up to 100%. This is the guy who really wanted to fight Dr. Gero's monsters. This is the guy who gave Cell a senzu. This is who Goku is, and he does not need to be reminded by Vegeta to be himself.

Now, on the flip side, this is also the guy who will 2v1 Raditz to save his son when there's no chance of winning in a fair fight, the guy who will rely on the strength of others to use the Genki Dama when there's no chance of winning in a fair fight, the guy who will rely on his much more powerful son to defeat the enemy when there's no chance of himself winning in a fair fight.

Goku is the kind of guy who will treat life and death battles like tournament matches, until it is clear that the match is lost, at which point he will use every dirty trick he can think of in order to make sure that the bad guy is defeated. He fucks around when he thinks he's got this, and if it becomes clear that he doesn't got this, he stops fucking around and goes for the kill.

He wants to use fusion when his back is to the wall and there is no winnable tournament match to be had. He breaks the Potara and says "it wouldn't be fair to Boo" when he thinks he's got this and is down to fuck around. That is because he is so much weaker than the fused Boo that there is no winnable tournament match to be had, and the pure unfused Boo is close enough to his level that there is a winnable tournament match to be had. Or so he thought; he didn't and couldn't yet know how short a match that a living Super Saiyan 3 is able to actually enjoy.

I understand this might be a little confusing to follow, because Goku typically fucks around first, and then later has to use his dirtiest tricks. So him giving Boo a fair fight after trying to use Potara is structurally unconventional by Dragon Ball standards. But, on the other hand, he ends up opting for the Genki Dama later anyway once the tournament match proves unwinnable, so it's not a complete inversion.

Either way, your analysis is neglecting a ton of very important characterization, from the way Goku's pride enters or leaves the driver's seat depending on the circumstances, to Vegeta's explicitly stated hatred for Goku and how that impacts his desire to share a body with the man.

User avatar
dbgtFO
Kicks it Old-School
Posts: 7941
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:07 pm
Contact:

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by dbgtFO » Thu Feb 27, 2025 2:45 pm

Toriyama only has Goku fight Fat Buu and Kid Buu. Against every iteration of Super Buu, Goku either tells someone else to fight him or directly admits he is straight up weaker and wants to use any form of merging against him, even coming extremely close to permanently merging with Mr. Fucking Satan. He never exchanges fists with any form of Super Buu, all confrontations are immediately and conveniently interrupted by something, that stops Buu from laying a finger on him.

Clearly this is Toriyama obviously telling us that Goku and Kid Buu are >> everything that came before. Another win for those with extremely advanced reading comprehension!!!

As usual this is and always has been a Toei-ism. The abhorrent disregard of all logic in favour of some stupidly hyped up "Battle for the Universe!!" that apparently can't be cool without the villain being stronger than ever, because kids are just that dumb apparently and wouldn't get excited for anything less.
It's a great example of what is fundamentally wrong with debates, discourse and discussions on issues more important than DB.
Oh well

Eu sou Perfeito
Temporarily Banned
Posts: 30
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2023 2:28 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by Eu sou Perfeito » Thu Feb 27, 2025 4:18 pm

Zephyr wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 11:03 am
Luso Saiyan wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 6:14 am
Zephyr wrote: Wed Feb 26, 2025 6:39 pmNext chapter, in the Kaioshin Realm, Kibitoshin throws them a new set of Potara, and says "Here!! Before any more planets get destroyed!!"
Goku says: "......no thanks. We'll do without 'em. ...Sorry...it's not our style...we like to rely on ourselves. Boo's on his own now, too."
That very sentence (bolded for emphasis) is the basis of my remark that it's their Saiyan pride talking..
Yes, but a convincing case that Saiyan pride influenced Vegeta's words and actions inside of Boo remains to be made.

Fighting somebody 2v1 isn't "Saiyan pride". Deliberately and happily weakening your opponent isn't "Saiyan pride". Refusing to fuse with Goku could be read as "Saiyan pride", but it is more straightforwardly read as hating Goku's guts, based on what he actually says in all of the surrounding context. These two things aren't unrelated, but it's important to be clear about what is the more direct and explicit thing motivating Vegeta's words and actions. Vegetto's entire existence is bookended by Vegeta's hatred of Goku.

In Chapter 503 (Viz 309):
Goku says: "Vegeta!! Put this Potara earring on your right ear!! Please!!"
Vegeta says: "...Why...?"
Goku says: "So we can combine!! We'll be unbeatable!!"
Vegeta says: "Combine? You actually think I'd combine with you...? Don't make me laugh!"
Goku says: "Arrgh! I knew you'd say that! But it's the only way to beat Boo!!"
Vegeta says: "In that case...I'd rather die.
Goku says: "Please, Vegeta! You've gotta put it on!!! This is no time for pride!! This is doomsday!!"
Vegeta says: "......I hate you for it... When you fought me--you hid your true strength!! Were you manipulating me--or mocking me?! I saw it all in the afterlife! "Super Saiyan 3"!!? You turn my stomach!! You think I want to be one with you?!"
Goku says: "...I-I'm sorry, there was a limit to how long I could transform...I had to save it for later, just in case..."
Vegeta says: "Don't make excuses. The facts don't change. You mocked me..."

Then Goku explains how Boo absorbed everyone, and Vegeta begrudgingly caves and get Vegetto. Then we get all of the stuff inside of Boo, such as Vegeta saying, multiple times, that he does not want to share a body with Goku again.

Vegeta hates Goku during this section of the story, more than usual. And no, pride isn't pride. You put pride in something. You are proud of something. And pride in one thing is not pride in another thing. That's not how language works. Vegeta's "pride" that Goku explicitly refers to here is the pride that he trampled all over in holding back during their earlier fight. It is because Goku did not respect Vegeta's pride as a warrior enough to go all out against him that Vegeta is so angry with Goku. It is because he is so angry with Goku that he refuses to share a body with him. It's not about Vegeta trying to avoid dishonoring himself by relying on the strength of another for a cheap advantage, it's about Vegeta being angry about Goku previously dishonoring him, to the point that he'd rather die than share a body with the guy.

Nothing that Vegeta says here, or inside of Boo, is evocative of what Goku says in the Kaioshin Realm.

---

Finally, you aren't acknowledging the point that Goku also has martial artist/Saiyan pride. This is the guy who gave Piccolo a free hit at the tournament. This is the guy who spared Vegeta to get a rematch. This is the guy who let Freeza power up to 100%. This is the guy who really wanted to fight Dr. Gero's monsters. This is the guy who gave Cell a senzu. This is who Goku is, and he does not need to be reminded by Vegeta to be himself.

Now, on the flip side, this is also the guy who will 2v1 Raditz to save his son when there's no chance of winning in a fair fight, the guy who will rely on the strength of others to use the Genki Dama when there's no chance of winning in a fair fight, the guy who will rely on his much more powerful son to defeat the enemy when there's no chance of himself winning in a fair fight.

Goku is the kind of guy who will treat life and death battles like tournament matches, until it is clear that the match is lost, at which point he will use every dirty trick he can think of in order to make sure that the bad guy is defeated. He fucks around when he thinks he's got this, and if it becomes clear that he doesn't got this, he stops fucking around and goes for the kill.

He wants to use fusion when his back is to the wall and there is no winnable tournament match to be had. He breaks the Potara and says "it wouldn't be fair to Boo" when he thinks he's got this and is down to fuck around. That is because he is so much weaker than the fused Boo that there is no winnable tournament match to be had, and the pure unfused Boo is close enough to his level that there is a winnable tournament match to be had. Or so he thought; he didn't and couldn't yet know how short a match that a living Super Saiyan 3 is able to actually enjoy.

I understand this might be a little confusing to follow, because Goku typically fucks around first, and then later has to use his dirtiest tricks. So him giving Boo a fair fight after trying to use Potara is structurally unconventional by Dragon Ball standards. But, on the other hand, he ends up opting for the Genki Dama later anyway once the tournament match proves unwinnable, so it's not a complete inversion.

Either way, your analysis is neglecting a ton of very important characterization, from the way Goku's pride enters or leaves the driver's seat depending on the circumstances, to Vegeta's explicitly stated hatred for Goku and how that impacts his desire to share a body with the man.
Regarding Goku's statement about him and Vegeta being no match for Super Buu's strength, there is one factor that you and other people in this post fail to take into account when using this argument to defend Super Buu's superiority over Kid Buu, which is "narrative context". In chapter 509, Goku said he could have defeated Fat Buu with his SSJ3, okay, everyone already knows that, but, during the previous chapters Goku said several times that he was not able to defeat Fat Buu, and that his only way to defeat him would be: fighting as a team with Vegeta and Gohan (all using stage 2 of the Super Saiyan) or merging with 1 of the 2.
Chapter: 469 (DBZ 275), P5.3-4
Goku: “…I’ll be frank. It’s no use. I can’t defeat [Majin Boo]. [ ] …There was practically no gap between Vegeta’s true strength and mine…And Majin Boo is still fine despite Vegeta sacrificing himself, right? Sorry, but I couldn’t win, no matter what.”
Chapter: 472 (DBZ 278), P10.7
Context: after Goten and Trunks question Goku’s power and Piccolo gets mad
Goku: “It’s alright, Piccolo…I really am weak. It don’t look like I can beat Majin Boo, not even a little bit.”


Even when Goku introduced Super Saiyan 3, he still didn't see a chance of finishing off this Majin Buu, even with his new super powerful transformation.
Chapter: 476 (DBZ 282), P10.5-8, P11.1-3
Piccolo: “Goku…There’s something I want to ask you while I’ve got the chance…[ ] …That Super Saiyan 3 thing earlier…if you had gone all-out, wouldn’t you have been able to defeat Majin Boo?...How about it, am I wrong?”
Goku: “Nah, I don’t know…When it comes to Majin Boo’s strength, it’s like a lie…I think that I probably couldn’t have won…”

At this exact point in the story, Akira treats Goku as being an inferior character (power) to Majin Buu (Good), and this was considered to be true throughout most of the Buu Saga story, with the arrival of chapter 509, Toriyama causes a retcon/debunking in Goku's strength scale, making the character stop being weaker than Fat Buu, and becoming stronger than that Buu.

Then, when Goku says this:
Goku: “Wait! Even though Boo has returned to normal a whole lot, we’re still simply no match for his strength! If we go outside like this, we’ll definitely be done in…!”
The author at this point in the story still considers: Fat Buu>Goku Ssj3.

User avatar
Zephyr
I Live Here
Posts: 4348
Joined: Sat Mar 27, 2010 9:20 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by Zephyr » Thu Feb 27, 2025 4:42 pm

Eu sou Perfeito wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 4:18 pmRegarding Goku's statement about him and Vegeta being no match for Super Buu's strength, there is one factor that you and other people in this post fail to take into account when using this argument to defend Super Buu's superiority over Kid Buu, which is "narrative context".
No, I discussed quite a bit of narrative context, actually.

Goku saying "I couldn't have defeated the fat Boo using Super Saiyan 3" is something that is later explicitly established to be a lie.

Goku saying "We cannot defeat the fused Boo without using fusion" is not something that is later explicitly established to be a lie.

A convincing case that the second statement should be understood (retroactively) as a lie remains to be made.

Eu sou Perfeito
Temporarily Banned
Posts: 30
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2023 2:28 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by Eu sou Perfeito » Thu Feb 27, 2025 5:01 pm

Zephyr wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 4:42 pm
Eu sou Perfeito wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 4:18 pmRegarding Goku's statement about him and Vegeta being no match for Super Buu's strength, there is one factor that you and other people in this post fail to take into account when using this argument to defend Super Buu's superiority over Kid Buu, which is "narrative context".
No, I discussed quite a bit of narrative context, actually.

Goku saying "I couldn't have defeated the fat Boo using Super Saiyan 3" is something that is later explicitly established to be a lie.

Goku saying "We cannot defeat the fused Boo without using fusion" is not something that is later explicitly established to be a lie.

A convincing case that the second statement should be understood (retroactively) as a lie remains to be made.
There is also the argument that he would not use Super Saiyan 3 against Super Buu and that at most he would only use Ssj2.

User avatar
Hugo Boss
Born 'n Bred Here
Posts: 5030
Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2013 3:04 pm
Location: Brazil

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by Hugo Boss » Thu Feb 27, 2025 6:58 pm

That argument would only work if Goku had implied any issue in using SS3 against Super Buu, but there’s no indication of that. In fact, he had no problem using SS3 when fighting Buu with Gotenks absorbed, so the idea that he would hold back against a weaker version of Buu doesn’t really track.

The reason he didn’t use SS3 earlier seems to be what he explicitly stated: he didn’t think he and Vegeta stood a chance without fusion. If someone wants to argue that he would have only used SS2 against Super Buu, they’d need to show some actual in-universe reasoning for why Goku would voluntarily handicap himself against an opponent he already considered too strong.

User avatar
MasenkoHA
Born 'n Bred Here
Posts: 6924
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2017 9:38 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by MasenkoHA » Fri Feb 28, 2025 7:45 am

Eu sou Perfeito wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 5:01 pm
Zephyr wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 4:42 pm
Eu sou Perfeito wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 4:18 pmRegarding Goku's statement about him and Vegeta being no match for Super Buu's strength, there is one factor that you and other people in this post fail to take into account when using this argument to defend Super Buu's superiority over Kid Buu, which is "narrative context".
No, I discussed quite a bit of narrative context, actually.

Goku saying "I couldn't have defeated the fat Boo using Super Saiyan 3" is something that is later explicitly established to be a lie.

Goku saying "We cannot defeat the fused Boo without using fusion" is not something that is later explicitly established to be a lie.

A convincing case that the second statement should be understood (retroactively) as a lie remains to be made.
There is also the argument that he would not use Super Saiyan 3 against Super Buu and that at most he would only use Ssj2.
He used Super Saiyan 3 against Fat Boo. Do you think Fat Boo is stronger than Super Boo?

He didn't want to burn unnecessary energy for an opponent he wasn't going to be able to defeat anyways .

User avatar
Jack Bz
Regular
Posts: 582
Joined: Thu Mar 14, 2013 10:44 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by Jack Bz » Fri Feb 28, 2025 8:51 pm

This is just for my own curiosity: do the people arguing that kid boo is the strongest boo also argue that Goku is stronger than all forms of boo besides kid boo? Because he's pretty much terrified and refuses to fight super boo, gotenks boo AND gohan boo alone at any opportunity.

Image

The way Toriyama drew Goku literally curled up defensively in fear at an approaching Gotenks Boo is itself pretty damning. Not to mention old Kaioshin moments before straight up saying that him and Gohan working together don't stand a chance. There's just so many levels that it doesn't make sense.

Eu sou Perfeito
Temporarily Banned
Posts: 30
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2023 2:28 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by Eu sou Perfeito » Fri Feb 28, 2025 10:41 pm

Jack Bz wrote: Fri Feb 28, 2025 8:51 pm This is just for my own curiosity: do the people arguing that kid boo is the strongest boo also argue that Goku is stronger than all forms of boo besides kid boo? Because he's pretty much terrified and refuses to fight super boo, gotenks boo AND gohan boo alone at any opportunity.

Image

The way Toriyama drew Goku literally curled up defensively in fear at an approaching Gotenks Boo is itself pretty damning. Not to mention old Kaioshin moments before straight up saying that him and Gohan working together don't stand a chance. There's just so many levels that it doesn't make sense.
Toriyama, when he still intended to leave Gohan as the main character, wrote Goku in this story of this arc as being a weaker character than Fat Buu, as he was not the protagonist, the one who would fight the final villain, Earth's only hope.
Chapter: 472 (DBZ 278), P10.7
Context: after Goten and Trunks question Goku’s power and Piccolo gets mad
Goku: “It’s alright, Piccolo…I really am weak. It don’t look like I can beat Majin Boo, not even a little bit.”
Piccolo: “Goku…There’s something I want to ask you while I’ve got the chance…[ ] …That Super Saiyan 3 thing earlier…if you had gone all-out, wouldn’t you have been able to defeat Majin Boo?...How about it, am I wrong?”
Goku: “Nah, I don’t know…When it comes to Majin Boo’s strength, it’s like a lie…I think that I probably couldn’t have won…”

Only from chapter 503 onwards, Goku returns to prominence alongside Vegeta and in chapter 509~519, he assumes the role of protagonist/the strongest, by the author's own choice,who was unhappy that Goku's son had the role of main character.

theherodjl
I Live Here
Posts: 2279
Joined: Mon Jul 13, 2015 10:12 pm
Location: The Planes of Lexington

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by theherodjl » Sat Mar 01, 2025 7:06 pm

What does that have to do with Goku clenching in a panic against Bootenks???
"Why is a raven like a writing desk?" - The Mad Hatter :think:

Eu sou Perfeito
Temporarily Banned
Posts: 30
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2023 2:28 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by Eu sou Perfeito » Sat Mar 01, 2025 11:36 pm

theherodjl wrote: Sat Mar 01, 2025 7:06 pm What does that have to do with Goku clenching in a panic against Bootenks???
Goku at that time was weaker than Fat Buu, so it makes sense that they have no chance against Buutenks.

User avatar
MasenkoHA
Born 'n Bred Here
Posts: 6924
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2017 9:38 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by MasenkoHA » Sun Mar 02, 2025 10:20 am

Eu sou Perfeito wrote: Sat Mar 01, 2025 11:36 pm
theherodjl wrote: Sat Mar 01, 2025 7:06 pm What does that have to do with Goku clenching in a panic against Bootenks???
Goku at that time was weaker than Fat Buu, so it makes sense that they have no chance against Buutenks.
By the time Bootenks was created, Toriyama obviously had changed his decision about Gohan being the lead and was changing course to make Goku the lead again.

Your argument, if I'm understanding you correctly, is that Goku was weaker than all the various Boos because of Toriyama's plan to make Gohan the hero of the story, and when Toriyama changed his mind he retconned all that to make Goku actually stronger than every Boo aside from Pure Boo. But that just isn't true. The whole point of Boo absorbing Gotenks and Piccolo to become stronger than Gohan was to get Gohan out of the story and put Goku back in. The panel Herodjl is referring to would have happened well after Toriyama had changed his mind about Gohan.

User avatar
Jack Bz
Regular
Posts: 582
Joined: Thu Mar 14, 2013 10:44 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by Jack Bz » Sun Mar 02, 2025 10:39 am

Eu sou Perfeito wrote: Fri Feb 28, 2025 10:41 pm
Chapter: 472 (DBZ 278), P10.7
Context: after Goten and Trunks question Goku’s power and Piccolo gets mad
Goku: “It’s alright, Piccolo…I really am weak. It don’t look like I can beat Majin Boo, not even a little bit.”
Piccolo: “Goku…There’s something I want to ask you while I’ve got the chance…[ ] …That Super Saiyan 3 thing earlier…if you had gone all-out, wouldn’t you have been able to defeat Majin Boo?...How about it, am I wrong?”
Goku: “Nah, I don’t know…When it comes to Majin Boo’s strength, it’s like a lie…I think that I probably couldn’t have won…”

Only from chapter 503 onwards, Goku returns to prominence alongside Vegeta and in chapter 509~519, he assumes the role of protagonist/the strongest, by the author's own choice,who was unhappy that Goku's son had the role of main character.
Goku refused to fight Gohan Boo and Super Boo after Gohan has already essentially been removed from the story and he had become the main character. He considered fusing with Mr Satan after Gohan was written out of the arc. He says he's no match for Super Boo after Gohan has been written out. Not to mention that the only Boo Goku says he could have defeated before he fights kid boo was fat boo, which is barely a retcon as it was already established by the conversation with Piccolo that you quoted that he didn't go all out and actually try to win:
Piccolo: “…Probably? Knowing you, why didn’t you try until the very end?...Does it have to do with that energy…?”

Goku: “No…I’m no longer a human who’s particularly even supposed to be here…I shouldn’t be the one to do it.”
Piccolo is clearly dubious about Goku's claims here.

User avatar
dragon boss z
I Live Here
Posts: 2042
Joined: Sun Nov 29, 2015 12:19 am

Re: Kid Buu vs. Buuhan: The Surprising Truth About Who’s Stronger!

Post by dragon boss z » Thu Mar 06, 2025 12:09 am

daniel1 wrote: Mon Feb 17, 2025 12:05 am I am not interested in debating this, frankly. If there is an actual error in the article, please feel free to tag me with the error or contact me on Bluesky about it. However, if your "error" is to question how I came to the conclusion that something with the title "...from the Dragon Ball Z anime!" is based on the anime, for example, then please do not contact me. I am actually a busy person so I kindly ask you not to waste my time with requests like that. All of the exact page numbers, exact episodes, and links for everything else are provided.
Your translation for Goku seems to be wrong in this part.

In this panel, Goku says to Buuccolo, 「はっはーっ!ピッコロが強くでてる!!フュージョンしたチブたちがもとにもどっちまったようだな!!時間切だ!!ざーんねんでした!!パワーがうんと落っこちまったぞ。」 which in English translates to, “Ha ha, Piccolo, you’ve become stronger! It looks like the little ones you’ve fused with have all gone back to where they came from!! But — too bad — time’s up! Your power is dropping as we speak!”

This is Herm's translation.

Chapter: 502 (DBZ 308), P10.4-5
Goku: “Hahha—ah! Piccolo’s coming out strong now! Looks like the Fused squirts have returned to normal! You ran out of time! Tooo—oo bad! Your power’s fallen a whole lot.

Now this actually has nothing to do with Kid Buu vs Buuhan, but the way you translated it makes it seem like Goku is surprised Piccolo is stronger than Goten and Trunks, but this is not the case.

User avatar
p-hyvo
OMG CRAZY REGEN
Posts: 972
Joined: Wed Jul 12, 2017 10:56 am
Location: Italy
Contact:

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by p-hyvo » Mon Mar 10, 2025 3:45 am

Kid Buu is stronger and I don't even wanna begin arguing about it because this topic had me probably a whole year ago at this point. You just have to disagree with way too many official sources to think than buuhan is stronger than kid Buu,ignoring the context of the arc itself which literally debunks the only 2 scans that buuhan riders like to use

Dragon15
Newbie
Posts: 5
Joined: Wed Feb 26, 2025 2:43 pm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by Dragon15 » Mon Mar 10, 2025 5:42 am

They didn’t want to fuse against kid buu but They did against super buu.
They didn’t underestimate kid buu. Goku ssj3 was showed to be equal to kid buu in power. He only lost because kid buu can regenerate a lot and because ssj3 can’t be used for a long time and use a lot of ki. But they weren’t wrong in the estimation of kid buu power.
What they got wrong was kid buu stamina not his strengh.

User avatar
PhantomSaiyan
Beyond Newbie
Posts: 104
Joined: Thu Jan 16, 2025 4:32 pm
Location: Demon Realm

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by PhantomSaiyan » Thu Mar 13, 2025 8:38 pm

p-hyvo wrote: Mon Mar 10, 2025 3:45 am Kid Buu is stronger and I don't even wanna begin arguing about it because this topic had me probably a whole year ago at this point. You just have to disagree with way too many official sources to think than buuhan is stronger than kid Buu,ignoring the context of the arc itself which literally debunks the only 2 scans that buuhan riders like to use
The official sources in question have not even been written by toriyama, imo the only thing that has to be taken into consideration is the manga itself, and the manga itself speaks clearly as many people have pointed out in this thread already. Using basic observation and logic one can pretty easily deduce who is stronger without needing to be handheld by an official guide book written by toei employees aka not the original creator.

User avatar
p-hyvo
OMG CRAZY REGEN
Posts: 972
Joined: Wed Jul 12, 2017 10:56 am
Location: Italy
Contact:

Re: Kid Buu vs Buuhan(Article):

Post by p-hyvo » Thu Mar 13, 2025 10:12 pm

PhantomSaiyan wrote: Thu Mar 13, 2025 8:38 pm
p-hyvo wrote: Mon Mar 10, 2025 3:45 am Kid Buu is stronger and I don't even wanna begin arguing about it because this topic had me probably a whole year ago at this point. You just have to disagree with way too many official sources to think than buuhan is stronger than kid Buu,ignoring the context of the arc itself which literally debunks the only 2 scans that buuhan riders like to use
The official sources in question have not even been written by toriyama, imo the only thing that has to be taken into consideration is the manga itself, and the manga itself speaks clearly as many people have pointed out in this thread already. Using basic observation and logic one can pretty easily deduce who is stronger without needing to be handheld by an official guide book written by toei employees aka not the original creator.
Yeah, sure. It's a real shame that many of that sources come from toriyama interviews in which he explains his writing and native style

But sure, continue thinking what you like more champ. You don't liking guides just because they contradict your bias doesn't strip them of their value as a source. Official guides>>whatever opinion you may have, like it or not

Post Reply