If Goku failed to kill Buu the responsibility of defeating Buu would still fall on the kids, only now they wouldn't have any chance because they wouldn't have learned fusion. Like I said, any choice involved a huge risk. Its easy to say on hindsight that Goku should have fought because the Gotenks didn't manage to defeat Buu, but what guarantee was there that Goku would be able to defeat him quickly..? None. Remember that when Goku decided, he didn't have the means to know if in fact the boys would fail or not, just like he didn't know if in fact he would manage to kill Buu quickly before he ran out of time. All he could do was guess and choose what he believed was the choice with most advantages and seemed right to him. So, both choices had huge risks and I don't see how Goku fighting would be a better choice. Its true that Goku had more experience, but, as Goku predicted, Gotenks turned out to be incredibly powerful, and even stronger than a much stronger form of Buu than the one he was supposed to fight, and he only failed to kill Buu due to a matter of seconds (he was preparing the final blow, when his fusion ran out). If Gotenks had fought the Buu that he was supposed to fight, I don't see how he would lose. So, I really see no fault in Goku's decision.DBZAOTA482 wrote: It's short-sighted because bearing the responsibility on two rookies to defeat an omnicidal maniac is NOT a good way to teach them how to handle future threats (considering it didn't teach them a damned thing) especially when lives are now at stake, and Goku didn't want Trunks and Goten to use the ROSAT. Besides he could have prevented the whole conflict if he had just pull out SSJ3 on Vegeta and hit him so hard that he is knocked out.... or better yet, fight him together with Gohan.
The same problem regarding SSJ3 existed when he fought Vegeta. Its true that he would have ended the fight more quickly, but he would lose valuable time on the living world, especially now that Earth was under threat. Goku wanted to only use his SSJ3 as a last resort due to that problem which is why he refrained from using it from the get go of his fight. Once again, its very easy to say that he shouldn't have done that in hindsight when we already know the end result. As it was happening? Not so much, especially since Goku had no idea if Buu was close to be released or not or what was about to happen. He had no way to know that his brief fight with Vegeta at SSJ2 would be enough to free Buu which surprised even Babidi (in the manga, it was a very brief fight, Gohan didn't even have time to start his fight with Dabura again). So, even before he had much time to consider using SSJ3 to finish his fight with Vegeta more quickly, Buu was already loose. And then, Vegeta seemed willing to help against Buu, so he had no reason to use it against him at that moment. So, sure, it wasn't the best decision on hindsight, but he had valid reason for not wanting to use SSJ3 right from the get go and he was surprised by Buu being released even before he could change his mind about using SSJ3. Is that really so wrong...?
As for Gohan helping out, that's true. Its one of those prideful decisions. Vegeta challenged him to an one on one fight. He wouldn't have Gohan helping him. It wasn't the best for the planet, sure, but this one is not a question of being short-sighed. Its just a matter of pride. Its a matter of personality, one of the things that makes Goku different from a random super-hero.
Because, with his teleportation and all, he couldn't still be around his family frequently?OmegaRockman wrote:
On topic, I think it was pretty shitty of Goku to leave his family to train Oob. Well, his sons were adults at that point at least, so I guess it isn't TOTALLY bad. But his poor wife...
As I said, he had valid reason to use SSJ3 only as a last resort and he had no way to know how close Buu was of being released, which perfectly explains why he didn't want to use SSJ3 from the get go. And after that he had no time to change his mind since his fight was so short. In hindsight? Sure, not the right decision. But Goku didn't have the privilege of knowing exactly what was going to happen.Blade wrote:
Exactly, which also fails to mention that Majin Buu was only ever released in the first place because Goku chose to indulge Vegeta and fight him as a Super Saiyan 2, as opposed to quickly defeating him as a Super Saiyan 3.





